Loomio

About accepting Bart back as Charter Member

Venka PublicSeen by 322

I propose a motion as below;

Motion: To consider Bart's resignation as charter member withdrawn
with immediate effect.

Accept Bart back as Charter Member

proposal by Anita Graser Closed Thu 15 Sep 2016 1:01PM

Outcome
by Venka

Motion rejected

(moved here from https://www.loomio.org/d/Edyfz50P/proposal/SUVvP0J2, originally posted by Venka)

Motion: To consider Bart's resignation as charter member withdrawn
with immediate effect.

Results

Dirk Frigne
Abstain

Becoming a charter member is following a procedure of election by all the existing charter members. I don't have a mandate as a board member to create new charter members.

Maxi
Block

I agree with Dirk,
there are rules. next election i will vote for BART. Don't misunderstood me, I love Bart and appreciate his contribution and strongly want him back. But otherwise Jeff could ask to be reinstalled as president with the same rights.

Dirk Frigne

I 'd like to agree to, but I am not sure if I can. Becoming a charter member is following a procedure of election by all the existing charter members. The existing charter members are also responsible to elect the board members. I am not sure I have the mandate as a board member to create new charter members.
I talked to Bart at the FOSS4G conference and I am very pleased he want's to join OSGeo again as a charter member. I will be the first to nominate him. But the decision is not mine. So I will abstain.

Jody Garnett

One question and two observations:

a) Question, has anyone asked Bart if he is willing to be reinstated as a charter member?

b) Observation: We did just miss an opportunity to nominate Bart as a charter member, the easiest way to reinstate his membership while respecting our procedures.

c) Observation: Bart withdrew over a conflict, that could of been more smoothly handled by our code of conduct committee. Has this conflict now been resolved?

Venka

a) I have asked Bart and he has agreed to be reinstated as a charter member. He also agreed that I take up this matter with the board.

b) Observation: Yes, we did. However, I think if Bart communicates specifically that he wishes to withdraw his resignation, he can be reinstated without "re-nomination" and re-election.

c) Observation: The fact that Bart has expressed his willingness to be reinstated is an indication that the "conflict" has been smoothly handled. I would not wish to rake up the matter again investigating whether the "conflict" is resolved.

The way I planned to handle this matter was to first get the motion passed by the board and then send an e-mail to the charter-members list stating that if anyone has a serious objection with the board decision, he/she could express his objection (supported with a valid reason) within 48 hours. If there is no objection before the deadline, the board decision will stand.

This is a special case considering Bart's long standing contribution to our Foundation and I do not think our by-laws forbid us from reinstating a Charter Member if he.she withdraws his/her resgination.

Dirk Frigne

Venka,

If you are sure we don't brake any rules of the by laws by reinstating the status of charter member, I will change my position in Agree. Can anyone second that?

Anita Graser

I think Venka's suggestion for how to handle this instance makes a lot of sense. Since I have trouble interpreting the by-laws (not used to legalese), I won't attempt it.

Anita Graser

@venka you can now use the Set Proposal Outcome button to sum up the decision.

Acknowledging TIB for longterm preservation of FOSS4G conference videos

proposal by Venka Closed Tue 27 Sep 2016 12:53PM

Outcome
by Anita Graser

moved to dedicated discussion thread (https://www.loomio.org/d/LzCkPfSF) since this motion has nothing to do with Bart's membership status

Motion to acknowledge TIB and display TIB logo/tagline on
OSGeo website

Results