Abstention - Do Loomio voting options foster participation ?
Today, a proposition may be read by 50 people, but only 20 vote. What if the other 30 were made visible ? Would that not increase the sense of belonging in the community, acknowledging the commitment of both the proposer and the readers of the proposal ?
The "orange light" resulting of "abstain" is not representative of very different voting intentions (undecided, not caring, blank cheque, no legitimacy, etc.). Comments, while helpful, do not impact the interpretation of the charts.
To solve this, I propose to 1) change the orange icon title to "undecided", and 2) create a white icon "abstain".
Change the orange icon title to "undecided" and create a white icon "abstain"
proposal by Fabio Balli Closed Tue 3 Nov 2015 11:58PM
Results
| Results | Option | Votes | % of votes cast | % of eligible voters | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Agree | 3 | 38 | 0 | ||
| Abstain | 1 | 13 | 0 | ||
| Disagree | 4 | 50 | 0 | ||
| Block | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Not voted | 891 | 99 |
Interesting but i guess the low rate is more a global Internet syndrom than due to anything in loomio… i may change my vote later but still am not certain :)
This complicates the simple premise of the software, in my humble opinion.
I may be able to be talked into clarifying what the positions mean per proposal (which has been suggested a few times before), but not changing this core tenet of Loomio.
Low 'voter turnout' is prevalent in most online communities, even for rare scheduled events such as elections of annual officers, etcetera. There are many reasons for low participation, which can be addressed both generically and per-community.
Why not just test it? The rate of undecided people seems an interesting figure to me.
No real need. I would go for a FB-like option x people read this proposal, and you could mark that as white in the chart, but not with a new button. Conscious choise for this would be Abstain.
Seems to me the main resistance is people don't like too many colours because it doesn't look as pretty. I think white is smart, because it's a lack of any colour (because it's a lack of any opinion) while orange becomes an active expression of :-S
What a great proposal. This has generated some really good ideas. Thank you OP. I love the idea that whitespace on the pie represents people who've read the proposal and did not vote
Include people who viewed a tread but did not vote as a white slice in the pie chart.
proposal by Fabio Balli Closed Sat 7 Nov 2015 12:08AM
Results
| Results | Option | Votes | % of votes cast | % of eligible voters | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Agree | 7 | 37 | 1 | ||
| Abstain | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Disagree | 12 | 63 | 1 | ||
| Block | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Not voted | 880 | 98 |
This is actually a very good idea.
Looks good.
Viewing a thread feels too light-weight and ambiguous an action to be concretely represented in the pie chart
I really like this general train of thought, but I don't think we're 'there yet'. IMO Matthew said it perfectly: views feel too lightweight and ambiguous for direct representation in the pies.
I vote for this proposal because this kind of change is needed in my view. but I would change it to people who commented not just looked
Much more in line with what we really want to see :).
At a minimum this needs to be an option, not default behavior.
Weak disagree. I concur with the position that viewing is too weak an action to be meaningful. I'll open lots of tabs (I have 196 open right now), but that doesn't mean I've read any of them.
Like Zack, I would agree if the proposal was based on comments, not views.
The idea that viewing a resource contributes a change violates the expectations (and RFC's) concerning HTTP and web applications.
agree with Matthew and Zack
Hitting a URL does not mean someone actually read the content on that page. Even commenting in the discussion does in my opinion not constitute abstaining.
I think the pie should only include people that engaged with the voting.
Alternatively, there could be sub-options for the those voting 'abstain' to explain their reasoning. Possible scenarios would be 'don't care, undecided, no time to follow, etc.
Maybe not necessarily on the chart itself but I find the idea of having an amount of lurking users awesome.
I love the idea of displaying engagement stats, but don't think it should be presented in the pie graph.
Perhaps the "viewers" should be shown as "not decided yet" or "still not decided".
Changed because there is enough information about the not decided. They have to accept that democracy means to be part of a decision. And the group have to improve the contact to those for that they take part.
I think that online communities can benefit from peer feedback/ sociometric tools which are much more finely granulated and nuanced than stuff such as "like", "upvote/downvote" and "agree/abstain/disagree/block"; however, I think that a four point system is quite strong for formal decision process.
Thanks for these first feedbacks. :)
@raphaeljadot @gregorycassel For me, it is not so much about having more people take part to the discussion but about making the one who invest time in reading the topic visible (immaterial contribution).
Let's say we propose a topic. It has a totally different signification if we see 10 votes and have no clue about the others, or if we see them, but also know that 30 people have taken the time to read the proposal. Maybe that could be a "people who read" automatic number @matthewbartlett ?
