Loomio

Discussion-level privacy

Richard D. Bartlett PublicSeen by 181

We’ve recently made some changes to how group privacy works on Loomio.

You can now configure your groups to be public, private, or hidden:

  • Public - discussions are public. Anyone can see the group name, description, and membership. Anyone can ask to join.
  • Private - discussions are only visible to members. Anyone can see the group name, description, and membership. Anyone can ask to join.
  • Hidden - only members can see the group and its discussions. People have to be invited to join.

You shouldn’t need to do anything, we just wanted to give you a heads up about the new settings :)

Let us know if you have any questions!

Feel free to email rich@loomio.org if you have privacy concerns that you don't want to discuss in public :)

Alanna Irving

I love that you blocked your own proposal (0)

mix irving

we've talked about this a lot in person and it's a slippery problem to make something which has subtle complexities easy for a user..

I hope we can communicate what we're thinking shortly.

I like that you're discussing who can join, we haven't talked about that so much but I think it's a good idea

PauKokura

Moreover, I erased de "we" in "we can do better". All of you are doing great XD
To block yourself is really useful to keep on moving! It's what I just said in my last comment in other thread.

PauKokura

@johnirving "in person" ;( I would love talk HOURS about it (with some beers). I'm not very sure, but the "who can join" option can be related in unexpected ways (unexpected for me) with the "share link" in @jonlemmon 's mobile mockup.

Miles Thompson

I like the wording public, private and secret - because they immediately convey the differentiation - especially that between private (behind closed doors) and secret (there is no door, what door? did you say there was a door?)

Never mind the connotations, clarity i feel is more important in this context.

PauKokura

So, let's go part by part... new proposal!

John Graham

Apropo of nothing, here's a cryptic riddle:

What do you call a public, private secret?

John Graham

Back on topic - people seem wary of connotations of whatever we come up with, so, the plainer the better.

Riffing off 'confidential':

The core issue seems to be, people want to be confident that they can speak in confidence - so how about, simply,
"In Confidence" as a setting?

Alanna Irving

I just want to thank everyone who is engaging on this topic - feedback from people from different kinds of groups, who speak different languages, and have diverse perspectives is incredibly valuable.

Just a reminder, decisions made in this group are non-binding. That's mostly because our design process is very iterative. We make something, try it out, learn from what happens, and then change it.

So when it comes to something like the wording of these new group types, it's likely not to be set in stone for a long time. No matter what happens going forward, though, we're going to value and learn from the opinions shared in this thread to inform the decision.

John Graham

Great, thanks for the reassurance @alanna, makes it more fun.

In which case, how about I suggest additional settings like "Paranoid" or "Conspiratorial", for those of us less confident about confidentiality online. :)

Alanna Irving

"Stalk me", "Meh", and "Go Away NSA"?

Deleted account

The thinking going forward is that we are going to change the 'secret' group privacy option to 'hidden'.

PauKokura

It seems hidden is better considered than secret. (So public and hidden for now)
Although if we find a good alternative to private, I think we could have a 100% green pie, prepared for the three levels if they are developed.

@alanna I know, this is just an aproach. But it also helps (me) to translate to my language, it's important for non-english versions.

@milesthompsonkapit I dont know what do you mean with the word consensus "makes me twitch"
I think its the same in all languages and consensus is the spirit of loomio. I'm wrong?

Help me, simple-english wikipedia! -->

https://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consensus

Robert Guthrie

@jellelangbroek closed could be interpreted as a group that once was active and now is not.

Jelle Langbroek

ah right. then it's a bad translation from Dutch I did :s (luckily we do have a word for it)

I searched for the synonyms for 'secret':
Synoniem van secret: clandestine
Synoniem van secret: classified
Synoniem van secret: concealed
Synoniem van secret: concealed
Synoniem van secret: confidential
Synoniem van secret: covert
Synoniem van secret: furtive
Synoniem van secret: hidden
Synoniem van secret: hush-hush
Synoniem van secret: illegal
Synoniem van secret: not to be disclosed
Synoniem van secret: not to be mentioned
Synoniem van secret: off the record
Synoniem van secret: private
Synoniem van secret: restricted
Synoniem van secret: secretive
Synoniem van secret: stealthy
Synoniem van secret: surreptitious
Synoniem van secret: top secret
Synoniem van secret: undeclared
Synoniem van secret: undercover
Synoniem van secret: underground
Synoniem van secret: unprofessed

