Loomio

Add smileys support ?

Deleted account PublicSeen by 162

I was thinking it would be cool to replace some common signs by smileys in posts and comments. It's an easy thing to implement and it can add some coolness to the UI. Don't you think ?

Rob

And yes, @goob, if you hate smileys and emoji you definitely should block any attempt to implement support for them. And it should take a whole lot of yes votes to overcome your (or anyone else's) block. Cause it will significantly alter the landscape, no doubt.

StefOfficiel

The graphics of smilies allows given color.

It's almost as if you were chatting in a chat with someone and you send him a picture (Snapchat, MMS whatever) with a grin! It's more alive than explained that grimace text!

By cons when I speak of emoticons or smileys, I'm referring to the basic ones such as these:

:-) :-D :-P :-( :-/ etc...

To overcome the problems, it is possible to make [;-D] for example !

Personally I'm not a fan of big emoji where there are hundreds!

I saw more than a small batch of smileys like a phpBB forum!

Rob

I promise you this: Once you open the pandora's box of graphic smileys there's gonna be no stopping the flood. So either keep that box shut tight, or face it head on, embrace the madness, and do it right.

Deleted account

@goob : I think you are thinking too pragmatic. The problem I see with no smileys is not a semantic one. It is aesthetic one. Smileys are fun, that's all. And what is fun makes d* more attractive, more intuitive.

Now, I understand your position. In a sense, I feel that you fear smileys to turn diaspora* into an empty social network, with no critical sense, like Facebook is, and I can't refrain from agreeing with you... It's difficult...

goob

Smileys are fun, that’s all.

We can also disagree on this point, then.

Deleted account

Well, for a great part of the users, at least think I. Maybe we sould vote ?

StefOfficiel

I tend to agree with @augier. Smileys are fun. Following as evoked @augier if your concern is that Diaspora become a Facebook uninteresting, do you honestly believe that it will be different without smileys?
I'm sure not. And then it takes for everyone. Let's vote!

Should we implement graphic smileys in chat, posts and comments with possibility to disable auto-transform text to graphic smileys ?

proposal by Deleted account Closed Tue 21 Oct 2014 6:29PM

Outcome
by Deleted account

Not relevant

Currently, the Jappix chat automaticly transform text smileys to graphic smileys. Should we keep this feature and extend it to posts and comments with the possibility to disable the automatic transform to graphic smileys ?

Results

Faldrian
Disagree

I don't want to see graphic smileys. If I turn them off and their token-code is not ascii-readable as the same emotion, that would be a big no-go for readability. And people will start wishing for other kinds of smileys. So: No.

Roy
Agree

Absolutely. This NIMBY attitude about smileys is startling. Nearly every socially connected application web or otherwise supports smileys. There must be a way to turn them off, I think that is fair, but to ban them outright is ridiculous.

Roy
Agree

Absolutely. This NIMBY attitude about smileys/emojis is startling. Nearly every socially connected application web or otherwise supports smileys. There must be a way to turn them off, I think that is fair, but to ban them outright is ridiculous.

Jonne Haß
Disagree

I yet have to see a smiley set that would integrate well into diasporas design. I agree to such a general proposal.

Jonne Haß
Disagree

I yet have to see a smiley set that would integrate well into diasporas design. I cannot agree to such a general proposal.

Flaburgan
Abstain

Anyone can already embed any images he wants. I don't care, but I will not spent my time to work on something useless like that.

Rob
Abstain

I lean slightly in the direction of sure, let's have smileys. But the way it's implemented will determine how much of a nuisance they are, so I can't really vote Yes until I see a more detailed implementation strategy.

Jonne Haß
Disagree

Sorry, now that I read the proposal I don't even have to comment on the issue. This is NOT a proposal. It doesn't contain a clear statement that one can agree to or not agree to, instead it's phrased as question.

Jonne Haß
Block

Sorry, now that I read the proposal I don't even have to comment on the issue. This is NOT a proposal. It doesn't contain a clear statement that one can agree to or not agree to, instead it's phrased as question. Please make a clear proposal.

shirish
Agree

Smileys have been the done since IRC and possibly even before that. The first hello world might have been the smiley. Graphical smiley which convert to normal ASCII smileys and vice-versa would be good.

riveravaldez
Abstain

I fail to see the necessity of this feature.

