Loomio

Membership applications

Kate LebedeffKate Lebedeff Mon 11 Nov 2013 7:50PMPublicSeen by 308

Currently we have all applications routed to council@openmandriva.org
At the same time we have a membership committee, which is taking care of memberships and membership data.
At the same time we received a number of concerns from members-to-be about supplying their private data to a wide ML (as council ML).
what is clear:
1. members concerns have to be respected
2. council members have to have access to this data if needed (and they guarantee, that this data goes no further)
3. safe encrypted storage of data within membership committee has to be guaranteed

Suggestion: to make sure that membership committee ML is fully closed and to make it primary email for membership applications.
To announce this change and the above reasoning on the relevant wiki page

Kate Lebedeff

Do you agree to route applications to fully closed membership committee ML and implement changes as suggested in the text above?

proposal by Kate Lebedeff Closed Thu 14 Nov 2013 7:55PM

Results

ResultsOptionVotes% of votes cast% of eligible voters
Agree209530Raphaël JadotJohn CaveAnurag BhandarijclvanierKate LebedeffLeonardo MeloAlexander KhryukinrugyadaBen BullardRobert XuChris TannerDiogo TravassosRaul Liota da RosaAlisson Oliveira FerreiraTomasz Paweł GajcPaulo César Pereira de AndradeJochen SchönfelderDavide GarattiMARCOUREL DenisDenis Silakov
Abstain152mdawkins
Disagree000 
Block000 
Undecided4568Wayne SalleeCharles SchulzBernhard RosenkränzerAndrey BondrovVladimir RubanovJoão Azevedo PatrícioGuilherme MoroModise MakhethaColin ClosejdronovaLeonardo Silveira CoelhoMarco Antonio BenattoJhonatan Piffer SiqueiraSvetoslav ChukovAndrey PonomarenkoRodrigo MacedoMaik WagnerEdward G. HowardkarolRolf Pedersen

21 of 66 votes cast (31% participation)

John Cave

John Cave
Agree
Tue 12 Nov 2013 7:09AM

Yes, but it should also be between membership committee and the team leader, particularly for teams like Infra where there is data at stake :)

Raphaël Jadot

Raphaël Jadot
Agree
Wed 13 Nov 2013 8:49AM

Maybe we should OpenPGP certificate for membership list.

Tomasz Paweł Gajc

Tomasz Paweł Gajc
Agree
Thu 14 Nov 2013 8:06AM

Seems to be fair.

jclvanier

jclvanierWed 13 Nov 2013 4:16PM

@Raphaël: could you be more specific?