Organizing a growing Social.Coop: an idea for a proposal
As Rene Magritte wrote, "this is not a proposal." This is a draft for discussion that may lead to a formal proposal for a new organizational body for Social.Coop. Drafted by Matt Cropp and Matt Noyes in consultation with the Community Working Group Ops Team.
On February 22nd, we will consult with interested members to consider creating a formal proposal.
See this editable pad document (feel free to comment, highlight, etc.): https://pad.disroot.org/p/Organizing_Social.Coop_Doc_Feb_4_23
Here is the text of the draft:
Organizing a growing Social.Coop: an idea for a proposal.
Matt Cropp and Matt Noyes, in consultation with the Community Working Group Ops Team
Process: initiate discussion of document on Loomio -> two weeks discussion -> make formal proposal on Loomio.
The Problem/Opportunity
Social.Coop has grown dramatically since November of 2022. The addition of new members has made the instance richer and more complex. It has also strained the existing forms of organization, particularly the Community Working Group Ops Team, which has been taking on onboarding, moderation, education, strategic planning and other tasks.
Our existing organizational structure consists of three working groups: Tech, Community, and Finance (a legal working group is in the works), each of which functions differently and often with little coordination. Which decisions are made at which level and by whom, and who does the work, is inconsistent. Decisions made in one working group often have unexamined implications for other working groups. Groups change form: the CWG has lapsed and been replaced by the CWG Ops Team, for example. Ad hoc groups can also form, like the Reading Group.
With discussion and operations spread across multiple platforms – Mastodon, Loomio, Matrix – it is difficult for the membership to provide coordination and leadership. This lack of coordination and internal communication has resulted in, among other things, a tendency to do-ocracy and a deference to members who are perceived to be leaders, either because of longevity, activity on the instance, or other qualities. This raises the risk of “tyranny of structurelessness” type dynamics, and has troublesome implications for diversity and inclusion. It also undermines accountability. Finally, while Social.Coop functions collectively, we still lack the kind of organization needed to really operate as – and achieve, if we want it, the legal status of – a cooperative.
To meet our current needs for coordination and to organize Social.Coop members to take this experiment in member owned, governed, and operated social media to the next level, we intend to propose the formation of a Social.Coop Organizing Circle, with the features described below.
Create a Social.Coop Organizing Circle (OC)
A group of people consistently committed to holding this group (circle) and coordinating among working groups and ops teams, providing a space for ongoing conversation and coordination.
-
Composition (who is on it? How are they chosen?)
-
A mix of ops team and at large members
one member from each working group/ops team,
seven members elected at large
-
-
Nominations and Elections
Social.Coop members* can self-nominate
OC members will be elected to two year terms
Half of the OC to be elected each year, to maintain continuity
Subject to recall vote upon petition of 10% of members* [*active? Good standing? Registered?]
Election process: juried sortition (to ensure diversity and inclusion)
-
Roles:
OC Coordinator (coordinates the circle)
Membership Coordinator (maintains membership list, coordinates onboarding)
Treasurer (keeps and shares financial information)
Communications (keeps and shares records)
-
Decision-making process
[something like sociocratic consent]
-
Compensation
OC members will receive a stipend for attending OC meetings
OC members with designated roles (coordinator, membership coordinator, treasurer, communications coordinator) will receive an additional stipend for work out of meetings
-
Scope of Responsibility (what will these people do?)
Coordination The Organizing Circle (OC) should meet at least monthly to coordinate, monitor, guide the work of the cooperative, and communicate with members.
Strategic Planning The OC will facilitate a strategic planning process and adopt a strategic plan (subject to member approval), with regular periodic reviews and updates of the plan. The OC will also make major agreements with external organizations (like joining another organization) subject to membership approval.
Financial Oversight and Budgeting The OC will provide financial oversight for Social.Coop, creating and approving an organizational budget, including budgets for each Ops Team; approving expenses above budgeted amounts; approving expenses not coming from Working Groups or Ops Teams.
Support and Oversight of Operations The OC will provide support and oversight to the Ops Teams, help create new Ops Teams, approve budgets, and approve the selection of Ops Team members who are compensated for their work.
