Loomio

Reading Club: First Reading

Alex Rodriguez PublicSeen by 7

Ronen has offered up an idea to read a book together. I'm making this thread in an attempt to create a container for us to establish the parameters for forming a "reading club" in which we read a text together and gather to discuss it in some form. For starters, please leave a comment in the thread below if:

1) If you would like to propose a book for us to read together. Ronen has already put forward Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance by Robert Persig

2) If you have any general thoughts, requests, or needs related to how we form the reading club that will allow for the space to be accessible to you and supportive in engaging with whatever text we choose

Related to the second item above, I have a few questions that may prompt a response: How much time do you anticipate being able to dedicate to reading? To reflection and discussion? Do you like to read in large time increments or small ones? What rhythm of discussion with the rest of the crew seems like it would be supportive for you?

Jennifer Damashek

Thank you for creating this container. I could spend a few hours a week reading a book and reflecting on it. I like putting aside a few hours a week to reading a book and I also like listening to audio books while I drive and work around the house. Compared to Robert I am a very slow reader but I absorb more quickly when I listen to audiobooks. I could meet once a month to discuss a book.

Ronen Hirsch

I remember that in Synagogue there are segments where everyone reads (the same text) to themselves. That is what is happening when you see the men swaying back and forth and the space is filled with a mumbling sound. But there is a technique used to move everyone along together. The person leading the prayer (I'm not sure it's a Rabbi, I think there is another role there) will once in a while chant out loud a sentence and that signals to everyone where the group is and that is how the reading converges. If you are slower and have not yet reached the chanted phrase you know you need to scan forward a bit quicker.

For me, reading is a dynamic process with changing rhythms. Especially if it is a text that I engage with deeply. Sometimes the space in my life changes. Sometimes the text requires more or less space. And so, my thinking was to not place a schedule on this. I imagined the collective reading coordinated dynamically via a discord channel:

  1. The "Rabbi" facilitator of the reading will indicate starting a segment in the reading journey by pointing to a scope-of-content (eg: page range, chapters, etc.) and a time-range (eg: one week, two weeks, one month, etc.).

  2. The "Rabbi" facilitator can give a sign half-way into the reading ... as a kind of pulse for the group.

  3. The "Rabbi" facilitator gives a sign when the segment is over.

  4. Participants can reply to these orientation signals with signals about their progress. This can be a thumbs-up or a comment. It can be a request for more time.

  5. In response to the signals from participants the "Rabbi" facilitator can ... facilitate ... move on to the next segment, extend the current segment, adjust the scope and time of the next segment to better match the rhythm of the group, etc.

Expanded conversation/reflections take place on a dedicated Loomio thread. So far this is all asynchronous!

Synchronous gatherings are on demand. Whenever someone in the group feels a desire to speak, to converse or to hear others, they can propose a gathering (with an upcoming sandbox time as the default preference).

In addition I imagined another async experiment. It originally arose as an experiment in losing individual identity and experiencing collective identity. It is a shared (Etherpad) online document where participatory writing takes place. Anyone can do anything, add, modify, delete ... write coherent parapgrahs, sporadic thoughts, poetry ... whatever WITHOUT any personal identification. In a crew like ours we will probably be able to identify some of the contents just based on writing styles. But the point is to drop ownership of words/paragraphs ... to tend collectively to the wholeness of this document ... whatever it is.

Josh Fairhead

The general format works for me but I don't wish to adopt the synagogue metaphor. Given the books nature maybe we immerse ourselves in that context instead? Easy riders with pit stops setting the pace instead? I can imagine that our riding experience could be informed, tailored and adapted from the narrative as we go?

Responding to:

It originally arose as an experiment in losing individual identity and experiencing collective identity.

I'm wary of the terminology (I don't wish to identify as an individual or group), but the idea of playing with stigmergic writing and dropping ownership is fine with me (Chatham house rule?). Anyway, once (re)setup we can pretty easily use Obsidian for the purposes outlined.

Robert Damashek

I tend to read in bursts and will dedicate some time each week to read, so I think the monthly review tempo @Jennifer Damashek proposed fits well. Though what @Ronen Hirsch proposed is interesting to know about, I think I agree with @Josh Fairhead that I don’t feel it would be helpful to me and instead might inhibit me reading ahead if I get into the book and just want to absorb more and enjoy it at my pace. But I don’t want to inhibit the collective process or its unfolding either, since I think I’m finding it harder than it should be to shift into this social dynamic.

Josh Fairhead

I think I agree with @Josh Fairhead that I don’t feel it would be helpful to me and instead might inhibit me reading ahead if I get into the book and just want to absorb more and enjoy it at my pace

To be clear this is not what I meant Robert. I just don't like the religious metaphor. I don't mind trying the pace setting thing though, but I don't know if I'll adhere to it either (no imperatives in this space anyway right?).

However, if we go with Zen as a book I really think embracing its narrative could be a good way of designing a collective experience/adventure. I'm typically very resistant to narratives (such as books of faith) and for the largest part don't trust them at all. Zen is something very different for me, I've had experience with it and trust the words and author.

