Allocating the PledgeMe Funds
Here are some of the ideas we have previously discussed: Jon and Aaron each need about $2k. Rich needs about $1K for now. There's also the questions of desks... we could pay to keep using desks here, or pay for internet at 19 Tory, etc.
I'd like to pay a reasonable koha for desk space at Enspiral.
My financial situation is not quite at as dire as it was last week, so I could get by with a smaller lump sum if necessary. $1k would be ideal but half that would be wonderful.
It's likely that Enspiral will agree to give desks to Loomio for a koha that's less than the $700 it would normally cost for two desks. There's also the option to ask the rest of the office how they'd feel about us setting up in the server room. We'd have to pay something for that, but not as much as desks.
Obviously any decisions about Enspiral giving Loomio desks would be run as a Loomio on the Enspiral group...
I personally don't like working in the server room. I find it really lab-ratty. Would rather work from home if I had to choose between the two.
Also, I'm just wondering about giving some of this money to Kiesia. If some of this money could help keep her working on the project instead of her having to take on more paid work, I'd be happy to see some of my share of the green-apple pie going toward that.
About the server room... I understand it's not ideal but if it's between that and not being in the office I think it's really important to have the team in the office...
Hasn't Enspiral agreed to give loomio desks for free until there is a space squeeze or paying desk renters?
Allan - the agreement with Enspiral was for a limited period of one month. We could propose to extend it, but the situation is a bit different now since if Loomio wants to stay, we'll need to buy more desks from OSR, as opposed to last time when we had the free desks around.
I am fine with paying koha with pledge me funds for two desks at enspiral. I agree it is beneficial to be in the cozy enspiral nest, at least until we can fly...
I join Jon on his point. Even if it's not relevant as I'll leave next week, I really don't like the idea of working in the server room. I've done this during a 6 month internship. between the cooling system (which shouldn't be a problem here), the noise and the nice view, I can't say I'd start over again with great pleasure.
Yeah, I think healthy work environment (physically, emotionally, etc.) is really important for longevity. If I had to work in the server room I think I'd start to resent coming to work every day.
What if Aaron, Rich and I each take 1k for now, and then we can decide what to do with the rest later?
Later on we could choose to give some of the other money to other team-members, use it for various expenses, and/or maybe give more of it to Aaron and Rich and I later.
OK assuming we give koha to Enspiral for two desks, what should the amount be? We charge out desks at $350/month, and pay $300 to OSR (the difference is for office expenses, etc). I think we could successfully pitch paying less than that and asking Enspiral to cover the difference.
I have no clue about anything related to Enspiral financials. What do you and Josh think is fair? This might be a discussion we should open up to the Enspiral group?
We can either figure out what we want to pay and see if it flies with Enspiral, or we can raise a Loomio over there and see what people ask for.
discussion sounds like it's (sort of) a criteria of the ff.:
80% People - proportion of effort so far, urgency or importance of need/financial leeway, Loomio priorities
10% Process / Facilities - desk space, administration
10% Technologies - Internet, domain names, SSL certificates
which might help with determining how much to pay Enspiral for the desks, etc?
Really no into the server room. I've done that before and it kills your health after a while.
$1k each to Jon, Aaron, and Rich. Rest of the money and desks to be decided later.
proposal by Alanna Irving Closed Mon 28 May 2012 5:45AM
Results
| Results | Option | Votes | % of votes cast | % of eligible voters | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Agree | 11 | 92 | 1 | ||
| Abstain | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Disagree | 1 | 8 | 0 | ||
| Block | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Not voted | 889 | 99 |
We gotta make sure these guys get enough food in their plate to survive
I agree with RDB
I agree with JV
$500 each to Aaron, Jon, Kiesia, Maz, Rich, and Enspiral
proposal by Richard D. Bartlett Closed Tue 29 May 2012 9:12AM
Results
| Results | Option | Votes | % of votes cast | % of eligible voters | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Agree | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Abstain | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Disagree | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Block | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Not voted | 899 | 100 |
$500 each to Aaron, Jon, Kiesia, Maz, Rich, and Enspiral
proposal by Richard D. Bartlett Closed Thu 31 May 2012 9:19AM
Results
| Results | Option | Votes | % of votes cast | % of eligible voters | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Agree | 11 | 79 | 1 | ||
| Abstain | 3 | 21 | 0 | ||
| Disagree | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Block | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Not voted | 889 | 98 |
I think this is a reasonable way to start. And we could potentially hand out more money later if the group wants.