Alanna Irving

I think we should use "furtive group" "hush-hush group" or "unprofessed" group! LOL (those sound funny in English)... sorry @jellelangbroek it seems translation when we don't even know what things mean in English is a pretty hard job :/

Jelle Langbroek

@alanna :) I know. But sometimes just seeing these kind of translations make thoughts spring up in peoples minds. No harm done I say ;)

Richard D. Bartlett

Update

I've just released the new language: "public, private & hidden". Let's see how that feels and we can change it again later if it doesn't fit.

Thanks for teasing this out @zombilechuck!

John Graham

And to round out the discussion from my end....

@jellelangbroek, continuing the spirit of fun and brainstorming: I know some people hate this kind of cryptic riddle. I expect groans and rolling of eyes...

BUT

There is another word, synonymous with 'hidden'(in some contexts)

The answer to my cryptic riddle was a bit, well, cryptic.

"What do you call a public, private secret?"

...

It's hidden in plain sight!

...........Cryptic. :)

Miles Thompson

hiya @zombilechuck! sorry for massively delayed response here - just saw that you had mentioned my name some time ago.

My apologies if this was an english as second language barrier for you - not something to worry about as it doesn't matter at all.

But for what its worth I love the word 'consensus' and yes I think it means much the same in all languages. 'Consensuate' is the one that made me twitch. I guess you would call that the verb form of 'consensus' but it's not technically a word, rather an impromptu 'verbing' and as Calvin said 'verbing weirds language'... http://www.strangehorizons.com/2006/20060313/verbing_weirds_language.gif

That said languages are meant to evolve.. and since there doesn't seem to be a word for 'bringing to consensus' ya'll have it !

'Focalize', though is another story. I will never be able to hear a request to 'focalize' on something without twitching... since there is already the perfecly good verb 'focus' for that purpose.

PauKokura

Thanks for the response, no matter how late. In the 15M we had a claim that said: "We're slow because we're going far" ;)

English is not my second language, it's my third one... and my other languages have this verb consensuar ;)
I supose verbing is something more common in romanic languages... either in esperanto verving is normal and accepted: konsenti (verb) konsento (noun) and if it makes sense... konsenta (adjective) konsente (adverb).

"Focalize" and "focus", thats a difficult one for catalan speakers, as "focus" sounds like a noun (in catalan "un focus" means a lamp) so focalize (for us) seems more as a verb like in "visualize"...

Nevermind, good job everyone and happy new year or... in Esperanto... Feliĉan novan jaron!

Chris Taklis

now i see 2 different things...

1) first of all in subgroups the posts remain hidden even to main group, and members can't access discussions.

2) i don't like if a group is private everyone can see the members (i think that must be available only to public)...

Deleted account

Perhaps there is room for a fourth option:
Anyone can see the group. Discussions and who's in it are only visible to members by default.

Danyl Strype

Trying to find the right discussion to fit a suggestions in. I see it's now possible to have private discussion in a public group, which is useful, but it makes for some confusion about whether a given discussion in the group is private or public. I can think of two ways to differentiate:
1) Supplement the icon scheme you have with other visual cues, for example differences in colours or layout for public vs. from those for private
2) Replace "post" in "Post comment", so that in a private discussion the box shows up as "Private comment", and and in a public discussion as "Public comment".

If you go with 2), you could add another features that allows people commenting inside public discussions to toggle between public and private comments .

In either case, those logged in and able to see private comments should see a visual difference that reminds them those comments are confidential.

Robert Guthrie

Thanks @strypey. Right now we're thinking of just reminding people as they are posting. A line of text "Your comment will be public" above the post comment button might do it.

Danyl Strype

@robertguthrie that would deal with suggestion 2). I presume your code would check the privacy level (public/private?) of the page, and concatenates the text string "public" or "private", as appropriate, to the end of a string variable holding "Your comment will be".

Seems to me it would be about the same amount of work as putting the code in the button object, and have it concatenates "public" or "private" to "comment" in the variable that currently holds the text "Post comment"?

I hate to be pedantic, I just really like that the information about whether the comment was public or private would be right in the button they are clicking, the thing they're focusing on as they post ;)