For once I'm actually open to playing narrative make-believe using this specific book as a framework that may allow the emergence of a more engrossing adventure/experience. Something like a LARP (Live Action Role Playing) if you catch my drift?

Toni Blanco

Is "I am very resistant to narratives" not a narrative? ;-)

Josh Fairhead

#turtles; it's a meta-narrative. Narratives being pretty inescapable.

Let me rephrase @Toni Blanco: "I am often resistant to narratives of a transcendental modality, especially deceptive ones".

Toni Blanco

Just for the record, I am often attracted by narratives of a trascendental modality (as long as they are symbolic and not literal) 😂

Ronen Hirsch

"In our traditional systems of Law we remember, however, that everyone is an idiot from time to time. Punishment is harsh and swift, but afterwards there is no criminal record, no grudge against the transgressor. Perpetrators are only criminals until they are punished, and then they may be respected again and begin afresh to make a positive contribution to the group. In this way, people will not lie and shift blame or avoid punishment by twisting rules to escape accountability. They can look forward to a clean slate and therefore be willing and equal participants in their own punishment and transformation. which is a learning process more than anything else."

Tyson Yunkaporta - Sand Talk

I am offering this book as another candidate for the reading club ... I am just getting started with it and it is, at least in my mind, overflowing with relevant and poignant conversations!

It also feels like an answer to my wish for indigenous guidance, possibly a candidate for sharing the GP with that intention?

Toni Blanco

I feel that I resonate much more with this proposal!

Ronen Hirsch

" ... Schrodinger's Cat ... In this famous thought experiment, you imagine poisoning a cat and putting it in a box. You don't know if it has died yet because you can't see it, so in that moment the cat is simultaneously both alive and dead. The act of observing the cat breathing would make it alive, and the act of seeing its sightless eyes frozen in a death mask of agony and panic would make it dead. Jesus.

From an Aboriginal cosmological point of view, the uncertainty principle is resolved when you admit you are part of the field and accept your subjectivity. If you want to know what's in the box so bad, drink the poison yourself and climb in ... I begin to see the uncertainty principle not as a law but as an expression of frustration about the impossibility of achieving godlike scientific objectivity."

Tyson Yunkaporta - Sand Talk

Ronen Hirsch

we could talk about this ... if we had a reading club ;)

Ronen Hirsch

""It is difficult to relinquish the illusions of power and delusions of exceptionalism that come with privilege. But it is strangely liberating to realise your true status as a single node in a cooperative network .... You won't be swallowed up by a hive mind or lose your individuality - you will retain your autonomy while simultaneously being profoundly interdependent and connected."

Tyson Yunkaporta - Sand Talk

Ronen Hirsch

"Sustainability agents have a few simple operating guidelines, or network protocols, or rules if you like - connect, diversify, interact, adapt.

Diversity is not about tolerating differences or treating others equally and without prejudice. The diversification principle compels you to maintain your individual difference, particularly from other agents who are similar to you. This prevents you from clustering into narcissistic flash mobs. You must also seek out and interact with a wide variety of agents who are completely dissimilar to you. Finally, you must interact with other systems beyond your own, keeping your system open and therefore sustainable.

Connectedness balances the excesses of individualism in the diversity principle. The first step in connectedness is forming pairs like kinship pairs) with multiple other agents who also pair with others. The next step is creating and expanding networks of these connections. The final step is making sure these networks are interacting with the networks of other agents, both within your systems and in others.

Interaction is the principle that provides the energy and spirit of communication to power the system. This principle facilitates the flow of living knowledge ... transferring knowledge (and energy and resources) ... with as many other agents as possible ...

Adaptation is the most important protocol of an agent in a sustainable system. You must allow yourself to be transformed through your interactions with other agents and the knowledge that passes through you from them. This knowledge and energy will flow through the entire system in feedback loops and you must be prepared to change so that those feedback loops are not blocked ...

... In Aboriginal languages there are many more [pronouns], including pronouns that are translate as: I, I-myself, we two, we but not others, we altogether. Repeating the plural ones twice can mean "It's up to us", but repeating "I" twice can mean "I go my own way!" There is a balance between self-definition and group identity. These two are not contradictory but entwined, and there are names for all of the roles you occupy as an agent of complexity in Aboriginal society. You perform these roles alone, in pairs in exclusive groups and in networked groups ...

In Aboriginal English there is a very useful term to help us draw lines in the sand between these roles, asserting both boundaries and connections. The word is "lookout" ... which is not a warning but refers to a person's appropriate sphere of influence and accountability. If a person is being push and expecting you to get involved with their frantic business in an effort to control you, you might say, "That's not my lookout" ....

You have to keep moving ... if you are following the four protocols ... little systems of vibrant complexity will spring up around you ... These will attract other agents, but they will also attract narcissists in droves. You need to insulate yourself against these entropic elements, but also have a responsibility to help them."

Tyson Yunkaporta - Sand Talk