Organisation structure + principles
One thing that Ben noted resonated in me that the one thing that is not timely and should underly everything is the need to maximise positive social impact. On this our currrent 'pillars' or guiding priciples should be built. Transpanancy, re-distribution of power, all-inclusive participation... basic human necessities(rights) for all humans is not something we would trump but something that should be guiding in some cases.
I think it's important to note that the idea of different roles (users, contributors, members, kaitiaki) having different 'rights' only makes sense if those rights are matched (or surpassed) in importance by the additional responsibilities that these roles incur.
I really like Alanna's idea that these roles should not be desirable to anyone who doesn't share the core motivation of maximising social good - i.e. if someone wants power for the sake of having power, then they're looking in the wrong place; likewise, if someone wants money for the sake of having money, they're looking in the wrong place.
To me, emphasising the additional responsibilities and minimising the additional rights of these roles makes a lot of sense, both in the way that we talk about the structure, and the way we think about it.
We've been having some discussion lately about the structure of the Loomio organisation, and the different roles people will play in that organisation. E.g. one option is to have concentric rings like: users -> contributors -> members -> kaitiaki (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaitiaki), with different rights appropriate to each role.
If you're interested in more background, the notes from the intial 'core members' meeting can be found here: http://goo.gl/Mhsey
In order to clarify this discussion we've identified a need to spell out exactly what our core values are, so that we can then measure any decisions to be made against our agreed upon set of values. Ideally we'll come up with a brief statement that is compelling, accurate, and useful. To that end, we are seeking broad input. Here's a starting point for the conversation:
1) The 'bottom line' or chief purpose of the organisation is to maximise our positive social impact.
2) We believe that the best way to do this is to develop systems that will enable all kinds of groups to maximise participation and transparency in their decision-making, while distributing power and resources equitably.
3) These systems are guided by principles of sustainability, kaitiakitanga, and collective wisdom.
Each of these points is up for discussion. Here are some keywords we came up with at the retreat that might be useful: http://goo.gl/lknmr