Loomio

Proposals 81 - 100

NP Natasha Penn Public Seen by 159
NP

Poll Created Wed 31 Jul 2019 10:33PM

81 YouthLaw Aotearoa Inc Closed Thu 15 Aug 2019 12:04AM

Results

Results Option Points Mean Voters
Innovation 50 7.1 7
Undecided 0 0 4

7 of 11 people have voted (63%)

AM

Audry McLaren Tue 6 Aug 2019 9:45PM

5 - Innovation

The resulting works could be impactful to the broader community. In developing the works, those deeply involved will likely have Deep Impact. I'm unsure if this is innovative. However it does excite me as a proposal. How cool to bring the arts and laws together.

SP

Shalini Pillai Mon 12 Aug 2019 9:44AM

7 - Innovation

I think there is significant potential in addressing our priority. There is also opportunity for this to part of a collaboration of multiple projects.

JT

Jade Tang-Taylor Tue 13 Aug 2019 10:48AM

8 - Innovation

Believe this has the potential to be truly game-changing if done well, and authentically co-design with rangitahi out South. Think that all young people should know their legal rights, and best delivered and communicated by other young people too!

S

Shona Tue 13 Aug 2019 12:03PM

8 - Innovation

This unlikely combination is both interesting and right in the impact sweet spot together with good design process. Like.

NP

Poll Created Wed 31 Jul 2019 10:34PM

82 Pam Fergusson Charitable Trust (2) Closed Thu 15 Aug 2019 12:05AM

Results

Results Option Points Mean Voters
Innovation 25 4.2 6
Undecided 0 0 4

7 of 11 people have voted (63%)

AM

Audry McLaren Tue 6 Aug 2019 9:50PM

2 - Innovation

Community funding candidate.

JT

Jade Tang-Taylor Tue 13 Aug 2019 10:55AM

5 - Innovation

Love the "kaupapa of e-Pou we have approached our engagement with every community with the understanding that our role in their journey into the digital future is to walk alongside and support them." Strong concept and strong team, rather steep staff costs though? Worth exploring...

NP

Poll Created Wed 31 Jul 2019 10:34PM

83 Literacy Aotearoa Greater Auckland Closed Thu 15 Aug 2019 12:06AM

Results

Results Option Points Mean Voters
Innovation 24 3.4 7
Undecided 0 0 4

7 of 11 people have voted (63%)

AM

Audry McLaren Tue 6 Aug 2019 9:54PM

2 - Innovation

Waiheke v S.A. populations are so different and can success on the island be translated into SA?
Proposal sounds to me v similar to a polytech time situation.

SP

Shalini Pillai Mon 12 Aug 2019 10:57AM

6 - Innovation

could be an interesting project to consider. not so new but could be part of a bigger, multifaceted project.

SP

Shalini Pillai Mon 12 Aug 2019 10:57AM

5 - Innovation

could be an interesting project to consider. not so new but could be part of a bigger, multifaceted project.

JT

Jade Tang-Taylor Tue 13 Aug 2019 10:41AM

4 - Innovation

Interesting... Again, not 100% on whether it's community led & driven by South Aucklanders. Not sure if it's truly "innovative" v/s something that could be supported under core-funding.

S

Shona Wed 14 Aug 2019 9:26AM

3 - Innovation

Echo the other comment about connection to community. Its a busy space and I cant see the innovation fit with this fund.

NP

Poll Created Wed 31 Jul 2019 10:35PM

84 Tongan Catholic Chaplaincy Diocese of Auckland Closed Thu 15 Aug 2019 12:06AM

Results

Results Option Points Mean Voters
Innovation 38 5.4 7
Undecided 0 0 4

7 of 11 people have voted (63%)

AM

Audry McLaren Tue 6 Aug 2019 9:56PM

5 - Innovation

Would like to see focus on u5s for resilance training with secondary on youth. Otago points to this being fundamental to overall life outcomes.
Has potential for signifanct ompact.

SP

Shalini Pillai Mon 12 Aug 2019 11:02AM

7 - Innovation

I like this project - seems like it could be a good case study for similar projects in churches. Strong team and seems like a well thought out project.

