Setting editorial policy for the new journal
If there is to be a new low-cost, open-access vision science journal, what should be its editorial policy and reviewing process?
I think we all agree that reviewers should judge papers to be of "high technical quality". Other questions I'd like to discuss are:
- Should reviewers also consider novelty? If yes, could the journal have a section specifically for replications?
- Can we innovate in the reviewing process itself?