Loomio

Fixing Notifications

Robert Guthrie PublicSeen by 38

I want to present my solution for improving the UI and backend for the notifications system in Loomio.

We remove notificaiton generation for all events except for things which directly involve you, requiring acknowledgement, such as when you are mentioned in a comment or win $1000 and need to claim your prize.

We introduce a new component called Recent Activity which uses the Daily Summary backend to group activity around discussions and motions, showing at most 1 item per discussion where there has been activity since you last looked

Things I'm unsure of:
* If the Recent Activity should be a dropdown alongside notifications and groups, or a page or both, or even integrated into them somehow.

  • Should the Recent Activity component show recent activity for all groups or just the one you are currently viewing?

Things I would like someone else to do:
* Mockups

Robert Guthrie

I have to say.. creating that discussion was a LOT snappier than in 1.2. Yay

Richard D. Bartlett

I'm unsure of why you'd want to outsource the job of making mockups for this feature?

Robert Guthrie

Ok I'm willing to mock it up but if someone wants to give it a go before then that would be nice.

Robert Guthrie

Why didn't I put this in features??? What kinda noob am I?

Anyway @richardd.bartlett I have a mockup for you:
https://loomio.mybalsamiq.com/projects/fixnotifictionswithactivitydropdown/Activity+and+Notifications+Side+by+Side+in+Harmony+Forever+%E2%99%A5

I may have shot myself in the foot putting a heart character in the title of the mockup.

I think this could exist as both a full page and a drop down.

@jonlemmon how do we move this discussion to the features group?

@benjaminknight Hows it going?

@aaronthornton hows the coffee today?

Robert Guthrie

Or would it be better in the UX subgroup?

I DONT KNOW!

Aaron Thornton

Hey Rob, Coffee is very nice. How did you know I have fallen into the habit of catching up on Loomio while I drink my morning coffee at home. Uncanny timing, If I were a paranoid conspiracist I might think you had control of my webcam. Any who, I love your mock up, got to say it again Balsamic rocks and am glad you gave us the push we needed. The issus I have is an age old one. This seems to be replacing the Dashboard(Home). Its the Dashboard/Dropdown juxtapose we had with the groups. All this information is displayed on the dash. Agreed when your not on the Home page it may be useful, but thats what the Homepage is for, right?

Benjamin Knight

This is awesome Robbie - I think @aaronthornton 's point gets to something more fundamental - that any redesign of the notifications system ties in really closely to the redesign of the dashboard/homepage. Worth tackling both at the same time to ensure coordination?

Robert Guthrie

I think we agree the widgets are right.. it's just a matter of their containers and positioning.

What are the other functions that you expect of the home page? I've got another (more radical) UI concept brewing.

Richard D. Bartlett

I agree we need radical UI thinking, so long as it is informed by the user feedback we're seeing. Right now we're still failing to communicate the basic mental model: user has many groups, group has many discussions, discussion has many decisions.

For whatever reason, our UI does not make this model as intuitive as possible: people still don't grasp the discussion-has-decisions idea. We're seeing people start decisions when they really mean to start new discussions.

I have a hunch that people who make this mistake might not even know the group page exists. Perhaps one solution is to make the connection between the group and the discussion clearer. Here's a quick stab to give you the gist of what I mean.

I woke up this morning with a phrase on my lips: notifications are navigation. I don't use my notifications to find out things relevant to me, per se, I use my notifications to tell me what page to go to next.

IMHO, having a list of this group's discussions readily available like this would solve the navigation issue (prev/next buttons being problematic) and reinforce the mental model in one swoop!

Robert Guthrie

I think it might be a bad idea to try and solve this by explaining the model. It's better if you can just get them to click where they need to click and have them pick up the model later.

I think that the home screen is doing most of the same navigation as the nav bar... and if a big drawer with some group list, activity list, notification list popped down, with the same format as the home screen that might be cool.

Robert Guthrie

Hey I like that sidebar @richarddbartlett

Jon Lemmon

Sweet, I'm loving the direction of this conversation. Let's keep brainstorming and producing more unique ideas. Then we can iterate the design of each idea independently and once we get further down the track we can choose one we like. This concept is known in the UI/UX world as parallel prototyping. It's known to have really good results because it keeps the designers detached from a specific mockup and produces results you might not originally have thought of. Also, usually the different ideas end up influencing each other. I'll try to submit some mockups soon as well.

