Loomio

Whether the Loomio Community group should be kept public

Nicolas Wormser PublicSeen by 61

Updated context:
Nicolas kicked off a great discussion with concerns about the lack of privacy in the Loomio Community group. At the same time, we've been talking a lot about our online organisational structure, and how to align it with our offline structure and our principles around active transparency.

Current proposal:
That we set up a Loomio Contributors subgroup for people working directly on Loomio to make operational decisions, with a privately-viewable safe space for discussions involving sensitive/personal information.

Original context:
TL;DR Big Brother is watching us and we’re naked. I know we love naturism, but PLEASE, let’s draw the curtains before we end up on Youporn.

Typing "Loomio Community" in Google brings directly over here. The link to our group page also appears in the first few results of other searches related to Loomio. That means that some people willing to learn more about Loomio are being sent over here. Is it what we want? I think people should be brought to the app only if they have read the stuff that is on our home page, and are interested in using it. And certainly not land in the Loomio Community group.

If the logic behind this is "our business is 100% transparent and we want to prove this to the public", fair enough, but I think this is a bad strategy. It’s a bad strategy because, some people will inevitably take things we’ve written out from their original context and use them in ways that will make us a bad press, intentionally or not. If anyone treats us as a rival/competitor and want to turn us into dust, we’re just making the job extremely easy for them at the moment. This will get more and more dangerous as public attention increases.

Are people posting here aware that every single thing they post is available to the world, scanned by search engines, cached about 10 000 000 times and backed up forever by sites such as the web archive (a diaspora conversation is already backed up there, you can expect many more as our traffic increases). This means that if something is posted and we want to get rid of it, sometimes we just can’t, it will be online forever and there is nothing you can do about it.

Plus, personally, I might want to share things with the 85 of you guys that I don’t want to share to the world. Damn, among the 6,973,738,433 people on the planet right now, I tell you there are quite a few I don’t trust whatsoever! And for the time being, they can stalk me and potentially cause me trouble. It’s like being on CCTV all the time but you don't even know who is filming, and what they will do with the tape.

So guys, it might be too late for this discussion, but can we please turn the CCTV off right now, go on stage when we feel ready and to talk only about things we want to say to the world.

Nicolas Wormser

I just want to add I think it would be a good idea to create a public group to handle feedback, and probably other things, but I am convinced this needs to be done only for very specific needs.

Also, I think that if the strategy is to stay relatively discreet until we want to go viral, the present situation is exposing us too much. Plus, if we want to be exposed, I think we should reopen the blog first, and do that only when we want to attract people’s attention.

That we close all of our groups now, and build the feature “relation between groups” to reopen them to specific groups

proposal by Nicolas Wormser Closed Sat 23 Feb 2013 11:49PM

The Loomio Community group and all of its subgroups become private to avoid business vulnerability issues and privacy concern.
Please refer to the discussion context for more background information.

Results

Richard D. Bartlett
Disagree

I think this is the wrong solution to a legitimate problem

vivien maidaborn
Block

The problem is right, the solution is not clear. Lets improve the proposal first

Alanna Irving
Disagree

I think transparency is very important. However, it might be worth simply making a visual indication (like a banner) that you're posting in a public group, so people are aware.

Benjamin Knight
Disagree

I feel like it's a bit early to jump to a solution - let's put heads together to delve into specifying the problem first :)

Nicolas Wormser
Disagree

I think this is what would be the safest direction to go, but I agree that it is important to give us time to come up with a solution that better match our transparency policy.

We set up a Loomio Contributors subgroup for people directly working on Loomio

proposal by Benjamin Knight Closed Sat 2 Mar 2013 4:54AM

Background: It'd be helpful to have a group framework that encourages us to make discussions/decisions in the appropriate forum*

Let's talk about a proposed first step toward a solution :)

Proposal: That we set up a Loomio Contributors subgroup for people working directly on the project to make operational decisions. This may or may not involve a privately viewable subgroup for discussions that involve sensitive/personal information.

*By 'appropriate forum', I mean a group that involves all the people most affected by the decision, but avoids inflicting our day-to-day operational decision-making on people who aren't interested/involved, and avoids publishing sensitive/personal information in a public forum.

Results

Benjamin Knight
Agree

Feel like this is something we've needed for quite a while :)

Nicolas Wormser
Agree

I think this is a good first step, though we have to keep in mind the aforementioned privacy challenges for public discussions.

Aaron Thornton
Agree

I like that we are not flooding the public community group, and the stuff that we put their gets filtered indirectly by our own processes.

Alejandro Ribó
Agree

Opening the community group allows a good exchange of information between those that are early adopters of the tool. At least at this moment, I think it is also essential for the creation of a community around loomio.

