Loomio

DocPad Blog platform decision

Michael Duane Mooring PublicSeen by 19

http://j.mp/docpad-blog-loomio - shortlink
https://github.com/bevry/meta/issues/6 - GitHub discussion

PLEASE USE THE GITHUB ISSUE LINKED ABOVE FOR DETAILED DISCUSSION ON THE ISSUE AT HAND. Thank you.

DocPad needs an official blog to post things but many things are shifting under DocPad right now as much of the weight is transitioned of founder Ben and onto a more distributed group.

The argument is that having a out-of-the-box DocPad powered blog (something like docpad.org/blog/posts/hello.md) is showing that we use our own stuff and we too believe in it.

Ben has proposed we use Tumblr as an immediate/temporary solution for blogging as it's a nice polished full-blogging experience and we won't have to worry about maintaining it. Chase seconds this idea.

Also we have a collection of blog posts on Medium as another blogging platform option.

(This decision was discussed in last night's Hangout: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Ag0lArnzpw&feature=share&t=14m39s the DocPad meta-discussions are happening here: https://github.com/bevry/meta/issues)

Which platform should we use right now?

DocPad powered blog

proposal by Michael Duane Mooring Closed Sun 20 Apr 2014 8:07PM

This way shows that we too believe in and use our own product. As the phrase goes "we eat our own dog food."

Results

Michael Duane Mooring
Disagree

Tumblr will be best to get online immediately at a url like blog.docpad.org while DocPad is being refactored.

Naatan
Agree

I use DocPad for far more than just blogging, and I use it precisely because I wanted to move away from bulky CMS-like tools. Using the very tools that DocPad seeks to replace seems counter-intuitive to me.

Chase Colman
Disagree

It is a developer's web log, not a political or marketing platform. Once DocPad has been broken down, whatever it becomes may be able to adequately take over this purpose to fulfill the "dog food" requirement, but for now let's keep it simple.

Michael Duane Mooring
Abstain

Tumblr will be best to get online immediately at a url like blog.docpad.org while DocPad is being refactored.

Michael Duane Mooring
Disagree

Tumblr will be best to get online immediately at a url like blog.docpad.org while DocPad is being refactored.

Eduardo Lávaque
Agree

I think it wouldn't be too hard to do this and as Michael said it sorta shows we use our own stuff. My personal reason though is that we have way more contro over what happens with the content.

Michael Duane Mooring
Abstain

Tumblr will be best to get online immediately at a url like blog.docpad.org while DocPad is being refactored. But I'm still open to using DocPad. ;)

Eduardo Lávaque
Agree

I think it wouldn't be too hard to do this and as Michael said it sorta shows we use our own stuff. My personal reason though is that we have way more control over what happens with the content.

Michael Duane Mooring
Disagree

Tumblr will be best to get online immediately at a url like blog.docpad.org while DocPad is being refactored.

Peter Flannery
Disagree

Thinking in a lean way my thoughts are its easier to start with tumblr at this point in time then later use docpad (if the blog is still required)

Naatan

Note imo it is perfectly acceptable to use a an old but stable build for the duration of the transition. The blog does not need to be using the latest (unstable) build of DocPad.

Benjamin Lupton

This issue around this is primarily the advantage of DocPad as discussed in the presentation: DocPad’s Eco-System, why DocPad is so interesting! https://medium.com/building-docpad/3b0fa98fc49b

The thing with DocPad, is that our selling point is that we are a Decoupled Content Management System. That means, you always get to use the best tool for the job. An interface is a tool for the job. The Tumblr interface is the most superior blogging interface and experience that I know to date. DocPad’s benefit is that it allows us to hook into things like tumblr, and use them side by side, as collaborative tools, rather than competitors.

Using DocPad for our blog, is saying denying this selling point of DocPad to reach it’s potential, as is a bit hypocritcal of the direction we are pursuing with a decoupled content management solution.

Yes. DocPad can be used for a blog. Yes, developing blogging features for DocPad is good. However, why develop features that have already been developed? We are best off leveraging the entire eco-system, of which, other tools besides DocPad exists in that eco-system as well.

The only time I can see myself +1'ing using DocPad for our blog, is when we use DocPad for rendering out Tumblr content, when there is a clear advantage of doing so.

Dogfooding is good, but it’s a double edged sword that causes one to see everything as a nail for your hammer, and can risk us loosing focus of what is important. Building the best decoupled content management system, versus the best blogging platform. If people want the best blogging platform, they’re using the wrong tool — that’s Tumblr and Ghost, not DocPad. We must leverage out strengths, not our weaknesses.

Benjamin Lupton

Another future suggestion here, is that ideally, the blog is one that pulls in content from many external sources.

It pulls in things about DocPad automatically from Youtube into our blog.

It pulls in the articles from our Medium collection into your blog: https://medium.com/building-docpad

It pulls in our Tumblr blog.

It pulls in plugin updates from npm automatically into our blog.

It aggregates github activity automatically into our blog.

Etc, etc.

The future of the CMS isn't with CMS's that try do everything, or get the user to do everything, but in CMSs that pull in the best from everywhere else, with little user involvement.

Benjamin Lupton

"The argument is that having a out-of-the-box DocPad powered blog is showing that we use our own stuff and we too believe in it."

I guess there is a presupposition here that needs to be challenged. What is it that we believe in? Is DocPad the best blogging tool there is. No, it isn't. Will it ever be? No, it won't.

Is it the best way of building a decoupled agnostic website? Yes, it is.

I don't think there is anything shameful, or embarrassing in representing your strengths and weaknesses accurately, and leveraging them accordingly.

Benjamin Lupton

Not being able to edit your comments on Loomio is really annoying. Editing is my kurt filter. :)