JT

Jade Tang-Taylor Tue 13 Aug 2019 10:37AM

5 - Innovation

Interesting Church community connections in colab with a Health Org.. I truly believe that all young people need to learn the importance of resilience, however this feels rather niche targeted to the Tonga Church population. Potentially more effective though?

S

Sarag Wed 14 Aug 2019 2:15AM

5 - Innovation

Having coffee with Alliance Health CEO Friday am (not FN work) happy to ask any questions if required - let me know

S

Shona Wed 14 Aug 2019 9:23AM

0 - Innovation

Reading this I felt myself assuming this already existed. Its is a big ask for a new program and is very 'planned' for the stage of innovation that they are at. I'd want to see a more incremental, test learn iterate approach to design. Also, who are the other potential funders in this space - is this not something churches fund?

S

Shona Wed 14 Aug 2019 9:24AM

3 - Innovation

Reading this I felt myself assuming this already existed. Its is a big ask for a new program and is very 'planned' for the stage of innovation that they are at. I'd want to see a more incremental, test learn iterate approach to design. Also, who are the other potential funders in this space - is this not something churches fund?

NP

Poll Created Wed 31 Jul 2019 10:35PM

85 Kai Ika Closed Thu 15 Aug 2019 12:06AM

Results

Results Option Points Mean Voters
Innovation 53 6.6 8
Undecided 0 0 4

8 of 12 people have voted (66%)

CH

chloe harwood Sun 11 Aug 2019 9:08AM

6 - Innovation

i like the focus on using the underutilized parts of fish - think this is worth learning more

SP

Shalini Pillai Mon 12 Aug 2019 11:08AM

8 - Innovation

sounds like an amazing project that has potential for replication, and multiple outcomes. Especially if there are also employment and sustainable food growing outcomes for communities as well.

JT

Jade Tang-Taylor Tue 13 Aug 2019 10:34AM

5 - Innovation

Love the idea of Waste Minimisation and using food as a connecting element. However, feel like this is a slight iteration of a previous "food community hub" idea. Maybe potential to convene a "food hui" and connect in with KAI Auckland initiative?

S

Sarag Wed 14 Aug 2019 6:26AM

7 - Innovation

like the specific focus on fish

S

Shona Wed 14 Aug 2019 9:12AM

8 - Innovation

What makes this high on the innovation score for me is the multiple benefits that are created from this enterprise. This is true circular economy meets community in a space (fish) I haven't seen before.

AH

Aroha Harris Wed 14 Aug 2019 6:54PM

7 - Innovation

Papatuanuku Marae have been innovators in waste minimization having won awards and been leaders hua parakore (teaching traditional Maori practices of growing food systems). They are active in teaching te reo me ona tikanga. They have an idea and a plan that helps feed the community, earth mother, takes care of tangaroa (our harbour) and looks to create a more sustainable future.

NP

Poll Created Wed 31 Jul 2019 10:36PM

86 MyPro Closed Thu 15 Aug 2019 12:05AM

Results

Results Option Points Mean Voters
Innovation 24 3.4 7
Undecided 0 0 5

7 of 12 people have voted (58%)

CH

chloe harwood Sun 11 Aug 2019 9:02AM

2 - Innovation

employment generation app - not connected into the community

SP

Shalini Pillai Mon 12 Aug 2019 11:13AM

4 - Innovation

Not sure about this one. Could be good but need more information or a conversation, i feel.

JT

Jade Tang-Taylor Tue 13 Aug 2019 10:17AM

4 - Innovation

Like the strengths-based approach to an community issue around under/unemployment. I wouldn't under-estimate the amount of resource it takes to pull something like this off, especially if they are yet to get started. Unsure of financial sustainability of the model. Potential partnership with W&I, MBIE or MSD?

S

Shona Wed 14 Aug 2019 9:06AM

2 - Innovation

I've seen a number of these 'matching' type platforms for employment attempted in the past and they really struggle with getting the scale of use and adoption that makes them helpful. I believe Youth Connections does something similar for young people. I'm not sure how that's going but if people want to proceed I can find out.

