Payment plans
As i saw today in transifex (translation system, for those who don't know), came the payment plans. And i wonder the following:
- How much would be the price? It doesn't be fair if it's the same price for example, business and families, or organizations and social movements.
2) Would be fair prices or the groups are going to be dissapeared because the can't pay? Because business have money to pay, but social movements or families probably they won't.
3) As i saw it says about how many people are going to be in your team. But really what happens if they think that can be 50 people and only came 5? Is there going to be other prices about how many people are actually in each group or just what each group think how many people will come?
4) What will happen to a group or groups that can't pay the money asks Loomio? Is Loomio going to close them?
and many other questions... That are only for beginning.
Of course i understand that Loomio needs to pay for Servers and that money probably can't come from nowhere or only from donations.
But i want everyone to think and decide for himself/herself if they want a Loomio for few people that can pay or for many who probably some won't have to pay . And how a bit of the world is going to change if social movements or organizations or anything else that probably won't have money can't have somewhere (in the internet) a free platform to give them a choice of discussion and decision ???
Hey @christaklis good questions! Thanks for starting the discussion. We (i.e. the Loomio Co-op) have spent many hours agonising over the question of how to resource this project without compromising on our values.
This page gives an overview of the pricing model. Our first principle is that money shouldn't be a barrier to access, so we will do whatever we can to make sure that people know they can use the tool without paying. On the other hand, we're trying to simultaneously create a 'social norm' that people who can afford to, pay to use it.
Some of our other principles (e.g. we won't sell advertising, we won't sell your data, we won't sell control of the project, we will remain independent of state or corporate interests) seriously limit our funding options!
We haven't got definite answers to all your questions, because there are 100s of different options for each one. We've just chosen what we think is a sensible starting point and will iterate from there, based on the feedback we get from the community.
Loving the launch guys and will be at that partaaay on Fri - congrats!!
@jonlemmon and I talked recently about differentiating between non-profit orgs and profit-oriented enterprises in the payment plans. Gen Zero for example would struggle to pay the USD200/month it's currently sitting in the member bracket for. Where has Loomio Co-op got on this chat?
Awesome stuff :)
@richarddbartlett before payment plans come in place will there be a simple way to download all a group's data and move it onto another platform (CMS/forum/whatever) should they wish to not continue with a Loomio that has charges?
@christaklis we mustn't forget the costs involved with keeping the Loomio team going, so they have time to work on the ongoing software development, maintain their office as well as the other costs associated with developing and promoting Loomio. I can imagine it is a somewhat expensive.
My reaction to the pricing plans is that they don't take into account the financial realities of organisations which have small budgets.
To have the asking price the same for well funded organisations/government departments/businesses as for a community organisation/social movement with, for example, an annual budget of $1000 seems a little inequitable.
I think it would be good to have a either a discounted plan or an organisational "pay what you can" option for those organisations with a turnover of less than $X, £X €X ..where X= maybe 20,000 or 30,000 in their respective currency.
I would expect having such a plan/option for small organisations would assist in the virality of Loomio, and may in fact increase Loomio's income.
Setting the price plans must be one of the hardest decisions the Loomio Coop has to make.
Hi @davidpeterson, excellent question :)
As far as I know, there's no easy answer to data exporting. I mean, it's trivial to generate a CSV dump of a group's data (i.e. a great big spreadsheet of all content), but packaging that data into a format that could be imported into another platform is quite a challenge! FYI, we're currently working with MIT to make sure we maximise interoperability between this and other platforms.
As it's early days, there's plenty of decisions yet to made. In the meantime, you can expect us to be permissive, to err on the side of user freedom wherever possible. For instance, as we currently have it designed, when a group fails to pay their subscription, the worst that happens is a little message at the top of the screen. We don't want to wind up in a situation where people are locked out from their important content because of some minor clerical error!
Thanks for your understanding @neilmorris - yep, building a billion-user democracy app is not cheap! As we expand, our monthly expenses are already heading towards $20k USD. To date the majority of this funding has come from co-op members and loans from our friends and family, with an increasing ratio coming from revenue (mostly subscriptions + consulting). Our aspirations for this project are totally dependent on becoming financially sustainable, so we're committed to getting to break-even as fast as possible.
Regarding discounted rates for groups without much of a budget, like @jacktolley and @neilmorris describe, we are yet to figure out how to provide this option without making the payment system overly complex. At the moment, these groups are more than welcome to select the 'Pay What You Can' option and contribute as much or as little as they like.
@richarddbartlett glad to see you are thinking about data exportation :-)
As it did just suddenly occur to me (as I'm with PPNZ, and we're a new group to Loomio) when I read this thread that this could be a major problem if there isn't an option. As you know from a user's perspective lock in sucks :-/
If you were to target the most likely places a group might export it to a CMS (WordPress?) and a forum (phpBB?) that would be ideal. Once a group can import to one major platform (such as WordPress) then plenty of tools already exist to transform that to be used on another (such as TYPO3, which is another great CMS but with a much smaller userbase than WP).
$20k USD / month .
Ouch!
@richarddbartlett i didn't know that were too much the money each month... $20k USD.... It is really a lot of money.
@neilmorris the only am i say is to be fair for those who can't pay today but they can in future. Sure companies will have money to pay, but neighboorhoods or social movements maybe not but also can owe somewhere else money.
