Loomio

fedwiki

mike_hales PublicSeen by 140

I wonder whether some of the solutions adopted in fedwiki are more generally useful in OAE. Specifically, I found the UX in fedwiki exciting, fluid and responsive, and I wondered whether Mikorizal's open-value network apps might have that same sense of UX. Interestingly, it seems to me that the UX emerges directly from the architecture, and isn't just floated on top. I blogged a thought on this - here in fedwiki - and would be interested to learn what folks feel about fedwiki's approach potentially contributing in OAE architectures and apps? Are there fedwiki hackers here?

Here's a note on fedwiki - in a fedwiki on 'commoning'.

Jon Richter

No, the federated wiki is built on the Commons, why every page is automatically licenced by its author as CC BY-SA 4.0. Every change of this fact would break the federation. The data model keeps track of the transitions of content between users (neccessary for attribution). Else I could not fork your content.

One could imagine a secret federated wiki farm in an enclosed namespace, only accessible via VPN. An eventual payment model for accessing that private environment would not mean the content cannot exist outside. Any wiki client attached to the VPN/namespace could fork content into the wild. The license in combination with the client-side federation are contagious here.

Higher degrees of privacy can also be reached when using the dat:// wiki via Beaker Browser, and only secretly sharing the links (via encrypted communication channels) to trustful parties that will not share them.

Good commoning work actually tries to work around the reciprocity principle and invent new forms of relations between people.

Patrick Steyaert

Thanks Jon for your answer.

I am thinking about some kind of meta-reciprocity. Share with those that share, transact with those that transact. We are in the particular situation where the content that we share has value for commercial organisations; i.e. commercial organisations extract value out of it without necessarily contributing. They are willing to pay for it. At the same time we have a group of individuals that is willing to contribute but not necessarily willing to pay. For us both have value. I do not want to idealise one model over the other; to the contrary, I am looking for ways to integrate models (relational models inspired upon Alan Fiske's relational model theory).

Today it seems that the difficult choice I have is between something like fedwiki which I find very appealing but is, as you say, based on complete openness, and a wiki that can be put in a closed environment. I find that a very difficult choice.

Danyl Strype

IANAL but I have been a CreativeCommons advocate since it was founded. If your work is on FedWiki and licensed CC Attribution-ShareAlike (BY-SA), then anyone can copy it verbatim, but the license legally obliges them to give the creator(s) credit (attribution), and places their version under the same license. Which means anything they change or improve can be reincorporated upstream, back into your work. These are both forms of reciprocity.

Is this sufficient to avoid:

commercial organisations extract value out of it without necessarily contributing.

If not, can you expand on what you mean by this in the context of your work?

Bob Haugen

This a meta-question, possible for @Jon Richter and @mike_hales and/or anybody else.

I'm looking for a word or phrase for the general differences between the various interaction/human-experience models of Fedwiki, Mediawiki, Loomio, ActivityPub (eg Mastodon), SSB, etc. Model is too general. Paradigm is even worse.

And also between any and all of those and typical apps which have "users" vs "apps". Actually, I guess Mediawiki and Loomio have "users" and "app", but Fedwiki may not. And while ActivityPub and SSB do talk about "users" and "apps", on another level, AP with personal pubs and SSB do not really have "users", they have agents, as I think does Fedwiki.

I hope this question makes more sense to somebody else than it does to me. I am groping for something that I have not quite grasped yet...

mike_hales

Hmmn, complicated I think, Bob. And a number of concepts involved, not a single descriptor or dimension.

One of the dimensions is moderation and consensus. Mediawiki has moderators, who apply rules for consensus in media content. Fedwiki agent/contributors are free agents, and if there is convergence, it is produced in some other (media) space. In a Loomio group moderation is only informal and in my experience a little rare. In Mastodon (eg social.coop) moderation is variably formal/informal, and variably stringent; social.coop is now learning to moderate its media content formally in ways that were not deployed at its original formation. Leaning also to manage and fund the instance/platform operations.

Another dimension is federation/ownership. The different federal formations (SSB protocol community, SSB pub communities, social.coop tooter community, Mastodon code community etc etc) overlap in complex ways and ‘own’ different kinds of stuff in different ways?