Communications The OC will receive regular reports from ops teams and share that information with the membership, maintaining a shared calendar.
-
Scope of Authority
-
Relation to membership
The OC will review and decide on expulsions of members proposed by the CWG Ops Team
-
Relation to working groups/ops teams
The OC will review and decide on appeals of Working Group or Ops Team decisions
-
-
Transparency
Meetings open to members
OC members can choose to meet in closed sessions for things like negotiations with vendors, personnel issues related to ops team staffing, and expulsion of members
Budgets, income and expenses, are public via Open Collective
Meeting minutes and recordings available on Loomio
-
Sample Decision-making matrix
(This is just an example to illustrate how we might designate at which levels decisions are made. Need to consult bylaws.)
Working Groups/Ops Teams |
Organizing Circle |
Members |
|
Elect OC Members |
X |
||
Dissolve Social.Coop |
X |
||
Create New Operations Teams |
X |
||
Propose Paid Ops Team Members |
X |
||
Approve Paid Operations Team Members |
X |
||
Develop and Propose Strategic Plan and Modifications |
X |
||
Ratify Strategic Plan and Modifications |
X |
||
Approve non-budgeted expenses |
X |
||
Create ad hoc groups (like the reading group) |
X |
||
Approve the budget |
X |
||
Decide how to spend Ops Team/WG budget |
X |
||
Propose expulsion of a member |
X |
||
Hear appeals of Ops Team/WG decisions |
X |
||
Change the SC bylaws |
X |
||
... |
Just too many other priorities to juggle at this time. While I don't have a whole-body-yes to helping lead the process, if anyone has reason to believe that I would have particular insights for particular questions, feel free to ping me.
idk how I missed this discussion but I love it and want to help out after I digest it a bit more
I would love to help with this but am over capacity with other work right now. Good luck and I look forward to reading the next version!
I am booked solid until my spring semester ends on May 19th. That said, I've been very interested in getting involved in CWG type responsibilities when the summer comes, so depending on what the timeline is, I might be interested in helping out then.
Happy to help.
I'm happy to see something like this move forward, and willing to help if I can. For my part, as a new-ish participant in social.coop and sociocratic processes more generally, I struggle to get more involved here partly b/c I've never been 100% the best way to "plug in", and partly b/c of decision fatigue (or more accurately, the fear thereof, since I've not participated in a whole lot of decisions to-date).
So while I don't want to see social.coop become too autocratic at any point (although, I question how realistic a threat that is), I also don't want to see it languish for lack of clearly articulated structures for governance and participation, so the "unspoken" structures don't come to dominate. And on that account I guess I lean more towards, "let's lay down some clear, if imperfect, guidelines now, along with some mechanisms to improve them over time" as opposed to just "let's see what happens", if that makes sense?
I believe my POV is a tad too partisan to be helpful in redrafting the proposal.
I don't know enough to be helpful, nor do I have the necessary time to spare. However, I will read any future iterations of the proposal.
We should not go ahead w/ proposals pitched by few to substantially restructure our org w/o first collecting information via meaningful surveys from all stakeholders in our co-op on their experiences, interests, unique perspectives, suggestions, and how it's been working for them. Survey's not a word encountered, indicating robust participatory democracy = afterthought, while members r not provided w/ open opp to b heard on how SC can b more engaging, enriching, enjoyable and how we may flourish
I am a little late to this but I will provide some input.
Consider this a provisional yes - my career is Customer Service so I've written some processes / training material in that environment for quite some time. I am currently on chômage (French unemployment) and at the mercy of random / last minute calls to explain myself to my conseiller, interviews, and / or training courses, depending on what your deadline is could be an issue or not.
I'm not seeing concern about global structural representation in the discussion. (Maybe it's there, I've only glanced.) Like: proportional guidance for representation by non-males, persyns whose ancestors were traded as commodities during transatlantic slavery, formerly colonized & indigenous persyns... I feel the material quality of social.coop's growth & governance depends on the contribution of voices such as these. Though I'm not skilled, I would try to hold space for such perspectives.
It's a fascinating organizational challenge at a moment that has historical significance, right? That said, my time is full. My participation will be erratic. However if/when I am able to show up, I'll be all in.
