Loomio

Discussion-level privacy

Richard D. Bartlett PublicSeen by 181

We’ve recently made some changes to how group privacy works on Loomio.

You can now configure your groups to be public, private, or hidden:

  • Public - discussions are public. Anyone can see the group name, description, and membership. Anyone can ask to join.
  • Private - discussions are only visible to members. Anyone can see the group name, description, and membership. Anyone can ask to join.
  • Hidden - only members can see the group and its discussions. People have to be invited to join.

You shouldn’t need to do anything, we just wanted to give you a heads up about the new settings :)

Let us know if you have any questions!

Feel free to email rich@loomio.org if you have privacy concerns that you don't want to discuss in public :)

Chris Taklis

That's what I was waiting... Thanks

Alanna Irving

Will this option be adjustable as time goes on, such as if a thread starts private but then you want it to be public or vice versa, or is it a set it once and you're stuck with it type decision?

Richard D. Bartlett

Yep we're thinking discussion authors and group coordinators can change the discussion privacy at any time.

Richard D. Bartlett

@mjkaplan suggested 'Confidential' might be a better word than 'Secret', due to some negative connotations with that word. What do you think @jonlemmon?

Joshua Vial

+1 to Confidential

PauKokura

+1 Confidential

Marcos Siqueira

Sorry if newbie question again, but isn't it interesting that you guys are using +1 in the discussion instead of creating a proposal and voting?

Jon Lemmon

I'm not so sure about 'Confidential'. I think it could be a slightly confusing term. I think I'd like to stick with 'Secret' for now unless people have serious concerns. We can always change it later.

Jon Lemmon

@marcossiqueira sometimes proposals are too heavy-weight for certain discussions/decisions. For this reason, we plan on implementing an "ideas" feature in the future.

Matthew Bartlett

'Confidential' is in my view insufficiently differentiated from 'private'

Robert Guthrie

I like Confidential too. Feels more descriptive than private.

Chris Taklis

i don't think the name is the problem... both are good.

Make this reality, and then as @jonlemmon said you can change it later... i think that matters more than how to name it!

PauKokura

I didnt realise before, but its confusing with private as @matthewbartlett said.
If I look strictly, I dont like neither "private"... you are not the "owner"! I wouls say something like members-only. But internet words are what they are and mean what they mean.

In my opinion, in an ideal world I would define groups like this: (excuse me if its poor translated):

  • For the commons. Visible without account. Sign in to enter the group. (no need to request membership). You cannot have confidential discussions in a commons group.

  • Free-association Visible without account. Need to request membership or invitation. Discussions can be public or members-only (default).

  • Confidential Need an invitation. Only members can participate. No one else can see anything, even the group existence. You cannot have public discussions in a confidential group.

Benjamin Knight

Sorry if this is too late to be helpful, but this just an idea:

I was wondering if it might be clearer/simpler from a user perspective to have two levels of privacy, ‘public’ and ‘private’, but with ‘private’ groups you have the option of checking ‘do not display my group name/membership in the public groups directory’ and ‘do not allow public discussions in this group’.

(and public and private groups are differentiated by whether the default is for discussions to be public or private)

Thoughts?

@jonlemmon @hannahsalmon

Benjamin Knight

(ps just take this as a lightly held suggestion to throw in the mix, I'm sure lots of layers of thought have gone into the current design thinking)

PauKokura

after all... agree with @benjaminknightloom --> Keep it simple, I say it again to myself... keep it simple.

What about the request membership feature? Is that even possible? And how about calling them "open" and "closed"?

  • Open group. All discusions and members will be visible in the public groups directory and can be indexed in the web. Option: Require invitation or request to enter? yes / no (any loomio account can enter without aproval).

  • Closed group. All discussions, the group name and members are private and will not be displayed anywhere, except for members. Invitation is required.

I think a combination of this two options is enough. For ex. an open group with open and closed sub-groups. This makes clear a private group is really a private group. A group with public and private discussions in it can be a mess, even if you mark with an icon public or private to distinguish them. (- I saw that, - I didnt. - Oh, sorry, it was hidden for you) In my experiencem that was (is) one of the major difficulties using n-1.cc

PauKokura

Well, now I realise the topic is "Discussion-level privacy" but... thats my opinion for groups. If we turn to a "discussion-first" model (discussions without a group) then they could also be "open / closed discussions"

Jon Lemmon

@benjaminknightloom interesting idea... seems like it could actually be more confusing though. with radio buttons you only have to select one option, whereas with checkboxes you have to think about all the different combinations...