NP

Poll Created Wed 31 Jul 2019 10:36PM

87 PlusPlay Closed Thu 15 Aug 2019 12:06AM

Results

Results Option Points Mean Voters
Innovation 39 5.6 7
Undecided 0 0 5

7 of 12 people have voted (58%)

CH

chloe harwood Sun 11 Aug 2019 9:00AM

6 - Innovation

team - has specialist skills , interesting concept , like the idea of being co developed , worth exploring

SP

Shalini Pillai Tue 13 Aug 2019 5:33AM

4 - Innovation

Could be interesting but unsure. How does it engage young people with each other?

JT

Jade Tang-Taylor Tue 13 Aug 2019 10:13AM

6 - Innovation

Completely agree that "Play is how we learn best and healthy social connection is necessary to combat isolation and anti-social, criminal behaviours" however, I don't know if they're realistic on the cost of designing/developing an app/ gamification digital around this. Worth exploring...

S

Sarag Wed 14 Aug 2019 6:31AM

6 - Innovation

interesting concept - looks like the team have good skills

S

Shona Wed 14 Aug 2019 9:02AM

7 - Innovation

I'm really interested. I think they'd have no problem developing a high quality product. I'd like to see a good theory of change pop out of the discovery phase so that the connection between the outcomes and game design is well considered. Ownership and access would be something to explore.

NP

Poll Created Wed 31 Jul 2019 10:37PM

88 Piri Pāua Closed Thu 15 Aug 2019 12:06AM

Results

Results Option Points Mean Voters
Innovation 18 2.6 7
Undecided 0 0 5

7 of 12 people have voted (58%)

CH

chloe harwood Sun 11 Aug 2019 8:50AM

3 - Innovation

worthwhile - cluster of projects looking at developing language resources across pacific languages

SP

Shalini Pillai Tue 13 Aug 2019 6:15AM

2 - Innovation

I feel like this has been done before? have fudned under core funding?

JT

Jade Tang-Taylor Tue 13 Aug 2019 10:09AM

3 - Innovation

Sounds like an interesting bi-lingual approach. however for some reason the application doesn't instil me with confidence.

S

Sarag Wed 14 Aug 2019 6:33AM

4 - Innovation

Govt has just funded $20m over 4 years for pacific languages - PEC are the Pacific Ministers key fale of four rep language - this could plug into one of those places v standalone - i like the flashcard concept - presume there might be something out there already?

S

Shona Wed 14 Aug 2019 8:51AM

2 - Innovation

Same comments for proposal 90. It doesnt meet my idea of the minimum level of innovation for this fund

NP

Poll Created Wed 31 Jul 2019 10:37PM

89 SPCA - IOSIS - SCSP Closed Thu 15 Aug 2019 12:06AM

Results

Results Option Points Mean Voters
Innovation 36 5.1 7
Undecided 0 0 5

7 of 12 people have voted (58%)

CH

chloe harwood Sun 11 Aug 2019 8:34AM

4 - Innovation

interesting angle and partnership - possibly a better fit with core funding

SP

Shalini Pillai Tue 13 Aug 2019 6:52AM

7 - Innovation

I like that this is about teaching children kindness and empathy towards the other. And how to relate to themselves adn each other. Mindfulness is key to healing trauma as well.

JT

Jade Tang-Taylor Tue 13 Aug 2019 10:06AM

4 - Innovation

Interesting idea around "targeted interventions" - And I'm sure this is evidence-based research. For some reason this just doesn't feel quite right and not necessarily "community-led & driven" by South Aucklanders. Potentially for under BAU/core-funding?

S

Sarag Wed 14 Aug 2019 6:34AM

3 - Innovation

not sure if this is a fit

S

Shona Wed 14 Aug 2019 8:55AM

7 - Innovation

One of the first proposals I've seen that really connects rigourous insight to the proposed. "design and testing of accessible interventions that address the underlying causes and risk factors related to violence and child victimisation." Its obviously a big need area - directly related to persistent inequalities. Would like to see them more further into Virtual Reality space rather than static resource as they've shown to generate empathy.