@jameskiesel maybe that is just about wording, not adding an element ? From what I understand, the orange "abstain" is in fact "neither agree, nor disagree", and the "undecided" - which I saw is already used for non voters -, is "non voters".
Ah — I hadn't understood that. I love the idea of making lurking more visible.
It's not possible to directly register whether or not someone has taken the time to properly read a proposal. If someone has indeed read a proposal carefully and they feel undecided, they can use Abstain along with a comment such as "I'm undecided." I think that this is a good communication tactic, but I don't think it's been strongly cultivated in groups which I belong to.
@fabioballi wdyt if then would be automatically added the amount of
* unique clics on a proposal
* connected users who opened the proposal
It certainly can be done automatically :)
@fabioballi I think one of the strengths of Loomio's present format is that 'lurking' is legitimate...it's possible to feel part of the conversation without actively participating. Ambiguity can be a strength not a weakness here. I'm sympathetic to your concern (How many people are watching but not contributing?) but I don't think trying to crytallise this uncertainty is necessarily the solution.
Being able to see who has viewed a proposal might help the group understand more about how a proposal was received. And it would not require the user take any extra actions.
The four options (agree, disagree, abstain, block) are based on a consensus process which has a long tradition of use in face-to-face meetings. I agree that changing the buttons around would be very disruptive without adding much of value. However, I really do like the idea of using white space in the pie chart to proportionally represent the group members who have at least glanced at the thread (as opposed to being completely disinterested), but not taken a position on the proposal. Another variant could be white space for those who have commented, indicating some degree of active interest, but not taken a position yet.
I like the idea of, perhaps, counting those who comment without taking a position. In fact, the more i think about it, i think I'd recommend that there be a line of text (as someone else suggested), that says "x people have viewed this proposal" and put a white wedge in the pie for unique commenters without a position.
@strypey feel like mocking up some examples of how the pie change idea could look?
This is really off-topic, but I think that 'Block' is a less appropriate descriptor than 'Stop' for Loomio's general use-cases, which in my experience rarely involve formal consensus decision. This detail is the only reason that I'm not 100% smitten with your awesome comment above @strypey . :)
I would recommend to make the vote more specific...
I'm currently, ah, undecided. I don't mind the "clutter" as such. The one worry I have about this is that if the whitespace from "looked but haven't (yet) registered an opinion" tended to occupy a big chunk of the pie, it would make it less intuitive to judge roughly how much support or opposition a proposal had, what with both support and opposition being squinched over into a small part of the circle.
@purplelibraryguy What a great observation! So maybe the geography of the 'white space' (if this is technically possible) would need to be altered. Maybe "looked but haven't registered an opinion" is not actually the same kind of thing as 'agree/disagree/abstain/block" and should be represented outside the pie or in a different way somehow.
Here is the new proposal which I refocused on seeing the participating. For changing the wording, please refer to the new thread : https://www.loomio.org/d/S3I0HTq5/abstention-part-2-make-wording-in-votes-more-congruent
I like Fabio's visualisation, although I would swap the wording:
* orange remains 'abstain' - formally bow to the will of the group on this decision
* white is 'undecided' - commented (thus interested) but no position taken yet, not even to abstain
I'd really like to, and I know its easier for coders to discuss implementation once they see how the suggested feature could look in the interface, but I'm juggling some deadlines at the moment and I really don't have time to wrestle with graphics software (I'm a total noob at graphics). Is there anyone else who thinks they grok what I'm suggesting, and could have a go at visualizing it?
The thing I like most about all of this is the idea of tracking views of proposals, which would give coordinators / group members an additional layer of engagement to consider (and it's, of course, a thing we already do when calculating what thread activity you've read.)
What about having one large pie (the current one) for the vote results (agree, disagree, abstain, block, undecided), and a separate graph (pie/stacked bar) for participation (voted, viewed but didn’t vote, part of group, but haven’t visited).
Maybe something like this:
I really like this idea!
How about offering this as a feature to people who want it. Like me + thousands of people.
Then people who don't like it don't have to use it & everyone is happy?
Another general possibility is to scale the size of the pie based on the percentage of position-registration. I've considered this for other types of sociometrics. I generally recommend a logarithmically scaled visual representation, instead of a linear scale.
This is a somewhat thorny concept, which I have not yet explored exhaustively, but it seems relevant here.
Hmm perhaps the viewing/commenting slice should sit vertically symmetrical at the top of the pie, while block, disagree, abstain, agree slices would be tracked clockwise around the pie in the remaining space
@fabioballi — I really support your wish to 'increase the sense of belonging in the community'. However it's hard for me to see how changing the voting options or colours will help that. Maybe there are other ways we could achieve that?