Levels of visibility/privacy for groups and decisisons in two-step radio button question

proposal by PauKokura Closed Sat 30 Nov 2013 11:04AM

I'm making this proposal based on what its in the discussion but with some changes. I cant imagine any not-possible situation with this method and its as simple as I could. Probably there is no consensus yet, but we are not using too much "proposals". Why? WHY?

(The text should be written by someone with better english than me, please do not vote for the text but for the idea. Visible = public and hidden = private.

What kind of visibility do you...? (radio button)

1 Visible group with visible decissions.
2 Visible group with hidden decissions.
3 Hidden group with hidden decissions.

1 The group and its members will appear in the public directory. Anyone can see all discussions. If you want to hide some discussions, create a subgroup with the desired privacy.

2 Only the group name and members will be visible in the public directory. All discussions are hidden to non-members. If it has a parent group, it will also appear in the subgroup index.

3 The group name and members are private/confidential/secret and will not be displayed anywhere. As no one can see a "request membership" button, invitation is required. If it has a parent group, it will NOT appear in the subgroup index for non-members.

*What kind of acces do you... * (radio button)

1 Open
2 Aproved by members
3 Aproved by coordinators

1 Any loomio account can enter directly.

2 Request membership or invitation is needed. Any member can accept request or invite.

3 Request membership or invitation is needed. Only coordinators can invite or accept a request.

Results

PauKokura
Agree

It should be explained better (see image in discussion, in the same style it is now)

Marcos Siqueira
Disagree

Too complex I think we can do better. I personally like just public/private radio button with one checkbox as to whether to list group in the directory.

PauKokura
Block

Yes, we can do better...

PauKokura
Block

Yes, can do better...

Raphaël Jadot
Agree

At first glance, it seems interesting.... like it

Lets consensuate the wording first

proposal by PauKokura Closed Sun 8 Dec 2013 10:00AM

Outcome
by PauKokura

Naming three levels of privacy, the term "Public" is fully accepted, "Private" presents some controversy, and "Hidden" is widely preferred rather than "Secret".

Lots of options have been proposed... The details (visibility-access etc) need more discussion, but if we agree the terminology first, the debate can turn to details. So...

Public, Private and Secret

Disclaimer:
yes - totally agree the three terms.
abstain - i would prefer another, but accept it.
no - Other option has not been considered enough!
block - I will never accept a word like "Public", "Private" or "Secret".

Results

PauKokura
Abstain

I dont like connotation of private and secret, but proposed alternatives seem unclear for others.

Richard D. Bartlett
Abstain

Out of character for me, but I don't care about the words on this one. I think 'hidden' might be a good alternative to 'secret'.

Robert Guthrie
Abstain

We can change this as we get a feel for it. Currently I think Private is not that self explanatory. Public and Hidden are good.

Miles Thompson
Agree

I think public, private and secret easily understood and for something like a radio box setting clarity is paramount. The word(?) consensuate makes me twitch, though ;_)

Miles Thompson
Abstain

I think public, private and secret easily understood and for something like a radio box setting clarity is paramount. The word(?) consensuate makes me twitch, though ;_)
EDIT: sorry changing my position because public, private and hidden are better.

Raphaël Jadot
Agree

Hidden or secret are both ok to me :)

Benjamin Knight
Abstain

I personally think 'secret' sends an odd message and would be more comfortable with 'hidden' or some alternative - but can live with secret as an intermediate step

Sophie Jerram
Disagree

I think the word secret is pretty odd and would much prefer hidden or Ben's suggestion of private with 'do not display' option.

Lets consensuate the wording first

proposal by PauKokura Closed Sun 8 Dec 2013 10:00AM

Outcome
by PauKokura

Naming three levels of privacy, the term "Public" is fully accepted, "Private" presents some controversy, and "Hidden" is widely preferred rather than "Secret".

