Loomio

Using Loomio in campaigning organisations

Chelsea Robinson PublicSeen by 88

I'm really interested to hear from people around the world form Greenpeace, any of the Youth Climate Movement organisations, Friends of the Earth...

How does it work for you getting the balance of grassroots ideas with high level political strategy?

It's very difficult to build volunteer excitement unless you're talking big visions (which may disillusion them in the long run) or involving them so deeply that they have ownership over the stunts, actions, stalls, flashmobs that they create for a campaign to be made visible.

How could we use Loomio to build strategy inclusively?

How has it worked for you without Loomio?

Let's see if there's any winning strategies around, and can we amplify their impact by facilitating it all on Loomio?

Chelsea Robinson

@frederickstark this discussion is for you! :) Can you invite Lucy & Kirsty? I don't have their email addresses. Just click "invite people" in the top right :)

Alanna Irving

@megansalole might have some comments too

Alanna Irving

@marianneelliott might have some interesting thoughts as well (but she's on holiday right now)

Deleted account

Strategy into action....where should I start?

Firstly thanks Chelsea for starting this discussion it has really got my brain churning. lots of things to think about and lots of potential rabbit holes.

I am interested in hearing what others have to say about the grass roots-strategy dynamic before diving too deep into one of said rabbit holes.

Chelsea Robinson

Nice one @joehopkirk - I guess where I'm interested in exploring is from the perspective of working with different levels of engagement in a way which is empowering and leads many different types of people to take action and to take ownership of those actions.

Traditionally, it might look like saying "Day of action 21st October 2008 - every community do something on this day, start organising now and we'll send you stickers!"

This is highly decentralised, united by nothing but a meme. Its a massive win for creativity, massive win for local ownership. What it doesn't enable is cumulative, deeply committed, shared strategy where many interventions over time add up to something very visible and remarkable.

Is it possible to decentralise the ownership of strategy?

Quentin Grimaud

I use loomio for 2 campaigning organisations. Here is a copy of the email I wrote to Alina, answering her "Stories from our loomio community" question:

"Here is my loomio story:
I proposed to use loomio in several democratic communities I am involved in. It has convinced people from my 2 main communities: The Kind Viruses for Democracy (gentilsvirus.org) and the "Démocratie Réelle" (Real Democracy, democratiereelle.eu) list of my region for the european elections.
So since around november for The Kind Viruses and since a couple of months at Démocratie Réelle Ile-de-France, we are using loomio daily as our decision making tool, and the number of voters is increasing.

Our use cases:

  • The Kind Viruses

We are a global comminty of citizens (mainly French-speaking) who think that most of the problems our society faces are the result of the political impotence of citizens, and would be resolved long ago if the people could really do something about it. And this impotence is because we can only elect masters who will decide everything for us. This is written in the Constitutions of our countries, which are written by politicians, who have no interest at all to limit their powers. There is a conflict of interest, the politicians should not decide of the limits of their own power. So our problems come from the fact that we, the people, do not care about the Constituent process enough, and we let politicians write the Constitution for us. We want more direct democracy, a better constitution (for example written by a Constituent assembly whose members are picked at random among the citizens), and we try to convince people that only electing masters once in a while is not enough for a true democracy.

We use loomio to decide democratically how the content of our gentilsvirus.org website will evolve. So people make proposals, discuss how the information could be organized and what kind of information could be presented, and then when the vote is over, a developper implements the change on the website and it goes live. Or it can go the other way around: a developer makes a change to the website and makes it available on a demo page, and creates a proposal which links to it, so that the community can see the difference between what is proposed and the current state, and decide.

  • Démocratie Réelle for the European elections

Citizens build lists for the european elections (25th of may). Our only promise is, for each law proposal which comes to the european parliament (proposed by the european commission), to make an online referendum on our site, and the parliament members of our list would vote exactly like the result of this online vote. So this is a way to bring more direct democracy in the current political system. It is a kind of imperative mandate. We have lists of candidates picked at random among volunteers in all 8 regions ("circonscriptions") of France.

The community around the list of the Ile-de-France region uses loomio to make all the decisions which engage our list: we decided to make a second lotery to have even more candidates on our waiting list, and because we lack women in our list. We are also voting for which promises each canidate will have to write in a promises letter to be able to join the final list. We will soon have to decide the appearance of our voting ballot, and how we will manage its distribution to the voting places.

So that's it for my use case! A feature request we would have is to make different kind of proposals, not only "yes"/"no" question like now, but also preferential voting (using Condorcet method, like on Liquidfeedback). But I guess that a change like that would complexify a lot the classic decision making process of loomio, which is very simple and intuitive and that's why we have so much participation! Thanks again for that!"