NP

Poll Created Wed 31 Jul 2019 10:38PM

90 Pacific Kids Learning Closed Thu 15 Aug 2019 12:05AM

Results

Results Option Points Mean Voters
Innovation 28 3.5 8
Undecided 0 0 4

8 of 12 people have voted (66%)

AM

Audry McLaren Sun 4 Aug 2019 2:11AM

5 - Innovation

Soudns kind of cool

CH

chloe harwood Sun 11 Aug 2019 8:23AM

2 - Innovation

not sure that classroom resources and apps are an innovative space for this fund

SP

Shalini Pillai Tue 13 Aug 2019 7:55AM

6 - Innovation

i like this programme, but i think COMET already supports somethign like this? COMET has the expertise and the connections.

JT

Jade Tang-Taylor Tue 13 Aug 2019 10:02AM

4 - Innovation

Haha' love that it's a "newly registered social enterprise that has been in a long incubation period" - Do they mean multi-lingual v/s bi-lingual as there's quite a few pacific languages to consider in the design/development of this app'

S

Sarag Wed 14 Aug 2019 6:36AM

4 - Innovation

lots happening in this space - might be worth looking at all the connects

S

Shona Wed 14 Aug 2019 8:47AM

1 - Innovation

Some similar proposals in this space suggests a bit need or lack of awareness of what is available. Again, I scored the other proposal low on innovation so doing the same here.

NP

Poll Created Wed 31 Jul 2019 10:38PM

91 Manukau Auckland Volleyball Incorporated Closed Thu 15 Aug 2019 12:04AM

Results

Results Option Points Mean Voters
Innovation 19 2.4 8
Undecided 0 0 4

8 of 12 people have voted (66%)

AM

Audry McLaren Sun 4 Aug 2019 2:09AM

3 - Innovation

Another mentoring programme??? Where are all these mentors going to come from? Volleyball is a key sport for Pacific communities and this programme could have good reach into churches, schools and clubs. I believe we are expecting an application to CG via Volleyball NZ. Would seem that communication between NSO and RSO could be strengthened.

CH

chloe harwood Sun 11 Aug 2019 8:13AM

3 - Innovation

more suited to core funding

SP

Shalini Pillai Tue 13 Aug 2019 7:54AM

1 - Innovation

mentoring / leadership aspect is good, but don't think this is innovative.

JT

Jade Tang-Taylor Tue 13 Aug 2019 9:53AM

3 - Innovation

I love that they are involving and considering Indian communities from South AKL, but sounds like a very expansion volleyball programme to run and sustain over an extended period of time. Also not particularly "Innovative"

S

Shona Wed 14 Aug 2019 8:45AM

2 - Innovation

So much Sport and mentoring! I'm going with a similarly low innovation score across the board.

NP

Poll Created Wed 31 Jul 2019 10:39PM

92 Manurewa Marlins Rugby League Club Closed Thu 15 Aug 2019 12:03AM

Results

Results Option Points Mean Voters
Innovation 24 3.0 8
Undecided 0 0 4

8 of 12 people have voted (66%)

AM

Audry McLaren Sun 4 Aug 2019 2:06AM

5 - Innovation

A greate opportunity for a club with deep connections into the community to make a diffrence. Low ask. Worth purusing. The club also mentioned moving from its current location and needs to determine the reasons for this and whether it is a real need or just a difficult phase in the eveluotion of being in a shared space.

CH

chloe harwood Sun 11 Aug 2019 8:10AM

3 - Innovation

while a well identified need and area for focus cannot see innovation in the approach , wonder if other clubs are providing these wrap around services

SP

Shalini Pillai Tue 13 Aug 2019 8:02AM

1 - Innovation

doesnt seem innovative to me. I like that sports orgs are thinking about more than just sporting outcomes but i feel like they do this anyway, just more about extension of the programme.

JT

Jade Tang-Taylor Tue 13 Aug 2019 9:50AM

3 - Innovation

Again, sport is not my forte but I love the "Atuatanga & Maramataka to further enhance preparation and awareness of self." - Maybe there's an opportunity convene a conversation, around sport & rec, and overall wellbeing of rangitahi? Feel like there's a theme emerging.

S

Shona Wed 14 Aug 2019 8:43AM

3 - Innovation

I echo Shalini's view on this around the value of broader outcomes. Low on the innovation score - very much a cluster of proposals in this space - suitable for BAU?

