Loomio

Gathering #16 October 7, 2021 - Cycle 3 Retrospective

Ronen Hirsch PublicSeen by 8

A container for preparations, documentation, and ripples from gathering #16

14:00-16:00 UTC (with possibility for overtime) @ Discord Congregation

Ronen Hirsch

I want to suggest the following outline and guiding questions for this gathering:

Part1: Retrospective

  1. In your mind and heart, what has this cycle achieved?

  2. What is a prominent experience you are left with from this cycle?

  3. What did you most enjoy about this cycle?

  4. What made you uncomfortable or uneasy during this cycle?

  5. What collective cultural habits have you come to appreciate and would like to carry forward?

  6. What collective cultural habits would you like to improve?

  7. What collective cultural habits would you like to leave behind?

Part2: What Next?

  1. What is currently mostly alive for you in our process?

  2. What would you like to do next?

  3. What do you feel is the correct next thing to do?

Are there are other questions for reflection that you wish to offer into the space?

I invite us all to invest some asynchronous time in this reflection (we have almost 3 weeks until the gathering). You can both contribute your own thoughts and take in and respond to thoughts offered by others in the crew. This will allow us to focus on the things that most matter to us when we are together during the synchronous gathering.

Robert Damashek

@Ronen Hirsch When you say contribute our thoughts, do you mean thoughts on the outline (such as additions/changes), or thoughts on answering the questions? I think by your suggestion you are presenting a candidate outline, and wouldn’t want us to answer the questions here.

Ronen Hirsch

Both @Robert Damashek :)

My intention was to offer the outline as a seed and an opportunity to start the conversation here asynchronously ... though clearly that invitation has not found appeal :)

And I am curious why you think I would NOT want answers here :)

Robert Damashek

Ok - I didn’t catch that asynch element of responding - agendas and synchronous meetings are so ingrained in my world 🙂 Anyway, I am posting the answers I have come up with!

Robert Damashek

@Ronen Hirsch Here are my thoughts on the questions:

Part1: Retrospective

  • In your mind and heart, what has this cycle achieved?

    1. It has introduced the GP to several people, and expanded the crew with two new members and perspectives

    2. it has produced an audio reading of the GP to make it more accessible

    3. it has begun the process of grappling with the position of money as a strong center

    4. it has led the crew to explore a new platform for collaboration on the GP

  • What is a prominent experience you are left with from this cycle?

    • An increased level of awareness about the crew (who they are, what motivates them to contribute to the crew, how they think, how they work), the GP and the collaborative process, and a sense that I can contribute.

  • What did you most enjoy about this cycle?

    • Getting to meet and being accepted into the crew

  • What made you uncomfortable or uneasy during this cycle?

    1. Newness to the team and being awkward using the sociocracy techniques

    2. Not being able to respond rapidly due to proposal workloads

    3. I feel that we have left the GP less whole because we as a crew have as yet been unable to fill the center that Money held

  • What collective cultural habits have you come to appreciate and would like to carry forward?

    1. Deep respect for each other and each one’s voice

    2. Skilled use of collaboration tools

  • What collective cultural habits would you like to improve?

    • Can’t think of any

  • What collective cultural habits would you like to leave behind?

    • Can’t think of any

 

Part2: What Next?

  • What is currently mostly alive for you in our process?

    • The crew and the GP itself

  • What would you like to do next?

    • Find a way to keep the GP more alive in us

      • Take a scenario and role play it?

      • Take a section and practice

  • What do you feel is the correct next thing to do?

    • Introduce others to the GP and gather their feedback

    • And find a way to keep the GP more alive in us

  • Are there are other questions for reflection that you wish to offer into the space?

    • Would the crew be willing to revisit how to fill the center that Money held?

      • I believe that the GP can be made whole again by adding a strong center describing the dynamics between Offer and Need as the driver for value exchange, and that this will unfold space for Money as a weak center

      • I am willing to propose those additional changes to the GP for consideration by the crew

Toni Blanco

Elements for reflection/retrospective of cycles

June 2020 - First cycle - 3 months

September 2020 - Second cycle - 5 months

February 2021 - Third cycle - 8 months

October 2021 → Fourth cycle - We don't know, but are we heading to a 12 months cycle this time?

Retrospective

  • The space sound description, crystallizing ideas of the previous cycles, and introduction of new ones.

  • A new way of not working collaboratively in the design of a generative process as more insights to do it (via negativa)

  • A better shared understanding of what we are trying to achieve, and the specifics of the invitation. The generativity of what was not understood. Alignment around the scope of work.