I look forward to seeing the refined proposal
Keen to ensure alternative perspectives are given consideration and hopefully a place within the creation of a new proposal.
I really, really do not like the idea of yet another group I'm in creating a final decision-making small and closed executive council, yet branding it as something new and different through language that appeals to people trying to avoid these classic top-down structures. I wish by my age that I knew how to communicate more gently, as I like everyone in Social.Coop, and I do not believe that anyone is doing any coopertivewashing / solidaritywashing intentionally, but this is very disturbing. Having arrived late to the discussion, I understand that my feelings on this will likely not be noticed or given much consideration, as there's so much fervor expressed here to get to work on this and tweak a few items, but I do not feel it would be ethical to just roll my eyes and not say that this is absolutely not what I believe we should be replicating if we do indeed see ourselves as building and showcasing an alternative vision for the world. Will go through some components in the next comment, as I cannot figure out how to do 2 consecutive line breaks in an edit field.
@M. Page-Lieberman - jotaemeisocial.coop It took me ten minutes to figure out how to reply to you. I so appreciate what you have shared here. I hope you will be among those who vote to contribute critically to the discussion.
I'm aware of sortition being used for gigs nobody wants and gigs more people want than there are spots available. In both cases, it's supposed to be an equalizer, but I really question this belief. In the case of using sortition for elite spots at universities, to sit on executive boards, or win the lottery, there are going to be many, many people who are told that by the luck of a draw, they missed out and cannot participate or have access to those opportunities. As Social.Coop is a digital space, I really do not understand why we're considering adopting this idea of sortition at all or placing numerical limits on participation in any body made up of volunteers. We're dealing with dilemmas of people being burnt out, and some taking on too much of a load, while others are left out of the loop, and an ostensibly concerningly low participation rate, so we decide to create a new executive committee where 99% of the membership cannot via statute participate in the ultimate decision-making? I do not understand. If we want to make sure that all the work gets done that needs to be done, then that's where sortition makes sense. No one would be excluded by not being picked. They would simply be fortunate if they lucked out from doing the undesirable work in a given week - but maybe not the next week. If we want to be fairer still, then we should use rotation of who has to do the undesirable work each week. The most disturbing element of this proposal to me is that the executive committee would be able to reject the recommendations of another body after the latter had done their due diligence and work and determined who they believed needed to get the boot for unacceptable behavior. This is how the gods awful Boston DSA I briefly participated in operated. It's how the mayor of my city operates. The big boss boy or big boss girl or non-binary big boss takes recommendations under advisement from the commissions that do all the work researching the topic and should be trying to figure out who they would like to add to their bodies. Yet, this is what we believe is part of the sociocracy model? Just a quick review, via Wikipedia: "Each circle has the responsibility to execute, measure, and control its own processes in achieving its goals." I do not know if we need to find some clarity on this, but sociocracy is not just provisional consent voting in round-robin, and it doesn't just mean having subgroups, but which are referred to as circles. One of the critically important ideas behind sociocracy is that it enables groups to move forward without all of the bureaucracy and confusion about how and where to go, and it creates less friction and barriers for those who are most engaged in specific work without their needing permission to proceed on the matters that they best understand beyond all others who are not engaged regularly in that specific work. We are a digital space though. Groups can be as big or as small as they believe they themselves may be to get whichever task done - but most importantly to not exclude anyone! If we want to see more people participate, then mentor, mentor, mentor! If we want to see some more tasks being done, then invite, invite, invite! Groups should be open and regularly letting the community of members know which jobs they could use some help with. If the only invitations that are ever sent out are for people to vote on another big idea proposal and comment on it, then naturally, that's the only kind of wide participation that we'll see.
@M. Page-Lieberman - jotaemeisocial.coop
Thank you for posting all this. I am quite new, and am still learning and listening. I'm a big fan of consensus, but have really only "done" it before in a small living co-op of 8-10 people.
I'd love to hear what solutions you have to what I think are pretty clear problems with the current setup.
From my perspective as a newcomer, the big problems seem to include 1) maintaining social cohesion as the group grows (resulting in lack of trust), 2) fatigue in the governance bodies, 3) unclear expectations about the responsibilities of general members, 4) fragmentation of information and conversations across multiple platforms, 4) general onboarding process, 5) lack of clarity on how decisions get made.