A third dimension is what material kind of stuff the practice is actually managing/producing/clustering around. A repository of code? A released version of an app? A platform (an instance of an app on a server on the web)? Media content on a platform? Collaboration of persons and conduct of social or tech or economic projects via media traffic on a platform? Etc? All of the above? Confusingly, often the latter?

My own hunch (you would guess this I think) is to see things in terms of commons. Rather than ‘agents’ (= a federationist/libertarian notion?) commons are concrete associations of persons whose members simultaneously contribute/curate common-resource content, steward/police/sanction commoner actions and enjoy/mobilise/use (but don’t use-up) the social-materia-cultural substance of the commons, in literate and self-aware ways. Their practice is the ‘dance’ between all three of these continuing constitutive processes. A commons of material stuff (eg food or housing) will do these in different ways than a commons of protocol or code (ActivityPub, Mastodon, GitLab) or a platform commons that co-owns an instance running on a server, and these will differ from a commons of labour power (typically but unhelpfully called ‘knowledge’), which is what I think Wiki and Fedwiki are, as platforms not as codebases. (social.coop too, I would say). ’Associationist’ social and economic movements and groups are commons of labour power too, I would say, if they’re any good.

I doubt that AP or Mastodon, for example, are commons. It would be nice if they were? Mastodon is a typical FLOSS Benevolent Dictatorship, of code? AP may be the same, of protocol. GitHub might have looked like a commons, but Microsoft thought different and bought the platform (not the code) off the previously benevolent owners (if Facebook can make profit from this ‘fake-commons’ business model, why not Microsoft?). Git itself (the protocol), www, etc are more benevolent dictatorships with oligarchic tendencies, espousing values of federation? (Just a guess, this.) This is all complex and hard to evaluate, especially for someone like me, who’s not a coder-participant in any of these. But I suspect commoning will get us further, as a sensitively applied verb-descriptor of practices, than agent will, as a noun (or as a value, which is what it often is?) - especially, a noun that is carelessly used of both humans and code entities.

btw . . in all of the above, I’m not addressing bundles of ‘stuff’ (code etc) and their ‘models’ or even their ‘interfaces’ with users. I’m addressing practices of production and use. So I guess I’m saying, whatever the answer to your question is, it’s a question about practices, not a question about code or apps or designs.

Jon Richter

Maybe you are looking for something like platform or protocol?

Stackoverflow brought a new kind of conversation to the table: Choral explanations, which mix wiki and conversation modes. https://hapgood.us/2016/07/12/choral-explanations-and-oer-a-summary-of-thinking-to-date/

Also many ideas in this space here were coined by the IndieWeb. https://indieweb.org/

Or are you looking for something between conversational user interface (chat), wiki and bulletin board/newsgroup? From a technical perspective, what we see here are probably "social" messaging patterns.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human%E2%80%93computer_interaction

Or are you more interested in user interface patterns, like card-based composition UIs, as we find them in Ghost, WordPress and Wagtail (and which federated wiki pioneered half a decade earlier ;) )







https://docs.wagtail.io/en/v2.0/editor_manual/new_pages/creating_body_content.html#streamfield

Or what we get when building on data models for event sourcing (keywords: ActivityPub, CQRS, Task-focused interfaces)?

These are terms that were partly derived from the domain-driven design (DDD) world. And 🎉 we have a wiki for that!

But I think you were more asking for some socio-technical description of the way how these interfaces, protocols and platforms reproduce performatifity for the user.

Maybe you are looking for a more artistic interpretation of your question's context?

might have you covered. Or would this be closer to what you have in mind?

http://web.archive.org/web/20170711063332/http://www.wikinomics.com/blog/index.php/2008/03/26/wiki-collaboration-leads-to-happiness/

Bob Haugen

@Jon Richter thanks a lot for an apt set of links. I'll wade thru and see if I can explain what I am thinking about better after that experience.

Jon Richter

Bob, what is it that you came up with, what your original intention was about?

Instead of models or paradigms, were you maybe thinking of (interaction) patterns?

Bob Haugen

Jon, thanks for the reminder to get back to this question. I got distracted by another project and never got back to conceptualizing this question. But interaction patterns are definitely part of the puzzle, thanks again.