Billy
Agree

sounds sane

Richard D. Bartlett

Making the community group public was an intentional decision that I personally have no problem with, I guess because I was involved in the decision and aware of it's implications.

I think you've identified a legitimate problem, which is that people could be posting in this group without being fully aware of the implications of that little padlock icon at the top of the screen.

I think it would be more productive to think about how we can communicate those implications more clearly, rather than freaking out about 'Big Brother' and locking the groups down.

vivien maidaborn

I love the instinct @nicolaswormser , but think the proposal is two different things in one proposal. Yes we need to share only what we want to share.
Lets discuss how we get from here to there and raise a proposal at that point.

Nicolas Wormser

If that helps, the "relation between groups" feature, not specified at the moment afaik, and also referred as "Connecting groups together" would allow groups to access each others discussions. If people don't agree the feature would do this, they can block the proposal for being not specific enough.

Nicolas Wormser

@alannakrause and @richarddbartlett I also agree that transparency is very important and I would love to be able to practise it without taking enormous risk. We've had the need of removing discussions in the past. Now, do you realise that similar situations, and situations that might be way more compromising may arise in the future, and that we will have no possibility to control them (because the data will be on servers that do not belong to us).

There are so many areas where we can be transparent. Putting all our business documents online is OK and awesome, giving all the numbers and being transparent on everything happening to the business is good I think, as long as we chose the words we use to do it, and we can't do that on Loomio because we're speaking to each-other, not to the world.

Richard D. Bartlett

I don't understand what specific content you think constitutes a risk @nicolaswormser?

As a related aside: one thing I've been thinking about is setting up a new subgroup in the Loomio Community for operational decisions. I wonder if that would help a bit too.

Jon Lemmon

I'm not too worried about anything we've posted thus far (nothing damning that I've seen). I think the opportunity cost of NOT being transparent outweighs the risk.

Obviously we're going to have sensitive discussions at some point, but let's take them as they come. The current proposal seems too pre-emptive to me.

Nicolas Wormser

OK, you need examples, I understand and this is normal. Sharing how I feel about this is very hard, because we haven’t had any bad experience with leaving the groups open up until now… But for some reason I feel we are damaging the very concept of the conversation. A conversation is a space of freedom where people informally turn their thoughts into words to share how they feel about something. It is directed to a specific audience, and very often we choose different words depending on who our audience is (sometimes without even noticing).

I’ve tried to make something up that could be used as examples, but these situations haven’t happened, so they don’t sound real, and I’m not sure this will help make my point whatsoever. But here are 3 examples:

  • Story 1: We’ve got a meeting scheduled with mister the justice minister of Danmark Morten Bødskov in person, with the potential output of making Loomio an offical instrument used in support for all consensus conferences happening countrywide. We’re having a discussion on Loomio to prepare that meeting − to evaluate the features that would be the most interesting for this situation, choosing the arguments that could be of interest etc…
    When we turn up at the meeting, we’re told that Mister Bødskov cancelled the meeting because its secretary reported him that some elements in the public conversation we were having were judged ”insulting to Mister Bødskov” and ”highly misrepresenting all the efforts that had been put by the government in terms of democratic decision-making”.
    After a little bit of investigation, we find that this is due to one of us writing “Haha, I guess M. Bødskov doesn’t even know what the word consensus means ” in one of the comments.

  • How I feel about this story: Derisions of our politics (and people holding power in general) are often made as some sort of joke in informal conversations. I think it is important because in some situations it can help people feeling more confident about what they’re doing. Now, if walls have ears and that it is prejudicial to us, then our Loomio Group is neither a safe nor a cool place to have such conversations.

  • Story 2: Marie is interested to do be our full time graphic designer. There’s a discussion on Loomio where we are discussing if she might be a good fit for the project. Everyone is very keen on her. But Bob, who’s joined the Loomio crew two weeks ago says he had a very bad business experience with her. While he doesn’t have any evidence it was her fault, he expresses how he is feeling about her on the Loomio discussion, with quite harsh formulations. Marie stumbles across this conversation by browsing the public Loomio group and announce to the group she would feel too uncomfortable working with people who doubt her honesty. It turned out the problem with Bob was due to a series of misunderstandings.

  • How I feel about this story: I think it was important that Bob expressed his feelings about Marie and I also think it is normal Marie got offended by what she read. This wouldn’t have happened if this discussion had been private.

  • Story 3 Lani is looking for a job, when she comes to an interview, the employer talk to her about something embarrassing she said on loomio 5 years ago. He found that info using Yasni…

Humm… I feel I’m not going to make my point through examples… But I’ll be back :P.