I posted a thread asking about how proposals get made, and although I got some helpful responses back, I still don't actually know the answer. At first someone posted a document explaining that proposals should be reviewed and discussed by the appropriate working group, but later someone else posted that they hadn't even known that that document exists. As far as I understand it, it seems that technologically anyone can make a proposal with or without a deliberative process beforehand, and that makes me worry that our written policies could quickly change in ways that don't reflect our collective values, simply based on a motivated person doing an active PR campaign.
Most members don't vote on most proposals, and I don't know whether this is because they don't care, don't know the proposals are being made, don't happen to be online that week, are too busy to keep up with everything that's going on on Loomio, or what.
What I'd like to know is that there is a clear process in place that everyone understand and is on board with. And democratic participation should be easy, not a source of stress.
What do you think we should do?
@M. Page-Lieberman - jotaemeisocial.coop Thank you thank you, I did not find time to read all the backlog, and I just want to echo that everything you're saying matches my concerns. I strongly support your points about making sure this doesn't turn into another level of hierarchical entrenched power and exclusion. The best way to be sure of that is not to simply be confident that the people working on it have good intentions but for everyone to recognize that pitfalls are likely and watch out for them proactively.
@Dynamic As I read it, @M. Page-Lieberman - jotaemeisocial.coop is making several suggestions:
don't use sortition for any body made of volunteers
an organizing circle should be made up of volunteers
do use sortition to distribute work members don't want to do
let working groups/ops teams operate as sociocratic circles, with autonomy to make decisions that are part of their work (e.g. let CWG ops team have final say on moderation decisions)
do lots of inviting and mentoring to help get people involved in operations work
Is this accurate? Please correct so we can think about how to address these concerns in a proposal.
@Dynamic Hi! First, please pass to me a link to the thread you started, so I can take a look at it. I've been meaning to respond to you since this morning, but I've had a very hectic day and just got home and can calmly respond. I believe the answer to your very good and extremely important question (because of the far reaching implications, as this is a ubiquitous issue in all kinds of social groups beyond Social.Coop) has a simple answer. The caveat is that it takes a lot of work, as we're referring to culture.
I'm not a fan of referring to certain habits and beliefs via reified social constructions of essentialist retrograde concepts such as gender ("toxic masculinity") and race ("white supremacy culture"), but I really am not sure there's much of a better term for this phenomenon that so many groups like Social.Coop struggle with than bro culture practices. I'm tired at the end of this day and can perhaps record a video elaborating on Tuesday, but first, I ask that you glance at these three quotes (most or all of which, I imagine you're already familiar with):

"How Standards Proliferate", Randall Munroe, July 20, 2011
Some people, when confronted with a problem, think “I know, I'll use regular expressions.”
Now they have two problems.
Post to the comp.emacs.xemacs Usenet discussion group, Jamie Zawinski, August 12, 1997
Those of us who stand outside the circle of this society's definition of acceptable women;
those of us who have been forged in the crucibles of difference -- those of us who are
poor, who are lesbians, who are Black, who are older -- know that survival is not an
academic skill. It is learning how to take our differences and make them strengths. For
the master's tools will never dismantle the master's house. They may allow us
temporarily to beat him at his own game, but they will never enable us to bring about
genuine change. And this fact is only threatening to those women who still define the
master's house as their only source of support.
"The Master's Tools Will Never Dismantle the Master's House" (comments at the “The personal and the political panel,” Second Sex Conference), Audre Lorde, September 29, 1979
I can say how we can solve these issues, but I'll be citing those three items.
@Matt Noyes Yes, those are some alternative suggestions I made, but some of them are more so to streamline work that needs to be done, but I'm not sure that they would address the particular experiences that @Dynamic has had, which were discouraging - and which, I know from experience in many groups (especially those which mostly interact online) are fairly typical. What I believe is that we do not need to create new rules or new bodies. What we need to do is be willing to change how we interact with each other and slow down - to be mindful and conscientious.
