Abstention - Do Loomio voting options foster participation ?
Today, a proposition may be read by 50 people, but only 20 vote. What if the other 30 were made visible ? Would that not increase the sense of belonging in the community, acknowledging the commitment of both the proposer and the readers of the proposal ?
The "orange light" resulting of "abstain" is not representative of very different voting intentions (undecided, not caring, blank cheque, no legitimacy, etc.). Comments, while helpful, do not impact the interpretation of the charts.
To solve this, I propose to 1) change the orange icon title to "undecided", and 2) create a white icon "abstain".
I agree with @hannahsalmon that a large white space could make it harder to see the first few positions taken, but what would be gained is to see at a glance that most members engaged enough to comment are still undecided. I worry that with the current setup, where the first person to take a position fills the whole pie with their position, this may give a disproportionate impression of how much support that position has, and create an unintended network effect dragging the group in that direction. To mitigate this, I usually don't take a position on proposals I've created until at least a few other people have.
How about offering this kind of decision options to your group/s. Telling, that not taking part of the proposals will mean undecided and the abstain means abstain. Then You probably need to make an effort that decisions for proposals need at minimum 50 % of voices otherwise it is not decided. Therefore You don't need a change of the voting system.
What do You think?
@gregorycassel I wonder if the white could represent 'understanding' as opposed to just 'viewed it'. I like to gain understanding of a topic by reading a thread or researching and sometimes I just want to understand it. I don't feel the need necessarily to contribute because i don't feel strongly pulled either way. But it shows i've engaged with the discussion on a critical level, maybe later i will come back to it after i've decided. I find during meetings I spend a lot of time listening and trying to gain deeper understanding of what is being talked about. Often meetings are too noisy.
Thanks for describing your perspective, @wikihouseharry ! I have some similar experiences.
How could Loomio help participants to specify 'understanding' instead of just 'having viewed' a topic? RIght now, I only perceive that happening with an additional, actively chosen position/'voting' option. I'm not strongly opposed to that, but I agree with Loomio developers that a four-position system-- reflecting the history of formal consensus-- is more accessible and generally helpful.
I've always found it reasonably easy to explain my abstentions when I register my position. It could be helpful for Loomio to add some suggestions along these lines to its Help materials, and perhaps to highlight those ideas with a blog post on "the art of abstention". Actually I wouldn't be surprised if @richarddbartlett has already written something like that. (Sorry Rich I don't have time to mine your wealth of helpful writings right now. :) )
Now I'm going to deliberately muddy the waters a bit, or maybe it actually adds clarity from some perspectives.
I think that assessment/ratings/feedback systems can often be improved by allowing users to expand their options when desired. For instance, in theory, a four-point position system could allow people to simply select "Abstain", but to also click something like "Advanced Options" or "It's Not that Simple", and then pick from a submenu.
I'm reluctant to point this out because I'm sure that Loomio devs have their hands full, and poorly chosen or presented submenu options could practically defeat the purpose of consensus-oriented process.
In the long-long-term, I reckon that some carefully chosen (or community-generated) submenu options would be useful. In the short term, however, I think there are much higher priorities:
- education on consensus-oriented decision process
- education on the advantages of online asynchronous decision process (as opposed to traditional meetings and votes)
With such urgent priorities, I think that advanced options would perhaps mainly add noise and confusion.
www.represent.cc
and
www.vocaleyes.org
are perhaps useful case studies here?
Those examples from Represent.cc and VocalEyes from @lukeflegg are superb. In fact, although this is tangential, their use of score voting is key. The providing of extra details for abstention is nice too, but score voting is really nice, much better resolution. Consider http://scorevoting.net for the complete compelling thing about score voting.
My own primary reason that I hesitate to really use and promote Loomio is specifically because I want to use a system that supports that sort of score voting.
I agree strongly that score voting is a key form of sociometric. That's a key focus for me personally. On the other hand, I'm far from convinced that it's more appropriate for collective decision-making than the agree/abstain/disagree/block protocol which many groups have used in formal consensus process for decades.
My perception is that gradient metrics are preferable for general discussion,and for some sorts of organically 'soft decision making'-- but Loomio style seems better for those rare but important times that people need to collectively make key decisions with long-term consequences.
@gregorycassel We actually agree here. I think there are different cases: 1. facilitated consensus, 2. fallback voting; and there's the distinct case 3. general take the temperature sort of thing.
For both temperature and fallback voting (and also any form of elections for representatives!) score voting is essential. For the consensus process (which is always preferable to a vote), it makes sense to just have a yes or no on whether everyone consents (but I don't think marking the numbers or letting a majority win is healthy when the point is checking for consensus). Finally, a hard block option should be available for any vote separate from the score vote; but the block needs to have a justification / reconciliation process.
