Discussion activity chronology
We're rolling out natural discussion item chronology early next week (7.10.13).
We wanted to have a place where members can go and talk about the change. The user testing we've done has shown that the flipped discussion order will be quite intuitive for new users. On the other hand, our lovely members who have grown accustomed to "new to old" discussion chronology may have some growing pains.
In the end, we think that our users will love arriving at a new discussion and reading from top to bottom, and commenting in the flow of the dialouge.
Here's a blog about the changes.
Hey guys, I've added a jump link to the top right hand corner of the discussion. Discuss
Functioning pretty well for me! But display is wonky (I'm using Chrome).
Hrrmmm.. so am I and I don't see that wonkyness..
Ooh! It jumps! Yusss
Is anyone else experiencing the layout bug @alannakrause posted? @alannakrause, are you still seeing this?
Yes I am still seeing it
@jessedoud Got any ideas about this?
The width just needs to be adjusted, but I can't replicate. @alannakrause let me know when is a good time to have a look. Will take less than 5 min.
There have been a number of good design solutions suggested here, but one of the simpler ones seems to have been lost on the flow: provide a button where the user can toggle from 'most recent first' to 'oldest first', like email clients do. You still have to decide which will be the default, but users can decide which order they like best, case-by-case, with the touch of a button.
Sticky proposals sounds good, as does making the discussion title (and maybe Context Box?) static. What about making the comment box static as well? It would save a lot of scrolling back and forth to give quick replies to multiple comments along the thread.
In terms of a process for rolling out potentially disruptive features, would it be possible to offer new features to admins, and let them opt-in? When a feature gets a certain proportion of opt-ins (eg 51% of 75%), and presumably has an major dents hammered out of it, you announce in the app that it will be rolled out as a new default feature, and when. I'm thinking along the lines of keeping the users as participants in the development process, rather than just consumers of a commodity which is changed arbitrarily by invisible decision-makers.
@alannakrause I did! But I had issues with set up as it appears to be a nonstandard implementation of postgres - which causes issues with all of my other projects.
This plus will_paginate is pretty much all you need: https://gist.github.com/lachlanp/6999049
Just so you know, members of the Permaculture Council were quiet thrown by the sudden reversal of the familiar UI, and it's made them a bit concerned about using Loomio. They'll get over it, but it confirms the need to involve users in the roll-out of UI changes.
@strypey thanks for passing that on. Yeah, we've definitely learned a couple lessons here. :)
I still don't like the new order of posts - it involves a lot of scrolling each time I visit a thread to catch up on the one or two newest posts. If you could code it so that the page automatically scrolls to the first new post on the thread, that would help a lot. But to me, on a 'live' presentation, latest activity first (at the top) is more natural.
Thanks @goob, good to hear your feedback. We're about to do a big overhaul of our entire UI (designing mobile-first) starting with the discussion page, with our sole aim being to make everything as easy and natural as possible. I'm feeling pretty confident that the new designs will fix most of the pain people have been experiencing, but we'll be posting up all the designs for feedback and do extensive user-testing along the way to make sure we get it right. So stay tuned. Will probably have a blog post up about it next week.
Also, I agree with @christaklis that different users have different preferences, and really big discussions are going to want to be displayed differently than smaller discussions. So having a UI which is flexible enough to respond to these different sets of needs is going to be really important. And that will probably mean being able to sort comments by a number of different factors (e.g. chronologically, most liked, etc.).
Thanks, Jon.
@jonlemmon as i said in the User preferences and/or group preferences, users and groups must have their own preferences.
And that is because Loomio is growing fast and will grow. With everyday, every week, every month to have new features or have small or big changes.
How is going to be Loomio in 3 months or in 6 months or maybe a year? Perhaps not even close as it started! All that new ideas that are falling every day will make Loomio greater that we imagine.
In how long we don't know, but all users and groups don't have the same requirements or needs. So it is so simple, just users and groups have their own preferences, and that solves all the negatives that maybe someone has for a proposal or proposals, because they don't want it for their groups.
Sometimes what users think they want isn't actually what's best for them :) I know that an unpopular thing to say, but there is a reason not every user is a software designer. Sometimes you have to force change on people before they can understand why it's actually an improvement. On the other hand, sometimes software designers are totally wrong, too!
True @alannakrause but uncofigurable software is only applicable in a very narrow band of functionality. Loomio plans to appeal to broad base and in my opinion it would be madness to try and build something this complex without preferences.
This doesn't mean you expect your users to be software designers but it does mean giving them choice in how they want the tool to function.
btw I'm still frustrated everyday by having to scroll to the bottom of the page to read comments and you might want to think about putting out a quick fix to that problem outside of your big 'overhaul the ui process'
@joshuavial use the little down arrow at the top of the discussion to jump to the unread comments. I'm using it and it's working great.
Does everyone have access to the "Jump to the latest unread activity" button...? Or is that just a select few.
@malcolmshearer everything's for everyone at the moment! With a bit of luck we'll shortly be able to beta test features with particular groups that opt in. That will be nice.
I also want newest posts on the top. It took me few seconds to get used to it and liked it ever since. it was following the natural flow of a discussion: read and respond to latest points raised instead of scrolling through all the things which were said. In fact I am more interested to see what they have decided before in decisions, so I would include that in the main discussion flow. But my main point is that it shouldn’t be required to scroll a lot in order to be active in a discussion.
@lachlanpriest did you know Loomio is open source? Feel free to jump in an implement endless scroll the next time you have 15 minutes :)
No but seriously, if you're keen, help out!