Tim Rayner

@chelsearobinson Is it possible to decentralise the ownership of strategy? I think yes. The tools we have already (Loomio is my favourite online tool at the moment). We need a cultural architecture to make it happen. @richarddbartlett makes this point in a recent G+ interview. Human beings take ownership of things; therefore to ask 'how can we take ownership of X?' is already to ask 'how can we organise as human beings?'.

How can we decentralise the ownership of strategy? It comes down to ethics or culturetech.

@quentingrimaud you are doing great work!

Tim Rayner

@chelsearobinson Developing this theme, the basic cultural principles will be familiar to most of us. We need to create safe and inclusive environments for radical collaboration, where leadership is emergent and often distributed across multiple agents. The watchword here is co-creation, so the people engaging these environments need to be proactive, disruptive, constantly trying to execute on their ideas, and ready to fail, learn, rethink things and try again.

It's the hacker way, I guess. It's the cultural background that brings collaborative communities to life. Most of us who hang around these communities absorb it by osmosis. But it can be taught, and it needs to be signposted, and perhaps even made a condition of entry, in communities collaborating on strategy.

Building on these cultural foundations, a community collaborating on strategy requires internal alignment. This means values alignment and a shared understanding of context. Getting this right can take a lot of work, and to be honest, it's best conducted face to face. This reflects another important aspect of cultural knowledge. Knowing what can be achieved online and what should be achieved through MeetUps, is vital. It's impossible to share vulnerability in a chat feed, and a group needs deep reciprochal understanding if it is to have a chance of becoming a powerful tribe.

here's obviously a great deal more that needs to be said to describe how a decentralised swarm can strategise from multiple centres. My thought, essentially, is that without the right cultural environment, there is nothing to motivate and inspire people to own the strategy-generation process. The desire to own a social process is ultimately a desire to belong. The desire to own the process of strategy generation is inflected with the desire to grow and expand the powers associated with belonging.

Tim's two cents.

P.S. I've been reading, over the past week, about the amazing cultural work you guys are doing at Enspiral. So I know none of the above will be news to you!

Chelsea Robinson

@timrayner this quote is epic:

"The desire to own a social process is ultimately a desire to belong. The desire to own the process of strategy generation is inflected with the desire to grow and expand the powers associated with belonging."

This is the crux of it I think. "hacker mentality" can also be something like "give everyone the sense that their creativity and insight, mixed with everyone elses, and put into action quickly, is the only way anything happens".
But what's lacking from this still is the back room scheming which pulls all the data points together into something seriously coherent.

As in

  • Small group comes up with a breif
  • Small group takes to large group to build wider thinking and ownership
  • Small group (maybe a different one) is mandated to take some of that forward
  • Large group is engaged by small group to put their thinking into action

If this is happening in a locality - how are all the small groups networked in such a way that there isn't a representative democracy layer? Seems to me that representation really stamps on ownership and dulls it.

Hmm.. I think I'm dancing the "top down, vs bottom up" questions here. @joehopkirk you were going to launch in before, what did you want to bring forward?

Alanna Irving

@timrayner great comments.

At Enspiral we recently ran a process called Mastermind using Loomio to set our 2014 strategy (briefly outlined here ). It's given our rather large decentralised network a whole new level of cohesion and focus. After the strategy was agreed, we've moved into a system of working groups to move all the pillars forward.

@joshuavial was behind the process, along with @silviazuur ... I'm really keen to do another iteration for 2015 later this year, and then work on open sourcing the process and collaborating with other networks about distributed strategy setting best practice.

Deleted account

Like most things, once you scratch the surface strategy will not boil down to a item decision. as a catch all rule top down is likely to be a leader but there will always be exceptions.

I think this comes from the purpose of strategy as a part of an organisation and gaining an understanding of that.

Strategy is not just about setting a high level goal or creating the vision of the world looking how it has been changed. this is one small facet of strategy. (and of course requires the inspirational leader types to work on it). but a strategy that is not able to be understood and implemented is a waste of time, money and a frustration to everyone involved.
Strategy is implementable, and understandable, it should be used to explain the endpoint and then align the objectives in a way that leads to the actions of an organisation into having both power and purpose.

This is a conceptual example of the wider idea of strategy rather than a tangible example. I will think of an example after coffee.

JH

vivien maidaborn

wow, I am feeling very warm reading this thread, meta levels of inquiry and learning and support. Makes me feel like I am in the right place. Thanks for initiating @chelsearobinson

Chelsea Robinson

@frederickstark I haven't heard from you yet, interested to see what you think about this.

Marianne Elliott

I'm really interested in pursuing this line of conversation - I'd love to play with how Loomio could be used to create real opportunities for ActionStation members to have input into campaign design and planning...