Loomio

New "discussion-first" mockups

Jesse Doud PublicSeen by 46

Here's a mockup of a new way of using Loomio that we've been working on here in Wellington. The idea is that people won't have to start a group, they'll just start a decision and invite people and groups to participate. We've started designing "mobile-first", but the designs would expand and look different on a desktop display.

Keen to hear any feedback people have!

Benjamin Knight

I would love to see what happens when people choose to add a proposal!

Jesse Doud

@ben here you go!

Jesse Doud

@benjaminknightloom, that is :) ^

Mary Jo Kaplan

I really like this concept! I can see people using Loomio MUCH MORE OFTEN as part of day to day planning with family and friends
with this approach and then appreciating its power for workplace and community.

Katia

Looks nice and simple to me!

PauKokura

Nice! I see two options here:

A: I understand you are using "start a decision" as a way to create a new group with fewer clicks (topic is really the group name), starting it with an empty discussion and an optional proposal. It's basically a change of terminology and a better user experience, but not a core change, correct?

B: Or you're saying to have "decisions" that are not in any specific "group"?

Some ideas:

  • I also see the call-for-action button in the landing page should be "start a decision". like doodle.com

  • Decissions without a group can be considered "loose threads" for light-use quick decisions. In second term, "create a group", seems useful for heavier users and stable collectives coordinating.

Looking the mockup, the section "Participants" could include privacy settings with this light-usage possibility, just adding a checkbox called "public decision".

  • If not-checked (default). A new private group is made (as topic is groupName). You (coordinator) could then send the mail invitations. [You could also "get the link" (dropbox/google drive/etherpad) to let people see or vote without register, promted to login to other actions) that's another debate]

  • If checked, a public decision is created. Internally, it is automatically included in some kind of public group called, lets say, "loose threads". [The invitations and the "get the link" option are then like a normal social share button Everyone could then access to see, or vote with or without register, in the same way, and forced to login for the rest.)]

Once logged in, the upper menu could show something like:
- "Decisions" (as "my decisions", but I dont like the "my", ordered like now in "home")
- "Groups" (Groups I belong to)
- "Commons" (Discover page for public unattached decisions & the existing Public Groups page )

"public groups" is useful for collectives, while "public decisions" for anyone to ask/give a concrete opinion at anytime (like a public survey etc).

Does something of all this make sense? XD

Jon Lemmon

Hey, thanks for the feedback @zombilechuck! :)

Did you manage to see this thread?

Sounds like your thinking is really in line with what some of us have been thinking as well. In the second video specifically it discusses a lot of what you're talking about.

Yeah, definitely going for a larger structural change, where groups are a part of discussions, instead of the other way around. That way you can invite multiple groups and other individuals to a particular discussion.

Also, this blog post might be interesting to you as well.