Loomio

CoTech to become an industry circle of workers.coop - towards a proposal

Sion Whellens (Principle Six) PublicSeen by 135

There is a new, independent worker co-op federation and at the summer gathering the idea of joining forces and making CoTech the first industrial circle of workers.coop received a generally positive response. I now want to work towards a proposal to act on and formalise this.

There are both political and practical reasons why this should be a no brainer, although as always the devil's in the detail and it would also need the coordinating circle of workers.coop to agree and to work on it. Essentially CoTech would operate exactly as it does now, but I think the subs-paying members of CoTech would also need to join workers.coop as enterprise members (many of them have already joined, have agreed to join, or are considering joining). The CoTech circle could involve non-workers.coop members and non-CoTech subs paying co-ops as it does now and have autonomous decision-making and administration remit, sending a member to the worker.coop coordinating circle.

The advantages - apart from the main one - together we are stronger - are that we would be able to merge some admin and infrastructure functions; for instance workers.coop would be the contractor with CoTech's coordinator and could have its own financial ecscosystem, raise money if it wants as it does now for special projects, events, circle expenses (but potentially cross-subsidised from workers.coop general funds); we could merge our NextCloud instances but CoTech could keep its own wiki and other organising tools; and so on.

I know perhaps some CoTechers are not familiar with workers.coop, which is itself in startup mode, and I'm happy to respond to all clarifying questions and then reactions/critical concerns, with a view to writing a proposal for CoTech decision. Meanwhile I'm sharing this summary business plan doc. Here's how a primary worker co-op can join the federation. For transparency: I'm a mission circle (board), coordination circle and communications circle member of workers.coop :)

Would like to be in a position to formulate a proposal in the next couple of weeks, i.e. by Friday 10th Feb 2023.

Sion Whellens (Principle Six)

@Chris Lowis (Go Free Range) Re qualification for membership, workers.coop has a pretty broad definition of who can join as an enterprise member - a worker co-op, a democratic employee-owned enterprise, or a worker-led multi stakeholder co-op. But CoTech could continue to define who qualifies to be a member of the CoTech industrial circle. So for instance: I think GreenNet might join workers.coop (because it walks, talks and identifies as a worker co-op despite its technical status as a charity); but CoTech can continue to exclude them, because CoTech's definition relies on the form of legal incorporation.

Or, CoTech could decide to adopt the federation criteria for its own circle membership, and see how it goes.

Doug Belshaw

Yes, I'm happy with this. @Chris Lowis (Go Free Range) could you start the thread? I'm heading on holiday for three weeks after this week, and I can see the discussion getting quite a bit of traction. It might just be me, but I always fee like it's the original poster's job to keep things on track*, and I won't be able to to if I'm away!

*and the admins' job to keep things in line with the Code of Conduct, etc.

Shaun Fensom

@Chris Lowis (Go Free Range) a belated reply to your comment. I agree that the debate about who is and who is not a worker coop has been tedious in CoTech and I hope and believe that workers.coop will take a catholic view of that. However, as an example, some tech coops may prefer to remain members of Cooperatives UK and not want the cost of also joining workers.coop - not planning anything, just musing on possible corner cases. Would such coops be forced to leave CoTech? Would they lose their say?

> I hope and believe that workers.coop will take a catholic view of that

I've not sure what that means? What is a catholic view?

However the current proposal for workers.coop:

> ## Cooperative Enterprise Members > Co-ops that are majority owned by their workers (employee, > > self-employed or volunteers) Or Community and Multi-stakeholder co-ops with significant worker control evidenced in secondary rules or other evidence provided

Is arguably less strict than what we have for CoTech:

> To join CoTech you need to be a worker owned co-operative providing digital or technical services in the UK.

And also this:

> Each member of the network is a company that is owned and democratically run by it’s workers (and, in some cases, customers).

(PS trying to edit posts here using Markdown is really horrible compared with Discourse...)

Shaun Fensom

> I hope and believe that workers.coop will take a catholic view of that

I've not sure what that means? What is a catholic view?

catholic | ˈkaθ(ə)lɪk | adjective

including a wide variety of things; all-embracing: her tastes are pretty catholic.

MoA between CoTech and workers.coop

proposal by Sion Whellens (Principle Six) Closed Tue 10 Sep 2024 11:00AM

Outcome
by Sion Whellens (Principle Six)

Pleased to confirm the vote was unanimous to align CoTech as an industrial member group of workers.coop under the terms of the memorandum. As workers.coop has already approved the agreement, we can get going on practical steps.

This vote is to approve the terms of the formal association of CoTech and workers.coop, with the aim of reducing duplication of organising and fundraising effort, amplifying our collective impact and capacity, while conserving CoTech’s culture and much of its operational independence.

The terms of the association are contained in the attached Memorandum of Agreement (MoA) which has been worked on by CoTech members over the last few months. It has already been approved by the Board of workers.coop, so it will come into effect if it receives consent here.

Some background to the discussion leading up to this proposal is in another PDF attached. The MoA is the culmination of 8 months of discussion here and back-and-forth on the terms and wording.

Leaving this open for voting until September 10th, to get as close to full CoTech governance member participation as possible.

Results

I'm sure CoTech would have been a industrial group within workers.coop if workers.coop had existed at the time that CoTech was formed so this makes sense.

Sion Whellens (Principle Six)
Consent

It's a good agreement... but noticed that in the background doc it says there hasn't been a CoTech gathering since 22. Might have been true at the time of writing :)

Mariano Marey
Consent

co-ops of the world unite ✊

James Mead (Go Free Range)
Consent

Voting on behalf of Go Free Range. Thanks so much to everyone who has worked on this! ❤️

@stevewest I think this is intentional -- the advantage of having the vote end before the gathering is that we won't need to debate this matter at the gathering and can consentrate on talking about other things and also implementing the changes we will need to making as a result (assuming the vote goes in favour).

Alan Peart
Consent

We're happy with it, hopefully it leads to good things in future!

PollyRobbinsOutlandish
Consent

At Outlandish we're a bit nervous that amalgamating with workers.coop will add more layers of governance and decision making to CoTech, and therefore detract from the amount of time people have for supporting each other to win work or grow their co-ops in other ways. We were disappointed that business development/client leads weren't really featured in the objectives of workers.coop. That said, we think this is safe enough to try and grateful for those engaging in it.

Mark Simmonds (Co-op Culture)

At the moment I think that CoTech is an unincorporated association with its own governance. I'm unclear on a quick read of the proposal whether that legal from would be preserved into the new arrangement or whether CoTech becomes part of workers.coop.

Can someone clarify?

Sion Whellens (Principle Six)

@Mark Simmonds (Co-op Culture) I think the way to summarise it is that CoTech becomes part of workers.coop, since all CoTech members will be members of workers.coop. The CoTech 'circle' would have its own decision making domains as outlined in the MoA, qualified by the policies of workers.coop

Lucinda Broadbent

Thanks everyone for thinking this through, it's a great idea. Unity is strength