Legal: Permits? Do we need stinking permits?
Let's research the laws about sleeping on the sidewalk as protest - Lets be aggressive in opposing limits to free speech by real people. The 1% is now able to spend as much money as they want- why can't we spend as much time as we want even overnight
A vote no from @allstr33ts: We feel this is a bad idea. It's too noisy, and it is creates the wrong feelings. We do not support.
What does @allstr33ts not support?
@juliaclark Julia, What are you Blocking?
Cecily McMillan's s case has helped foster realization that militarized police– not protesters– were reason for OWS's "failure" http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/may/19/cecily-mcmillan-three-months-jail-occupy-future-protest
@sea I stated why I was/am blocking.
Julia's block i believe is to address including an invitation to the gov.
It is being addressed in another disc. and proposal.
https://www.loomio.org/d/J6BlG2Ic/invite-gov-brown
and doing poorly. I am assuming we met that, or will have when the proposal closes. Julia?
This discussion and the proposal, 2nd Draft of letter to Gov. Jerry with edits and cc's, is what we must address to come to a decision.
I propose we extend this proposal closing date, give folks a chance to view in editable place, http://natgat2014.titanpad.com/74, and encourage more folks registering agreement or dis..
I've had a hard time digesting the letter reading it here. and would also like a link to the Human Rights Council resolution 15/21.
After listening to Sea talk about strategy tonight, it made more sense to me - the piles of text on many threads turns me off to the topic. Now that I've digested it more I think we may have found our "launch" material and message. Free speech and the right to assemble as the main focus. They're incarcerating every type of protester.
forget the anxiety of a press release. send this letter in a coordinated media blitz of our social media, and occupy email base of 8 -10K in the form of a newsletter/email.
(e.g. http://crm.interoccupy.net/civicrm/mailing/view?reset=1&id=387) send to msm or not. it was said in the first year of occupy the network on twitter extended to a million people at one point.
We should also establish who on the ground in Sacramento and online will field questions from media. and where to send media requests - I'll pout it on media somewhere.
thoughts?
Sorry, Julia. My browser doesn't let me see the reasons for a person's vote. Its old, like me. :-)
I like Cres' idea to start the media campaign with the week beginning June 9th. Thanks Cres and Tricia.
It says proposal closed. What was the result?
The letter(s) have been put on a pad for editing:
http://natgat2014.titanpad.com/74
I believe the block has been addressed.
next steps?
Edit the letter to be ready June 8th and sent out June 9th.
Just saw the outcome - don't believe the invitation passed with 4-3. not strong decision. But, yes, moving forward with the letter; seems to be agreement for June 9 release.
I am concerned that only one Occ Sac voted on this proposal, and think the final edited version should be presented on a call for a decision - whether that is the planning call or media call, not sure.
After it's edited the final version can go to a the call and to the Occ Sac GA for final approval
Maybe those folks want to help edit; @sallyg reminding myself to send the current text and link to the e-mail list—should it be to full list or to media?
The way it will work with the Occ Sac GA is that the letter campaign to officials will be first brought up on June 7 and it won't pass until June 21. However that doesn't mean that the media campaign won't start before Occ Sac GA approves the letter. The letters aren't the media campaign. Whenever Cres imparts information to media, he will know the drift of the impending letters, or of any other moves that could effect his media work.
This is critically important to understand. Cres' target date for the media releases beginning on June 9 is good, even though the GA will not at that time have approved the first letter. The GA does not approve media releases. Similarly, the GA will not have to approve every letter. They must just approve the general outlines of the letter campaign, knowing that it is being vetted through Loomio and the Conference Call, and knowing that Cres won't let us down.
Make no mistake. Cres' media releases are not the letters, although the releases will be informed by the letters. Here on Loomio we are now discussing a series of letters which will probably bear little resemblance to the original letter posted on this discussion. Still, a particular letter may be similar to the original. The content of each letter and who receives it, isn't being decided on Loomio, because the critical part of our disagreements over letters (not over media releases), only concerned Governor Brown. He is an official sui generis. Each official will receive a differently worded letter, and only after the previous shoe drops, ie that we have assessed the result of the previous letter. Then we will have more shoes to drop.
