Cycle 4 Anchor
Point of departure for all things Cycle 4
Thank you Alex for this offering.
If this form is taken as a whole I think a single gathering will not provide enough space to delve in deeply. This raises three possibilities (that I can see):
Just start and it takes as long as it takes ... though this may break the flow.
Take one step at a time collectively .... so everyone does step 1 and it there is space in the same gathering move on to the next, if not the next step is next gathering.
Dedicating a gathering to one crew-member at a time ... so going through the whole process but one person at a time.
I am leaning towards the 3rd option.
Comments on the form itself:
"Appreciative Inquiry" feels to me ... a bit forced ... like "let's all say something nice before saying something potentially disturbing or hurtful" ... it feels to me like "tell me that you love me" which I've never felt comfortable doing (especially on demand). I have reservations about this ... but no hard objections (for now).
"Matters of Concern" feels like the heart of the matter ... so I prefer to go directly there.
The title "closing exploration" seems unnecessarily biased towards closure/convergence. As a result, the question for-reflection also feels narrow and restictive. I'm guessing that better prompts will arise naturally after the previous steps ... but if I had to choose something now it would probably be more like "What do you wish for next?"
I also want to suggest regarding time that:
If possible everyone try to leave a space (15 - 30 minutes) both before and after sandbox time without other things scheduled back to back (on either end).
If not, to avoid tight/rapid/incomplete endings, I suggest that we treat the time available as 1:45. That will allow either for soft closure or a bit of overflow that we seem to usually need.
I'd like to let this take how long it takes, even if it is a bit of an awkward flow. One way that we could move it along in the meantime would be to offer step 1 observations acknowledging each person's contributions asynchronously before the meeting on Thursday for folks who have time.
I appreciate the suggestion of wrapping up the meeting after 1:45 minutes to allow for some flexibility on how things end. Thanks for that!
BTW Ronen I don't need an agenda item to tell you that I love you <3
Re: "closing inquiry" I'm not attached to the title, the idea is just to get us circling around a specific question as we close the sequence. Maybe call it "winding down inquiry" if that is helpful for step 3. "What do you wish for next" is really the crux of step 4, so step 3 gives us all an opportunity to each share some context to work with on that crucial question.
Appreciative Inquiry" feels to me ... a bit forced ... like "let's all say something nice before saying something potentially disturbing or hurtful" ... it feels to me like "tell me that you love me" which I've never felt comfortable doing (especially on demand). I have reservations about this ... but no hard objections (for now).
Probably bad wording; we could call it "Acknowledging inquiry". It Is not about niceness, but fairness. About our place in this crew. About us being seen and our contributions being seen. About value flow. How is it, if any, perceived from my contributions and my skills. It is quite relevant for me to understand my skills valued for the future, and its fruits so far in our work.
I will not discuss what are you valuing. I want to listen carefully and learn how this crew is aware of everyone's contribution. I want to know what is valued. That seems to me as relevant as the difficulties to keep working together. It is very important, at least to me, to see how I can contribute to this crew and how it will be acknowledged.
Maybe the best way to do this is writing it in advance and send it to Alex, or copy/paste in the chat and hit intro at the same time. We can read the answers, make a round of comments, and move forward.
If possible everyone try to leave a space (15 - 30 minutes) both before and after sandbox time without other things scheduled back to back (on either end).I am available before as much as you want, but not after, for I have a meeting at 16:00 UTC.
Just to be clear: this first sequence can be quite disturbing or hurtful as well. But we can work that in the second sequence.
Knowing I may sound like I am repeating myself, I believe that this should not be done as a one-off thing but should be a regular process. Some contributions are valuable in a moment, or in a cycle but fade over time, some create a more lasting presence. I have ***suggested*** a way to approach this in GenSeq - Contributions (within "Wholocracy").
Doing it in the present moment is unappealing to me because I experience the crew as stuck/dormant. I would have to go back in time to recollect specific contributions.
I also feel that contributions are NOT directly related to "belonging in the crew." Your place in the crew is, in my mind, related to your interest/desire, your showing up, and your resonance with and contribution to the vibe in the crew. I feel that is what needs tending to in our present moment. Approaching that by recognizing and appreciating contributions feels to me like it misses the mark.
Well, this response is not redundant and actually quite informative to me; because of that I am OK to move forward to talk about concerns (and agreements to tackle them). Let us hear the rest of the crew.
there was a typing error in my comment ... I've corrected with the addition of the "NOT" 😏
Hi @Ronen Hirsch---I hear that this exercise is unappealing to you. I'm not sure based on this response if you are open to doing the steps I've outlined with the rest of us. It is very important to me that whatever we do next that we do it with the consent of all five of us. Do you object to us moving forward in this way? If so, let me know and I will adjust the plan accordingly. If not, then I'd like to continue forward with the proposal. Thanks for offering that clarification so we know how to proceed.
