Loomio

~~ Loomio Community: The Wall ~~

Jon Lemmon PublicSeen by 548

This is a place for anyone to share stuff with the Loomio Community that doesn't really deserve its own discussion. You can post links to videos or blog posts, rants, etc.

Think of it as the "high volume, low priority" area within the Loomio Community.

Benjamin Knight

A less current but still really interesting article about the political situation in Hungary

"Until recently, Hungary was deeply divided.

Half of the population believed that only the socialists could be trusted to run the country's affairs competently. They despised the current Prime Minister, Viktor Orban, as a populist demagogue.

Meanwhile, the other half saw Mr Orban as a saviour from the corruption of the socialists, who were seen as a bunch of detestable self-serving ex-communist apparatchiks in new suits.

But now the country is becoming more united again - united in despair at the entire political class."

Simon Tegg

Just ordered this book Tempo from fishpond (not amazon)

Richard D. Bartlett

Good spotting @simontegg.

If there were a subgroup in the Loomio Community for Loomio Admins, I would invite the admin of that group to it. It would be a great place to start having conversations about how some groups are structuring themselves with Loomio. e.g. it might be useful for the Chakra Project to set up a broad public group to replace their mailing list, and a narrower private/closed-access sub-group for decision-making.

Alanna Irving

I think an Admins subgroup could be a great idea... they have it on the yammer customer network, for example, and discuss things only relevant to admins. Might not be needed until we have a more fully featured set of admins tools though.

Richard D. Bartlett

I was thinking of it more as a place for sharing best practices for the 'cultural technology' aspects of Loomio.

Alanna Irving

Went to the Startup Compass (the ones who created the startup genome project) website to see if Startup Genome Project was capitalized, and got utterly lost in their blog ... careful @simontegg and @richarddbartlett tharr be dragons!

Chloe Waretini (Loomio Helper)

Jon Siddall who I met last year when he had been in NZ working on some social enterprise sector development stuff is in Wellington this week presenting at the Philanthropy NZ conference. His area of expertise is Venture Philanthropy - in particular getting ventures ready for sizable investment. He has been back in the UK doing a One Planet MBA at Exeter Business School. I told him about you guys last year and he was pretty interested. Let me know if any of you would like an introduction!

uk.linkedin.com/in/siddalljon

Alanna Irving

@benjaminknight @vivienmaidaborn what do you think about meeting Chloe's contact?

Benjamin Knight

Thanks for the offer @chloewaretini! Do you know if Jon is going to be around on Thursday or Friday? An email intro would be great

Alanna Irving

A small but exciting piece of news: this community has grown so much that I had to bump up the "max members" size for this group!

Jeff Swift

Is there any discussion about making the Loomio API open or making it embeddable in another site? I would imagine there are some groups who would be interested in using Loomio but would rather keep people on their site rather than sending them somewhere else.

I apologize if this issue has already been addressed--I haven't been able to find it in the various discussion in the community but that doesn't mean it hasn't been discussed.

Richard D. Bartlett

Hi @jeffswift, the question of an API has come up a few times. As far as I understand it, it is not a top priority yet, but there is a pretty strong sense that it is going to be a very important part of Loomio's large-scale adoption.

My technical knowledge is pretty threadbare on this topic but to the best of my knowledge, good object-oriented coding practices are preparing the ground for an API in the future. So progress is being made, even if no one is explicitly thinking 'I'm building the Loomio API'. Is that fair @jonlemmon?

p.s. it would probably be good to take this conversation to the Code group if we want to get technical :)

Jon Lemmon

@jeffswift yes, transitioning Loomio to using an API that anyone can access is definitely on the cards.

Embedding in other websites... we talked about this a while ago, but I think there are some other priorities which are going to have to get sorted out first (e.g. making the site faster, making the UI responsive). Check out this trello board to see what's on our radar for the next few months (specifically, have a look at the By June column).

Alanna Irving

Saw readrboard in the wild for the first time today. Interesting! Essentially lets you make one word comments on individual words or sentences in text on the web. Something to consider for our "comment on comments" need?

