Logo Update
new Logo options doc here:
https://docs.google.com/a/enspiral.com/file/d/0BzwI7aXuCzS7ZXlYU2lZeHA4amc/edit?usp=sharing
Version 5, currently being discussed:

I'd also be super keen to see a few variations - I like the radiant light-bulb lines Maz was playing around with for a while!
I agree with Matthew that it does draw too much attention to itself, possibly because we have looked at naked for so long. One solution I think might work is using the thread like it is used on the left most leg of the 'm', but up the other way. In this way it does not cross over itself like an 'e' does. I think that would do it without needing to break the thread or add anything else. @mazhermon can you or anyone else visualize that?
mmmm I want to like it cause it still gives a nudge to the lightbulb idea but I agree with everyone else. Its perfecting doesn't quite fit the style of the rest of the letters I don't think. I wonder if the whole word needs to be redrawn so the clarification applies to everything in the same style and feel?
(to be read in the friendliest of tones please :) The reason the 'i' draws so much attention to itself is because it's the only new element in something that we've all been looking at for the last year. I'd say no matter the solution we'll all be unfairly drawn to the i for the next while. I'd suggest again to just sit with it for a while before getting all of our thoughts on the table, but I realise this is how you work. As always with the design process this is the result of various stages of development and iterations of many of the ideas being presented. So my advice would be to give it some time and then start a discussion :)
I agree that we're all just noticing the i because it's new. However, I would like to see a version that closes the loop on the i, with no dot, as Matt and Aaron suggested. But Maz is the expert and if he says we just need to sit with it a while I think we should take his advice.
Yep I like that idea too, I'm certainly not trying to put a full stop on anything, just keen to give the options some breathing space
nice
Really respect your point of view Maz. I'd be interested to see some of the development and iterations if possible? Not to necessarily look at them as possibilities, but more to see the process and exploration?
I like this new version @mazhermon, almost as much as I like your approach to receiving feedback :)
For reference, I did a quick photoshop job along the lines of what @aaronthornton was suggesting (grabbed the loop off the 'm' and inverted and squished it to make an 'i'):

Nice work @richarddbartlett the 'i' certainly looks lees like an 'e'. We might get away with this.
OK now that we've had some time for this to sink in a bit, where are we at? @mazhermon ?
Here is another idea of what to do with the i...

1 minute ago · Like · Delete
Sorry I fell off the wagon there, sorry for lack of reply. YES I LOVE the one Rich posted of Aaron's suggestion. I'd sugest going with that as the final solution. I'll recreate it from the original though so you have it as a vector.
@chloewaretini sorry I missed that one Chloe
Awesome @mazhermon , sounds great! I'm wondering if it should be even more squished (somewhere intermediate between the one Rich posted and the one Alanna posted). Is it possible to get that as an option to consider?
I think the opening is crucial to keeping the image balanced. That's why it works. regarding the version Alanna has posted - I've been there and feel that its too cut off and looses the flow of the image.
Recreate the logo in the below post by Rich as the final logo solution?
proposal by Maz Hermon Closed Wed 3 Apr 2013 3:18AM
Maz is going to create three versions and show them to the group
Results
| Results | Option | Votes | % of votes cast | % of eligible voters | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Agree | 13 | 93 | 1 | ||
| Abstain | 1 | 7 | 0 | ||
| Disagree | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Block | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Not voted | 887 | 98 |
Yep, keen. Either way I'll plan on doing this, then showing you three options to choose from. 1. This one 2 The last presentation version 3. The three lines on top, and then give my strong opinion on which one is best and why
Awesome stuff Maz! I reckon it's the best option, and totally agree the gap is important (though I'd love to see how it looks if it's squished a tiny tiny bit more to make sure we remove the 'e' confusion)
what a glorious synergy of ideas! thanks Maz
I'd be happy!
I love the three options as next step bit.
Go with Version 5 for the Logo Update
proposal by Alanna Irving Closed Wed 8 May 2013 5:25AM
Results
| Results | Option | Votes | % of votes cast | % of eligible voters | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Agree | 12 | 80 | 1 | ||
| Abstain | 3 | 20 | 0 | ||
| Disagree | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Block | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Not voted | 887 | 98 |
clear and simple!
Mean
Good stuff guys.
satisfactory
Hey @mazhermon, is this the first proposal you've put through Loomio? Is it the historic moment that I'm thinking it might be!?
@mazhermon if you have the new logo done, I could use it on the investment documentation I'm about to send to print...
Great idea @matthewbartlett ... Maz sometimes doesn't check Loomio every day so if you don't hear back try email or phone
Will get these options out to you guys asap, there's no final logo yet, have talked to Matthew already about this. I'm on mega deadline attack at the mo but will get this done very soon
Hey @mazhermon just wondering how it's going with this? Are you still snowed under?
Yep, was just about to email you all but found this thread again. Totally feeling the need to get this to you guys asap, has been on my mind. Racing the clock on two things so haven't found the time but will try to get it done during the weekend. Keep hitting me up and I'll get it to you asap, sorry for the super-delay
Thanks @mazhermon ... you rock!
Once thursday comes around I'll be straight on this. Promise. I'm even writing it in my diary as I type :)
Hi all,
new Logo options doc here:
https://docs.google.com/a/enspiral.com/file/d/0BzwI7aXuCzS7ZXlYU2lZeHA4amc/edit?usp=sharing
not sure if I can attach a file here? is that an admin privilege?
My recommendation has been noted as #5 with reasons given on the doc. Happy to talk this over soon.
Thoughts on viewing:
Perhaps sit with it on your own before talking together.
View each logo large and small if you're able to zoom in and out within the google doc viewer.
I should really have presented this to you in person but as I have delayed the process already, here it is. Keen to talk over your thoughts next week.
Cheers
Yip, version 5 for me
Love your work @mazhermon I'd be happy to have any one of these options on our masthead. Agree that 5 is prob my favourite :)
I'd be super happy with version 3 or version 5!
5 is totes my fave... Nice work @mazhermon
High 5
Version 5! Thanks Maz!!
I like it. I wonder whether a by line should be included - the word that comes to mind for me is "Neutral"
Best
Nick
Where has the tail gone?
Hey @mazhermon I know you've been away but I'm wondering if you're back now? When you're ready it would be great to finish this process so we could update the logo on the website, business cards, etc.
@mazhermon do you have a version with a long tail, or a vector version that I could play with?
@matthewbartlett it would be sweet if you could track Maz down proactively about this... been waiting for him to turn up but I think he's been busy with other stuff. Business cards and other projects have been waiting on this.
I don't think it quite works. Though it's nice that it's now a recognisable i, that hollow dot draws too much attention to itself, makes the logo feel less like a unity. I'd love to see some variations — e.g. using a closed dot; closing up the hole in the i so it looks less like an e.