Sacramento has a strongly functioning GA that adheres to the original Occupy Wall St guidelines for decisions, including hand signals and Blocks.
A note to jemcgloin. What you say is correct that the Block seems used in a weird way on Loomio. But not so at the GA. A Block in the Occ Sac GA always gets resolved because with rare exceptions we always get good consensus. Occ Sac GA takes its work very seriously. We're good at side-lining idle issues or disrupting Blocks. We paid a heavy price for not being able to side-line such from 2011-2012. Now we know how.
However the process of approving the letter goes deeper since people still think the letters are for the media.
The letters are to put pressure on officials, who, if they don't play nice, the media releases will expose.
The person doing the media, who is very professional and all of Sacramento respects his work, doesn't work through the GA. He follows what is happening and then does the best media alerts he can. That is Cres. He doesn't need to approve the letter, other than he will give good advice on its wording. Likewise, the GA doesn't need to approve his media releases.
Each letter is a tactical move within encompassing strategic moves, which involve more than a particular letter, and which also involve things done besides letters, or besides media releases. Each successive letter is tailored after the previous letter is sent out. Each letter is directed only at officials in their official capacities. Each official has a different capacity. This was confused because the first rendition of the letter made it seem that a single letter would be sent to all the various officials. It was further confused by thinking that the letters were for the media. The only way the details of the official letters will be overtly known to the media, is if we have to do a full-page ad in the Sacramento Bee exposing City officials. That will only happen if by the first week of July, we feel that the officials want to be violent. We already know their every move. This strategy and its tactics will prevent them from having any idea of what we are going to do. Other than they will know it is to their advantage to cooperate with us.
Cres will massage the outcome/responses from the officials, to make a hit with the media. And hopefully Homer Simpson :-) will be doing his best to comment on both the letter campaign and the media releases, and on developing events on the ground. Particularly if the officials seem determined to prevent us from camping. We'll have an idea of whether they can hit our hard-balls before the end of June.
I repeat. The Letters are not Media Releases. The appropriate media releases will be made, with foreknowledge of what letters have been sent out.
Folk should read in great detail the discussion titled "Legal, Permits, do we ... ". It describes the letter campaign. It does not describe the media releases. Read it many times and read between the lines.
I think it's understood that the letter this the news and Cres will share with the media and the media will report on the news.
I don't see a proposal for a series of letters. This needs to be discussed as to the why/how.
Also I didn't actually agree that we would sign the letters "Abe Simpson" ~ that was just a joke.
I thought you meant that humorously, stylistically, and effectively, "twitter" (ha, ha) might spread rumors of Abe Lincoln's deathbed prediction concerning the impending doom of officials who oppose Occupy, that was revealed to Homer Simpson in a dream.
Sea certainly suggested a series of letters a while back, not a formal proposal while we were working on wording for the governor’s letter; I am in a rush going to work or would figure out how to make such a proposal now.
I sent the 2nd draft to the Sacramento ACLU ~ They don't have lawyers so are sending it to the Northern California Chapter. Will post what they say here.
Point of Information: Yestetday a federal judge banned Idaho from removing #Occupy Boise tents on state grounds because it would violate the constitutional right to protest. http://m.tribtown.com/view/story/9dee6b938006408388a948862460d791/ID--Occupy-Boise
Thanks Tricia. I forwarded this to our Legal team. Any information like this I will forward to Sacramento's Legal Team.
The local ACLU is interested in helping. I will forward this news to them and see how they can help.
The ruling in Boise was in federal court so applies nationally.
Tricia,
Who are you dealing with at the ACLU? I am a former ACLU board member in Sacramento, but left to co-coordinate the National Lawyers Guild chapter here, which has been much more "friendly" to Occupy. We have our own legal team in Sacramento - about 30 plus lawyers - who worked pro bono on cases. 110 Occupy arrests, and everyone one of them dismissed. FYI, the ordinance in Sacramento prevents anyone from being in city parks after 11 p.m. weekdays/midnight Fri-Sun. And also prevents any other night camping, even on private property, for more than 24-48 hours.