  • External signaling and precious feedback.

  • New members, more diversity. I feel more comfortable having Jennifer and Robert voices.

  • We squeezed Collective one, and we decided to experiment with Obsidian and Github. 

  • Alex and I envisioned a new space for collecting and experimenting with "ripened fruits" of the process, to open new possibilities of contributing to the new cycle, and also to not to defer value exchange (and money) to the moment in which the space is created.

Some learning may be more personal, not shared:

  • I understood a little bit better the work of Christopher Alexander, and how my limited understanding made me sometimes be misguided in my proposals and contributions. At the same time, I reflected a lot about the difference between crafting a generative process of an inanimated artifact such as an origami bird, and a space of social complex interaction. I also stumbled upon the work of that Japanese professor that has been experimenting for years in this field, and some of his findings such as the "egg" are now in my toolbox and I am delighted with it. 

  • However, I gained some confidence in my intuitions of the generative process. My comments and objections were seen at first (or at least that is my perception) as me being out of tune with the wholeness of the generative process, but finally even Ronen himself felt, for instance, the weakness of the money sequence.

  • I also enjoyed the richness of the different contributions of the new, and the different energies we brought in. The joy of finding other beautiful souls with other talents and offers that the ones we could bring in.

  • I understood also the other day that the concept o microsolidarity is not after the idea of solidarity being micro, but the collective being solidary being micro. Isn't it?


What's next. 

  • I have the feeling that we could benefit from making a new version of the generative process just with the most essential. I imagine for instance to see a prioritization of cards from each of us (picking a limited number), talking, and seeing what we feel stronger after listening to each other.

  • Exploring together options/possibilities/scenarios of a concrete implementation would clarify, in my opinion, the money dimension of the generative process. As I said, the generative process of the Japanese tea house nor describe the process of the first one ever built, nor the funding model of its construction.

  • Refining the tools for working together and improve the generative process.

  • Designing in our lab experiences/tasters of the space. Share them out there.

Ronen Hirsch

Retrospective

For me this cycle has a flavor of maturity, commitment and focus. While we may still become musical producers, we are, for now, focused on manifesting in the world a digital space. There are, in my mind, a few indicators for this:

  1. The GP has arrived at a kind of steady-state. Though it can and will continue to unfold it feels like a "thing"

  2. This. in turn, feels like it made us available to (summon?) encounter, connect and integrate Jennifer & Robert into the crew.

  3. This has placed a kind of evolutionary pressure on the need to collaborate, which has led to Josh initiating a tool transition.

For me, the most prominent experience was the initial call with Robert & Jennifer while I was in Israel. The stark contrast between feeling alienated in Israel vs. feeling belonging in the crew (while it was shifting phase!).

I most enjoyed the feeling that whatever we have done so far has placed us in tune with an emergent field. I sensed this emergent field in the way that a random stimulus within the crew led to my meeting with Jennifer which led to her & Robert fluidly joining the crew which led to the friction around money which led to a kind of distillation of the GP which led to the conclusion of this cycle and to the aroma of another cycle already in the air.

I continue to feel uneasy around a kind of gap that exists between our collective wish to dedicate ourselves to this work and our actual ability to do so.

I look forward to feeling like the force of initiation is shared and more spread out among the crew. I feel like a lot of initiation sits with me. I experience it both as a power and an obligation, both of which are qualities I prefer to be more distributed in the crew.

I deeply appreciate our ability to flow well together. I am recalling a conversation from another cycle around rhythms. I find myself feeling amused that it feels like we have found a good rhythm together ... but I can't really say what it is ... it is not as simple as a beat that can be named ... it is a complex, subtle, and mostly improvised rhythm .. but I do feel it is there!

What Next

I see a potential for two parallel activities: sharing and exploring money.

I would like to amplify the sharing dynamic. I would like to formulate an intentional measurable target (how many sharing, with whom, etc.). This is, in my mind, an Alexandrian effort to get a felt-sense of if/how the GP meets the ground ... how people that may benefit from it experience it. The outcome is (interestingly) binary in my mind: build it or don't build it?

The money exploration is very much alive for me. Though it has morphed, expanded, and refined itself. In my mind it is currently an exploration of value, equity and money. In order to prevent this exploration from becoming theoretical and detached I want to bind it to concrete needs and questions (assuming we the outcome of sharing is "build it") such as:

  1. Equity: how do we express the value of what has already been created so that this notion can grow as we bring on more people and resources?

