Loomio Coop Constitution
Stephen has done a big chunk of work on our Constitution. There's a lots of questions we're going to have to answer. Take a look at the doc here.
Notes from previous meeting
- we agreed to ditch the Kaitiaki concept for now, and just have Co-op Members and Board
- the intent is continue to make our decisions with broad input from all stakeholders; the Members would provide a safety-net to fall back on if the larger collective decision-making process fails
- we want users and workers to be eligible for membership, though at the time of founding we are likely to only have worker Members
- we're aiming to have a pretty light-weight constitution outlining the principles, vision, and values of the co-op without going into a huge amount of detail. Detail can be added by way of shareholders agreements.
- the board would be composed of two categories of "directors": those appointed by co-op members and those elected by users. There would be a set minimum required percentage of board directors that are also co-op members.
Questions to work through
- Part 1: purposes of Loomio: "The co-op is formed to [blank]". We have to finish this sentence.
- Sweat equity: do we want to include provision for this in the Constitution? If so, do we want to create another Share Class for the founding Members?
- How does somebody get sacked from the coop? Is this covered sufficiently by ‘Elligibility of Shares’ section? What actions could a shareholder take that we think could threaten or adversely affect the interests of the coop or its shareholders?
- What direction should there be in the constitution about the balance of how surplus is distributed: i.e. what’s the split between the workers, other aligned projects, and reinvestment in the coop. (s9.1, 9.2)
- What’s the difference between dividend and distributions (s9.5)? If people are exchanging their dividend for shares, how does that affect their vote (s9.8)?
- s14 - Need a statement about our general consensus-finding approach, and that these clauses define a bottom line we fall back to when the consensus-finding process fails (as determined by the Board). What would we consider a sufficient majority to make an ordinary resolution, e.g. 75, 85%? Ordinary resolution: like writing the budget or strategic plan. Non-ordinary resolutions are defined in 14.5: do we need to amend this list?
- Proportional makeup of the board, mechanism for election, duration of terms?
Oh god... took one look at that doc and died a little inside. Definitely feel better about going over it in person.
Yes it is a daunting document, lots to talk about on Thursday!
I read the yellow bits, looks like what we asked for. Nice to get it explained some more though.
@viv Wednesday!
How do we want to work through these questions? I feel like we need someone providing the 'pull' on this work and I don't know who that person is!
@richardd.bartlett As I'm working through the Loomio Business strategy spreadsheet, specific constitutional questions around sweat (now renamed 'fluid') equity and share classess keep coming up. I'm just going ahead and implementing what I remember from a convo yesterday with @vivienmaidaborn and @benjaminknight, but going over these once I'm done may provide some pull.
You rule @simontegg !
Speaking of which, where are we at with the constitution now?
@alannakrause I should have said in my last comment: "I have updated the context with a list of questions for us to work through."
And this is why I don't like the 'Show More' button :P
We're at the point where we need to provide answers to all the questions raised by Stephen in the document (see context), and get back to him. @vivienmaidaborn and I are trying to set up a meeting with a lawyer who is expert in cooperative structures in the very near future to make sure we're going down the right path, and I'll organise a meeting with Ramsey after that.
It would be really good to get lots of people's ideas into the document to distribute the load a bit!
this morning Rochelle and are are meeting and going over both the clarifications reached in previous conversations and thinking through how Rochelle will build them into the constitution, and exploring the questions from our joint point of view and making suggestions, or next step actions. I will list these here, as well as comments in a new document we have called Loomio Constitution - working document Viv and Rochelle - here is the link
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1DCTnY5cq1iI69WSxgYn5Mjxwq9sjZvzsHURs6zdMsb8/edit
1. A work programme agreed to keep learning about Fluid Equity in relation to tax treatment and investors in particular.
2. A definition of decision making threshold at 75% that relates to all decisions where the consensus model fails.
3. how do we sack someone - Rochelle will research legal stuff and make a recommendation to us. Behaviour of Coop members who are staff will be governed by employment law. And if you are sacked/dismissed for Serious misconduct you would no longer meet the criteria for Coop member. User will be more complicated but doesn't need clarifying yet.
4. My view now is that apart from adding Fluid Equity shareholders and from describing the elements of balance to be achieved between workers, social good, reinvestment in the coop and disbursement to preferential shareholders the Board should decide on an annual basis.
5. Distribution is the wider class, and a dividend is a subset of this class, Clause 9.3 describes this quite well
6. Roc and I think that consensus defines our approach and goal and except where this is unpractical or has failed will be used. Where not then 75% is the fall back.
7.
""I think the coop is as outdated as the corporation. It adds more democratic processes into our economy, and democratizing the economy will definitely have an impact on our governance systems, making our representative "democracy" more democratic. But coops aren't well- equipped to extract value from the long tail, which is the core of the new p2p paradigm. They are boxes with well-defined boundaries, NOT networks.
I have the impression that once they bite on the value network model these coops will dissolve further into smaller grain networks." -Tiberius Brastaviceanu (Sensorica) http://p2pfoundation.net/Are_Coops_Outdated_in_a_Network_Age
Just an update - we're setting up a meeting with Alastair Hercus (NZ expert on cooperative law) hopefully this week or next, to run our current thinking past someone who knows cooperatives intimately. @simontegg , if you have specific questions about potential constraints that the coop legal structure might present for Loomio, it would be great for us to bring them up with Alastair!
PS I was just alerted to some nice examples of '21st Century' coops in Netherlands - ICSE (icse.nl/Cooperation/231/home_eng.html), a networked sustainability consultancy in Eindhoven (tech capital of Netherlands), and Call For Action (http://www.call-for-action.com/), a cloud service provider.
Update on an update. This morning we met with Alistair which was really great. There were some great refinements of our thinking so far and also some completely new things to think about. The process Ben and I thought might work fron here is:
Rochelle will draft up constitutional document further including identifying decisions or options we need to decide on within 7 days.
Ben and I will update the all hands meeting on friday after which we can add broader conversation threads here in loomio. Feels great to have spoken with someone who has experience in the field , and now to be focused on getting our first Constitution complete.
@vivienmaidaborn @benjaminknight Can we get another update on this? Suspect the update may have happened in a meeting but it would be good to add the info to this thread too. Thanks!
You suspect right! Will make time for a decent update for this thread early next week!
Ok, pretty simple really, we have completed the initial round of decisions that go into making the constitution draft one. These are being written up by Rochelle, hopefully due next week. The most recent documentation to look at is in google drive ( sorry on iPad I can't do links) search for constitution, it is the one with Loomio Consitution, working document Viv and Roc in the title.
All the yellow bits are where we have discussed a d made a decision that Rochelle is writing up. When this doc come out we can have another go, put it up on Loomio and get feedback. Alistair Hercus has agreed to have another look at it for us as well. I will follow up on a timeframe with Roc.
Trying to organise a meeting with Stephen so he can talk us through the document on Weds