Add smileys support ?
I was thinking it would be cool to replace some common signs by smileys in posts and comments. It's an easy thing to implement and it can add some coolness to the UI. Don't you think ?
Personally, it frustrates me to use Diaspora without smileys, I use Diaspora because I know it's still in dev. But if tomorrow, Diaspora is stable version, and having voluntarily transferred the smiley for outlandish reasons, I think it would be one of the point you have to leave! And by then, social networks, there will surely others ...
Smileys have always existed on the web. And then well the hashtag @ uses for city smileys why someone would suddenly lost their place ? For what it's kikoolol ? And ?
Knowing a <3 currently doing a heart ...
Hi all, A net user since mid 90s. I dunno how people equate smileys with fb/facebook only. I remember being on usenet and IRC in the first few days being on chat and the same was also used, abused, exploited whatever in email and all sort of correspondence since then. Characters like :) :P :( and others do share from where a person is coming from. If a person makes a rude statement about something or somebody when s/he is in a sad state, people would perhaps have a bit more latitude to that person, or otherwise be more rude to that person.
I do understand that it could go to the other extreme as well and have no answer for that. If D* wants to have non-geeky people this would be one of the basic features people would like.
We can have debates about the best way to achieve that but not having it would probably be an dodo like attitude .
My 2 paise.
If D* wants to have non-geeky people
That question that seems to be at the heart of just about every feature discussion here...
That question that seems to be at the heart of just about every feature discussion here…
An that's a bad thing ? In what ?
diaspora* is a social network, naturally attempting to reach each and every person, not only the computer scientists...
We know how to escape characters because we've used it a lot. Not everyone do... This is logic.
@augier It's not a bad thing at all. I completely agree with you! Read my earlier comments, I'm all for smiley's and understand them as essential even though I don't particularly need them myself :)
@rob12 : Okey, I apologize ! :)
@stefofficiel @shirish
Yes, we've always had smilies, but the decision to make them into graphics has been more recent. In fact, we have smilies on Diaspora right now, as :) and =P and >:-( all work. The argument is whether or not to include graphics.
FWIW, I'm not against graphics, although I do think that UTF-8's extended character sets are a more elegant solution. I also quite like emojis, like they have on Ello. The issue I have is with text substitution.
I quite like @Flaburgan's suggestion here:
https://github.com/diaspora/diaspora/pull/4860
Add a link to the ASCII table in the publisher. This gives users easy access to smilies as well lots of other special characters. Perhaps it could be a dropdown menu, or something like that?
Which do not help me to decide whether or not to drop the graphics smileys on Jappix ! :)
IMO, it makes more sense to have the extension conform to Diaspora, not change Diaspora to conform to the extension. I'm in favor of dropping them from Jappix.
@rob12
The software SHOULD show me everyone else’s smileys (or emoticons, or emoji..) exactly as they intended it. I’m not sure, but it sounds like some people are saying they never even want to see a smiley (for aesthetic purposes?) and so want an option to filter them out while reading other people’s posts. That sounds pretty misguided, bordering on censorship. You might as well filter out all swear words, or words that begin with the letter Q, or the names of football teams you don’t like…
Oh, not this argument again. How on earth does choosing what I see amount to censorship? You might as well say I'm censoring by choosing not to read every single blog post on the internet. It doesn't stop anyone from publishing what they want (which is what censorship actually means); it just enables me, personally, to choose what I see, personally, with my own eyes. Please don't call this migsuided or try to equate it with censorship.
ps: I'm just about to 'censor' all films currently on release by not going to the cinema tonight.
Another way of saying it: censorship is preventing people from saying what they want to say. Allowing people to choose what they see doesn't prevent anyone from saying what they want to say, so isn't censorship. What you're proposing, on the other hand, means forcing people to see what they don't want to see, which is definitely misguided.
@goob On more pragmatic means : we cannot store unfinished posts and treats how to display them based on wether or not they decided to display smileys in their timeline.
If we decide to implement smileys, it's everything or nothing : the poster deceided to have smileys, everyone sees smileys. The poster decided not to, nobody sees smileys.
IMO, it makes more sense to have the extension conform to Diaspora, not change Diaspora to conform to the extension.
I agree with you, but still, I think ddefinitively dropping graphic smileys is a huge step backward...
You've mentioned me name in your reply but quoted someone else, and appear to be addressing a point not made by me.
