Loomio

Dyad Echos

Josh Fairhead PublicSeen by 6

A container for reflecting dyadic echo's back into the space

Josh Fairhead

Sunday 17th October,

Context: On Saturday, I checked-in with @Ronen Hirsch to make sure he didn't feel disoriented or left behind with the Obsidian experiment, as my assumption was that it would be his preference to get involved when things were a bit more stable. He said he felt too out of alignment for tech-hacking at the moment so I suggested a personal call instead. We then slowly arranged a time over Sunday daytime and converged in the evening.

Content: It was largely an improvised personal call with no agenda or imperative, a spark to get the fire lit with an implicit understanding that we were just hanging out while it remained warm. We covered a number of topics over a few hours just enjoying each others company. The first constellation of topics I remember us conversing around were practice, rituals, processes, interactions with the world. Finding the right ecology of practices and the difficulties of that path. Life-curation and life-simplification.

We discussed a book Ronen was reading about symbols, which was fertile for discussions. What stood out to me was the idea that at some point letters, previously having meaning and significance, became phonetic instead. This allowed for a looser abstraction space, but at the cost of grounding.

The word `dissociation` which @Alex Rodriguez presenced last meeting remains a descriptor that stayed with me and applies to the symbols/language discussion. This lens came around a few times over the course of our evening conversation. In relation to this we talked about re-association, embodiment and so on. This is where juggling came up, a practice of mine that brings me back to self.

The conversation looped and weaved, so the above are paragraphs might be considered centres that unfolded and became more elaborate as we continued to discuss things.

Ronen Hirsch

@Alex Rodriguez and I partook in a 2 part dyad.

The first part was about dealing with frictions and tensions in couple relationships.

The second continued into an exploration about when is it correct to be authentic and direct and when it isn't. This drifted into the notion of a learning process that swings like a pendulum from discernment to integration.

We talked about basic communication skills and efficient signaling. This led to a specific conversation about how Alex & I interacted on Loomio around the reading club and specifically about conscious decisions and motivation in using polls (or other decision-making Loomio tools) or threads.

Alex mentioned that he recently had (is still having?) a good experience with an organizational development consultant which in retrospect I want to connect to the consultation exploration currently held by @Robert Damashek and @Toni Blanco ... Alex may be able to provide insight as a "customer organization."

Ronen Hirsch

... and this also came up: everywhere I look ... no matter what domain I feel I would like to be active or contribute to ... I feel I first need the digital space ... basic communication, basic listening, basic expression, basic objection, basic triggering, basic deciding, basic accountability

this is probably, at this point a biased perspective :) but there it is!

Jennifer Damashek

@Alex Rodriguez and I spoke on 11/1. I asked to speak with him because I wanted help processing the sense I had that I'm not welcome to bring my full self here. I also asked him to help me understand the hesitancy I experience on the part of the crew to seek direct funding for building the digital space.

I also want to note I'm not sure why we write these reflections or what is expected to be contained in them. I don't feel I had a say in whether or not these reflections are required, how to write them, or why to write them.

Ronen Hirsch

In this specific case, you writing this brief reflection lets me know that you feel not welcome to bring your full self to the crew and leaves me wondering 1) why that is and 2) if your conversation with Alex helped you process this and if so how? Had you not posted this, I would have not known.

I am also not clear how you came to experience that the crew is hesitant to seek direct funding. Can you say more about this? (<- could be a dedicated thread or a response on cycle 4).

Jennifer Damashek

I sensed I was not welcome to bring my full self to the crew for a couple of reasons. The most immediate was because Josh expressed anxiety over what I wrote in comments under the invitation to a Lunar Ritual Encounter. He also indicated that for him associating feminine energy with the moon was identity politics.

It’s ok with me if what I write and say generates anxiety, but I’m not sure that’s the case with others. I also am not sure it would be welcome to ask Josh about why associating feminine energy with the moon and lunar rituals is identity politics in his mind, but I do have that question. I wasn’t sure if there was space for me to express myself freely after that exchange. I have been hesitating to post on Loomio because I didn’t want to cause anxiety or discomfort, and it surprised me that exchange did so. It left me feeling there might not be much I could say without generating discomfort here, and my sense is that the discomfort isn't welcome.

I also felt that way after exchanges with you, Ronen. I expressed strong feelings about the word “financial” and you had uncomfortable feelings about that. I want to emphasize here that I was comfortable expressing my strong emotions, and it surprised me to learn later that they troubled you.

You also had a reaction to the recorded conversation between Robert and me. These two events left me feeling it wasn’t welcome to express myself freely. That’s why I hesitated to post on Loomio and I hesitate now.

I do want to avoid troubling anybody if possible, but I won't do that at the cost of not being myself.

