What we have to do with email notifications?
I always deactivate email notifications and I think most people do the same. In Equo people is using many internet tools. One of the first things they have told me about loomio is that they have received so many notifications. In the search of the consensus...
Support Rob's idea
I'd like for users to choose their own settings during account set-up, and for it to be super clear and easy to opt out (while also making it clear why email notifications might be important for some people).
@yagoabati, regarding your comment "Another good idea is to create a visible link into the email to disable notifications", did you notice that the emails have a link "Unsubscribe or change your email preferences" at the end of them?
I don't think turning off email notifications by default is a good idea. As I have a lot of subgroups to track, I find email notifications to be incredibly useful for ensuring that I stay on the up-and-up relating to what's going on.
I just worry that newcomers might mistakenly think there's not any activity going on if their emails are automatically switched to "off".
As an aside, would it be reasonable to instead do daily email digests with a summary of active discussions and comments in an email?
I think we have only half finished this feature, which is why it's not ideal yet - the other part is functionality so you can reply by email. If we had that, I think we'd clearly see engagement going up thanks to email notifications. But that's a question that can only be settled by actual testing.
Love where that thought is heading @Sean: maybe if there were more content in the daily digest there'd be less need for the New Discussion and New Proposal emails.
I agree with @jonlemmon - I think that the "someone mentioned you" and "proposal closing soon" emails are good to have on by default.
Replying by email would be a wonderful feature in and of itself. It's one of my favorite things about GitHub, and the interactivity adds real value for users that don't want to log in to the site from mobile.
Oh yes.. i'm sorry @matthewbartlett ! what do you think about "permit administratos to manage group notifications" vote !
I think we should ensure that the new user signup process includes a screen where the user is given a choice for email notifications.. So we don't need a default for people to opt in or out of. However if they choose to opt out of really important emails then we should warn them of the risk of not being engaged.. and if someone turns off notifications and does not login for a week or 2 then we should email them once, as a last chance to ask them to reconsider their choice.
please anyone knows why i can not close the proposal? @richarddbartlett i would like to reopen another one with Rob proposal!
@yago In PIRATA we do need Email notifications...in fact most of us would love to have the possibility of partcipating to conversations on Loomio through their email clients and enter the platform only to cast their votes :-). So I think Loomio should remain as flexible as possible.
Hi @yago, you should definitely be able to close the proposal! Is the Close 'proposal' button not showing on the right-hand side? Let me know if you have trouble!
Thanks @benjaminknight now it works. I don't know why yesterday the button was gone!
@robertguthrie I like your proposal but i don't see why its incompatible with permitting administrators to manage group notifications. Why they can not coexist together?
@richarddbartlett i would like to leave open this proposal and open a new one with @robertguthrie `s.. but its not possible!! :(... :)
@Yago, you've identified another aspect of Loomio that needs work (and that people are currently working on solutions for) - concurrent proposals within a discussion!
It's also a tricky question, but we're confident that with everyone's input we can collaborate an elegant solution in the coming months.
Regarding notifications, I'd venture a guess that if you can come up with a proposal that allows for the harmonious coexistence of new users selecting their email settings during account set-up AND admin ability to manage group notifications, then you're likely to get quite a few thumbs up :)
It's also totally fine to leave the conversation going a bit longer as the ideas are further developed before a new proposal goes up - something we see over and over in Loomio is that it's really easy to get shared group agreement once the discussion has been sufficient to build shared understanding, but can be tricky otherwise (especially if it's a complex issue with multiple components).
Adding onto Rob's suggestion, I think every time you join a group there could be a popup asking you to choose your notification settings for that group. People don't join groups very often, so I don't think the extra click would be that annoying, and I think there could be a lot of benefit.
@jonlemmon your idea popped into my head too. I think you're right: When you join a group you should be made aware/given the choice about email notifications for that group.
@yago I've enjoyed this discussion. thanks for bringing it up. You asked about group admins setting defaults - 2 points:
a) I like to keep admins as unnecessary as possible.
b) I don't think that admins are going to be significantly better than anyone else at deciding what a particular user would like, if we have to sacrifice consistency of the default when joining a group then I don't think it's worth it.
Mockup time I think
Aaa. Options creep!
oh! why @ don't work inside proposals texts!!?? Thanks everyone I think the two colums: discussion-proposalvoting is a very powerful consensus searcher!! :)
Just want to say I really like seeing this discussion happening! It's great to get a diverse range of viewpoints and work toward the best solution.
A choice during group joining would be nice. But if possible I would avoid pop-ups which some find disturbing. It could be an option part in the join-group page. And it should include other options to keep user informed/involved on group activity: weekly summary mail, x days until close and RSS feed.
This is like a consensus proposal!
:) let's go on, which is the next step?
The next step is to create some mockups! =)
The Loomio collaborative design process currently looks something like this:
- Someone identifies a problem or presents an idea to the group
- The group discusses and comes to an agreement of what the solution should be
- At this point, anyone can create mockups to convey how the feature might look inside the app
- The group approves one of the mockups
- An interested developer decides to pick up the feature and code it.
- Once the developer is finished, the code gets reviewed, revised if necessary, and then accepted and deployed onto the site. =)
So, Yago if you or anyone else are interested in creating a mockup for the proposed solution please do so! A mockup is just a couple of screenshots showing what the feature will look like and an explanation how it works (e.g. what happens when you press the buttons?).
I for one love email notifications. I wouldn't be commenting here if not for them. But it would be awesome to see this move out of the realm of anecdotes and into the realm of data. That would help a lot in identifying a solution. Data like:
Just adding knobs isn't always an improvement, without understanding the underlying problem well. How will administrators decide, other than with more anecdotes or assumptions?