@goob Well, I said bordering on censorship. I know it's not the same. I probably shouldn't have used the word at all, sorry. Not sure what else to call it, but I still think it's a really bad idea. Not horribly dangerous and illegal like actual censorship, just bad for communication in general. If I am using a certain platform to communicate with you, then I am trusting the platform to deliver my message accurately to you. Once delivered, you can do whatever you please with it. It's totally your right to install or create a browser extension to block or alter things however you want. I just don't think the platform should be complicit in the mangling of my message. That erodes my trust in the platform.
@goob : I was answering to :
Allowing people to choose what they see doesn’t prevent anyone from saying what they want to say, so isn’t censorship. What you’re proposing, on the other hand, means forcing people to see what they don’t want to see, which is definitely misguided.
And I wanted to mean that we cannot format written messages based on the willing of every one that is going to see them.
To answer both Rob and Augier:
In what way does replacing a yellow cartoon smiley with a text-based emoticon (and potentially vice versa) change the meaning or content of a post? Text-based emoticons and their cartoon equivalents convey (or are intended to convey) the same significance. Really, it's akin to displaying a message in a different typeface. There's no change in meaning. There would potentially be a change in meaning if smileys were completely blocked, which is what Rob proposes above.
I will absolutely block any proposal to introduce support for graphical smileys without also introduce a user option to display their text-based equivalents. That is a terrible idea.
@goob It occurs to me you might be thinking of this as just a display question, but I see it as a content question.
This would be the quick and superficial way to implement:
User A has "convert to smileys" option turned on, types a message with :), sees a graphic smiley, but the message is stored with the original plain :). Then when the message is displayed to User B there is another opportunity to convert it again or not, and so it seems logical that User B should have some say in the matter. I would call this a non-implementation, since User A has no reason to believe his message will be seen as intended, and the smileys basically amount to window dressing for his own amusement.
I think this is the correct implementation:
User A has "convert to smileys" option turned on, types a message with :), and it is actually converted to a graphic smiley. Or maybe they choose from a menu of graphic smileys, or emojis, or god-knows-what other awful dancing sparkly stupid things he wants to include. Either way, the graphic smiley (or at least, some code indicating THAT specific graphic smiley) is embedded with the stored message, and is PART of the message, as if I had embedded my own custom image or anything else.
If I think a winking smiley, a monkey, a birthday cake, and a pair of sunglasses is an essential part of my message, then the platform should respect that and deliver it faithfully. If you think that makes me sound like a dumb teenager then you can block me, but don't ask the platform to change what I said.
In what way does replacing a yellow cartoon smiley with a text-based emoticon (and potentially vice versa) change the meaning or content of a post? Text-based emoticons and their cartoon equivalents convey (or are intended to convey) the same significance. Really, it’s akin to displaying a message in a different typeface. There’s no change in meaning.
I don't think there really is an obvious one-to-one map of text to graphic and back to text when you get into more complicated smileys, and especially with emoji, etc. Yes, for the simple ones like :) and ;) the meaning is pretty clear, but there is WHOLE world of graphic icons out there, with different subtleties and accents. Every smiling face is not the same. That's like if I posted a picture of my dog, and you changed it to a different dog and said "what's the difference? It's still a dog".
There are really two debates getting mixed up here:
Should we support smileys or emoji or anything like that at all? This is a valid debate about how essential these things are to communication in general, how much we want to cater to the general public, etc. I would personally be totally fine with none of this stuff on D* whatsoever -- though I also see the point of those who argue for it.
IF WE DO decide to support them, how should it be done. This is what I feel strongly about. If we are going to support them, we should support them correctly and properly. Your suggestion is essentially feature sabotage: "Sure, go ahead and implement as long as it doesn't affect me in any way". I don't think that's valid. Either you implement or you don't, but if you do implement you implement correctly.
There would potentially be a change in meaning if smileys were completely blocked, which is what Rob proposes above.
Where did I propose that?
And yes, @goob, if you hate smileys and emoji you definitely should block any attempt to implement support for them. And it should take a whole lot of yes votes to overcome your (or anyone else's) block. Cause it will significantly alter the landscape, no doubt.
The graphics of smilies allows given color.
It's almost as if you were chatting in a chat with someone and you send him a picture (Snapchat, MMS whatever) with a grin! It's more alive than explained that grimace text!
By cons when I speak of emoticons or smileys, I'm referring to the basic ones such as these:
:-) :-D :-P :-( :-/ etc...
To overcome the problems, it is possible to make [;-D] for example !
Personally I'm not a fan of big emoji where there are hundreds!
I saw more than a small batch of smileys like a phpBB forum!
I promise you this: Once you open the pandora's box of graphic smileys there's gonna be no stopping the flood. So either keep that box shut tight, or face it head on, embrace the madness, and do it right.