Jon Lemmon

It looks like it hasn't been announced yet, but I just noticed that Trello has released their "business class" package, basically just extra organisational features for Trello targeted toward larger businesses. Really interesting to see the feature set they provide and their pricing structure:

https://trello.com/business-class

The features are stuff that really only businesses would need, and it's also quite cheap (and isn't dependent on the number of users).

@benjaminknightloom @vivienmaidabornloo @simontegg

Matthew Bartlett

Some GK Chesterton, from A Miscellany of Men, 1912, that resonated for me:

Self-government arose among men (probably among the primitive men, certainly among the ancients) out of an idea which seems now too simple to be understood. The notion of self-government was not (as many modern friends and foes of it seem to think) the notion that the ordinary citizen is to be consulted as one consults an Encyclopaedia. He is not there to be asked a lot of fancy questions, to see how he answers them. He and his fellows are to be, within reasonable human limits, masters of their own lives. They shall decide whether they shall be men of the oar or the wheel, of the spade or the spear. The men of the valley shall settle whether the valley shall be devastated for coal or covered with corn and vines; the men of the town shall decide whether it shall be hoary with thatches or splendid with spires. Of their own nature and instinct they shall gather under a patriarchal chief or debate in a political market-place. And in case the word "man" be misunderstood, I may remark that in this moral atmosphere, this original soul of self-government, the women always have quite as much influence as the men. But in modern England neither the men nor the women have any influence at all. In this primary matter, the moulding of the landscape, the creation of a mode of life, the people are utterly impotent. They stand and stare at imperial and economic processes going on, as they might stare at the Lord Mayor's Show.
Round about where I live, for instance, two changes are taking place which really affect the land and all things that live on it, whether for good or evil. The first is that the urban civilisation (or whatever it is) is advancing; that the clerks come out in black swarms and the villas advance in red battalions. The other is that the vast estates into which England has long been divided are passing out of the hands of the English gentry into the hands of men who are always upstarts and often actually foreigners.
Now, these are just the sort of things with which self-government was really supposed to grapple. People were supposed to be able to indicate whether they wished to live in town or country, to be represented by a gentleman or a cad. I do not presume to prejudge their decision; perhaps they would prefer the cad; perhaps he is really preferable. I say that the filling of a man's native sky with smoke or the selling of his roof over his head illustrate the sort of things he ought to have some say in, if he is supposed to be governing himself. But owing to the strange trend of recent society, these enormous earthquakes he has to pass over and treat as private trivialities. In theory the building of a villa is as incidental as the buying of a hat. In reality it is as if all Lancashire were laid waste for deer forests; or as if all Belgium were flooded by the sea. In theory the sale of a squire's land to a moneylender is a minor and exceptional necessity. In reality it is a thing like a German invasion. Sometimes it is a German invasion.
Upon this helpless populace, gazing at these prodigies and fates, comes round about every five years a thing called a General Election. It is believed by antiquarians to be the remains of some system of self-government; but it consists solely in asking the citizen questions about everything except what he understands.

Alanna Irving

Blog post written by Jason Kottke after "The Wisdom of Crowds" was published in 2004...


The wisdom of crowds you say? As Surowiecki explains, yes, but only under the right conditions. In order for a crowd to be smart, he says it needs to satisfy four conditions:

  1. Diversity. A group with many different points of view will make better decisions than one where everyone knows the same information. Think multi-disciplinary teams building Web sites...programmers, designers, biz dev, QA folks, end users, and copywriters all contributing to the process, each has a unique view of what the final product should be. Contrast that with, say, the President of the US and his Cabinet.

  2. Independence. "People's opinions are not determined by those around them." AKA, avoiding the circular mill problem.

  3. Decentralization. "Power does not fully reside in one central location, and many of the important decisions are made by individuals based on their own local and specific knowledge rather than by an omniscient or farseeing planner." The open source software development process is an example of effect decentralization in action.