NP

Poll Created Wed 31 Jul 2019 10:41PM

93 Sueina Lisati – Sewing printing and translation projects Closed Thu 15 Aug 2019 12:05AM

Results

Results Option Points Mean Voters
Innovation 24 3.0 8
Undecided 0 0 4

8 of 12 people have voted (66%)

AM

Audry McLaren Sun 4 Aug 2019 2:02AM

3 - Innovation

Perhaps women coming togehter to tell teh story of climate change would have greter impact than scientists. A ground swell of concisousness. Seems like something CNZ might fund.

CH

chloe harwood Sun 11 Aug 2019 8:05AM

2 - Innovation

two very different aspects to the proposal - more suited to core funding

SP

Shalini Pillai Tue 13 Aug 2019 8:16AM

4 - Innovation

I dont fully understand this, but some elements sound amazing. would like to explore further.

JT

Jade Tang-Taylor Tue 13 Aug 2019 9:47AM

3 - Innovation

Love the idea "to support, encourage and promote us women with creative and amazing ideas with different skills" and to bring about a much-needed conversation on Climate Change. Not entirely convince by the proposal, team and/or use of funds though :-/ Maybe a CNZ / FN Diversity Fund oppotunity?

S

Sarag Wed 14 Aug 2019 6:39AM

4 - Innovation

two very different sides. like the sewing side - i have had a few meetings in the make a space with specific reference to creative fashion economy of late.... area of focus in some spaces

S

Shona Wed 14 Aug 2019 8:41AM

3 - Innovation

I love that they've come in for funding for the first time. I'm not convinced by either proposition as they are outlined. I like Audry's spin on it!

NP

Poll Created Wed 31 Jul 2019 10:41PM

94 Manurewa Marae Closed Thu 15 Aug 2019 12:06AM

Results

Results Option Points Mean Voters
Innovation 36 4.0 9
Undecided 0 0 3

9 of 12 people have voted (75%)

AM

Audry McLaren Sun 4 Aug 2019 1:40AM

2 - Innovation

Would revisit the C4C application for Taiohi Whai Oranga - similarities between this and that.

CH

chloe harwood Sun 11 Aug 2019 7:59AM

6 - Innovation

I am keen to hear more from Aroha and Rosie ( connection to our cfc ) - this sounds as if they have identified some key ares where they can focus and grow , this has real potential - whether it is this fund

SP

Shalini Pillai Tue 13 Aug 2019 8:25AM

3 - Innovation

seems like this will be a costly project to sustain. GIven the changes manurewa marae have been through recently, i think perhaps the timing is not right?

JT

Jade Tang-Taylor Tue 13 Aug 2019 9:43AM

5 - Innovation

Love that they are "flipping the script on Urban Maori Potential." - Much needed mahi, but not entirely sure how "innovative" it is... Could potentially be under BAU/core-funding? Keen to hear from Aroha on this one :)

S

Shona Wed 14 Aug 2019 8:38AM

3 - Innovation

I'm keen on working with the Marae in South Auckland but I'm not sure this proposal hits the innovation alignment with the fund. I'm also lacking a whole bunch of context that's probably vital to make a useful assessment here.

AH

Aroha Harris Wed 14 Aug 2019 6:32PM

7 - Innovation

Manurewa Marae has been active in the space of re-engaging with their community and exploring what their community wants. Food sovereignty and manaakitanga sits at the heart of community wellness. The skills learnt in both of these domains are transferable. The benefits of teaching maara kai, growing of food, harvesting of nutritional food, food planning and preparation is central to building healthy homes and healthy communities.

NP

Poll Created Wed 31 Jul 2019 10:43PM

95 Pacific Enterprise People Closed Thu 15 Aug 2019 12:04AM

Results

Results Option Points Mean Voters
Innovation 25 3.1 8
Undecided 0 0 4

8 of 12 people have voted (66%)

AM

Audry McLaren Sun 4 Aug 2019 1:38AM

3 - Innovation

anticipate an intial small reach with small team. Like the capacity building. Sounds like a small business consultancy - could be attached to small business accounting or the like, or through the church, or CAB

CH

chloe harwood Sun 11 Aug 2019 7:46AM

2 - Innovation

while well needed support for getting people into job or enterprise - community capability building - giving a series of talks does not feel innovative - suggest could maybe link in with some others who have already started to deliver in this area

SP

Shalini Pillai Tue 13 Aug 2019 8:34AM

6 - Innovation

Think there is a lot of potential in supporting people in enterprise, whatever the level. The team seems strong and well connected.

