Organisational Structure
We had a big workshop this morning to answer the question ‘how do we want to organise and govern ourselves?’
We went through the 'ORID' process, starting with the Objective questions, asking first what do we know? Out of this we distilled 9 key points:
- We measure what we do against social impact;
- Collective ownership;
- Balance between individual and collective autonomy/mandate;
- Flexibility and adaptiveness
- Participatory decision-making + distributed authority;
- Transparency of information, culture, work processes, accountability;
- Collaboration, cooperation, mutual-aid;
- Permeability: there is a path to the core;
- People’s influence in a decision is in proportion to the degree that it affects them
Then we moved on to the Reflective mode, which is about feelings. What feels good about our experiences so far, what are some bad experiences we’ve had relating to organisational structure? The main outtakes:
- Bring whole self to work
- Social equality, equity, parity
- Challenged but supported
- Perpetual learning (e.g. mentors, apprentices)
- My needs for autonomy, relatedness and competence are met
- Feels light, laughter is present, energising
- Power is shared in the room, empowered not alienated
- Feeling supported in a clear framework
- Trust and honesty
- Space for dissent
- Issues are resolved quickly
We then moved into an Interpretive stage - looking for the big questions that are missing from the first two stages:
- The way we’re currently functioning is pretty close to the ideal working structure. How do we maintain this as we scale up the organisation and become more distributed?
- Need more clarity about where is a decision is made, who it includes (appropriate mandates/delegation), how to apply the principle of matching decision influence to effect.
- Could we articulate what needs explicit framework material and what is implicit cultural stuff?
- How do we respond if something goes horribly wrong - when someone is pursuing self interest at the expense of the group?
- How do we maintain ‘balanced job complexes’ - unfavoured but required work gets shared around?
Finally we moved into the final mode, where we start to make Decisions and Design choices. We first identified the distinct elements that an organisational structure needs to cover:
- Decision-making framework (inc. delegation + mandate; comprehensive enough to encompass everything from operational to strategic decisions) Accountability
- Communications (internal + external)
- Measuring social impact
- Core values & principles
- Work allocation (project based + role based; balanced job complexes)
- Remuneration
- Recruitment & retention
- Stewardship
We then made a first sketch of an ‘org chart’ for Loomio (inter-galactic expansion plans are left as an exercise for the reader). We will have to decide how to split the mandate between the members and the board but to start with we agreed on the principle that the board exists in service to the members. The members hold the core purpose. The board takes a long-term perspective and makes recommendations to the members to ensure that purpose is met. So the members might make operational and strategic decisions with recommendations from the board, and the board might have decision-making power over things such as financial accountability and disbursement.
After all this work we were all starting to fade a bit so to finish up we identified the priority pieces of work necessary to turn these ideas into a legal reality:
- Revise and update constitution; determine what needs to be in the constitution and what can go into a shareholders agreement
- Determine the interface between the board and the members
- Research and develop a work allocation framework
- Agreeing a system for fluid equity so we can hire the talent we need without necessarily having the cash on hand to pay them market rates
- Develop a statement of values
- Decide on a delegation model to balance individual autonomy and collective purpose: which circle is this question appropriate for?
Comprehensive notes here
This is fantastic -- exactly what I would love to see pinned down. I would love to know what role different people have in a decision making process, and to have explicit statements for how different stakeholders can plug in. This is, IMHO, a critical prerequisite to a functional decision making process.
Would love to hear your ideas if you're happy to share your experience @charliedetar! What do you think a good multi-stakeholder decision-process looks like?
The main challenge I think we're facing is the balance between inclusivity and appropriate delegation (giving everyone a say in decisions that affect them, without crippling the process through info overload and unnecessary bureaucracy).
Input appreciated!
I am struck by how useful this information is as a basis for designing the structure and work allocation systems. I think we have also done a great job at defining how to measure success of ethe system from e members point of view. It would be great to add measures from the user point of view as well, although issues resolved immediately is a big one!