Loomio

What does it really mean to be a social enterprise? A values-driven company? Can Loomio by its design have a positive social impact?

Alanna Irving PublicSeen by 48

I was reading this aspirational blog post from Asana about how their project and task management software is going to make the world a better place.

> Every time we talk to a new customer, we learn a new way that we’re enabling a team to succeed. By helping people work together more easily, we make it more effortless for groups to coordinate their collective action, so that they can achieve their goals and manifest the missions that drive them. In the next few years, we’ll reach millions of people working in groups to improve the world we all share. Through them, we’ll improve the lives of every person on the planet.

Now, Asana is a fine product and that's great. It came from some former Facebook employees and is steeped in the typical Silicon Valley startup culture. Plenty of products that come out help people who are doing really positive work do that better. But that doesn't mean they are a Social Enterprise. They are a traditional business.

Loomio is trying to do something differently, baking positive social change into its business DNA. We are trying to build a product that not only helps people do whatever they do a bit better (although we hope that for sure!) but also inherently and by design helps groups make decisions more democratically and inclusively. We have a core belief that by doing so, we will have a real positive impact on society.

Sure, a group with bad intent could use Loomio to be more effective at their badness. But in general, truly including more diverse viewpoints and letting all voices be heard helps people not make decisions that will hurt others. Loomio also makes the decision making process very transparent, and as they say, sunlight is the best disinfectant.

Loomio has tried to live its values very practically, and we're still striving every day to live them more and more. Things like incorporating as a workers cooperative, putting our commitments to support social good projects as a social enterprise right in our company constitution, and working to make our processes as open, inclusive, and transparent as possible speak to this. Of course, we are a long way from perfection and we'll just keep striving.

I wonder what Loomio could do to express its values even more, and design the software to be even more effective at nudging all kinds of groups toward the kind of participatory decision making that can be transformative.

Mike Hargreaves

I have been doing a lot of research on infographics and business intelligence, or more the point merging the two to engage lay people in the essential parts of their organisations. Think Google Analytics but for real life activity.

Currently there is a reasonably solid graphic view around a particular decision with the pie graph. I wonder if by building up the metrics of the community into a graphic report, accessible by all members, you could start to show more of a path to the most beneficial way of developing dialogues and participation.

So lets say you had a tab on the groups home page where you reveal key graphics around group members, amount of discussions, posts, % of posts by members, % of members who have posted, decisions made, decision to discussion ratios, members posting to members voting to % in agreement etc

By making particular graphics more prominent you are suggesting the items you feel are the most important in encouraging the participation.

This would allow group coordinators and participants to see the areas that they could work on while not actually dictating a particular style of group engagement.

Over time you could build different baselines to compare to, which could be used to celebrate (Your group is in the top 10% of voting rates) or cajole (Your group has a low rate of contributors to members). These could also be broken up along the lines of the group type or groups could set their own benchmarks based on examples that Loomio could provide.

As an aside it would give the designers something to go nuts on and great stuff to share in a PR sense.

Alanna Irving

Awesome ideas @mikehargreaves ! I have had similar ideas for visualizing Loomio participation. @simontegg has thought about this stuff a lot too. I would absolutely love to see that become a reality. I think it's really interesting and important that you're linking good metrics back to social impact.

Rachel B. Wickert

As much as I believe in the potential of a tool such as Loomio, I think it is also healthy to recognize its inherent limitations. I am not a "luddite" but some of your techie discussions about "good" metrics make me wonder what space is left for emergence, fun, and humanity in your design. Maybe by expecting/asking too much of a software, you are missing out on the other less tangible dimensions going on? The things that can't be easily captured with the kind of metrics you are suggesting.

max noble

People attention naturally gravitates towards things that stand out in their environment...so emphasize the good and it will prevail.

Mike Hargreaves

@rachelbwickert I think the conversation is directly around how to make the software work better at helping its users to make better decisions. One way would be to engage users in the data behind this process. Which could get pretty heavy as you state in your comment. The purpose of using infographics http://goo.gl/uW2Y3Y would be to try and overcome this issue by making the data easily understood.

There is probably a very interesting wider debate to be had around whether exposing metrics could affect the more intangible qualities of the system. The issue being you would probably have to collect data to make a good call on that!

Rollout the A/B testing and customer sat surveys... Although you could argue these in itself could have a negative effect... Its like the UX equivalent of Schrodinger's cat. Intriguing!

Rachel B. Wickert

@mikehargreaves I like your cat metaphor! It makes me think of the Zen's Koan, the existentialist angst or Bateson's double bind. I know I'm pushing it. I can see the useful purpose of metrics in this case. Am a fan of infofraphics. I am just very conscious of their potential, however sophisticated, to hide the authenticity of human encounters. Before I wrote my comment, I was reflecting on measurements of vulnerability: http://rdwbizz.blogspot.co.uk/2013/09/the-many-meanings-of-vulnerability.html

To me it boils down to creating a space in and out the software that acknowledges the "other" side of the reality. I think the Loomio team is doing a fantastic job to keep away from binaries. They are putting a lot of energy in looking out for and sharing the human stories behind and beyond the software. Metrics are useful, stories are essential. They make the glue stick. Just thinking of Aaron Swartz and Lessig…

max noble

The Values listed are awesome. I don't know how to improve on that.

Maybe like @rachelbwickert was saying add a metaphor or a story to each value to help communicate the value in a different way.