I guess Mike Strode from Kola Nut Collaborative is not here in Social.Coop (SC), but last year, we had an informal conversation, and I mentioned what @freescholar (who is the reason that I originally found out about SC and joined in 2018) said at, I believe, a Libre Planet conference a few years ago. It was that when people are interested in getting interested in free software projects, they should look around and see what they're interested and then jump in. It was of the sense that no one was going to hold their hands, so they'll have to figure it out and get to work themselves - to take some initiative. Mike and I talked about how that makes a lot of sense in the culture of open source software projects, but that this is not necessarily the same for cooperating in many solidarity economy work. And, I'll add now, especially not the case for those not primarily composed of upper-middle class professional white guy tech workers. I can elaborate at another time, but I think we need to do deeper reflection and learn from others if we want to create a community that is healthy and rewarding for people, and in which people feel that it's easy to find their way around and talk to people who have the time for them and support them in their learning and growing.
@M. Page-Lieberman - jotaemeisocial.coop +1 @freescholar
@M. Page-Lieberman - jotaemeisocial.coop Here's the thread I started about how proposals are made: https://www.loomio.com/d/vzhQxDHA/how-we-use-proposals
I'll now go back and read the rest of your post.
@Aaron Wolf @Matt Noyes @M. Page-Lieberman - @jotaemei@social.coop
This statement by Aaron,
Thank you thank you, I did not find time to read all the backlog, and I just want to echo that everything you're saying matches my concerns.
I think touches on the crux one of our central problems currently.
The Loomio threads are quite long, and anyone who is late to the conversation is confronted with the choice between 1) reading through a massive backlog (which they might not get through) before weighing in with their own perspective, or 2) looking at the most recent comments and responding to what looks interesting (and thereby quickly making the backlog even longer for anyone who is joining the conversation late, while possibly repeating points made upthread).
Proposals and straw polls are a possible tool for cutting through some of this, but then we end up with proposal fatigue. I think that happened, for example, in the "Framework for Moderation" thread here: https://www.loomio.com/d/Ahx86rZJ/framework-for-moderation (you can do a keyword seach for the words "novel" and "long", as well as "CWG" for the various suggestions people made that we should stop going back and forth on details and let the CWG use its judgment).
@Dynamic I agree, hence the attempt by @Jonathan Bean to get help from ChatGPT to summarize the thread and create a proposal.
@Andrew Shead I don't want AI anywhere near my democracy.
Very wise. I just read it and the replies, and I think we should move that conversation to the top of our priority list. I should be able to comment there later tonight or tomorrow. There were some wicked helpful experiences and perspectives shared. The one aspect I found distasteful, which can continue to be seen there is the RTFM response. This is why I also detest Robert’s Rules of Order. No one should need to read assorted explainers (themselves, not always kept up-to-date) in order to not feel overwhelmed with how confusing their initial experiences have been. As you mentioned that you’re new here, I’ll share that I’ve been here nearly 5 years, and I’ve attended two video meetings in all this time after being able to determine when they would be, but generally it’s confusing and such knowledge is kept undocumented and just in the heads of people who do not expect anyone else to be interested in dropping by to observe in order to try to get an sense of what’s going on. This is not a Social.Coop failing. It’s ubiquitous, and I’ve various stories of this practice from multiple groups along the year leading to people who are new feeling discouraged.
It’s mostly a result of automatic habits and a lack of thought put into how to make spaces more welcoming and inviting for others outside of those who we expect to see each week or month to get a job done.
Em ter., 28 de fev. de 2023 às 18:00, Dynamic (via Loomio) escreveu:
@Dynamic I agree with you completely about keeping AI away from democracy.
@Dynamic In addition to the long backlog, some of the posts are walls of text. That can be a slog to read through.
@Andrew Shead I have no time for AI in this or any conversation involving social.coop.
Hi guys I don't know how useful it is but just for fun I asked ChatGPT to summarize our Loomio discussions and the proposal and to write the proposal for us and what are some suggestions for us. feel free to take a look. Let me know if it is any good or what questions need to be tried better?
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1x2qE0Abrk-md3HFPJ2Uc-IDk8MKXwiFiWqhrHvYALBU/edit?usp=sharing
PDF is also attached.