  2. How do we do "hiring" - reaching more people and bringing them on board to build "the thing"

  3. How would we take on an investor?

  4. If we had money, what would we do with it?

There is a generative sequence alive in me for playfully exploring equity together.

Jennifer Damashek

I have a few reflections related to the gathering today.

First, the sharing from one of the crew members about something that happened during a previous gathering that troubled them stayed with me throughout the day. I realized that in the future, I want to be reflecting on gatherings and communications here to be watchful for these kinds of unintentional hurts. The hurt that arose shouldn’t have been a surprise to me, since I have experienced the same very personal topic causing extreme reactions and rifts in communities of mothers in the past. The topic evokes very strong feelings and opinions. I want to watch out for and tend to those kinds of potential hurts in the future. Something that I could have done which would have been simple and easy would have been to point out that not everyone in the gathering may agree or make the same choices on the subject, and there are good reasons to see things differently. That’s true for almost any topic I can think of that tends to bring out strong emotions. I think just saying that could help resolve upset and hurt.

The other thoughts I have are about money, investing, equity and one possible way what has already been generated by the crew could be put into practice.

In my mind, this crew already are the investors in the digital space. You have invested your talents, knowledge and skills. You have invested your time. If the digital space is going to be for-profit, I would hope those investments would be part of the calculation when it comes to equity and distributing profits, not only financial investments.

I would like to know if there an opening for considering making the digital space not-for-profit? Just because a business is not-for-profit doesn’t mean those involved can’t profit from it, it just means the legal purpose for the business is something other than simply making a profit.

Ronen asked in his thoughts before the gathering, if we had money what would we do with it? The answer to that to me is to pay the members of the crew who want/need to be paid to build the digital space.

An idea for how to put the generative process of the digital space has been percolating in my mind for a while.

Alex mentioned today that the organization he works for just lost three staff people, and this was disruptive for the organization. The non-profit I volunteer for also had to let a staff person go recently. I believe the same non-profit (and many other non-profits) could also use help finding, nurturing and retaining dedicated staff and volunteers needed to do essential work for the organization.

I think this is a common problem in organizations that are seeking to work in different ways, ways that resonate with this crew.

This way of working is not easy. People who are traumatized can’t work this way, even if they truly want to be able to. And almost all of us carry trauma from the world we live in.

If the digital space could support the training and development of people who are interested in working in the way the crew works, this would be valuable to many organizations around the world seeking people like that. They are hard to find. I think organizations would pay for access to people trained in working this way and who have demonstrated they are dependable and capable.

Another slightly different path to generating an income that came to my mind is from people who offer paid activities already and are looking for certain kinds of people who are capable of being in groups like this crew. They also might pay to have access to people drawn to the digital space.

I think we could possibly start by simply starting to work with more people who are drawn to the idea of the digital space as described in the generative description. We could organize activities for them and start building the digital space to support those activities.

Any potential path to generating an income will take time. In the meantime, Robert and I would like to say again we are willing to put money into this project.

One way this could look that would be simple and easy is to use the Open Collective Foundation as a fiscal sponsor. This would only work if the digital space were non-profit. They want to work with groups in alignment with the solidarity economy.

If Open Collective were a fiscal sponsor, we wouldn’t need to make a legal entity or open a bank account for the digital space right away. Money would be put into Open Collective and they do all the tracking. Crew members could simply make requests to be paid from the account, and they would be paid.

Those are my thoughts right now.

Alex Rodriguez

Thanks for offering these reflections, Jennifer. Interesting that you mention Open Collective---I've been working on a project with Metagov to build a consent-based collective decisionmaking integration with Loomio and Open Collective that could be useful if we were to set things up on there.

Josh Fairhead

Thanks for these thoughts Jennifer,

I would like to know if there an opening for considering making the digital space not-for-profit? Just because a business is not-for-profit doesn’t mean those involved can’t profit from it, it just means the legal purpose for the business is something other than simply making a profit.

In my view we are involved in a 'for purpose' endeavour. I'd be cautious of prescribing a particular set of legal constraints though as all choices will have unintended consequences. For instance if we adopt non-profit legal status now, it will rule out the ability to create services that can be funded through the likes of pension funds in the future (as there is no ownership, there are no shares that can be traded or profit to be extracted - fwiw I'm perhaps talking naively here). This example may or may not matter, but in my opinion its just too early to tell. My personal frame on this matter is that legal structures are just tools to pick up for specific purposes as I feel that these structures only give the illusion of security - there are many really great for-profits and many absolutely rotten non-profits.

