Loomio
Sun 19 Jul 2020 9:30PM

Implementation of Plantain in OverseerFM

CR Caroline Read Public Seen by 28

This discussion provides information on, and an opportunity to discuss, the way Plantain is to be implemented in OverseerFM

AM

Alister Metherell Fri 31 Jul 2020 2:28AM

Have pasture quality differences between plantain and grass/clover pasture been considered? Did the FRNL project provide data which could be used to update the Overseer pasture quality database?

MS

Mark Shepherd Fri 31 Jul 2020 2:45AM

The FRNL team might be able to add further information. They have collated a large database. From this, we concluded that there was no consistent difference in N concentration between standard and plantain-rich pasture, even though the starting hypothesis in FRNL was that there would be a difference. Analysis of the database did pick up the difference in WSC, hence we have captured that in our partitioning scalar. There is potential to use the FRNL database to update the OvS database with other quality parameters (P, K, etc for example).

AM

Alister Metherell Fri 31 Jul 2020 2:51AM

Thanks Mark. I was thinking more in terms of ME differences which are an important driver of intake in Overseer, which in turn has a big impact on N excretion.

MD

Mike Dodd Fri 31 Jul 2020 2:56AM

From the Tararua plantain rollout project sampling over the last 18 months there is no evidence of significant ME differences for grass-based pastures with plantain in them. Plantain-clover mixes are a different story, as one might expect.

MS

Mark Shepherd Fri 31 Jul 2020 3:01AM

Yeah, sorry. I missed the point. The database was unable to show consistent differences in ME between standard pasture and plantain-rich pasture

B

Barenbrug Fri 31 Jul 2020 4:12AM

Barenbrug's comments are in the attached.