Add vote up/down buttons to motion comments
Add vote up/down buttons to motion comments
proposal by Jon Lemmon Closed Fri 13 Apr 2012 12:00AM
Feature: Add vote up/down comments in the discussion section of a motion (in a similar way to stackoverflow.com)
Reason: Trying to discuss things on normal web discussion threads can be a total pain in the ass. We need a way of filtering through discussions and giving users the ability to tag comments with meta-data (e.g. this is an insightful comment, this is not an insightful comment)
Long-term vision: Just voting comments up and down kind of sucks. The problem is that with just up/down votes there is no context (up and down in terms of what?). That's why on reddit you get a bunch of random stuff at the top. Sorting by up/down votes without any context ends up rewarding viral content (i.e. "thumbs up if you think justin beiber sucks"). Personally I am more interested in voting/tagging posts in regards to a context (e.g. thumbs up/down in terms of "is this an insightful post?"). Ultimately I see there being lots of different contexts in which you would be able to "rank" a comment.
Obviously there's a lot of thought/discussion that needs to go into this decision. I'm not suggesting that we SHOULD implement generic vote up/down buttons. But I'd like to start the conversation here and see what we come up with.
I would like to stress that I DO think it's important that we start implementing some sort of ranking/filtering for system for comments as soon as possible. I think this is crucial to the vision of Loomio. It's just a question of where do we start?
Results
| Results | Option | Votes | % of votes cast | % of eligible voters | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Agree | 2 | 22 | 0 | ||
| Abstain | 2 | 22 | 0 | ||
| Disagree | 5 | 56 | 1 | ||
| Block | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Not voted | 893 | 99 |
It all got to happen sooner or later
I'm feeling a bit either way at the moment. if someone can present a better initial feature to implement for comment ranking, I'm all ears. Otherwise, I think this could be a good place to start.
this is a BIG question that needs a lot more discussion before I give it thumbs up
I would suggest a like feature for now and we think more about other options
Would like to see other options explored more in depth first.
We really need to discuss this further. I mean, yes, voting is a good idea, but we have to talk in terms of dev priorities and what's most needed
Very much agree that more discussion is needed, but, also feel that if it's easy enough to implement, it could be a good starting point for the smooth capability-rich discussion platform we'll be building up to.
Exited there is new thinking around this but needs more architecture.
I think with the current (and immediately foreseeable) userbase, we don't need an up/down system per se. Each member of each group knows each other, so the signal-to-noise ratio will be far better than for e.g. Reddit.
It might be useful to add a simple 'like' mechanism a la Facebook: it is a very quick and non-binding kind of voting. Beyond that I'd prefer to see us heading in the direction of Slashdot than Reddit, at this stage at least.
I think it is probably nearly time we got a specialist in, this stuff is not to be underestimated. IMHO metafilter.com has one of the best signal/noise ratios I've ever seen in a comments section and that is done with no technical wizardry, just 4 active human moderators and a really strong community culture (~20,000 active users)
In any case, we've already got a useful filtering system in that we have discussion on the left and summary statements on the right.
[rather you implemented ajax loading on comments first. ooh and Markdown]
How about we just implement a simple like feature on comments to start with? I feel like yammer and facebook have conditioned me so much that I feel constrained whenever there is a comment thread where I can't like people's comments.
Maybe at the top of the thread we could just display the x most liked comments (3) - really simple way to start to get a sense of group sentiment
"[rather you implemented ajax loading on comments first. ooh and Markdown]" - would have liked/upvoted this comment, as it's something I was going to say ;)
Like StackExchange's, maybe - the benefit to upvoting is higher visibility in the thread due to its position, but it doesn't get moved. And/or, merge votes' "statement" with the comments section; show the person's vote next to their name on the left? And on the right, just show vote, with name, in time descending order.
You can partially blame my crappy connection for that... haha, perhaps a delete button? :P Or, a delete button that stays for ~5 minutes and then disappears (like Facebook's ~5 seconds)
+1 for delete button
I think at this stage we are more interested in catching +1's than moving the best ideas to the top though right? and yeah like I said, if we're going to go beyond +1ing then I'd lean heavily in favour of slashdot's slider + category model. I see a lot of juicy data in the categories.
I think threading is a higher priority. So a "reply" function. I think our goal for a first stage of basic usability should be reddit style voting + threading. But we really need to have a larger discussion about this together before I feel it's ready to come to a loomio motion.
We still need to work hard out striking 'vote' from our collective Loomio vocabulary!
I think there's no harm in implementing a Reddit-style up/down feature as long as it's optional - would be very interested to see how it changes the dynamic of the discussion (can't wait to see the ultimate lolllzz and twisted porn that float to the top of every Loomio motion from now on). But it's definitely a matter of priority - I agree a reply function and ability to delete comments would be really useful immediately
For example, I wish I could delete that comment and remove the term 'hard out', which was meant to read 'hard at' - I promise I'm not secretly a 15-year-old from Invercargill.
Alright, just within this conversation I'm seeing how much I really miss the "like" button. I'm going to make an executive decision here to close this motion, because it seems like we're pretty much on the same page here. Basically, there are other features that could come first and might influence how we feel about this.
On second thought... I'll leave voting open for a couple more days just to let other people express their position
You mean you'll leave decision expression open for a couple more days? Gosh it just flows off the tongue!
Doh!
Are you using that ancestry gem? it would prob help with threading.
At the moment I'm just using the acts_as_commentable_with_threading gem... which has threading built in. Not sure if it's the best way to go...? Should work for now though.
So part of me feels like we SHOULD implement generic up/down votes, just as a place to start. Even though they are ambiguous and may even lead to a little bit of tension when certain comments get down-voted, I think it will be a really interesting experiment to see what happens. And in the spirit of agile development (ship feature quickly, then refactor based off user feedback), part of me just wants to give it a go and then see what happens and readjust as necessary. I think it could give us a lot of insight as to how we want to do the "real" contextual comment ranking in the future.