Can you provide a summary of this conversation I can post to the Loomio group to help people understand the value of this conversation that I will post to google docs or a post?
Sure! Here's a summary of our conversation:
We discussed several topics related to Social.Coop and the transition to a solidarity, regenerative, and equitable economy. We started by exploring the history of Social.Coop, its organizational structure, and the challenges it faces in scaling and achieving its goals. We then discussed some potential solutions, including the formation of an Organizing Circle, the adoption of guiding values and principles, and the exploration of new partnerships and collaborations.
We also talked about your career interests and skills, and how you might be able to leverage these to support Social.Coop and the transition movement more broadly. We discussed the potential value of AI technology in supporting your work, including the ability to conduct research and analysis, create content and messaging, and engage with members of the Social.Coop community and other stakeholders.
Overall, our conversation highlighted the importance of active participation and engagement from members of the Social.Coop community, and the potential for innovative solutions and partnerships to drive forward the goals of the platform and the transition movement more broadly.
@Jonathan Bean It's a fun idea. A little creepy that ChatGPT reads our site and creates content...
@Jonathan Bean I find no value in ChatGPT or any LLM summarizations of our conversations.
Item removed
I'm finding ChatGPT a useful tool and don't think it serves progressive social movements to vilify or overly fear this technological advance. In fact, we could likely make impressive gains in coordination by utilizing it to summarize trends about which we have very fragmented knowledge - who of us actually KNOWS the extent of social cooperative organizing in the world? ChatGPT will likely be able to represent an accurate 'count' - this could be encouraging to those of us who have been variously fighting for reforms/revolution for years and decades, perhaps lifetimes!
@Stephanie Jo Kent fine, as long as you are so kind to mark texts you post from that sources as Large Language Model Generated (LLMGT), I have no issues with it.
@Stephanie Jo Kent I haven't seen anyone vilify ChatGPT here on Loomio.
However, the inaccuracies of LLM summarizations make them no better than human summarizations. Therefore, as I stated in a previous message,
"I find no value in ChatGPT or any LLM summarizations of our conversations."
@Stephanie Jo Kent ChatGPT may be useful for some purposes (e.g. drafting emails or rewriting one's own resume), but I still don't want it anywhere near my democracy. Using it to "summarize" content isn't really a summarization, but a statistical model of what a human-written summary might look like. It's therefore extremely important that the author of the text being summarized take charge of making sure that the summary accurately conveyed what they were trying to say.
The current ecosystem of LLMs do not parse sentences in order to extract meaning (although there is other, less flashy, natural-language software that is designed to do that). Because of the way the models work, they can seem to produce high quality summaries of some kinds of text, especially if the text is structurally similar to texts in their training data, but there is no guarantee that they will capture all views (it doesn't know what a view is), nor is there any guarantee that they won't introduce extraneous content. This makes them extremely poorly suited to extract information from a long involved conversation in which people are trying to hash out our desires for the future as part of a decisionmaking process.
Posting ChatGPT "summaries" invites readers who don't have time to view the entire thread to assume that the relevant information is represented, and I think it would be extremely unfortunate for our community if our members started adopting stances on proposals based on LLM-generated summaries.
If we can't figure out a real democratic process for representing the diverse views in our community, then maybe the right answer is that the community is just too big. I don't think we're to that point, but if people start seriously talking about LLMs as a solution for extracting meaning from our conversations, then I'd be inclined to say that we've reached that point.
At risk of stating the obvious, the ChatGPT summary that was posted by @Jonathan Bean clearly illustrates the dangers of inaccurate information being introduced by LLMs. This entire paragraph:
We also talked about your career interests and skills, and how you might be able to leverage these to support Social.Coop and the transition movement more broadly. We discussed the potential value of AI technology in supporting your work, including the ability to conduct research and analysis, create content and messaging, and engage with members of the Social.Coop community and other stakeholders.
does not reflect any part of our conversation thread as of the time the ChatGPT text was posted, and in fact is clearly geared toward an entirely different style of organization from Social.Coop. Until Jonathan Bean posted the the ChatGPT "summary", there was no discussion of AI at all in the current thread. And we don't engage with stakeholders beyond our own membership. ChatGPT couldn't capture this because it doesn't parse text or extract meaning. There is no comprehension of what has been said. The summary it gave is the best approximation it can come up with for summaries of text that is semantically similar to our conversation.
