CoTech to become an industry circle of workers.coop - towards a proposal
There is a new, independent worker co-op federation and at the summer gathering the idea of joining forces and making CoTech the first industrial circle of workers.coop received a generally positive response. I now want to work towards a proposal to act on and formalise this.
There are both political and practical reasons why this should be a no brainer, although as always the devil's in the detail and it would also need the coordinating circle of workers.coop to agree and to work on it. Essentially CoTech would operate exactly as it does now, but I think the subs-paying members of CoTech would also need to join workers.coop as enterprise members (many of them have already joined, have agreed to join, or are considering joining). The CoTech circle could involve non-workers.coop members and non-CoTech subs paying co-ops as it does now and have autonomous decision-making and administration remit, sending a member to the worker.coop coordinating circle.
The advantages - apart from the main one - together we are stronger - are that we would be able to merge some admin and infrastructure functions; for instance workers.coop would be the contractor with CoTech's coordinator and could have its own financial ecscosystem, raise money if it wants as it does now for special projects, events, circle expenses (but potentially cross-subsidised from workers.coop general funds); we could merge our NextCloud instances but CoTech could keep its own wiki and other organising tools; and so on.
I know perhaps some CoTechers are not familiar with workers.coop, which is itself in startup mode, and I'm happy to respond to all clarifying questions and then reactions/critical concerns, with a view to writing a proposal for CoTech decision. Meanwhile I'm sharing this summary business plan doc. Here's how a primary worker co-op can join the federation. For transparency: I'm a mission circle (board), coordination circle and communications circle member of workers.coop :)
Would like to be in a position to formulate a proposal in the next couple of weeks, i.e. by Friday 10th Feb 2023.
Also just speaking as me, not Code-op:
Very happy to see this move forward. I think the clearest immediate benefit would be using workers.coop as the contracting body for the network coordinator (see here for proposal on that).
I think the main risk is that Cotech and workers.coop might not communicate enough to be able to co-operate effectively. While that would be a shame and a missed opportunity, I don't think it would damage Cotech much.
For me it looks like the potential upside is large and the potential downside is small so I'd be up for it.
Hi John, we haven't worked out exactly how communication and accountability will work in the case of industry circles, but I think we would want to coordinate (sociocracy style) by having a link person between the CoTech circle and the Coordinating circle. Otherwise it comes down to how collaborative members want to be, or how siloed, and what members see value in sharing.
Speaking in an individual capacity too. At first (when we discussed it informally at the Glasgow gathering) I was a bit sceptical about this, but I've softened a bit now.
On a personal and practical level I do some of the organisational work in CoTech (book keeping, running loomio proposals, some forum moderating, responding to inbound emails etc) and I'd quite like a bit more help with that - having some of those functions taken on by "circles" within wookers.coop and being able to contribute to those sounds appealing to me.
I'd be quite happy if the CoTech "industry circle" were given a budget by workers.coop to spend autonomously (including paying for freelance coordinator assistance) and we scrapped the CoTech fund, encouraging the members to join workers.coop instead, I think.
I'd like CoTech to retain an identity, in particular I like our gatherings when they happen and I wouldn't want to see them go away.
I agree with Doug that we should try to make these decisions online for a variety of reasons.
Blending financial admin and sharing aspects of administration are obvious efficiencies. The federation's subs model (1/1000th of payroll or freelancer fees, minimum £150 p.a. with pay-what-you-can membership for up to two years) is anyway different from CoTech's, so would need to work something out if you wanted to not to continue the CoTech Fund. CoTech would anyway be free to additionally fundraise for its own projects. But maybe the simpler model is: the CoTech fund continues as that additional fundraiser (just done through workers.coop's books and revenue/cost centres), while the workers.coop membership fee covers general/shared workers.coop activity, as it will for every other type of member.
I'd like to maybe do a video meeting for up to an hour, with anyone here who wants to draft a proposal together that would stand a chance of getting broad CoTech support/consent. Who's up for it - and I'll send round a Doodle to fix a time?
Good idea, I'm on for that, you could use a Nextcloud poll for picking a date and time, rather than Doodle.
Perhaps a bit of both, for example I'd love to help shape up a first draft from yourself asynchronously (which also might help more people to contribute)?