Jason Robinson
Abstain

Don't care myself really - as long as ALL graphical smileys can be disabled by a user then whatever :) Any implementation without a possibility to disable showing smileys I would block as strongly as one can :P

Elm
Disagree

«A separate input method for inserting the unicode emojis (= “text”) with a nice icon font that matches our design could better do the trick.»

Brent Bartlett
Disagree

Given that this issue is so contentious, we probably should hold off on this until we've ironed out the issues a bit more. IMO, development with Jappix should move forward with the smilies left in. Design issues can be fixed later.

Rasmus Fuhse
Disagree

Just a personal note: I don't like emoticons at all. Sentences spiked with emoticons take me longer to read them correctly and sometimes I still won't understand what they mean. I'd be happy not to support emoticons that much in Diaspora.

Asher
Agree

You can do smilies in text. I think it is logical to represent them graphically. Also, phones can type unicode emoticons but right now I think diaspora filters them out.

Deleted account
Block

What? Is this about the chat? about comments? about posts? Please clarify the proposal and don't mix multiple topics.

Trolli Schmittlauch
Agree

Maybe this can be done based on Emojis instead of graphics

Deleted account
Block

I realize my proposition was really not clear. I will open another to clarify things.

StefOfficiel
Block

The question was not clear, @Augier am asking you to vote for BLOCK make a new proposal.

Roy

Embedding images is not a solution for emoticons and it is ridiculous to offer that as a solution.

Roy

I also wouldn't say diaspora has much of a design aesthetic currently. It's mostly a bootstrap-esque design. I do not agree that smiley's would be so detrimental to the design to not make them an option for people who want them. It would be easy to convert an emoji to its textual alternative for the NIMBY's: http://www.emoji-cheat-sheet.com

Jonne Haß

Note that I'm not so much referring to to the tile as to the description. Also it doesn't give the possibility to express the valid opinion to keep smileys in the chat but not integrate them anywhere else.

Jonne Haß

@roy2 there was generally very little community discussion in these days. Also that removed converting things like :-) to Unicode emojis, not graphical smileys

Roy

huh?

Deleted account

Also it doesn’t give the possibility to express the valid opinion to keep smileys in the chat but not integrate them anywhere else.

@jonnehass : It can be the subject of another proposition.

To make the proposition clearer :

Currently, the chat front-end converts text-smileys to graphic smileys.

I propose to add a feature to let the user disable this auto-convertion and extend the system to posts and comments.

Jonne Haß

If you intend multiple proposals then don't mix the topics, make one for whether we want them in the chat and one for whether we want them anywhere else. And as said avoid questions, make a clear statement to a agree or disagree with.

Jason Robinson

I am also concerned that there was already support for smiley’s but that support was ripped out with any community discussion

That was when community didn't have power to discuss. You might know things have changed ;) (hint: no company behind the project, just a community)

Florian Staudacher

I don't mind smileys as long as it doesn't auto-convert a combination of symbols to a graphic. I want my punctation to remain as I intended, and I also don't want to have images in my text where there should be none.

A separate input method for inserting the unicode emojis (= "text") with a nice icon font that matches our design could do the trick.

Roy

To expect people to be technical enough to locate an emoji image and also know markdown to embed the emoji as a solution to enabling emoji's on the site is a ridiculous solution. Hope that cleared it up for ya @brentbartlett!

Deleted account

A separate input method for inserting the unicode emojis (= “text”) with a nice icon font that matches our design could better do the trick.

This is what I expected to do at first. Jappix has a text-smileys replacement system hard-coded. I wanted to modify it to let podmins have their own smileys. But I don't want to spend too much time on that question. I didn't expect that topic to be that long and controversial.

Brent Bartlett

@roym Sure, THAT would be ridiculous, but there are probably better ways to do it. For example, you could have a menu which lets you select the emoji and then inserts the Markdown for you.

goob

I notice that several people who have voted 'yes' to this proposal have expressed opinions in their comments which are opposed to this proposal, for example the most recent one, 'Maybe this can be done based on Emojis instead of graphics.

Which just goes to show that this isn't a proper, clear proposal - which is why I haven't voted.

Deleted account

Please vote block. I will too. I wrote the proposition the wrong way. I will open clearer one soon.

goob

@augier, if you don't want this proposal to continue, you can close it now (as you opened it).