money well spent
I'm happy to work wherever - I'd like to give priority to coders having a nice space to work in to reach MAXIMUM PRODUCTIVITY
(and I'd fully support $$ going to Kiesia if at all possible)
I feel like we should change the proposal to include $1k for Kiesia's relentless hard work
@rdb and @m?b
how about creating a new motion to send 1k to kiesia as the two motions aren't mutually exclusive?
I'm so conflicted! Seems we are having a discussion here about where to allocate the funds, and it doesn't make much sense to bifurcate that discussion.
I'm sticking with 'no' not 'block' because I'm happy if the group decides to pass this proposal but I'd prefer it to include my amendment. But it closes in 5 hours so I can start a new proposal then if need be.
I think as a general rule, we should vote no on proposals if we think they could be improved by an amendment, and let them fail so we can raise a new proposal in the same discussion. So I think Rich is handling this correctly. When the current proposal closes, we can raise a new one.
However, I would really like to actually hear from Kiesia before we make this decision...
Yeah, I think we should leave it up to Kiesia to see what she feels comfortable with.
The way we originally decided on how to allot this money was we just went around a circle in a meeting and some of us said "It'd be nice if I could get 1k of this money" and other people said "I don't need any of this money right now". Basically, we just left it up to the people in the room to choose how much money they wanted to claim from the campaign. So I think we should give Kiesia the same option.
We (Aaron, Alanna, Ben, Jon, and I) had a discussion about this today: basically we were not too keen on the $1k x3 proposal so I checked up on some background with people and came up with a new proposal.
The amendments are as follows:
1) we'd rather have smaller lump sums shared further so we'll lower the amount to $500 each
2) both Kiesia and Maz have put significant chunks of work into this project and are both just as in need of financial support as any of us so we want to give them a thank you payment
3) Enspiral offered us free desk space for a month, which is up for renewal in a couple of days (http://loom.io/discussions/47). It is costing them $300/month per desk at the moment and they are not exactly flush with cash right now so we want to give them a koha to say thanks for your support so far and as a sign of good will while we come to a more lasting arrangement (which may take a week or two to facilitate).
I'm putting a short time span on this proposal so we can get this resolved ASAP, it's dumb having money sitting in the account while people are in need.
Whoops sorry about that last proposal, I put the wrong date on it :)
I didn't see any of the new discussion until now. So, hmm. My situation is that I have money for this week and then I am broke. $500 would keep me alive for another week, then I should get paid by one of my slacker clients ;-)
Sounds exquisitely equitable to me!
I'm happy as long as everyone else is. Smiley face
Sounds good. Should I go ahead and raised a loomio on the Enspiral side about giving Loomio the two desks for another month for $500?
@Alanna yeah that'd be awesome. Or how about instead of raising it as a proposal, start a discussion mentioning that we are interested in giving $500 for another month of 2 desks and then see what people say, and then if it sounds like there is consensus we make a proposal?
My intent was not for the $500 to 'pay for' the desks for another month, exactly, though that might be agreeable. Koha is quite different from trade. My intent was to acknowledge the tremendous support we've received thus far, and to start the conversation off on the right foot when we renegotiate the desk space with Enspiral.
Does that make sense?
Make it rain
We need to decide how to distribute the funds from PledgeMe. We haven't received them yet but should get them any day now. According to my calculation, the total is $5121.