SP

Shalini Pillai Tue 13 Aug 2019 8:37AM

3 - Innovation

Think there is a lot of potential in supporting people in enterprise, but is it more than just talks?

JT

Jade Tang-Taylor Tue 13 Aug 2019 9:38AM

6 - Innovation

Love the idea of "social enterprise capability building" for pacific people. Good team/person with strong experience in this area. Looks like they're potentially opening up the online market to China too. Could be more than just talks proposed, and move into hands-on workshops?

S

Shona Wed 14 Aug 2019 8:32AM

3 - Innovation

There are other similar proposals that I've broadly assessed as being low in innovation. The quality of the writing put me off.

NP

Poll Created Wed 31 Jul 2019 10:44PM

96 TUNUMA CREATIVE Closed Thu 15 Aug 2019 12:02AM

Results

Results Option Points Mean Voters
Innovation 31 3.9 8
Undecided 0 0 4

8 of 12 people have voted (66%)

AM

Audry McLaren Sun 4 Aug 2019 1:35AM

2 - Innovation

Did not get a real sense of what they propose. Use of funds seems high. Do like promotion of indepedence not dependence on programm/mentor - not aware this is evividenced about mentor/metee relationships

CH

chloe harwood Sun 11 Aug 2019 3:57AM

6 - Innovation

good team with specialist experience - clearly a cluster of organisations wanting to use creative arts and culture to engage young people - worth exploring

SP

Shalini Pillai Tue 13 Aug 2019 9:00AM

4 - Innovation

Sounds promising, but is essentially another mentoring programme

JT

Jade Tang-Taylor Tue 13 Aug 2019 9:33AM

4 - Innovation

Another mentoring programme? Love the potential magic of "ultimately helping them to realise their true identity and thus un-lock their true potential" but quite challenging to do in reality, and not entirely convinced by the application/video.

S

Shona Wed 14 Aug 2019 8:28AM

4 - Innovation

This fits in that bigger art/youth/culture cluster but not big on the innovation.

NP

Poll Created Wed 31 Jul 2019 10:44PM

97 Dominion Closed Thu 15 Aug 2019 12:05AM

Results

Results Option Points Mean Voters
Innovation 24 3.0 8
Undecided 0 0 4

8 of 12 people have voted (66%)

AM

Audry McLaren Sun 4 Aug 2019 1:30AM

2 - Innovation

Market garden for beneficiary families. Could be good, but hardly innovative given Auckland's history of epic market gardening in South Auckland.

CH

chloe harwood Sun 11 Aug 2019 3:36AM

3 - Innovation

suggest that could be considered with the work of the church

SP

Shalini Pillai Tue 13 Aug 2019 9:06AM

5 - Innovation

good project. could enable good outcomes for families of the church

JT

Jade Tang-Taylor Tue 13 Aug 2019 9:28AM

3 - Innovation

Yet another community garden? Like that they're leveraging church land and making the most of it their church community, but not sure how "innovative" it is.

S

Shona Wed 14 Aug 2019 8:26AM

2 - Innovation

If I were starting an enterprise I'd buy a bunch of gardening equipment and do quick turnaround leasing to these gardens - its a growing sector!

NP

Poll Created Wed 31 Jul 2019 10:45PM

98 Nasita Production Closed Thu 15 Aug 2019 12:04AM

Results

Results Option Points Mean Voters
Innovation 16 2.3 7
Undecided 0 0 5

7 of 12 people have voted (58%)

CH

chloe harwood Sun 11 Aug 2019 3:26AM

2 - Innovation

inspiring - feels like this is more about growing her individual business - but wonder if we could connect her into some of the enterprise schemes - maybe she could have interns working with her or further develop her own business

SP

Shalini Pillai Tue 13 Aug 2019 9:10AM

2 - Innovation

Outcomes are not clear, small number of young people benefitting, not doing much for teh system.

