Loomio Privacy Policy Update
We've put some effort into a more detailed privacy policy that clearly lays out how data is handled in Loomio - in particular we wanted to give details about what other services we use to provide the hosted version of Loomio, and why we use them. We feel it's increasingly important for people to know exactly how their information is treated online, so we've tried to make it as clear and specific as possible.
Loomio uses third party services to provide some of its functionality: e.g. SendGrid sends emails on our behalf so we can be sure they are delivered to you, Cloudflare caches copies of the content around the globe to make the app responsive. These services adhere to industry best practices, which means that they do not sell, rent, or give away any personal information without consent.
We’ve added some more detail to the policy so it is really clear about how we deal with your data.
If you’re concerned about third party services, we’re making it as easy as possible for you to install your own instance of Loomio, so you have complete control of how your data is treated. This way, self-hosted users will be able to easily disable these services and use their own internal networks for all data.
Ideally, we’d love to use free and open software exclusively, but in the near term it’s just not practical. In the meantime, we’re striving to find a balance that provides a high level of service with limited resources. We want to be really clear we will only ever use third-party services to provide additional functionality, and we will never share your private information for profit (unlike far too many widely-used online services).
Please use this discussion if you have any comments.
Also, reading that list of external dependencies, some of them are quite evil (Amazon, Bing/ Microsoft), and I’m guessing others are somewhat proprietary in nature. Is there any strategy underway to bring more of these functions into the core codebase or transition to freedom respecting services where necessary?
http://autonomo.us/2008/07/14/franklin-street-statement/
I really appreciate Loomio being upfront in presenting this information, and I ask that this comment be interpreted as a discussion starter, not an indictment of impurity ;)
Thanks for the prompt Strypey!
I'm not sure of the best way to break our dependencies on non-free software services.
Obviously the first step is to make it easy for someone to host their own installation that does not require those dependencies. Beyond that though, there's a difficult challenge of balancing our values with practical constraints.
I think it is fair for people to expect that their freedoms will be respected when they use this platform. I think it is also fair for them to expect a high level of reliability, so I would like to satisfy both criteria!
I'm open to suggestions. Perhaps there's a task here around researching alternatives, investigating their suitability, and then planning how we might get that work done.
Might be a nice job for some contributors in the community to help with, especially if we're talking about building adapters for other open source services. :)
Thanks for engaging on the @strypey.
While we need to develop a policy document about it, it's an intention that we ensure Loomio can always be run as a standalone system, depending only on Free software.
We've got a few things to change, most notably support for multiple file upload backends, but if you're willing to use loomio without fileuploads then it should run stand alone.
Translation will probably always depend on a 3rd party, and this is a feature not available in this situation.
In short we will provide optional support for proprietary services where the feature benefit is high.
Thanks @richarddbartlett and @robertguthrie, I love the fact that I feel safe to raise these issues here. Totally agree that it's a shared set of problems, not just something for the Loomio devs to fix. I threw the list at the Autonomo.us crew (I've been lurking on their email list for a while)
I already got one response back suggesting:
"Two swapping possibilities I see: looks like Airbrake could be replaced with Sentry (which I use in production and really like; also available as a service), and that Google Analytics could be replaced with Piwik."
Will keep you posted if any more come in, or feel free to come lurk with me::
https://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/autonomous-discuss
Another poster on the Autonomo.us list says:
MogileFS is a great alternative to S3. It's old, but proven by folks who have been using it for years.
The mailing list, site/wiki and bug-trackers are unfortunately hosted on a non-Free service, but they accept patches/pulls on the mailing list. There's no CLA requirement for contributions, either :)
http://mogilefs.org/Disclaimer: I have become a major contributor to MogileFS in recent years, but have never had any affiliation with any (now-defunct?) companies which formed it. I also maintain the Ruby client library and wrote an alternative, easy-to-install storage daemon (cmogstored).
Some information about free code translation tools:
https://flossmanuals.net/open-translation-tools/ch034_introduction/
Thanks Strypey. I'm confident we'll have no proprietary dependencies shortly.
Why does Loomio log IPs?