Final note: score voting when the question is a yes/no type of decision (as opposed to an election with candidates) can require a higher bar than just average-approval. One option would be requiring an average of 4 on a 5-point scale, for example (or 3.5 or it could be a 6-point scale with no neutral score, abstention has no score count etc). That is actually a very high bar because it requires strong approval from one voter just to balance a neutral vote from another, and even weak disapproval can kill the measure. So, score voting here can be compatible with keeping high bar for long-term decisions.
I had a quick look over at the score voting link Mr. Wolf gave. I don't really understand what's so great about it, especially for the kind of electoral contests it envisions. It says it avoids various problems of existing systems, but it seems to me that in reality it would rapidly degenerate.
If I'm voting in a scoring system, and I know that the winner is the candidate with the highest average, I have an incentive to give my favoured candidate perfect marks and everyone else zero (even if I kind of like them) so as to maximize the difference in average that I'm handing my favoured candidate. Doing anything else gives me, in effect, less than a full vote. Immediately it's in effect not a scoring system any more, just a vote. I suppose if I'm undecided it at least gives me the ability to in effect vote for two people, giving both of them top and everyone else zero. So there's a slight flavour of "affirmation ballot" to it.
Even in a question about "what to do", I think there would be a tendency for people to become partisan and score things more extremely than their real beliefs. I see it when people rate movies or manga or whatever and you see an aggregate score--people will give something a "5/5" just because its current score seems low to them, even though there's nothing at stake whatsoever.
The thing that scoring does bring in, to my mind, is the simple ability to compare multiple options. One thing that I've long believed and have noticed in this very thread is that consensus voting, traditional "Robert's Rules" style voting, and typical "proposition" voting share a fundamental weakness: They are all basically about evaluating a single proposal on a "take it or leave it" basis. People have various different ideas, often closely related but still distinct, and all those systems do not have an effective built-in mechanism for choosing between such multiple related options to find the one people like the most. Arguably the closest to having such a thing is actually the old fashioned "Robert's Rules" meeting with its amendments--but the process sucks. People working with consensus-based processes, such as here in Loomio, typically make a conscious effort to incorporate different people's contributions. You can see it operating in the thread. But there's no actual process for it; there's no way of telling how much support different suggestions have relative to each other, no real way to tell what is just an articulate individual and what represents a modification a lot of people want. In this case, it seems like the so far the end result was the primary proposal (and a couple of ad hoc modified versions) ended up with insufficient support to result in anything, while other ideas sort of hung around in limbo. And I've seen this happen a few times, it seems like a common result.
In other cases with more urgency, I can see situations in which something like the first proposal made shapes the discussion, implicitly ruling out other approaches because something must be done, and this is something.
I might argue for a process which went something like this:
--Problem or issue is brought up, with a solution or action suggested (or even more than one).
--People suggest other possible solutions. Interface allows you to look at the issue under discussion and a list of the proposals to deal with it, and signal your opinion in some way, whether with positives and negatives and abstinence and blocking, or with ranking, or what have you. Perhaps with scoring, although as I say I don't really get that.
--Loomio tracks, maybe with pie charts and such, relative positive votes for different ones
--some attempt to integrate related proposals
--Whichever proposal is "winning" (and optionally not-blocked) after a length of time then moves on to consensus process.
This would have the disadvantage of being slower, but I think it would broaden the alternatives that could be seriously considered and would have a better chance of reaching a conclusion, so might actually be more efficient in the long run. You could be pretty sure by the time you sought consensus on something that it was generally acknowledged to be pretty broadly supported.
@purplelibraryguy I don't want to derail this thread, just note that strategic voting with score voting is mild degeneration that leaves a result that is still the best form of voting. More details: http://www.rangevoting.org/HonStrat.html
Not everyone is strategic, and if you choose to downvote all your other options to help your favorite, that can be risky because you have just lost your vote entirely if your favorite doesn't win. Most people will find that they would rather be honest so that even if their favorite doesn't win, they'd rather have influence on who does win than to throw away their vote. Besides that, in reality many elections people don't have a strong favorite at all. Score voting allows people flexibility and the worst case of strategic voting isn't even bad anyway.
Yes, "approval voting" is very connected to score voting, it's score voting with lowest resolution of only two score options. It has most of the benefits of score voting except the better resolution and flexibility.
Anyway, I agree with you overall: the best form of consensus is one that actively works to incorporate everyone's concerns and not just go with a lowest-common-denominator but actually work for win-win solutions that include everyone's issues. In that process, the purpose of a score system is merely informational, not decisive, and most people in such a consensus-driven situation will be honest. It's possible to be strategic in any context though, such as not consenting to something you actually are okay with just because you think that failed consent will make others compromise and move to your favored view. That's why we need both good facilitation and fallback voting (so that consensus-blocking can't be tyrannical and impossible to get past).
I think you @purplelibraryguy have a valid point when range voting is used strictly for selection of 'one from many'; and I see other ways to reduce the influence of strategic voters, but this goes beyond my interest here (this thread) in Loomio's consensus-oriented decision process.
That way we can visually see the "balance" - the "gravity" of the votes