Loomio

Organising photos

G goob Public Seen by 211

It would be good to discuss ideas for how to organise photos in Diaspora. I've seen two ideas proposed so far: Facebook-style 'albums' and using tags to organise photos.

It would be interesting to hear people's views on the merits and drawbacks of these and any other ideas you have for organising photos.

BC

Balasankar C Thu 21 Nov 2013 7:49AM

Photo albums do play an important role in building the argument for a "social network". I don't think anyone will take the difficult path of joining diaspora + joining other sites for sharing photos. They can simply join any other existing social networking site where they can upload photos and share them in the same platform. And, from my experience, chat and photos are the two features that still forces users to stick to conventional social networking sites like Facebook even if they are aware of privacy infringement.

Why can't we have a photo album that has privacy options similar to posts? Each photo is a post that can be commented/shared.

KAK

Karthikeyan A K Sat 7 Dec 2013 2:49AM

+1 for albums

F

Flaburgan Sat 7 Dec 2013 5:16PM

We should deal with that smartly, and use tags to regroup posts containing photos. We could also possibly use the old beta profile, which was really nice to display images.

D

dremodaris Thu 23 Jan 2014 10:48AM

I'd like to add three things:
1) I completely agree with Balasankars last post.
2) An advantage of a tagged-post system over a directory system is that you can easily put one photo in multiple albums.
3) As a fix for the problem of adding new contacts, I propose the following: when you're viewing one of your aspects (i.e. the list of people in it), every contact would have a field for setting the point in time after which posts in this aspect are visible to the contact. By default, this time is set to the moment when you added the contact to the aspect, but you could move it back in time.
It would also make sense then, that, when you remove a contact from an aspect, he would remain there (greyed out), but with another field added, stating the time of removal (unless no post were made to this aspect during his being-in-it).
Finally, I think it would make sense if the poster could see which aspects he posted a post to (e.g. when hovering over "limited" - this information is already stored anyway, since you can filter your own posts by viewing different aspects). These features combined would make it 100% trackable whether person X can see post Y.

G

Poll Created Wed 29 Jan 2014 2:08PM

Use #tags to organise uploaded photos Closed Sat 8 Feb 2014 8:10PM

Outcome
by goob Tue 25 Apr 2017 5:15AM

We will use tags as the basis for organising uploaded photos.

As proposed in the discussion, use Diaspora's #tag system to organise photos rather than using Facebook-style static albums.

Results

Results Option % of points Voters
Agree 69.7% 23 JH JR F EG G DU PG SM CG SVB S AKS FTL N M KAK A MM QD A
Abstain 9.1% 3 L DB PP
Disagree 21.2% 7 ST PP RS- N A SP DU
Block 0.0% 0  
Undecided 0% 127 JL BK FS MS TS AA S CB HF BO DM GC JH M G AX PC BB LP T

33 of 160 people have participated (20%)

DU

Itai
Disagree
Wed 29 Jan 2014 3:17PM

IMHO we need both tags and albums, with ability to tag albums or individual photos to create 'themed' photo streams. Albums are more suitable for photos from specific events. Also,I don't find naming with tags convenient (e.g #southamericajanuar2014)

G

goob
Agree
Wed 29 Jan 2014 10:08PM

I think using tags gives plenty of flexibility, and fits in well with Diaspora's design and ethos.

KAK

Karthikeyan A K
Agree
Thu 30 Jan 2014 10:08AM

Good idea!

JR

Jason Robinson
Agree
Sat 1 Feb 2014 6:29PM

Sounds good :)

FTL

FÁBIÁN Tamás László
Agree
Sun 2 Feb 2014 10:18AM

I think it's a good idea and has a lot of potential for future features.

Load More