I sent them a heads up that it's happening. This is what the NorCal chapter said: (My comments are in parens)
I will definitely let them (the local chapter) know about it. There are some students and teachers in Sacramento that I work with fairly regularly who I will reach out to. Do you have a flyer? (I sent the flyer) The chapter is also a great ally—you can reach out to Tess Ahmad who originally responded to your e-mail about ways the chapter can be involved via tabling/public education/help with organizing etc. The chapter’s role is an organizing/public education role. The number/website I sent you to will be able to direct you to the resources that will help with the legal side of looking at your letter.
Best,
Tessa
tdarcangelew@aclunc.org
I sent the flyer attached and got this response
"Thanks, Tricia. Please keep me posted - our Chapter would like to help.
Tessnim Ahmad
435-720-0773
tessnim.ahmad@gmail.com"
I haven't felt clear (or had time) to write back.
There was a major ruling in a federal court in Boise Idaho that blows the local ordinance argument out of the water. http://rt.com/usa/165804-boise-idaho-occupy-camp/
I think this changes everything.
The NLG provides legal representation (in terms of arrests), and observers to any and all events, actions, etc. I'm coordinating a pro bono team of lawyers to handle court appearances, for instance, of the recent Rise99 Capitol arrests.
That said, where is the group at re: permits for Capitol Park grounds, or alternatives???
The Capitol park permits have been applied to for Thurs, Fri and Sun. LR is handling that.
The group voted on last week's call to get a permit and to allot the money for Southside Park for Sat. Cathy is handling that. Lisa is helping both with the transition.
So, we know where we are everyday now, and can start making more concrete plans for set up and activities.
@cresvellucci that's great about the NLG and coordinating a team of lawyers.
Did you see the thread elsewhere about coordinating a conference call with ACLU reps? Perhaps there can be a larger legal team call.
Jackie, thanks for making the "extra calls" discussion private. The questions you asked in the "Planning the Training" discussion are exactly the kind of questions I had hoped would arise when I spoke of the changes in Sacramento with 99Rise. I will try to give a really good answer to those questions, hopefully soon. However here I want to comment on the post above regarding the scheduling. And I will use this comment as a preface to the answer to your questions in the “Planning the Training” discussion.
The most clear first statement I can think of to fully express the beginning of this comment and of the answer to the questions you raised, is that, “we will only know if our plans work after the Gathering has come and gone.” As for the reasons why we think our plans would work, many have been given. I list them in random order and I do not imply that I think one is a better reason than another. The reasons are either historical, or ahistorical. I am only listing the ones I consider ahistorical reasons here. Though ahistorical, they can't help but arise out of the past of our worldly consciousness. So, though I call them ahistorical, they do point to history. The pointers then tell (they intimate or disclose) the historical reasons that I am not discussing here, but which, have been given in clear terms since 2011, and so most of us have some idea of them. But its the reasons that I call “ahistorical” that I think are most compelling regarding our Gathering, its prospects, and what the scheduling and Training has to do with it.
And before I continue, let me state my belief and inspiration. What has arisen in the Occupy and 99% movements in 2014, is consciousness whether historical or ahistorical. That consciousness grips the whole world, including “the rich”, Tea Partyers, Police, Pentagon, Obama, and Brown. So its our ability to “vision-out” consciousness, that will cause us to succeed.
The ahistorical reasons that have been adduced for the reasonableness of our efforts and our hope for success, include:
1 A shift in consciousness.
2. That the universe wants us to succeed.
3. That the world wants us to succeed.
4. That the repressive powers are not really as repressive as they seem, whereby a slick maneuver by us can out-wit them.
5. That young, poor, and disadvantaged people (along with women Blacks Indians and Immigrants etc), will simply not stand for such bad govt anymore.
6. That this is a “New Age”, etc.
7. That privileged “white” people are indeed capable of carrying out the revolution that T Jefferson said would be required.
8. That patriarchy is in retreat.
9. That horizontal decisioning works and vertical doesn't.
10. That the split between Occupy and 99%, is either not relevant to what we do, or that it will be resolved by what we do.
11. That violence has proven to “not work”.
12. That our “greatest minds” foresee this future.
If people want to add other reasons, that's good. However my comments here and the comments I'll make regarding the questions Jackie raised in the “Planning” discussion, will presume that regardless of whatever reasons for our success or failure are offered, I will only be commenting in terms of their ahistorical dimensions.