Basically, I think this is something that we should keep experimenting around with for a little while before committing to any one specific option.

Looking forward to seeing where this heads!

Aaron Thornton

@richarddbartlett I like the side bar. It adds cohesion through showing everything at once(google wave), but... take a step back and shake your head a few times... it adds complexity for the new user as there is more to take in all at once.
The usable screen would need to be bigger(reclaiming the 'taupe' colored side of the page) or the font a lot smaller as I dont think you want to squeeze this comment space any more. As a user coming from MY OWN level of understanding I would love to have that panel on the side, the question is...is this desire representative of our user base?

Benjamin Knight

@richarddbartlett interesting idea! I think it would be super useful, and defz something to explore further.

I don't think it resolves the need for Next/Previous navigation - imagine for a minute that tabbed browsing doesn't exist (for a decent proportion of our users this is effectively true). Still requires lots and lots of clicking back and forth (just now you're doing it inside a discussion rather than on the Home page or Groups page), which some people find super frustrating.

I like the idea we talked about a while back of converting the Home page into a page showing semi-expanded recent/important/active discussions/decisions, grouped by group.

And I LOVE NEXT AND PREVIOUS BUTTONS!

PS I will endeavour to learn to start making mockups to turn these meaningless words into compelling pictures

Matthew Bartlett

@benjaminknight I'm pretty sure RDB's mockup would take the same number of clicks as next/previous buttons... (i.e. half as many as the current scenario)

James McCann

@richarddbartlett The sidebar idea reminds me of the homepage mockup you did a while back https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B_Yex4bwI5AnbEF4WEl5WHQzYTQ/edit

I think there is potential for something similar to the above where full proposals could be displayed on the right pane (JS-style), i.e. you could reply/vote/engage with every proposal on your dashboard without having to leave the dashboard.

Nicolas Wormser

@robertguthrie I'd be curious to see what you came up with, but your balsamiq mockup is not public. Can you make it public, and could someone invite nicolas.wormser@gmail.com to balsamiq? Chur

Nicolas Wormser

That's interesting. But I wonder where the notification box would go, and if the activity widget wouldn't get overloaded if you go on a holiday for a week.

I think that instead of trying to make multiple widgets that pop out everywhere, we could think about how the dashboard can give a better overview of what activity recently happened. This probably means creating an "activity view", different from the "inbox view" (what we have at the moment). Then we could switch from one view to another…
Notifications-wise, we would get only one notification, saying that we've got new activity on the dashboard.

Here's my take at it :
- The activity view on the dashboard
http://imageshack.us/a/img201/692/dashboardactivity.png
- When we click on "Notifications (4)"
http://imageshack.us/a/img266/3451/dashboardnotifications.png

This is a solution that makes more sense to me.

p.s. An access to Loomio's Balsamiq would have been helpful

Richard D. Bartlett

@nicolaswormser that looks awesome!

@jonlemmon has exclusive rights to give people access to our Balsamiq account :)

James McCann

@nicolaswormser nice mockup. My only question would be is the inbox view even required - can it just be activity view and still work as well?

Nicolas Wormser

Thanks guys. @jamesmccann it could totally work without the inbox view. I was just thinking that maybe the inbox/current view had the advantage of being more compact, especially if you don't care about the discussions that have new activity.
But the point is, supposing that only discussions you're following (feature to come) appear there, I guess you WOULD care.

So yeah, let's ditch the inbox view (and add the pager to the activity view), I guess.

Nicolas Wormser

Also, to be more precise, assuming that we display only activity for discussions we follow on the dashboard, the blue marker in front of the discussions for which there have been new comments since last visit still makes sense (because this is for all discussions, not only the ones I follow).

Not sure if I'm being clear enough.

Aaron Thornton

@nicolaswormser and @jamesmccann I really like where this is going. The notifications dropdown will then reallly only be for 'likes', 'mentions' and proposals closing soon.
Everything on the home/activity page is activity. Only showing old discussions or those without activity when searching. Love the simplicity.