Parecon - yay!
Hah! I'm really happy / amused that @richarddbartlett mentioned Parecon as an influence for Loomio in his brilliant overview of how the Loomio community works! It's something I'm influenced by too. I bet we all listen to the same music and everything :-) My local activist group got Michael Albert over to shout at us once, it was fun. I've had interesting discussions within my organisation about how Parecon relates to other stuff we hold dear, like a strong belief in consensus.
I think the wider stuff about participatory society / holistic mutually-supporting progress (or oppression) in various areas that the Par* community is talking about is really poignant with the fledgling attempts at larger networks we're seeing springing up around the world. A related project I'm working on in the UK is around providing a forum for radical activist groups from various areas to meet up and see if they can find common ground to Do More Stuff in common. I hope we do :-)
I think the way that the IOPS project has gone is unfortunate. Did anyone else see that / is anyone involved with it? Some friends and I had an emotional discussion with the guy who project managed the website for that. It felt like it had gone very un-agile, with sad political ramifications, which made it hard for users to participate meaningfully. We ranted at him. It probably didn't help :-) Anyway, I think what they did is maybe an example of a brave attempt which can be learned from. Some kind of modern platform for large networks to do their thing together is definitely going to be A Big Deal.
I enjoyed reading the Parecon book when it came out.
I think best thing about Parecon, by far, is the decision making principle "that all persons should have a say in decisions proportionate to the degree to which they are affected by them". Most people seem to intuitively agree with and like it :)
I never liked the compensation by effort/ sacrifice stuff though. What about actual results and reputation etc. I've always like the idea of something like compensation = time x reputation / ecological footprint. Some of my friends/ colleagues have argued that eco footprint is just one aspect of reputation, but I don't really agree. I don't care how good your work is if you take far far more than your fair share of the Earths resources to do it.
@strypey struggles to stick to topic ;)
I've noticed that even the most "flat" organisations still have centres and edges. That's not a problem, so long as there is a transparent process for people moving into the centre, or reducing their involvement and moving to the edges. Larger scale co-operation between multiple "flat" groups seems to work best when their fringes overlap, and that overlapping area is populated by "connectors" (to borrow Malcolm Gladwell's phrase).
Ae, quantifying reward is hard. I think fundamentalist "free market" capitalism makes that harder by making even the necessary basics of life (housing, clothing, basic nutrition) subject to the quantified reward system. I can't see a society spending nearly as much energy quibbling about what portion of a quantified wealth pie they should have if everyone is somehow guaranteed access to the basics of life.
I think that IF we want to move towards less hierarchy in the world, then one hierarchy is the amount of power an individual has to consume, and conversely another hierarchy is how much "free time" someone has when they're not at work.
If we keep a disparity of income in utopia, I bet we would see ugly interactions with the rest of the less-hierarchical world. The "upper class" would be the better-paid more-free-time people. I like the Parecon principle of flat-ish-income based on amount of time worked, and how 'bad' the work is. I don't see any reason why one human should have more free time or consumption rights just because they're great at bridge-building or tofu-welding or something...
Agree that guaranteeing a good basic standard of living goes a long way to addressing a lot of economic issues, including the relationship between families and the economy - if kids and parents doing childcare were guaranteed to have their needs met by the wider economy then a lot of current inequality gets addressed.
In terms of devil being in the details, I think that this is true of everything - consensus, agile, cooperatives and other less-hierarchical relationships... :-) I think that there's not really any detail specified in Parecon, just some suggestions for how it could work, and the details are to be worked out... probably messily, like everything human!!
Seems to me that a good start would be more self-organising neighbourhood groups and workplaces, who might be interested in trying out moves towards increased networking and coordinated activities, and moves towards alternative progressive economies. Without them it's pretty hard to be in an economy of 1 :-)
Parecon sometimes feels to me like an idea that frustratingly can't be put into any large-scale practice - although roughly equal incomes, and being aware of coordination roles is something we can talk about and play with now. Also the idea of solidarity economics with other national economies discussed in there, which may become relevant to us at Aptivate as we talk about outsourcing coding work to other countries.
In Cambridge my partner and I are toying with the idea of setting up a little volunteer-run store in our coop of 85 people, and linking up with e.g. local producers, wholefood coops and local farmers, as well as basic bulk goods, which is our tiny stab at kicking off an entirely different economy :-)
In Cambridge my partner and I are toying with the idea of setting up a little volunteer-run store in our coop of 85 people, and linking up with e.g. local producers, wholefood coops and local farmers, as well as basic bulk goods, which is our tiny stab at kicking off an entirely different economy :-)
That is basically what most so-called Community Shops are (OK, so sometimes they have some paid staff too, but most rely of large army of volunteers too, which also makes them more resilient), who the Plunkett Foundation have been awesome in supporting. Their http://www.communityshops.coop/ site lists 311 Community Shops to date :)
Parecon yeah ! great stuff !
I've been aware of Parecon since the 90s. I remember thinking how few anarchists address the organisational structure of a whole economy, and being excited by the fact that Albert is one of the few anarchists willing to offer a vision of a what a post-capitalist society could look like.
As David Graeber points out though, there is a big difference between having a vision and realising even a small part of it. The devil is in the details, as the people of the Soviet block countries discovered, after their attempt to create "socialism" based on a pre-formatted template.