  4. Aggregation. You need some way of determining the group's answer from the individual responses of its members. The evils of design by committee are due in part to the lack of correct aggregation of information. A better way to harness a group for the purpose of designing something would be for the group's opinion to be aggregated by an individual who is skilled at incorporating differing viewpoints into a single shared vision and for everyone in the group to be aware of that process (good managers do this). Aggregation seems to be the most tricky of the four conditions to satisfy because there are so many different ways to aggregate opinion, not all of which are right for a given situation.

Satisfy those four conditions and you've hopefully cancelled out some of the error involved in all decision making.

Simon Tegg

Here is a governance model for an open-source "meritocratic, consensus-based community project." Mojito

Nicolas Wormser

@simontegg Very interesting overall! I especially like the section 5.3 on the different type of approvals. Offering the possibility to make a proposal with specific approval patterns/rules (majority approval, unanimous consensus etc…) would be very valuable I think.

Richard D. Bartlett

Very cool @simontegg. Do you want to reach out to them and invite them into Loomio? Looks like they would have a lot to teach us.

Danyl Strype

After the meeting the other day, I am thinking an open source community institution developing a repository of best-practice governance models, constitutions, privacy policies, CLAs etc etc would be really valuable. This is beyond the scope of even the FSF or OSI because it would be useful to anyone creating a social enterprise in any field. Community.net.nz (an advice service for people wanting to set up not-for-profits) is one example of what this could like like. Law is code!

Danyl Strype

Dave Pollard shares some insights on the history of the words democracy and consensus from the latest book by US anthropologist David Graeber:
"[Consensus] requires the ability to listen well enough to understand perspectives that are fundamentally different from one’s own, and then try to find pragmatic common ground without attempting to convert one’s interlocutors completely to one’s own perspective. It means viewing democracy as common problem solving among those who respect the fact they will always have, like all humans, somewhat incommensurable points of view.”
http://howtosavetheworld.ca/2013/04/29/the-democracy-project/

vivien maidaborn

Our colleague Wayne Mulligan mentioned Loomio in an email out to people and businesses who have supported him and his thinking as he makes his way to the USNZ business partnerships meeting in Washington DC. This is what he said...
"Kia ora, I have been asked to speak at a gathering of USA -NZ business and political leaders in Washington DC in mid May 2013.

I am extremely honoured and proud. For me working with leaders and people committed to doing the right things in business, for community and the right outcome for the environment is refreshing and energising.

You have received this because I acknowledge you and your influence.

We are not farmers, harvesters or traders.

We are instead framers; we imagine, we shape and we drive change, and we foremost value New Zealand's bio-diversity, NZ communities; NZ technology and science; and smart business partners.

Thank you.

I have chosen lyrics of a song from the 80s' Thunder Zone by Tina Turner, which sums up for me the current NZ business mindset "we do not need another hero" Let's replace hero with cow. I think the cow-hero relationship sums up the NZ parody....

Thank you whanau, friends and the following businesses: HoneyLab and Kanu; Anagenix; Loomio; Enspiral; Rima Group - Green Tech Village; Wakatu-Kono; iwiinvestor- TMG; Wi Pere; NRAIT; GibsonSheet; Udynamics; AbacusBio; Rydges; HarrisonGrierson; Poutama; Nga Mahanga - Marae Ora; Hikurangi Foundation; Fuel 5; GlobalHort; Kerasi; Foundation Trustee; Maori Tourism; and Novus- Stratum.

Alanna Irving

The debate over the supercity plan would be so much more engaging on Loomio... is this a possible target for our local councils strategy? @vivienmaidabornloo @benjaminknightloom

Richard D. Bartlett

So much to like about that email @vivienmaidabornloo

Nicolas Wormser

@matthewbartlett interresting. With this and readerboard that Alanna introduced just a few posts earlier in this thread, it's looking like in-context commenting (if I can call it so) is making its way.