Having said all that, Jackie tells us that LR is getting permits for Thu Fri and Sun and Kathy is getting one for Sat. However the one for Sat is a permit for Southside Park and yet we might be involved in an Energy Conclave on Saturday, which may or may not relate to how the Mime Troupe business is treated, which was originally thought to be on Sun at Southside Park, thereby Sat at the Capitol was available for our “big” events. There has been ultimate confusion about what will happen on Sat and Sun, yet Jackie's hopeful statement hasn't resolved that confusion, unless the Training, the plans of Laura and NikiV, the tedious discussion we did have about Fri and Sat, and Les from Sacramento's question, are ignored. Les's can't be ignored ultimately, however it will be ignored according to being in SouthSide park on Sat, instead of being there on Sun. Because the above scheduling is being done by people who have participated little in the Loomio discussion. LR and Kathy are doing good. However their good isn't the complete answer to how we can make our Gathering a success. Having specified permits and days, means that the Training is all the more needing to be focused on. And the training doesn't fall under any of the permits. And the only place where all of this has been discussed is on Loomio.
The energy conclave can be either Sat or Sun either at the Capitol or Southside Park. So this will likely work out. But the confusion will not thereby abate, and the overall prognosis for the success of our venture will not change. That is because a shift in consciousness is involved, and that shift in consciousness is not reflected in the report of the permits being obtained in Sacramento.
For those unfamiliar with issues surrounding the Energy conclave, it involves the Sac GA and its “abortive” NatGat planning group, Brother Carter and Chickenfoot Ranch, and Governor Brown. However the most dynamic part of this potential Energy conclave is being expressed by NikiV, and she too is infrequently seen on Loomio.
wow. well then, this does present some serious problems of collaboration. not one soul has mentioned "Energy Conclave", at least on the planning calls or spkrs group calls. (though br. carter's day plan was to be focused around energy - but he has as recently as a couple of days ago said he is not involved, and in fact does not want his name used in connection with any plans - if that has changed, please let the group know - though I imagine he would do that himself, since he was gracious enough to come to the call and let others know he was pulling out, instead of just disappearing.)
The capitol is NOT available for Sat, so it was never on the table (this has been known for months).
the folks on the wed call, of which Donna and Niki were part of, voted to get the permit for Sat. and thereby change the day we would see the Mime Troupe, the one thing that was in stone and on the schedule for months.
Sea, just saying that folks are unfamiliar and what they are unfamiliar with, does nothing to clarify to the wider group or the public looking for details, what to expect at NatGat.
I would suggest folks with concrete info either join the spkrs group, propose them on the main email list or loomio or the tons of other platforms.
It is disrespectful of other organizers' time and energies to not have everything proposed on the table at this point.
@oswgwhe - I challenge your assertion that "the only place where all of this has been discussed is on Loomio." Other than from you, I can find very little from anyone, including Niki, Laura, and Les. (Since Laura's initial post several weeks ago about Friday ideas, I've seen no follow-up from her.) I've combed many discussions, looking for concrete things; they simply aren't there. If Les is planning something, Sea, I request that you ask him (and anyone else planning anything definite) to email natgat2014@interoccupy.net with the specifics.
People interested in NatGat are wanting to know what the schedule is. In putting together the schedule, the spkrs-structure WG is needing to know as much as can be known about:
- What people are planning to do (and when).
- The likelihood that those things are going to happen.
I'll echo what Jackie says:
If you know either of those things, kindly let us know right away: mailto: natgat2014@interoccupy.net
I also heard Brother Carter state that he was not planning any events. In agreement that Sat at the capitol was never on the books. got to run; more later perhaps.
@laurarubalcaba @nikiv @les @oswgwhe @delphinebrody @donnapiranha1 Please let us know here and at natgat2014@interoccupy.net what definite plans are being worked on, so that they can get onto the schedule with others; the speakers group is on a call as I type this and wondering! We are trying to balance large events with open-space time in a noncompetitive way.
Sally, do I have to keep mentioning the Training on July 30?