@goob : I think you are thinking too pragmatic. The problem I see with no smileys is not a semantic one. It is aesthetic one. Smileys are fun, that's all. And what is fun makes d* more attractive, more intuitive.
Now, I understand your position. In a sense, I feel that you fear smileys to turn diaspora* into an empty social network, with no critical sense, like Facebook is, and I can't refrain from agreeing with you... It's difficult...
Smileys are fun, that’s all.
We can also disagree on this point, then.
Well, for a great part of the users, at least think I. Maybe we sould vote ?
I tend to agree with @augier. Smileys are fun. Following as evoked @augier if your concern is that Diaspora become a Facebook uninteresting, do you honestly believe that it will be different without smileys?
I'm sure not. And then it takes for everyone. Let's vote!
Should we implement graphic smileys in chat, posts and comments with possibility to disable auto-transform text to graphic smileys ?
proposal by Deleted account Closed Tue 21 Oct 2014 6:29PM
Not relevant
Currently, the Jappix chat automaticly transform text smileys to graphic smileys. Should we keep this feature and extend it to posts and comments with the possibility to disable the automatic transform to graphic smileys ?
Results
| Results | Option | Votes | % of votes cast | % of eligible voters | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Agree | 8 | 36 | 5 | ||
| Abstain | 4 | 18 | 3 | ||
| Disagree | 6 | 27 | 4 | ||
| Block | 4 | 18 | 3 | ||
| Not voted | 126 | 85 |
I don't want to see graphic smileys. If I turn them off and their token-code is not ascii-readable as the same emotion, that would be a big no-go for readability. And people will start wishing for other kinds of smileys. So: No.
Absolutely. This NIMBY attitude about smileys is startling. Nearly every socially connected application web or otherwise supports smileys. There must be a way to turn them off, I think that is fair, but to ban them outright is ridiculous.
Absolutely. This NIMBY attitude about smileys/emojis is startling. Nearly every socially connected application web or otherwise supports smileys. There must be a way to turn them off, I think that is fair, but to ban them outright is ridiculous.
I yet have to see a smiley set that would integrate well into diasporas design. I agree to such a general proposal.
I yet have to see a smiley set that would integrate well into diasporas design. I cannot agree to such a general proposal.
Anyone can already embed any images he wants. I don't care, but I will not spent my time to work on something useless like that.
I lean slightly in the direction of sure, let's have smileys. But the way it's implemented will determine how much of a nuisance they are, so I can't really vote Yes until I see a more detailed implementation strategy.
Sorry, now that I read the proposal I don't even have to comment on the issue. This is NOT a proposal. It doesn't contain a clear statement that one can agree to or not agree to, instead it's phrased as question.
Sorry, now that I read the proposal I don't even have to comment on the issue. This is NOT a proposal. It doesn't contain a clear statement that one can agree to or not agree to, instead it's phrased as question. Please make a clear proposal.
Smileys have been the done since IRC and possibly even before that. The first hello world might have been the smiley. Graphical smiley which convert to normal ASCII smileys and vice-versa would be good.
Just requires unwanted work.
I fail to see the necessity of this feature.
Don't care myself really - as long as ALL graphical smileys can be disabled by a user then whatever :) Any implementation without a possibility to disable showing smileys I would block as strongly as one can :P
I definitely think we can do better.
«A separate input method for inserting the unicode emojis (= “text”) with a nice icon font that matches our design could better do the trick.»
Given that this issue is so contentious, we probably should hold off on this until we've ironed out the issues a bit more. IMO, development with Jappix should move forward with the smilies left in. Design issues can be fixed later.
Just a personal note: I don't like emoticons at all. Sentences spiked with emoticons take me longer to read them correctly and sometimes I still won't understand what they mean. I'd be happy not to support emoticons that much in Diaspora.
You can do smilies in text. I think it is logical to represent them graphically. Also, phones can type unicode emoticons but right now I think diaspora filters them out.
What? Is this about the chat? about comments? about posts? Please clarify the proposal and don't mix multiple topics.
Maybe this can be done based on Emojis instead of graphics
Problem is, it's not only Facebook... It's as old as I use Internet (1998) I'm used t use them since I used MSN. For better or worse, they exists and are widely used, not only on Facebook.
I agree we shouldn't bend to whatever Facebook make, but we have a tiny latitude to move. Our decision should not impersonate lack of features.
I agree that smileys could be such a non-essential feature that we can afford to throw them. But I think we have to seriously discuss if his absence can hurt.