If the digital space could support the training and development of people who are interested in working in the way the crew works, this would be valuable to many organizations around the world seeking people like that. They are hard to find. I think organizations would pay for access to people trained in working this way and who have demonstrated they are dependable and capable.

Another slightly different path to generating an income that came to my mind is from people who offer paid activities already and are looking for certain kinds of people who are capable of being in groups like this crew. They also might pay to have access to people drawn to the digital space.

These insights feel like they have a lot of potential in them.

Any potential path to generating an income will take time. In the meantime, Robert and I would like to say again we are willing to put money into this project.

That's super kind of you both, the spirit of the offer is appreciated and I interpret it as coming from a good place but I feel a knot within myself due to past experiences that I should probably share. I'm particularly cautious of internally funded 'financial solidarity' as I've been personally harmed by it and have seen it cause a lot of unintentional consequences. In a nutshell even if the provisions are truly given in the spirit of the unconditional gift (rare, despite espoused beliefs), it creates a distortion field in the minds of appropriators which in turn gives rise to all kinds of power asymmetries, biases and blindness. Its hard for me to sum this up coherently but these days I feel quite strongly about living lean and remaining self-funded until the point of external validation (clients, customers ect.).

To me this feels like a generous offer made in good spirit, so I want to be clear that its received well and that I'm not drawing comparisons - I'm just yet to see and experience tangible upsides to internally validating a project through financial means. I'm open to the possibility that my perspective is just sample bias, but I can't disregard my past experience despite the differences in context.

Jennifer Damashek

Thank you, Josh for all you wrote here. I appreciate the feedback that you have experienced internally funded "financial solidarity" and have been harmed by it. Thank you for sharing that, it's helpful for me to understand where you are coming from on this topic of money and funding.

As for legal structures, I think any legal structure may work, as long as the endeavor is "for-purpose" as you say.

However, I do think there is a problem with strictly for-profit legal structures if it means that the legal purpose of the business is to make a profit. That doesn't seem to me to actually allow the endeavor to be, in fact, "for-purpose."

Ronen Hirsch

A LOT to unpack there Jennifer. However I will refrain from doing so here and now.

I feel that we need to find firm footing, a healthy sequence of exploration in order to do these subjects grounded justice.

Cycle 4 is upon us :)

Alex Rodriguez

In the US at least, there is also the "B-corporation" or "benefit corporation" structure that allows for considerations other than financial bottom line to be considered when making business decisions. In other words, there are other options besides the non-profit corporation model that we could consider. I've been working in the nonprofit space for the past two years and there are ways that it can be just as toxic as for-profit businesses if not tended to with care and commitment to purpose. This book has been a great resource and primer for me on understanding both the pitfalls and spaces of radical possibility within the nonprofit system in the US: https://www.dukeupress.edu/the-revolution-will-not-be-funded

Josh Fairhead

Echos from the retrospective

@Toni Blanco brought up his experience within the world of job security. That is to say that sometimes there is a lull which brings with it feelings of uncertainty. He put this into metaphor as the time between planted seeds and seeing a field of spouts. This sense of uncertainty rang true for me having worked in the gig economy and lived out of crypto (volatility). There's a sense of stability that emerges as a by product I find.

@Alex Rodriguez noted a sense of rhythm that happens from not disassociating into abstraction
@Ronen Hirsch shared a desire to hear about the centres that enable our groups sense of cohesion. He noted; safety, time and retrospective but asked if there were other things?
@Alex Rodriguez brought a counterfactual example to the group and added that trust and shared vision carried him through
@Ronen Hirsch asked if the example felt burdening to carry for the two months that he did?
@Alex Rodriguez said that it brought a sense of disassociation that he had to work through which opened up conversation about how we bring issues to the group and ways to more easily resolve tensions and being able to double back to open threads that need resolution. The metaphorical vehicle of gossip/knots was used as well as Guntis (not Chackras).
@Jennifer Damashek added value and beauty to the list
@Robert Damashek added the depth, shared vision and tangibility.
@Josh Fairhead summarised some of the discussion that followed as "disclosure, privacy and transparency".
@Toni Blanco brought up his concern for the material conditions of our crew and suntainability of the space.
@Ronen Hirsch made the request that if your having a dyad, try to leave an echo for the wider ecology. There was also a wish that we share the generative process with others and get a sense of how others feel it in order to keep the core of the work alive.