The training is of course on the schedule as Delphine requested long ago, to be promoted with the NatGat dates.
What the group could use is
Time
Location
Duration
We will be updating maps and FAQ this week.
Unless you are saying you don't want the training promoted?
Of course it should be promoted. The details haven't been clear for three reasons. It took Delphine time to locate the trainers who have been named and will train on the date stated. The duration of the training and its exact details depend on whether we use a familiar Occupy location, or whether a major church in Sacramento will host the event. It will last all day and all night. That uncertainty has changed with the change in Sacramento. The third reason is that there has been very little discussion and bye-in from the usual NatGat planners, on Loomio or elsewhere. If the usual NatGat planners don't start discussing it and don't decide to attend, then the rest of the Gather will be discolored thereby. So the promotion should be the promotion for people to get on board. Their reluctance will be a negative factor affecting the possibility of success, in light of the Changes which also need to be discussed. Part of the Training will be a training by 99Rise.
I am attending. I have not been asked for any specific help before I get there. What more is wanted? I do not see anyone making negative remarks, other than “you are not doing enough”, without specifics as to what that “enough” looks like. I am planning to arrive in Sacramento Tuesday night, maybe meet some folks if it is not too late, get settled, and come to the training on Wed.
Sadly, Sally, very few Occupiers have your attitude or perhaps your ability.
Surely most Occupiers would remember the split between 99% and Occupy, that continues to weaken us. With 99Rise, we can reunite. The Training will involve reuniting with 99Rise and with all people who have less privilege that "white" people, particularly "white" male people. The thing that is going to get Sacramento as a whole behind us, is the belief that we are going to do something about the basic inequality, which arises from surplus value being stolen by "white" people, usually male.
If we have the NLG and the ACLU on a call and strategize -- we might even be able to have tents on the grounds. It's our constitutional right as a federal judge ruled in Idaho last month. http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/06/12/us-usa-protests-idaho-idUSKBN0EN2SA20140612
This 99Rise reminds me of "99 Percent Declaration" who had something the first year in Philly '12. They ended up coming to the NatGat after their events and having a great time.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/99_Percent_Declaration
I suggest we do the duties that lie before us and get our head in the game.
Tomorrow, Tuesday 7/8 1pm EST is going to be an outreach party
If there is a schedule, even a rough schedule, I can work with fellow NLG and ACLU legal types here and see what we can do in advance re: an injunction. But, frankly, it's hard to get "hard" facts...when and where, and what (can be rough). We can't brief this to the court unless we know what you want (to stay on Capitol grounds x, y or z, or in a park, etc. Thanks.
LR's, Cathy's, and Lisa's efforts to get permits will be said at the Wednesday conference call, according to Cathy.. But I fear than even then the plans won't be firm, because interoccupy.net which holds the "final" schedule, is but loosely connected to what people are doing. Cathy said that they expect to get permits at the Capitol for Thu, Fri, and Sunday -- yes I said Sunday.
IMHO, I don't think we will know until, the "Planning for the Training" is given more credence. That's because it may deal with patriarchy and white privilege. Those, and Sacramento's GA have been chief culprits in discombobulating our plans, regarding the Capitol, x, y, z, the park, etc.
To wit. There is a communication gap between interoccupy.net and what actual Occupiers (with or without 99Rise) want to do. I only mean to assign blame to the Sacramento GA.
I hope these comments are helpful, re: what I see as a quagmire facing us between now and July 30 -- yes I said July 30. If I'm pessimistic I'm sorry. Its what I feel, hear and read.
The fact is a rough schedule is being drafted and should be available shortly.
Never fear.
Cal, regarding your post above "I challenge your assertioin" ... and "very little has been heard" regarding things people are doing, i.e. not posted on Loomio, why hasn't the Structures WG not posted events on Loomio? It would help us in Sacramento. interoccupy.net was set up to be a way to put info in so interoccupy.net could use it, instead of being a way for interoccupy.net to provide us with information, so we could use it. Am I wrong? What "boots on the ground" info has interoccupy.net posted on Loomio recently.
