Loomio

Variety and Choice of Emoticons

GPGP Thu 24 Apr 2014 12:19AMPublicSeen by 20

This discussion is about the emoticon offering on the forums.

Angel Montes

Angel MontesSun 27 Apr 2014 2:57PM

@gp I had the same thought. But some of them could work... Look at the winking Diddy Kong, or the smiling Ness one. I could edit them a bit if we do end up wanting to use them.

GP

GPSun 27 Apr 2014 7:19PM

Anyone willing to edit them?

Angel Montes

Angel MontesSun 27 Apr 2014 8:47PM

A suggestion: Removing The $ signs around that Wario emoticon could make a nice li'l emoticon

GP

GPSat 3 May 2014 4:58PM

What about getting rid of the painter?

It's not relevant enough to be used often.

Byte2222

Byte2222Sat 3 May 2014 10:36PM

I think we can afford to get rid of the painter. I think that the other Nintendo emoticons are good but they wouldn't gel with the ones we have at the moment

GP

GPThu 19 Jun 2014 7:42PM

Painter emoticon removed. Feel free to oppose this change by creating a proposal!

GP

GPThu 19 Jun 2014 7:45PM

What do you think of WordPress.com's smilies?
http://en.support.wordpress.com/smilies/

Dark_Link_13_

Dark_Link_13_Thu 19 Jun 2014 10:12PM

I like some of them, but I also like a lot of the ones we currently have

GP

GPFri 20 Jun 2014 5:35PM

If I compare both sets of emoticons, what I see as the bigger problem is not the design, but rather the variety of emotions portrayed by the emoticons.

Here are the emotions that are found in both sets:
:)
;)
:D
XD
:(
:'(
:|
:o
:P

:(
o_0
8-)
<3
:?
:roll:
:?:

Emotions only found in the WordPress.com set:

:D
:/
'
=-=
:evil:
:twisted:
:mrgreen:
:oops:
:idea:
:!:
:bear:
:star:
:arrow:

Emotions only found in the Nintendo Papercraft set:
^ (New!)
rofl
:thumbup:
:drool:
¬¬ (New!)
:whistle:
v_v
:thumbdown:
:grouphug:
:angel:

Actually, both sets lack very important portrayals IMO.