In a spirit of open expression, I have offered my thoughts and feelings about the exercise.
As I've stated before, I have no hard objections, so it is not my intention to block this.
I am happy to leave my feedback in your hands @Alex Rodriguez to do with as you please (or ignore). Regardless of what you choose, my intention is to show up authentically and if I experience tensions or frictions as we move into this, I will make them known and navigate my way through them with and within the group.
That sounds like a plan---thank you for clarifying. If @Josh Fairhead or @Jennifer Damashek has any thoughts one way or the other, please let me know (either on this thread or privately if you prefer).
Hi all, after some reflection I've decided that I will not be able to hold a space for the five of us to convene over video chat during our sandbox time this Thursday.
It has become clear to me through feedback I received from @Josh Fairhead , @Ronen Hirsch , and @Toni Blanco (each in different ways) that the plan we left with at the end of our last meeting---to prioritize cards on Trello and discuss matters of concern one at a time---is not a viable next step for us. I am also not confident in my capacity to hold space to create an environment where we can all speak freely to meet shared needs. I will, however, be available to talk with anyone in the crew during sandbox time or to try something else if anyone would like to propose anything in terms of how to create a container for communication during that time. Please feel free to ping me in the meantime, too, and I'll respond as soon as I'm able to do so.
Thank you @Alex Rodriguez. We had a good gathering and the list at Trello triggered very interesting conversations in dyads while the interactions in Discord where not as interesting and intense, as @Ronen Hirsch made me notice.
So I think that a good move is to keep the Sandox Time for dyads and see what emerge from there.
As I see it, we flowed to a different stage, thinking in a significant shift that goes beyond the commitment we had until now, which was enough for crafting a good draft of the GP, but makes unthinkable to move towards any implementation without clarifying stuff like time and money, quite interrelated for most of us.
In my dyad with each of us an idea manifested with different wording (collaborative forks @Josh Fairhead , groups @Ronen Hirsch, work in parallel @Jennifer Damashek, little congregation @Alex Rodriguez) the one of re-configuring the crew as a little federation of dyads/crews working in what it is most alive in them to move the vision of the digital space forward, making the most of their skills, choosing their methodologies and practices for organizing and contributing, and making this way easier the incorporation of new folks.
So I suggest to keep having this generative conversations and see if this (I perceive) shared desirable scenario can emerge form them.
though I don't have plans to utilize it, this pattern appeared to me and I am sharing it here in case others may wish to utilize it - Witnessed Dyads:
An initiator (one crew member) invites another 2nd crew member to a dyad - they are the participants.
The initiator and 2nd crew member choose a third crew member to be a witness.
The conversation starts between the participants while the witness is just listening.
At any point in the conversation, either of the participants can invite in the witness ... or not ... the entire conversation can be between the two participants with the witness silently watching.
The witness can then choose to either step in or reject the invitation and instruct the participants to continue.
If the witness chooses to step in, the witness chooses with which one of the two participants she wishes to dialogue and the other participant now becomes the silent witness.
Now the roles have changed ... the original dyad has now dissolved ... and the cycle can repeat numerous times from step 4.
If both original participants and the witness agree to it, other crew members can be present as an audience. Audience members are silent with webcams off and cannot partake in the conversation in any way. Audience members need to understand and accept that they may be spoken about in the space but they cannot speak into the space. An audience member can initiate a follow-up Witnessed Dyad which may weave together into a more encompassing exploration.
I think this may both enhance some bring some richness, clarity, and continuity to some of the dyads taking place and possibly transform them from a kind of back-channeling dynamics back into a collective or semi-collective experience space.
Hey everyone, I'm looking forward to seeing you on Thursday at sandbox time (14:00 UTC, same as last week). Let's start on Discord and if that gets wonky we can move to Zoom.
I spoke with @Toni Blanco on Friday and that helped clarify the loose structure I'd like to hold for the conversation. I'd like to propose the following form for our gathering:
Appreciative inquiry: we hear from everyone about each person's contributions to the crew and our shared intentions thus far
Matters of concern: everyone has an opportunity to articulate concerns about where we are. We will see if anyone has a proposal for how to address the concern through a shared agreement. If we are unable to address it, we will simply name that it is a concern that remains unaddressed.
Closing exploration: based on what has surfaced through the first two steps, we each explore the question, "are there circumstances that allow us to continue to work together?"
Next steps: address any next steps needed before the following week's sandbox time
In the meantime, I encourage all of us to reflect on the first two prompts. Also, please let me know if you have any concerns about this format or would like to suggest changes. Feel free to ping me on Discord if you want to check in before Thursday, as well.
See you soon!