What I would like is to know that even if I make a mistake or something I say generates unpleasant experiences for others, that is expected here. I would like to know that my presence and contribution is valued. Then I would feel welcome.

Yes, it helped to talk to Alex. It helped me to get his feedback and insights. Talking to someone who is able to listen without judgment or reaction helps me process my experiences and make sense of them.

I can see that posting the reflection of the conversation brought this to your attention. However, I wonder if would be better to leave it up to the people having the conversation whether they want to reflect to the crew that the conversation took place. Robert and I have conversations quite often about what happens here. What should we do about that?

I mean, we all have conversations in our own heads about these things, and we get to choose what we bring here publicly.

I felt there was hesitancy in seeking direct funding for the digital space because what I see being pursued first is jobs and other work for the crew. I can think of so many ways that the digital space might be profitable and venture capital or other types of funding could be sought for different applications of it. My sense is that those here who need more income want to get work as individuals or as a crew first, and then later build it? I’m not sure, all I know is what I see which is interest in jobs and some kind of work for the crew other than building the space. That's fine with me, I just wanted Alex's insights on why that might be.

Ronen Hirsch

1: Being yourself

Thank you for elaborating. My current understanding is that your conversation with Alex has resolved (at least for now) whatever needed resolving and that you are now able to be yourself in the crew. If that is not the case, please indicate what else you feel you need.

2: Dyad Echoes

I have more to say but nothing that feels needs to be said right now except for this: it IS up to the people having a conversation (dyad or otherwise) to decide if/what to share about it. I don't know where you got a different impression.

3: Direct Funding

I, personally, have not brought up direct funding because I can't see how that can be possible. I am especially concerned about VC funding given that we are trying to create something of a "Tibetan village" and I expect that VC funding will likely cause a "degradation a healthy, joyful community."

But more importantly: if you believe in this possibility why haven't you brought it up and carried it forward? If the answer to that question is the subject of being fully yourself, and it has been resolved, can you now help the crew to move forward with this?

4: Really ...

Personally, I am not really after funding or a job. I am interested in growing a healthy team that is able to manifest and care for the digital space while having their needs (and my own) met.

I want to be able to work peacefully without having to worry about the roof over my head. I want to experience abundance instead of being told fantastical stories about it. I want this for everyone who is currently a crew member and everyone who will join this effort in the future.

The work, I think, that really needs to be done now in terms of manifesting the digital space is:

  • Expanding the sharing in order to test relevancy and viability in different communal environments while forming an informal interest network.

  • Making it possible for the people on the crew to dedicate regular time and attention to the work.

  • Exploration of the technical stack upon which the space can be built.

  • Bringing on technically-skilled people who can begin to experiment and explore with the technical stack while gradually forming an iterative technological-design process that points in the direction of the digital space.

In the world we currently inhabit, money seems to be needed to do this.

Toni Blanco

Hi @Jennifer Damashek, I am using the time of a last-minute canceled meeting to pop up here. I am super-super-bussy and kidney stones stroke back, so I have not participated in the time I would like to.

Let me thank you first for fully expressing yourself. I think that I told you before but I say it again, I am a big fan of the kind of energy you bring to the crew and I wish I would be a little more like you. I think that generating anxiety, concerns, etc. on others is part of the journey; the key is what we do collectively with that. And we manage that fine.

I was surprised by Josh reaction to your comment and since he did not want to stay in the thread I was not sure how to talk about it. I understand that the relationship of gender and symbolism is sensitive because power dynamics take advantage and there is a long tradition of oppression. That said, I consider that making such a distinction between feminine and masculine in those terms is not necessarily oppressive or identity politics, starting with the classic point that feminine≠woman and masculine≠man. This is my field of expertise after my PhD so I can tell you that "the moon calling feminine energies" or "saying that is identity politics" is oversimplistic. All symbols are ambiguous by definition, and the moon is an extreme example, to the point that in terms of masculine or feminine, it is an archetype of the androgynous. In Spanish "la luna" is feminine and "el sol" is masculine, but for instance, in german, is the other way around ("der Mond" and "die Sonne"). Of course, the moon is strongly connected with the feminine and women, and often with a very negative valorization! (and that is why is problematic). Like it or not, the symbolic connection between the moon and women is not essentialism or biologism, is just an almost cultural universal fact (menstruation has a lot to do with it, in France the menstrual period is known as "the time of the moon" ). Again, what we do with it is what makes the difference.

I have a workshop of introduction to symbolic hermeneutics that I think clarifies a lot of these questions and misunderstandings. Happy to have a dyad with you (open to anyone) to go through it.

Toni Blanco

Money, funding... a friendly reminder to you guys that we just initiated a whole cycle to address this key and complex topic!