Robert Damashek

Thank you for this echo, Josh, it’s very helpful to me. 😊

Robert

Sent from ProtonMail for iOS

Ronen Hirsch

I feel a wish to focus on some practicalities that surfaced in this gathering.

1: "Gossip" Protocol

The conversation around the knot between Alex and myself helped to recognize some mechanisms that we have in place to handle knots:

  1. The "safety" within the crew.

  2. The understanding that things take as much time as they need.

  3. The retrospective itself as a place to address such issues.

The conversation led to recognition of another mechanism - the crew itself. Simply put, if person A is triggered by Person B then person A may benefit from talking to person C about what has been triggered. Within the context of this crew this would not be considered "talking behind someone back" but considered an act of ... well ... solidarity! To my understanding, this is now part of our agreement. We are open to helping each other in this way and we accept that this would not be considered a violation of privacy.

In reflecting on this event I realized and would like to make explicit my wish that this (and other crew-health-mechanisms) are used to preserve the permission to speak freely without having to walk on eggshells of fear of offending someone. This does mean being offensive or inconsiderate, but it does acknowledge that some eggs may be broken in the making of our omelet (<- not how I thought that word was spelled!!.

2: Trigger Emoji

I would like to propose adding another emoji to our agreed vocabulary. I feel like 💥 (boom) can be used to express "I am triggered"

3: Cycle 3 Complete

Though this conversation thread remains open and active, I am declaring cycle 3 complete ... unless someone states an objective.

3: Cycle 4 Proposal

I will author a proposal to frame cycle 4 around:

  1. Money

  2. Collaboration technology

  3. Sharing the GP

Scope Proposal for Cycle 4

proposal by Ronen Hirsch Closed Mon 18 Oct 2021 11:03AM

This proposal is intended to frame an intended scope for Cycle 4 as it emerged from the retrospective:

Money

Seeking ways to tend to the material needs of those in the crew who need to generate an income for their livelihood and well-being.

  1. We will explore this in the context of the crew as a social unit. How can we tap into the potential of us being a crew to generate income?

  2. We will explore this in the context of the GP. What role can money play in advancing the GP and manifesting the digital space described in it?

  3. We will explore if there can be alignment and resonance between the question of money as it pertains to the crew and as it pertains to advancing the GP.

  4. We will harness all of these to explore if/how money manifests inside the digital space for the benefit of all its inhabitants.

Collaboration

We will continue the experiment offered by Josh to migrate out of C1 to a technology stack (currently Obsidian & GIT) that will allow us to more fluently explore collaboration on generative sequences (and beyond).

Sharing the GP

We will begin to intentionally share the GP outside the crew. We will reach out to people who can give grounded feedback on the relevance of the GP to their lived communal environments. We will prioritize people who are actively involved in holding or forming community spaces where the core notion of "continuous practice in small crews" may apply and resonate.

By sharing the GP we hope to discover its potential to meet the real-world needs of real-world people who are exploring community. The feedback from the sharing will guide our choices moving forward with the GP.

Results

Robert Damashek
Agree

The proposal reflects the elements we have discussed for next steps

Toni Blanco
Agree

I don't know if this is everything we will do in the cycle but sounds like a good kick-off

Alex Rodriguez

Just wanted to add that it would be helpful for me to think about this next cycle with some time parameters in mind. I did notice that we've been filling out a Fibonacci sequence of lunar cycles---3, 5, 8--which aligns with the spiral dynamic that @Josh Fairhead sketched out for us early on in our work together. Dec 4, 2021-Dec 23, 2022 would get us through 13 lunar cycles :)

Not ready to put this out there as a proposal per se but curious if there are any responses/reactions to either a) the idea of putting a time-container around Cycle 4 or b) the idea of making it 13 lunar cycles

Josh Fairhead

Wow, this is the second time in two days that Lunar cycles have been brought up and I've been pinpointed (Ronen mentioned them when we talked yesterday) - I don't remember that discussion but sure. I don't really want to treat them as a box or imperative @Alex Rodriguez but I do enjoy your Fibonacci observation. If you wish to lightly hold that container I'm happy to play the game with a suspended belief in the narrative.

Alex Rodriguez

Thanks Josh, yes, this is definitely offered with an invitation to suspend belief in any narratives that may be trying to attach themselves to my thoughts here :)