Loomio

That Loomio have two principles for enabling free use of Loomio.

vivien maidaborn PublicSeen by 43

That Loomio start our business model generation phase with two principles for enabling free use of the Loomio. 1. Loomio will be free for groups up to a certain size 2. there will be a transparent way that any group can apply to have free access .

proposal by vivien maidaborn Closed Fri 20 Jul 2012 9:16AM

The commitment to enabling groups to use Loomio for no cost will be met through the testing and development of two initial principles
Firstly Loomio will be free to use for all groups under a certain number. This number to be agreed after further market testing and user feedback. The intention is to support fast growth of Loomio through supporting groups to easily sign up and engage
Secondly by always having another mechanism where larger groups can apply for free use of loomio. This ensures groups without resources but who may be strongly aligned to Loomio principles and values have an option to access free use as well

Results

Jade Ambrose
Disagree

I think a larger proportion of users should be free in order to promote growth.

Delete My Account Please
Agree

Seems like a good start at balancing growth and near term revenue needs. Growing the free offering if that is needed is easier than taking away what you've already given for free so I would err on the side of less free usage to start.

guillaume
Abstain

I just don't see where is the money coming from when reading points 1 and 2. They both are about free up to something, and way to be free above this point. But I guess I've missed too much lately to follow. Thus abstaining.

Richard D. Bartlett

Breaking these pricing model questions into bite sized proposals feels right to me.

Danyl Strype

This is similar to the model that OnlineGroups who host the Occupy Aotearoa list are using, except that the cut-off is 25 people. If you are going to offer conditional free access to larger groups, you will need to define exactly what the criteria for that are. This is true even if only for internal use, but I would suggest you make them public, the same way funding organisations publicise criteria for receiving their funds. Obviously these criteria statements could be revised over time, by the consensus of the operating group.

Jade Ambrose

I'm certainly in favour of Loomio bringing in some money, but I'm a bit concerned that having the basic cuttoff at only 10 people will mean that it will hurt loomio's growth.

In comparison to "groupspaces.com" for example, their free plan is for 50 people, for a much more fully functioning app than loomio. Additionally, the cost of $2 per person per month seems huge to me. Atamai certainly wouldn't want to pay it, but I'm imagining we'd probably host our own loomio installation anyway.

To compare to something more like the wordpress business model, it's very useful for free, and paying gets you premium features (like styling, custom domain, etc).

Richard D. Bartlett

It's a good point Craig but a tricky one, we're going to have to do some work to get all our assumptions out on the table and then gathering validation for them in a structured fashion.

I believe the reasoning behind the cutoff point of 10 people was the thinking that boards would be a big customer segment, and they frequently have 10-15 members.

If we're going to set the free/premium split based on population, ideally we need to identify what is the distribution of populations in our various customer segments. Then we open up the other can of worms, which is at what population point to orgs move away from SaaS to self-hosted systems-integrated versions?

Personally I am keen to copy Wordpress wherever possible. Like you say, very useful for free, more convenient, fully featured, customisable for premium, and you're always free to host your own version of the app. (relevant: http://techcrunch.com/2010/12/09/automattic-hits-300-million-unique-visitors-roughly-10-million-in-revenues/ )

I don't know shit all about this stuff but I'm having fun thrashing around! Very grateful to be hearing input from diverse viewpoints and more experienced peeps.

Alanna Irving

Craig just from your perspective, what is a price point you do think is fair for Loomio, per person?

Robert Guthrie

The wording of 'principals' sounds like you are locking into a business model very early on. I think the principals should not mention current business model thinking.

So I would restate it as.. There will always be a process for groups to apply for free use additionally the source code will always be free.

As for the business model itself.. maybe a free trial period for groups of any size would promote growth.

Delete My Account Please

Just want to clarify that this was conceived as free for all Loomio groups 10 or under, not all subscriber groups. This would allow a large corporation/org to test Loomio across an unlimited number of teams of 10 or less for free. Add on the ability to demonstrate a hardship and get free seats and we thought that would strike a balance between incenting people to use the tool org-wide and getting revenue in sooner rather than later.

More broadly, much of the commenting on this and the pricing thread seem to hew to a traditional, equity funded business model where you scale first and monetize later. Loomio doesn't have that option and you need to strike a balance between scale and financial sustainability in the near term. This is hard and the impulse to keep prices as low as possible for as long as possible really needs to be tempered by the hard realities of making this project viable.

Delete My Account Please

I also want to chime in on the idea of using a freemium model. In general this is not successful for companies, though some, like Wordpress have made it work. And Wordpress is a forward facing tool that people use to express themselves, so individuals have an incentive to pony up for a shinier site. It isn't immediately apparent to me what Loomio features could be split off into a premium offering (beyond custom stuff of course, but that is a different part of the business). And if you did go that route it seems like the current feature set would have to be free, and then you're talking about a lot more dev time before you have anything you can sell. That, frankly, from what I've been told, could kill Loomio the org and seriously cripple Loomio the software.

vivien maidaborn

It is amazing reading these responses and thinking how much of the way the discussion develops is based on the way the proposal is written - guess I am learning as I go here. I take your point Robert that the use of the word principles sounds like we are locking into a business model early on, and infact we are tryinhg to do the opposite but be clear what principles are not up for negotiation, i.e there will be free access to using Loomio apart from free access to the code. We have not tested 10 as a number though and I sense that a bigger group may reduce some concerns. We could in our alpha and beta stages agree with each group the number of free seats and also agree at what rate they would like to pay where it adds value for them. This might be a better way of expressing the principle rather than fixing a number of people?

vivien maidaborn

the principle feels more refined and is aligned with iterating the business model

Joshua Vial

Might be worth pinging craig and rob directly to see if the rewording of the proposal has changed their position - technically we should close the old proposal and start a new one if it has changed substantially, though I think it is fine in this case.

Jade Ambrose

Here's a totally different idea. Perhaps it should be free for groups which are public, and paid for groups which are private, regardless of size. That's more like the github business model. That might make it accessible for open source projects but ensure that your smaller boards will pay.

In terms of the changed wording of the current proposal, that does sound a bit better but I still don't really support the proposal. However, I really don't think my support is needed.

Richard D. Bartlett

We've discussed that in the past actually Craig. I quite like it. The only concern is that there are plenty of groups that could profit from using Loomio for whom privacy is non-negotiable, so we'd have to have processes in place to mitigate that.

vivien maidaborn

My reading of the comments and decision pie chart is we have broad agreement with some concern about too much limit on free access. These two principles are general enough to guide our thinking, ad development without constraining additional principles.
My bright idea relooking this afternoon might be to start a discussion on any open source based group contributing code to Loomio, by definition get it for free?

Matthew Bartlett

@vivien, I'm not much of a developer, but I think if a group is contributing code they will be able to host their own version of loomio, hence won't need our permission to run it for free.

Delete My Account Please

@Matthew B I don't think that is true, most OS teams don't need another thing to stand up and maintain if someone's gonna do it for them at no cost.

@Craig and Richard I think you'd really strangle adoption if you couldn't try it for free in private.