Thanks heaps for starting this discussion @christaklis - hopefully things have been clarified by the comments so far.
I think this really highlights how important it is that we do a really good job of communicating our payment model, so people know that money won't be a barrier to them using Loomio.
I've started a discussion here explaining things in a bit more detail. Hope that's helpful!
@benjaminknightloom i saw that explaining discussion you start... it explains everything.
And i am happy that Loomio doesn't look only to take money, as other tools made in the past!
I posted this in a new thread but as @richarddbartlett pointed out it should be here. Perhaps delete my other one?
--- Copy paste from there ----
I’d like to know the rationale behind the pricing, in particular making community organisations the same as businesses. Sports clubs are a part of my business and taking this at $2 a month a user to a club would be met with “friction” shall we say!
Loomio seems great but businesses have systems for getting to decisions using classic management structures so voting is not necessarily going to work for big decisions and if they were going out to wider staff / customers they may have to pay $100s of dollars a month when they could use other systems such as survey monkey.
If you are going for collective decision making then you are thinking clubs and societies (or obviously protest movements). Many members, committee decision making and no centralised day to day contact. $24 a member per annum (USD) is massive for sports clubs, most will charge $50-$100 a year and they have to pay for all sorts of stuff with that.
If its just committees then lets say 10 ppl so $360USD a year! Maybe (big maybe!) this floats price wise but there is a lot of free group comms systems - Reddit, Google Groups, Email - so you are really paying for the voting platform and then its $360 for something that can be managed at the monthly meetings or even in emails as the management requirement of the votes is low.
Personally Id be thinking a pricing model that kicked in after a certain size of group say 10+ and would be $1 to $3 a year per member a year. At least until you prove massive uptake. The groups themselves could fundraise that from their members rather than Loomio asking for a pay what you can which I would be surprised if that brought in any real revenue. Perhaps Loomio could offer a “ask for a better price” button where community groups could offer reasons why it would be hard for them to pay at a couple of dollars a member? That way you get good stories of how the groups are forming in tough circumstances and how Loomio is there to work for these groups in particular. This could help PR.
Apologies if this seems negative, especially as its my first post! Im sure there has been quite the discussion about this already.
@mikehargreaves thanks for taking the trouble to spell out your thoughts, it's incredibly useful to have such detailed feedback as we iterate the payment model.
Our first principle is that we don't want to exclude anyone because they don't have the means to pay. Comments in this thread lead me to believe that we've not done a very good job of communicating that yet.
At the moment, the question we're asking is "What kind of group are you?" but what we actually mean to ask is "What kind of payment model suits your group?"
Today we've been workshopping some language changes to help resolve this issue. I'll update this thread once the changes are live, and we can get another round of feedback then :)
Hey folks, the experiment continues... today we deployed some language changes that will hopefully make the system a little bit clearer. You can see the new language on the Start Group page - what do you think?
Love it Rich (except the colour of the sickly orange info box on the Start Group page)
This feels like a huge improvement! Would love to hear what others in the community think. @mikehargreaves , does this seem like a clearer message to you?
Hey @benjaminknightloom well it certainly seems clearer, in the sense that it is fair. I worry that the revenue from this will be far lower than is needed. There seems to be an underlying struggle with how to approach the pricing within loomio. I can see why as any product founded from the anti capitalist movement is going to have an interesting time when it comes to debating the money side!
I guess I'm not sure you guys have got the model right with user / group donations as you haven't differentiated the product. The expectation that some people will pay more than others by choice could be a mistake. Unfortunately human nature might work against loomio here.
There must be a big product roadmap somewhere, why not plan to make some of the features premium and charge for them? This is a far more standard model and there are loads of features you could add to make the product far more attractive to bigger organisations who would be able to pay.
The fact that they can pay an organisation will mean they have funds and therefore some sort of structure which controls these, this structure will wrap around their decision making as well. If you have a decision making hierarchy and an accounting function then there will be reporting and control needs that you will need or want when using a product such as Loomio. These needs wouldn't necessarily exist in a flat democratic structure such as a protest movement (or at least not to the same extent). Which to me means that you could have a Freemium model like Dropbox but allow power users to pay when they want power features. Then the trick is to make the features good enough to pay for but keep the free product good enough to attract a massive base of users, some of who will convert to paid.
Which would all mean that you have the cash to pay for servers and development of the product while not pricing your desired userbase out of the market. Plus you could still give out premium licenses to groups that you believed would benefit from them.
Ha when I met Viv and Ben I commented on how wordy loomio discussions / dialogues could seem. I appreciate the irony.
If you enabled bitcoin or litecoin also you could receive micro donations. Maybe if you teamed up with - https://propster.me/ - users could make regular easy subscription micro-donations with bitcoin, litecoin or US dollars.

Great questions @christaklis. I recommend you log out of your Loomio account and view the front page.
In short.. we offer two types of agreement to choose between:
A traditional SASS subscription system for those that have the money to pay on behalf of their users. Think if it like a github payment plan.
The other option is a "Pay what you can" option, where we ask each of the users of the group to make a contribution in exchange for the service and to help us grow. There is no requirement to make a payment if you are on the PWYC system.
Let us know what you think about these options.