Richard D. Bartlett

I think your examples do point to some genuine issues:

  1. People censor themselves when they are in a public space; which a) undermines the community-building effects of discourse and b) forces some conversations off Loomio and into other media that are not transparent or accessible.
  2. Our commitment to transparency shouldn't force other parties to be transparent against their will.

I think (1) will be solved when we have fine-grained control of discussions' privacy (e.g. 'mark this discussion as private'). I think (2) will be solved by a policy/shared understanding to guide us when we are talking about clients.

Nicolas Wormser

@richarddbartlett

More than the two issues you identify (I agree with (1), I don’t worry too much about (2)), I also identify the following. I agree that some of them will be addressed by additional features in the future such as making a discussion private, archiving discussions, creating a clear privacy policy etc… But they are still worth mentioning:

  1. People not choosing carefully their words while writing in a public comment in a discussion can have disastrous consequences (exemple of story 1)
  2. People writing something publicly without knowing who is going to read it can have unexpected consequences (exemple of story 2 and story 3)
  3. People sharing confidential info in a public discussion (phone number, time and place of a private meeting, amount of money someone earns etc…) is a privacy infringement that the business owners are legally responsible for, unless the person who writes it has signed some sort of “terms of service” contract
  4. Same as (3) with copyright infringement
  5. People writing something in the precise context of what a conversation is at a specific point in time, might become outdated or irrelevant later. Allowing people to access that information later can lead to unexpected situations (this is partly (see point 6) resolved by the archive discussions feature)
  6. Marking a discussion private, archiving it, or deleting it at some point in time does not guarantee it is not accessible via search engines, web crawlers and web archives

I think there are more to add to this list, but that’s a start.

Nicolas Wormser

I want Loomio to be a place where we can have conversations, that take all the dimensions they normally do in real life. This means that I want to be able to write a joke in the middle of a of a serious discussion, I want to be able to use humour, derision, sarcasm as tools that help making my point and express how I feel about a specific subject. I am aware that in some circumstances using these can offend people and and be misinterpreted, but in normal life, this usually does not happen because I know who my audience is.
People from very different backgrounds or with opposed views on a specific topic often need to make the effort of finding a common language before they can speak together.
The more we say things that are available to everyone, the less it will resonate individually for each of our readers and the more it will be prone to frustration and misinterpretation.

I also agree transparency is a very essential part of what Loomio is. But, I think what is important for the people watching us is the decisions we make, not the conversations we’re having. That’s why the solution to most of the problems discussed here would be very simple : make all discussions private, but keep the proposals accessible to everyone. This way people know everything we are doing, and we don’t have all the problems related to making comments public. If need be we could also give access to the updated context to give some background info, but I’m not even sure this would be required.

Wow, this now comes to me like the obvious solution I’ve been looking for. What do people think about it?

Benjamin Knight

Good job kicking off an energetic conversation @nicolaswormser!

It feels like there's broad agreement that we don't currently have things quite right in terms of the match between our intended audience (people with a stake in Loomio) and our actual audience (everyone in the universe). It also feels like there's broad agreement that active transparency is extremely important, and that we want to be as open as possible with our community of stakeholders.

The main tension seems to be coming in response to the proposed solution, which is to jump everything away from publicly viewable straight away until we've built features that address the problem.

Personally I think one downside to that approach would be the pressure it would put on us to develop something in reaction to a problem that we're having ourselves, without testing whether other groups also need a solution to this.

I think Nicolas' second suggestion (building an option to keep the discussion privately viewable but leave the decision panel public-facing) is getting closer, but I'd still want more brainstorming before going down that track.

Something we've talked about for a while is starting a Loomio Contributors subgroup specifically for people directly working on Loomio. This could be viewable to members only, and would be the obvious place to have discussions that involved confidential customer information or anything else sensitive. This is something we could implement immediately, in conjunction with developing some principles to guide decisions about which discussions are appropriate to have in which forum.

Would this resolve some of the tension for you @nicolaswormser?

Richard D. Bartlett

I really like @nicolaswormser's 6 points on the risks of transparency. There are probably additional points we could add to that list. It could also be useful to accompany this with an exploration of the strengths. Then once we have a comprehensive map of the problem we can start designing solutions.

For instance, while there is merit to the idea of private discussions with public decisions, in my opinion it would have some significant drawbacks. If all I see is the outcome of a decision, and I disagree with it, it's easy to assume the decision makers are stupid and wrong (c.f. parliamentary politics). On the other hand, if I can see the deliberation that went into the bad decision, I'm much more likely to empathise with the decision makers, and be able to identify the flawed logic or lack of information that led to it.

Nicolas Wormser

@benjaminknight

My first proposal was intentionally a bit extreme and it was intended to be more like a "temperature check" than an actual proposal.