Josh Fairhead

Apologies Jennifer, I did not intend to make you feel unwelcome. You are most welcome to query my perceptions, and I'm sorry that I did not query yours. I've not felt good with that thread as it feels like I'm an oppositional voice in the mix out of reactivity. In that specific thread there's a complex getting triggered for me which relates to fears of ideology and narrative (first hand experience in the world of blockchains and startups).

I chose to express what I was feeling in relation to the post and what it brought up for me, and by expressing these sensations openly I'm allowing myself free expression. I must grant these rights to myself so that I may be able to grant them to others (such as yourself). I'd therefore encourage you to do the same an express whatever comes up for you in the related context (e.g. the thread, here, ect). If I signal a desire to leave such as in the other thread, its just an honest signal, you may feel/do whatever you please with that knowledge.

What I would like is to know that even if I make a mistake or something I say generates unpleasant experiences for others, that is expected here. I would like to know that my presence and contribution is valued. Then I would feel welcome.

Yes! You are welcome here, please embrace yourself and make plenty of mistakes. The generative paradox that becomes apparent for me is at this point is that we're working on becoming comfortable in the uncomfortable (authentic self expression). Becoming expressive of these discomforts are to me a key part of what should be informing the design work we are doing.

Your suggestion that my words were judgemental is absolutely correct. Apologies though, I was not judging you, but expressing a strong response to some of the words and rhetoric being invoked (in accordance with my values). Sorry it felt directed at you personally.

not sure it would be welcome to ask Josh about why associating feminine energy with the moon and lunar rituals is identity politics in his mind, but I do have that question.

Please ask any questions you like. The topic is not particularly alive for me and explaining why is far more than I wish to articulate. I apologise for opening the door. In an attempt to close it back up I'll just say that I consider twoness as a number of polarity, complementarity and tension. When embedded in discussions and narratives, drama seems to be a characteristic that tends to emerge.

I can see that posting the reflection of the conversation brought this to your attention. However, I wonder if would be better to leave it up to the people having the conversation whether they want to reflect to the crew that the conversation took place.

I agree, there's no imperative to do anything here. Sharing back is a beneficial pattern worth discussing and practising in my opinion. I've not shared the last discussion I had with Ronen (and neither has he) back here yet but It's still on my nice-things-to-do-for-the-space list. I just haven't had the capacity; it's actually why I logged into Loomio but this thread felt more important.

I felt there was hesitancy in seeking direct funding for the digital space because what I see being pursued first is jobs and other work for the crew.

For me any hesitancy is the desire to move slow and plant things. Jobs are an instrumental means to put bread on the table, they come with a sense of environmental imperative that I wish to keep out of our crew space. In my view we have a duty to take care of our own well being as primary. If the crew can provide for participants in the present tense, and the experience is better than a job, then the motivational imperative to take care of oneself with a job wouldn't exist. Our present state of affairs suggests we have work to do but how can anyone do anything if they feel incomplete in some way? In other words I see work here as having much more potential than any short term gig, but taking much longer and running in parallel (at least until the actuality of being supported by a self-sustaining vehicle arises).

Jennifer Damashek

Thank you everyone who replied. I appreciate all that has been written and will digest it. Right now Robert and I are at the airport waiting to take a flight to Iceland. 🙂 Any further response here will probably be a few days from now. I am just grateful for the space and all that has been said. Thank you.

Also, Toni, I hope you feel better.

Toni Blanco

Oh, thank you so much, I do feel better. Drugs are our friends. Now drinking a lot of water to spell the rock in a hopefully gentle way.

Jennifer Damashek

After a few days of thinking about this thread and all the replies, I find there are a few things I'd like to write.

Dyad echoes: I thought it was expected to post about dyads because what I remember is that during the last gathering Ronen said he was happy people were having dyads but he wasn't happy that there was no record of what happened. My memory could be inaccurate, as memories tend to be. But that's what I recorded in my mind. After that, there were posts here about one to one meetings within the crew. I assumed those posts were expected. I'm more comfortable knowing it's up to me and the other person if we want to write an echo of a meeting.

Funding: I didn't think there was anything wrong with focusing on meeting material needs first. I wanted to understand that more fully. Now I have a clearer picture. I have no desire to initiate seeking of funding, at least right now.

I want to be able to work peacefully without having to worry about the roof over my head. I want to experience abundance instead of being told fantastical stories about it. I want this for everyone who is currently a crew member and everyone who will join this effort in the future.

I want this for you and everyone else here and everyone who will join this effort, too.

Values: I'm grateful for Alex's insights when we met. One thing he said that has returned to me over and over: that while ideologies may differ here, we share values. I think that is a key point and I needed it to be said to me. We aren't going to change anything from our perspectives or our ideologies. We can only change things by living from new values, by choosing our values and embodying them.

I'm grateful for the responses from Ronen, Toni and Josh, and I feel we do share crucial values, including authentic self-expression. Thank you.