Item removed
Not sure what went wrong with the link, try this?
I have written a draft proposal saved in a new CoTech (not workers.coop) Nextcloud folder 'Worker co-op federation' for contributors in this thread to critique/co-edit, or I could do it old style and email to you @Chris Croome (Webarchitects Co-operative) @Chris Lowis (Go Free Range) @Doug Belshaw @John Evans @Graham @John Atherton ?
If you don’t have a Nextcloud account get one via our new SSO
Thanks for drafting this @Sion Whellens (Principle Six/Calverts) I've added a couple of small bits to the document and also one comment, @Doug Belshaw 's comments are good and I think his suggestion to have a meeting to discuss it sounds like a sensible next step.
Item removed
(removed previous message as I got confused between CoTech and workers.coop NextCloud instances...)
Have added comments to the doc, thanks @Sion Whellens (Principle Six/Calverts) ! (if there's no reason to keep it closed, could you make it accessible for everyone and comment-only?)
Hi @John Atherton The link you've posted needs to stay private and only issued to coops that sign up to the worker fed, otherwise it can be targeted by spammers, as this loomio forum is open to the public.
I've deactivated the original link and will send you the new one.
Thanks
@Liam MacLeod (MediaBlaze Hosts) you're going to hate the way that WAO does... most of our work then 😅 https://pads.weareopen.coop (haven't had a problem in seven years)
Etherpad has been specifically designed to be open, the SSO for things like the workers.coop Nextcloud instance has been setup for members of co-ops that join workers.coop not anyone in the world, the forum is open to all.
So no documents on the Nextcloud instance can ever be shared with non-members? That seems sub-optimal as a design decision, but OK!
No @dougbelshaw sorry not to have been clear, of course documents on Nextcloud can be made available for people to read who are not members, it is the SSO that is specifically for members.
Docs can be enabled to be publicly viewed, but not i think edited. We havent settled on our permission policy yet. But the assumption is there will be member only content
Ah ok assumed co-tech was a private forum. My bad!!
It's ok, no harm done :)
@athertonjohn even if this was a private forum we don't want to enable anyone involved with CoTech, most of whom probably haven't joined workers.coop to be able to access all the workers.coop internal member-only services do we?
Thanks for the comments on the draft proposal for a CoTech-workers.coop merger. I have modified the doc accordingly, although the changes aren't extensive. Please have a look, and suggest next steps. For instance: a video meeting with key people from workers.coop? A poll here to see if it's clear enough/good enough to take to workers.coop's mission circle before further developing? The proposal is to 'work towards', so it wouldn't be a final decision.
Look good to me @sionwhellens I'd have thought we would need some support from CoTech to indicate that this might be agreeable before taking it to workers.coop?
CoTech to work towards merging with workers.coop, as its Tech and Digital Industries circle
proposal by Sion Whellens (Principle Six) Closed Fri 3 Mar 2023 12:05PM
The proposal to work towards a CoTech-workers.coop merger was accepted, with 12 in favour and 1 abstention. Maybe a surprisingly low turnout on a pretty important matter, but... As the proposer, can we suggest convening a small 'task-and-finish' CoTech reference group to nut out the details with workers.coop's coordinating circle, and come back with a final proposal? Who'd be up for that?
Full proposal wording:
CoTech to work towards merging with workers.coop, as its Tech and Digital industries member circle, with the following to be used as a basis of dialogue with workers.coop and then drafting of a Memorandum of Agreement.
Summary:
Seven years ago, when Outlandish called for a co-op of digital co-ops, there was no digital or independent worker co-op network in the UK. CoTech was established in 2016 for worker owned co-operatives providing digital or technical services.
In November 2022 an independent federation for all worker co-ops was founded. Called workers.coop, it is now in its first year phase of recruitment, formation and planning. Its high level purposes and objects are set out in the founding document. Broadly, its aims are to mobilise, educate and organise worker co-ops and their members across all industrial sectors, to meet our organisational, commercial and advocacy goals; and to spread knowledge of the worker co-op system among new generations and sectors of workers.
workers.coop intends to keep evolving as a ‘member animated’ network – “the members do the work” – with a mixture of volunteer, co-op member donated and paid-for inputs to deliver its strategy. workers.coop’s governance is sociocratic, and in addition to its working circles (e.g. communications, tech infrastructure, mobilisation, coordination, member services, mission/elected board) the aim is to develop industrial member circles.