The structures group does not create events; it gleans information from other sources and melds them into the 4 days (with a 5th for training!) in a way that seems to make sense, then presents it to the Wednesday call for approval, modification, etc. Titanpads have been constructed sequentially; here are the 3 for the speakers/structure group: Spkrs-Program-Structure WG Main Pad http://natgat2014.titanpad.com/59
Spkrs-Prog-Structure WG Agenda http://natgat2014.titanpad.com/60
Activities Confirmed, in the works and suggested https://natgat2014.titanpad.com/82
The first of these, pad 59, starts with a list of links to nontitanpad documents, reproduced here—including a link to 2013 and 2012 information, respectively, for purposes of comparison:
To coordinate and organize the structure of the event
Email list: ng-2014-spkrs-program-wg@lists.interoccupy.net
Subscribe to email list: https://lists.mayfirst.org/mailman/listinfo/ng-2014-spkrs-program-wg
Agenda
http://natgat2014.titanpad.com/60
Docs:
2014
NatGat2014 Contacts
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0Ah3I8WTDRzzpdEpDUVF2TDNyQWNRTWtLTFVEZDg0d1E#gid=0
NatGat3 Draft Schedule Template
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0Ah3I8WTDRzzpdExpdElWbUNiNHlBM2tmZVVnT3lXMFE&usp=drive_web#gid=0
Activity Creators, Participants, Presenters, Speakers - NG3
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0Ah3I8WTDRzzpdGlYYVFOQWVya0YxSG5CenNMdGloblE&usp=drive_web#gid=0
Volunteer Submissions - Outreach
https://calc.mayfirst.org/Volunteer_Submissions
Occupy Sacramento NatGat3 Scrounge list
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0Ah3I8WTDRzzpdDdMV05IWnJhX3ozWUI3blZfRTNwTFE#gid=0
2013
Draft NatGat2 Schedule Template
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0Ah3I8WTDRzzpdGRQMmZ2WVlmQm1PWTBMaFNQVnFzcXc#gid=0
this doc had both schedule and speakers
2012
Speakers List
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0At9uCvYdJclydFU2VkVYM1JVb1NTUnJOM1h6MFdaZEE&usp=drive_web#gid=5
this doc organized speakers, but there were many more actvites [sic] going on
The first link at the top of that page is how to get on that group’s e-mail list—a link that may also be found on interoccupy.net/natgat2014, at a button that says “help plan”. It is annoyingly ironic to be accused of NOT providing information when it has been out there since the beginning, being filled in as we learn of it.
WHOA! Hold on. DISPEL THIS MYTH IMMEDIATELY!
InterOccupy.net holds nothing, has no part in the planning end of natgat. IO offers TOOLS. Free, movement -based and -created TOOLS.
Talk about creating hierarchy around every corner, sheesh! - people seem to want to assume that IO has something to do with planning these natgats. All tools provided by IO for any action, call series, campaign, etc. are the responsibility of that effort. IO will offer training in how to use the tools, but it is assumed the group requesting these tools will handle them.
http://interoccupy.net/about/statement-of-autonomy/
Cal and myself, who are part of IO, joined the natgat planning effort quite independent of IO, and quite independent of each other, fyi. A couple of tech end folks help with the tech end when there is something I don't know how to do.
The IO tools were offered early on and decided by the group to use. The group could have chosen any tools they wanted.
nah. If you are referring to speakers group, Sally just gave all that info. The speakers group consists of Gandalf, Cal, Delphine, Donna, Jackie, Sally, Tricia and of course, previously, Lisa and Br. Carter, making 4 Sac folks, 6 Calif folks, and 3 online East Coasters.
DISPEL THIS MYTH IMMEDIATELY!
#COMMS FLOW
Re: the letters that are going to establish our legality: The idea included that we do events, sitins and protests that highlight what we and the officials have said, or ignored, before our gathering.
There is a walk from Benicia CA to Rodeo CA on June 14, and a walk from Rodeo CA to Richmond CA on July 12. Sponsored by Idlenomore. The walks are titled: "Connect the Dots, Refinery Corridor Healing Walks".
ConnectTheDotsHealingJourneys.org
I have the contact information. Such should be considered, and we should plan other impromptu events that are energized by our caravans. The events would highlight the responses we get from the officials, and would highlight our media stuff.