Toni Blanco

Regarding funding, I think that it makes no sense to talk about money in general and funding of the space in particular if we do not talk about concrete scenarios. I also want the crew to be aware that saying "anyone" means that we will let people self-filtering to our phantasy of the space being open to "anyone".

Another approach would be to select a funding model and then see what scenarios fit that funding model. 

Also, you and Robert imagine some concrete scenarios. Maybe you could have a double rol here as crew members and seed funders (and yes, I know you brought that generous offer in a different and unconditional light, but I can refine and expand my rationale here).   

Another way of reducing possible scenarios is to understand how many members of the crew would like to make the space a relevant source of personal income (and doing what). 

Regarding values, I have stressed many times that we do not even need shared values, but coherent values (and objectives), and we do have that. 

Big hug, and enjoy your trip!  

Toni Blanco

@Alex Rodriguez and I had a good two hours long talk in Spanish to make sense together of the wholeness and the 4th cycle after the gathering with Sergio. I wrote three pages in Spanish from my notes to capture the main ideas we talked, and sent to Alex. He will process that into a post at the Sergio's gathering thread.

Ronen Hirsch

@Alex Rodriguez reached out to me after the heated interaction with @Jennifer Damashek and he and I had an hour-long dyad. It was a good conversation. Good questions came up, that led to clarified framings and to a notion of potential next steps. I would like to try to recall and share some of these here.

When Jennifer posted her message I tried something new (for me). In addition to not responding (which is not new), I reached out to Alex and Josh to share my anger and frustration. 48 hours later I felt I was able to point clearly to the things that angered me and then wrote my reply.

One particularly resonant question Alex asked me was if I felt I was compassionate in my reply and this brought a lot to the surface:

  1. I perceived (and continue to perceive) Jennifer's comment as a source of aggression/violence/attack (masked in politeness).

  2. I made a choice that was both unconscious and conscious. The unconscious element originated in my general state-of-being but I was conscious of this being in play. The conscious element was a decision to not just absorb the blow (a familiar pattern) but to turn it around and respond to it. I don't like returning aggression in any situation and usually prefer to make an effort to absorb it (and have been blamed for avoiding conflict and bottling my emotions). This choice, I believe, was informed by my general state-of-being.

  3. I feel I made an Aikido-like move where I harnessed the attacking energy that Jennifer brought into the space and turned it against her. I want to say here that I do NOT feel that anger/rage is good energy-material. In my mind, where we are now is what that looks like.

  4. Though the aggression is more apparent in my comment than in Jennifer's comment. I believe that is because I chose to be open about it. I believe that Jennifer's comment politely masks aggression. I believe that politely masked aggression is more dangerous than directly and honestly expressed aggression. I recognize that these preferences are likely deep cultural inheritances both in Jennifer and myself.

  5. I waited 48 hours for the rage to subside and then responded as I did. Alex said he felt there was a passive-aggressive tone in the last part of my message. I clarified that my intention was to be openly aggressive and to take down what I considered (and still consider) to be a bad ideological movement. I was aiming to defeat an opponent (in this case ideas manifesting through Jennifer) but without causing injuring my opponent. Still, I am aware that getting spun around and pinned down (the image that came to my mind when Alex asked if I was compassionate) can be rattling if, especially if you are not expecting it.

  6. I did not enjoy writing that comment, I put much effort into it and I did not feel safe posting it.

  7. I acknowledge that my response embodies a critical value-choice: I was (still am) prioritizing a sense of truth and wholeness over Jennifer's personal well-being (or sense of safety). I suspect that a shared reading of Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance would shed light on this critical choice.

  8. This is not a choice I make lightly. I have made this choice many times in my life and I feel like I have paid for it dearly. I continue to make this choice because I believe it is correct.

  9. This is a personal living pain point because I believe it also plays a role in my deteriorated relationship with Iulia.

All this brought me to the following conclusions:

  1. I do not know how to get past this point.

  2. I do not feel that Jennifer and I can do this on our own.

  3. I am hoping that others in the crew can step in and tend to this, as Alex has started to.

  4. I will not be able to creatively explore money if every time we go near it Jennifer will get triggered. I find it to be exhausting and demotivating.

  5. And, as Alex pointed out, we will not be able to move forward together until we are able to gracefully move through such conflicts in this (emotionally depleted?) remote/asynchronous written environment.

  6. Figuring this out feels like a priority and a critical effort.

  7. I will show up to whatever arises and put in the effort to work through this and make the space safe (I do not feel entitled to safety, I feel responsible for generating and tending to it).

  8. I believe this will require synchronous gatherings ... but I leave that to whoever takes action on this front.

  9. I will not be responding in written format to further comments that were or will be made (including your's @Robert Damashek so please don't think I am ignoring you) on the subject until ... I feel it is safe to do so.