The benefit to CoTech members of joining workers.coop - and of CoTech itself becoming a section of workers.coop - is that it will give us access to new channels for mutual support, learning, solidarity and business generation while saving on CoTech overheads. Apart from simply enhancing its membership base, the benefit to workers.coop of such a merger are that it demonstrates cooperative unity (Principle Six), attracting support from and opening up the potential for collaborations with a wide range of domestic and international bodies and networks, including possibly funders.
More on the proposal
We propose that CoTech, while largely retaining its autonomy and identity, should merge with workers.coop and operate as the Tech and Digital industrial circle of the wider federation.
Suggested features and aspects of the merger (which would need to be worked out with workers.coop’s board):
· CoTech would retain its own branding and organising culture. It’s alignment with workers.coop can be a ‘secondary brand’ if it so decides.
· CoTech has its own circle finances and operations, but now as a cost centre within workers.coop. For instance:
· if CoTech raises money to pay for its own coordinator, the coordinator would be accountable to the CoTech circle. However the contractual relationship and financial admin could be done through workers.coop and since workers.coop is doing this it would reduce the duplication of effort. The same would apply if CoTech wanted to run events or programmes resourced independently by CoTech. However in time there would almost certainly be opportunities to co-resource worker time and activity between CoTech and other workers.coop circle budgets.
· Potentially CoTech and workers.coop could blend their admin and infrastructure e.g. Nextcloud instances, forums, wiki, comms, web presence.
· The CoTech circle could continue to involve non-contributing members, and non-members of workers.coop, in its own activity and sub circles. However:
· The governance members of the CoTech circle would need to be direct members of workers.coop. This would give those members access to all of the features and benefits of workers.coop membership, just like any other worker co-op member, as well as governing the relationship with other workers.coop circles including its board (mission circle).
· Although CoTech would be very largely autonomous in its own fields of activity, CoTech members of workers.coop would also be working within the terms of their membership agreement with workers.coop and therefore consenting to workers.coop’s policies as they evolve. It would therefore be necessary to make sure CoTech’s internal and workers.coop’s general policies were compatible.
· The governance relationship between workers.coop and the CoTech circle would need to be set out in a domain and decision-making competency description, in line with sociocratic practice and culture. There might need to be a single or double link between the CoTech circle and other circle(s), for instance with workers.coop’s coordinating circle.
Results
| Results | Option | Votes | % of votes cast | % of eligible voters | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Agree | 13 | 93 | 9 | ||
| Abstain | 1 | 7 | 1 | ||
| Disagree | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Not voted | 137 | 91 |
This works for me understanding that autonomy would continue for both entities.
Agreed on behalf of MediaBlaze Hosts, appreciate cotech resumes autonomy.
Autonomic are in favour!
This sounds like it could benefit everyone. We are in favour (Good Praxis)
We're in favour of making this happen - there's lots of benefits and we think concentrating the limited volunteer resources we have makes a lot of sense. We're interested in contributing time to make this happen too. If this proposal has consent we'd suggest following Sion's sugggested next steps, but ideally bringing forward a number of smaller incremental future proposals (as changes to the CoTech constitution) to make it easier to explain what is happening and get consent.
@Felix Lozano "Up to a point, Lord Copper" 😉
We have some reservations, but stronger together!
Just realised this is closing in 24 hours and we haven't got another WAO members meeting before that. So I'm voting agree personally, rather than on behalf of my co-op.
Agreed from code-operative
We haven't got round to discussing it properly (will do next week), but the initial response is positive.
If this proposal receives consent, we may want to create a task-and-finish group to refine and work with workers.coop towards an MoA that we would bring back for decision.
@Sion Whellens (Principle Six/Calverts) I think there's a missing word in the proposal.
3rd bullet point under "More on the proposal" says `However the contractual relationship and financial admin could be done through workers.coop and since workers.coop is doing this it would reduce the duplication of effort`, should it say `since workers.coop is doing this already`?
On behalf of CBN
We too have reservations. For example, we think that this takes us further away from meaningful cooperation between all tech coops including those that are not worker coops - a point we have raised before.