Democratic conversations by cooperative organizations clearly do not form a large portion of its training data, and if even they did, I'd be concerned that the "summary" it came up with would be a better reflection of some other democratic conversation rather than the ones we are having here.
@Dynamic It is important recognize the limitations of the GPT.
I should point out that the mistake is mine for not providing the proper context for that snippet of our conversation about this thread. In the google doc I do talk to it about my career interests and use of AI as personalized sort of suggester for what and how to vote and just secretarial kind of work, Imagine that everyone of us had an AI programed by us to create reports personalized for use on how to best represent us but of course with our final approval on votes.
So the summary is a summary of my conversation with the GPT AI about this thread and the broader social.coop Loomio and organization. At this point it is in the spirit of experimentation just something to be aware of as the trends around us grow.
I apologize as I have been quite busy and intended to participate more but some things have developed in my life taking a lot of spare time. Maybe there is some tech out there that would help manage the complexity a little better than we are with the current tools. I wish there was a plug in that could analyze the Loomio and allow me to participate with less time investment.
@Stephanie Jo Kent The tech is developing exponentially faster and faster and some say the newest version of GPT4 is pretty much at the level of a minor AGI Algorithmic General Intelligence capable of almost any human intelectual task. I am cautious about this transition but am optimistic that it would be very hard to make an AGI that was smart enough to be used to dominate us but dumb enough not be a benevolent intelligence as it seems in time greater intelligence tends toward greater benevolence as benevolence is the most intelligent strategy in the long game. But there are plenty reasons to still be worried about it.
But right now we can help shape the technology before less benevolent forces shape it.
I think I could probably ask it to make an AI powered Distributed Cooperative Organization platform at this point as I've seen many people simply engineering the prompt with natural language and getting fully functional code for entire apps to implement with very little modification.
I will write up some requirements and try to make it soon, hopefully we can solve this scalability problem with federated DisCOs assisted by algorithmic intelligences. So yes scary, but less benevolent forces are getting an edge and we might be left obsolete if we don't adapt. It is not the strongest that survives but that which is most adaptable to co-evolutions.
@Jonathan Bean
I agree that time is an issue, but I'd really prefer if we focused on social solutions rather than technical ones. I really feel like Loomio isn't currently working well for what we are trying to do.
Revised Social.Coop Organizing Circle Proposal
proposal by Matt Noyes Closed Tue 16 May 2023 2:52AM
THIS POLL IS FOR PEOPLE WHO VOLUNTEERED TO WORK ON REWRITING THE PROPOSAL. (I attempted to limit the notification to that group, but I think it got sent to everyone, which is fine, but this is just a preliminary step in the process before putting it to the whole group for discussion and a vote. - Matt N)
Hi all, sorry for the long wait! @Matthew Cropp and I revised the proposal, integrating the various comments and suggestions made. The revised version is attached. The document includes a previous version with comments, so you can see what was included. If you feel this version is "good enough for now, safe enough to try" we can propose it to the membership for a vote.
Results
| Results | Option | Votes | % of votes cast | % of eligible voters | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tiene buena pinta | 2 | 50 | 15 | ||
| Aún no estoy seguro | 2 | 50 | 15 | ||
| Preocupado | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Not voted | 9 | 69 |
Would still like to participate but I'm less sure what time I have to provide at this time.
I have reviewed the revised version and deem it 'safe enough to try'. I share concern that there may be some complexity cost, but for me the opportunity to manage significant periodic structural reflection and intervention in respect of global social diversity, inclusion and equity is worth that cost. I appreciate that this revision has respected the comments of previous participants & encourage everyone who committed to review and provide a sense-check before the impending deadline to do so.
Can someone help me understand why I received an email notification that I was invited to vote in this sense check but now have a Loomio message saying that I haven't been invited?
Yeah, ditto -- while I enjoy this sort of process-wonk work, the reality is that I'm over-committed to my eyeballs right now (something like nine positions across six organizations), so I can't volunteer in a responsible way this year.