JT

Jade Tang-Taylor Tue 13 Aug 2019 9:24AM

Impact investment opportunity? Feels like we would be funding someone's "screen-printing" business, rather than a community initiative...

JT

Jade Tang-Taylor Tue 13 Aug 2019 9:28AM

2 - Innovation

Impact investment opportunity? Feels like we would be funding someone's "screen-printing" business, rather than a community initiative...

S

Shona Wed 14 Aug 2019 8:22AM

2 - Innovation

This could be a good candidate to refer to 'The Generator' micro-business startup prorgam

NP

Poll Created Wed 31 Jul 2019 10:45PM

99 Auckland Football Federation & Pukekohe AFC Closed Thu 15 Aug 2019 12:05AM

Results

Results Option Points Mean Voters
Innovation 16 2.3 7
Undecided 0 0 5

7 of 12 people have voted (58%)

CH

chloe harwood Sun 11 Aug 2019 3:23AM

3 - Innovation

like the idea of collaboration between clubs and focus on multi sport - suggest that this be better suited to core funding

SP

Shalini Pillai Tue 13 Aug 2019 9:16AM

1 - Innovation

not innovative, should be the federation's business as usual, esp given Sport NZ's focus areas.

JT

Jade Tang-Taylor Tue 13 Aug 2019 9:22AM

3 - Innovation

Given this appears to be an "initiative that is part of a consolidated strategic approach to strengthen football and junior sport in the South Auckland area." It feels a bit like an idea that is lightly adapted to the locale without deep relationships into the community.

JT

Jade Tang-Taylor Tue 13 Aug 2019 9:22AM

2 - Innovation

Given this appears to be an "initiative that is part of a consolidated strategic approach to strengthen football and junior sport in the South Auckland area." It feels a bit like an idea that is lightly adapted to the locale without deep relationships into the community.

S

Shona Wed 14 Aug 2019 8:21AM

1 - Innovation

Echo the points that everyone else has made. Not a great fit for this fund.

NP

Poll Created Wed 31 Jul 2019 10:46PM

100 CLM Community Sport Closed Thu 15 Aug 2019 12:06AM

Results

Results Option Points Mean Voters
Innovation 26 3.7 7
Undecided 0 0 4

7 of 11 people have voted (63%)

AM

Audry McLaren Tue 6 Aug 2019 9:40PM

0 - Innovation

Where are the rangstahi in this proposal? Brings orgs togethar but not the voices of young people. Like the idea. Needs work to include the "affected".
Nothing about us without us springs to mind

AM

Audry McLaren Tue 6 Aug 2019 9:40PM

4 - Innovation

Where are the rangstahi in this proposal? Brings orgs togethar but not the voices of young people. Like the idea. Needs work to include the "affected".
Nothing about us without us springs to mind

JT

Jade Tang-Taylor Tue 13 Aug 2019 9:17AM

6 - Innovation

Love the idea of "a two-day ‘Hauora Symposium’ to be held in South Auckland" - Pretty straight forward use of funds that could have significant impact.

JT

Jade Tang-Taylor Tue 13 Aug 2019 9:18AM

5 - Innovation

Love the idea of "a two-day ‘Hauora Symposium’ to be held in South Auckland" - Pretty straight forward use of funds that could have significant impact. And agree with Audry that the voice of Rangatahi should be an instrumental part of the design'

JT

Jade Tang-Taylor Tue 13 Aug 2019 9:18AM

6 - Innovation

Love the idea of "a two-day ‘Hauora Symposium’ to be held in South Auckland" - Pretty straight forward use of funds that could have significant impact. And agree with Audry that the voice of Rangatahi should be an instrumental part of the design'

SP

Shalini Pillai Tue 13 Aug 2019 9:30AM

4 - Innovation

good model to bring the sector together.

S

Shona Wed 14 Aug 2019 8:20AM

2 - Innovation

I like the idea - agree Audry I'd like to see the 'voice of Rangitahi in here somewhere. Not a good fit for this fund though.