Nevertheless we support the proposal.
@Chris Lowis (Go Free Range) @Chris Croome (Webarchitects Co-operative) @John Evans @Doug Belshaw and others who have contributed to this thread: would you be up for a circle to progress this? Suggestions as to how we organise it?
I'd be happy to attend to feed in informally from a workers.coop side on practicalities, so when you put forward a SLA or whatever its realistic for what we currently do. On a site note, useful to know where you are up to with the Network Coordinator as that may be a more pressing area we need to act on?
Sounds good to me @Sion Whellens (Principle Six/Calverts) - perhaps start a thread on workers.coop forum in the first instance?
I agree with @Chris Lowis (Go Free Range) that this needs to be very visible on the CoTech forum so that it doesn't 'take people by surprise'.
Appreciate @Chris Lowis (Go Free Range) suggestion that we could progress this from the CoTech side by combing through CoTech's consitution , looking at what changes would be entailed, and breaking it down into a series of more digestible proposals to CoTech members. The initial things it seems to me are:
firstly, including a form of words that explains that CoTech is the Tech and Digital Industries circle of workers.coop and articulates the relationship in broad terms;
secondly, to check that the statement of CoTech's purposes and membership criteria don't conflict with those of workers.coop (I don't think they do), and
thirdly to say that only CoTech members that are also primary members of workers.coop have formal domain power and accountability, in terms of the link to other circles of workers.coop
As far as I can see, nothing much else in CoTech's constitution and infrastructure would need changing in the short term (e.g. CoTech Fund administration and hosting) - in effect this is CoTech's area of autonomy. From the workers.coop side, they will also need to check that the proposal in its current and evolving form makes sense (I think it does, but will now put it on the agenda for workers.coop's coordinating circle).
@Doug Belshaw @Chris Lowis (Go Free Range) does this make sense as a way to work on it? Will you start a thread in CoTech Forum on this, and look at the CoTech constitution to see what proposals you think would be implied?
Thanks Siôn. Forgive me if this has already been made clear, as I dare say it has: will a member of CoTech that chooses not to join workers.coop still have the same ‘domain power’ in relation to things CoTech only? Or put another way, do those not joining workers.coop lose their vote in CoTech. Not planning anything, just curious. Shaun
@Shaun Fensom Hi Sean how about this for a late reply? I think the short answer is no, only members of workers.coop would have full domain rights in the CoTech industrial circle. This would not prevent the circle giving non-members whatever access to its activities and deliberations it chooses to non-members of workers.coop, but I'd suggest for instance only members should have decision making power over (e.g.) the CoTech circle's budget within workers.coop, or its governance relationship with workers.coop and otyher workers.coop circles?
@Sion Whellens (Principle Six/Calverts)
@Sion Whellens (Principle Six/Calverts) Yup, that's quite a gap! I had to refresh myself on the conversation.
As per the discussion further down the thread, I like the idea of outsourcing the question as to who is and who isn’t a worker coop to someone else, because it has been tedious in CoTech. So definite advantage with this route.
However a) this theoretically could be pushing some members of CoTech away - unlikely but possible, and b) I never particularly liked the restriction to worker coops in CoTech in the first place, I would like to be able to admit other coops. But this an old battle that I lost years ago.
Thanks @Sion Whellens (Principle Six/Calverts) - that sounds like a good way forward. If @Doug Belshaw is keen I'm happy to work together to do as you suggest.
@Shaun Fensom - that's a good question and one I guess we'll have to thrash out over time. Personally I like the idea that someone else decides who/what a worker co-op is so we don't have to deal with the constant pain of that discussion everytime a new member applies to join CoTech. Saying that members of CoTech had to also be members of workers.coop (first), would certainly solve that (but cause other issues, no doubt).
Thanks Polly. In fact, generating new business opportunities for members - way beyond co-op intertrading - is an object of workers.coop and we will be codesigning how we do this in an organised, focused way so that it's not just a cosy club. It's definitely not about buying each others' goods and services, for which the scope is limited, but about sharing wider business intelligence to create opportunities for each other. Although of course intertrading is a way to test each others' offer, and thus qualify referrals and recommendations to third parties.