I was just taking the opportunity to put under the spotlight issues that I didn't realize earlier we were facing, and that I think − for most of them − are critical. I think they are all inherent to the very concept of conversing online and not specific to Loomio, but we will have to take them into consideration if we don't want to face unexpected harmful situations.

I'm happy to take the time it takes to work towards effective solutions to address these issues. I don't think creating a black box for contributors is a solution though.

Oh and, no tension on my side ;)

Nicolas Wormser

Fair point @richarddbartlett. That is definitely something we should take into consideration while designing the appropriate solution.

Jon Lemmon

I think it's important to start thinking about these things, but let's also be careful not design for a problem that we don't have yet. Otherwise we'll cause more harm than good. We don't want to miss out on all the great opportunities that occur from having open discussions. Let's welcome these opportunities, and when a problem arises due to our transparency, let's deal with it then and figure out the minimum amount of policy we need to put in place to keep it from happening again.

And in the meantime, let's just be sensible about what we post in public forums.

  1. If you think something could be interpreted the wrong way, do your best to rephrase it.
  2. If you want to say something cheeky, don't say it in a public discussion.
  3. If you need to have an online discussion that contains sensitive information, do it in a private group.

One thing to keep in mind is that online discussion is never going to be the same as face-to-face discussion. Online discussions stay intact in the digital world for a long time, whereas real-life discussions just disappear into thin air. So we're always going to have to watch what we say online, even if the discussion is private.

I think the most simple solution right now is to have a private "contributors" group for discussions requiring greater sensitivity. But even then, I think we should err toward public discussions wherever possible.

Benjamin Knight

I think this could be a nice way of making the Loomio Community group a place for accessible discussions/decisions that are actually relevant to the whole community (without flooding people with stuff they don't feel like reading/participating in).

The idea is very much to keep this in line with our principles around active transparency (i.e., make things public unless there's good reason for it not to be) and the notion that for things to be truly transparent, they need to be presented in a format that's accessible to people of all levels of involvement. I feel like we're not currently focusing on this here, with lots of the discussion happening at a pretty technical level that requires lots of background knowledge to understand/participate in.

Will be great to start actively community-building in here when we get this right!

vivien maidaborn

one of the elements that comes to mind for me in what @nicolaswormser is saying is the difference between designing Loomio including private and public for a known group or designing for a principles. We have a strong principle around transparency but we havn't really explored fully how to in-act it, yaa @alannakrause meeting next week. I like the idea of always having in mind designing for a known group of users. I really like the sense of honesty and spaciousness that opens when talking with a known group rather than the protection that necessarily happens in an unknown group

Richard D. Bartlett

I totally agree with you @vivienmaidaborn on: "I really like the sense of honesty and spaciousness that opens when talking with a known group rather than the protection that necessarily happens in an unknown group".

As a counterpoint I would like to offer that I really like that talking in an unknown group encourages me to communicate in a way that doesn't alienate anyone.

I really am feeling the need for a multi-dimensional options/incentives matrix here...

As a person who is predisposed to speaking without thinking, an open group encourages me to be more considerate in my communication.

As a person who is predisposed to be more reserved in speaking, an open group discourages my participation.

We need to balance the incentives for different personality types :)

Mitar

Why not just configure robots.txt (or similar technologies) from indexing those sensitive groups but allow humans to read them? Furthermore, I understand the need for being able to express sarcastic remarks and jokes because you believe that you know the audience in private conversations, but do you really? At least when an open source community grows so that you cannot personally know everybody, but still you "know" somebody because of his or her contributions. How to know if some joke somebody would not take as an offensive? Maybe somebody is already taking them, but just keeps quiet? But they can still hurt? I am not sure if it is really impossible to convey ideas to others without having to use sarcasm or wit. Yes, maybe things are more "juicy", but feelings about a topic can be expressed also directly. Sometimes it is better so that people do not have to read between the lines and maybe even misunderstand. Yes, it requires from all participants in the discussions to adapt to each other in some way. But this is what happens in any diverse and culturally mixed global communities. So "political correctness" have its value, it makes you not hurt somebody by mistake. And maybe open group would help everybody have in mind that you should convey information in "safe" way. Safe meaning with lower chances of hurting somebody. It could even be seen as a feature. Written above "the group is public, behave". What we have in our projects is that people can mark tickets with "security" or "privacy" flags and then they become private. But otherwise everything is public. So only really sensitive information should be private. Like phone numbers and other personal information. But words people create, where people have choice to decide which words to write down or not, why not having them public? And for Story 1 and Story 2 example: do you really want to work with people who based on one wrongly put word do not want to work with you anymore? And not even want to discuss the misunderstanding and be capable of going over it and continue life? Then you will have to be really precise with sarcasm if they are so sensitive once they join.