Lots of options have been proposed... The details (visibility-access etc) need more discussion, but if we agree the terminology first, the debate can turn to details. So...

Public, Private and Secret

Disclaimer:
yes - totally agree the three terms.
abstain - i would prefer another, but accept it.
no - Other option has not been considered enough!
block - I will never accept a word like "Public", "Private" or "Secret".

Results

PauKokura
Abstain

I dont like connotation of private and secret, but proposed alternatives seem unclear for others.

Richard D. Bartlett
Abstain

Out of character for me, but I don't care about the words on this one. I think 'hidden' might be a good alternative to 'secret'.

Robert Guthrie
Abstain

We can change this as we get a feel for it. Currently I think Private is not that self explanatory. Public and Hidden are good.

Miles Thompson
Agree

I think public, private and secret easily understood and for something like a radio box setting clarity is paramount. The word(?) consensuate makes me twitch, though ;_)

Miles Thompson
Abstain

I think public, private and secret easily understood and for something like a radio box setting clarity is paramount. The word(?) consensuate makes me twitch, though ;_)
EDIT: sorry changing my position because public, private and hidden are better.

Raphaël Jadot
Agree

Hidden or secret are both ok to me :)

Benjamin Knight
Abstain

I personally think 'secret' sends an odd message and would be more comfortable with 'hidden' or some alternative - but can live with secret as an intermediate step

Sophie Jerram
Disagree

I think the word secret is pretty odd and would much prefer hidden or Ben's suggestion of private with 'do not display' option.

PauKokura

This is now.

Dario Castañé

Sorry for not being more active but I want to share a little reminder.

With this last proposal, "now you are thinking in liquid organizations" ;) http://lyd.dario.im/ Please, feel free to use this blueprint as you want.

Alanna Irving

I <3 u @zombilechuck for making a mockup! Thanks for all the thought you're putting into this.

Would be great to hear from some people on the product team who have been working on designing this feature @johnirving @jessedoud @jonlemmon @hannahsalmon

Deleted account

Thanks for the feedback @zombilechuck! I must say I'm not 100% clear on what's being proposed. We did do a mockup for this feature that involved 2 group privacy settings and more options to customise these settings but it seemed like it might be overwhelming for a first-time user to be inundated with so many options when attempting to start their first group. I think it's important to note that this is just an interim step. We are in the process of building features that will support us segueing into discussion-centric Loomio, in which people can be invited into discussions without having to belong to the group, with the long-term focus being on people starting discussions from the home page, not exclusively from within a group. The group privacy interface as it currently stands is just for this transitional phase. @robertguthrie, @jonlemmon, do you have anything to add?

Tathra Street

Apologies, I haven't been part of the conversations that lead to this. And I'm a bit unclear. Isn't the point to provide a platform with transparency and inclusivity? That's one of the things I appreciate about Loomio.

Richard D. Bartlett

So there's two pieces to this puzzle: visibility and participation. I started the discussion with just the first, but I see @zombilechuck has brought in the second piece too.

Visibility is about 'who can see this?'; the design is described at the start of this discussion.

Participation is about 'who can interact with this?'; the designs we've come up with provide three options: anyone can join; anyone can ask to join; only people I invite can join.

As I understand it, this is providing the same functionality as zombilechuck's proposal, but with a slightly different way of asking the questions.

p.s. Sorry for the delayed response; I'm away from the office this week (Jon too).

PauKokura

Sorry, I will try to explain it better. I think @richarddbartlett understood what I was trying to explain.
“Visibility” and “participation” (think it like “see” and “edit” in a google doc) has the same issues to resolve in all levels: a group, a subgroup, a discussion inside a group, or an independent discussion (discussion-centric), also in possible “sub-discussions” (seen in feature ideas).

The question is how items interact, when you want some private items inside public items or viceversa. (Maybe you want others to see the discussion but not to participate, now this is made simply not accepting the requests)
If we accept that public items are allowed inside private items (that was my first concern), then every new item (group or discussion) could be configured with the same question, but an icon or color should mark the difference between public and private items (in groups and in root - home).

New proposal… phew!

Who can see this?

Anyone can see.
Only members in the parent item can see.
Only members can see.

Who can interact with this?

Anyone can join
Anyone can ask to join
Only people I invite can join