But for some reason I'm not 100% sold that it should replace traditional comment systems (though it's a nice addition for very concise, contextualized comments)…

Ramsey Margolis

Co-opoly is a well thought out board game @Stypey, I have one and am keen to play the game in Wellington.

Jon Lemmon

@ramseymargolis sweet. We should host a co-opoly night at Enspiral!

Noelia

@benjaminknightloom @alannakrause @richarddbartlett do you think loomio could be interested in this? i can look in to the selection process and application and let you know, sounds really interesting and they give you the opportunity to live in Chile. I've made a bit of research about people currently doing it and they seem to be very successful
http://startupchile.org/about/the-program/

Nicolas Wormser

Waahhh… I've just discovered FrontlineSMS. Ok their website is ugly but what they're doing really is awesome.

Probably something that it would make sense to use once we have the web/smartphones app thriving, and that we want to bring good decision making practices to people who don't have access to internet / or who engage more easily with cellphones than any more recent/sophisticated technologies.

I'm so happy when is see use of open-source software that has really important social impact like that!

Richard D. Bartlett

Great article thanks @noelia. Personally, the idea of going through an entrepreneurship training program sounds pretty unappealing. I'm sure there's a lot of value there, but it's not my thing. If there's a volunteer that wants to go, then we talk about how it fits in with strategic priorities.

Noelia

@richarddbartlett right, i guess i was more amused about the idea of going to S.A working on the ground with groups facilitating and teaching them about Loomio, thats how i came across with this startup Chile "thing", but maybe isn't something you guys are interested in now, do you think that the idea of going there is still crazy? i mentioned it to @alannakrause too but didn't really talk through, would you guys support me if I'll do it? (just go to S.A not startup-Chile)

Alanna Irving

Why do co-operatives
fail as co-operatives?

Excerpt

Co-operative Difference and Advantage
The key to the formation and the ongoing development and success of any co-operative is understanding, accepting and practicing the co-operative difference and advantage. It is the recognition that there is a co-operative difference - that the structure of a co-operative is unique and different from private and public business enterprises. In accepting the co-operative difference, it logically follows that this difference creates a
co-operative advantage.

The Co-operative Difference and Advantage has five interdependent dimensions:
• A clear philosophy of co-operation.
• A governance practice that reflects and reinforces co-operation.
• A management practice that reflects and reinforces co-operation.
• An ongoing co-operative renewal program.
• An ongoing member education program.
• An ongoing member participation program.

Alanna Irving

On Citizenship in Open-source software development:
How GitHub can revolutionize the field simply by empowering the users inside the repositories they contribute

TL;DR: By giving an actual social status to the people contributing to a repository, GitHub would solve the problem of zombie-projects with a scattered community. By allowing these citizens to actually collaborate with each other, instead of just with the owner, repositories will live as long as the community exists, completely on auto-pilot.

Some food for thought @jonlemmon @richarddbartlett @robertguthrie

Jon Lemmon

@alannakrause yeah about a year ago I was thinking about this exact feature for Loomio. That pull-requests would automatically be merged based on how the Loomio community voted on them. In retrospect, it seems a bit unnecessary at the stage we're in.

Also, the types of projects he's talking about are small OS projects that one individual might maintain in their spare time. So they are much more prone to the issue he's talking about than we are. It's totally a good idea though. Would love to see that happen.

Alanna Irving

Anyone else keeping up with what they're doing with Our Capital Voice? They've now launched a discussion forum around the city budget. From what I can see, they've posted pre-formulated proposals and people can leave comments. It seems to be attracting low engagement. The topics are quite technical and are presented as foregone conclusions. Interesting to compare to a genuine public collaboration as we'd do with Loomio. Very different approach. @vivienmaidabornloo @benjaminknightloom @chelsearobinson

vivien maidaborn

I am loving the energy in this group - feels like how I imagined the Loomio community would be

Chelsea Robinson

@alannakrause I'm having coffee with Janette (mother of Our Capital Voice) tomorrow so I can pick her brains. Send me any questions you want me to ask her - I'm planning on inviting her over some time for a bigger conversation - this is just step one :)