Has anyone seen wrangl.com? Does this kind of structured discussion have a place on Loomio?
My wife and I have used wrangle before to help make some pretty big decisions in our lives. I don't know how well this style of pro-vs-con scales to many people, but I figured it was worth discussing, at least.
SAP has a web based subscription tool called streamwork, that has a number of structured tools that are useful for focusing a discussion, including pro con, quadrant analysis (group avg'd), sorted list (group avg'd), etc. I think these are very useful, but must be UX'd very carefully to avoid confusion, which SAP failed at. As a result use of that tool required a fairly sophisticated facilitator and some implicit governance rules so it didn't turn into a free-for-all.
I have looked at wrangl and it's a neat idea. I can see some interesting applications. I think the central point of difference, which leads to profoundly different dynamics, is that wrangl pre-supposes the options you're choosing between, whereas Loomio assumes that there are things you probably haven't thought of at first, and thinking together with other people will surface some better ideas.