How to prevent corruption?
This is the bane of all systems.
How do we detect it?
How do we manage it?
How do we reduce it?
Oh dear, this is a topic I am passionate about so here we go.
Corruption is one of those things that is hard to prevent, mainly because it is not an issue in and of itself, it is a symptom (albeit an extremely damaging one) of a system that is broken.
Individuals will always work towards the easiest way to do things, and the ease of doing something does not correlate with weather or not that thing is right.
Reducing corruption is about creating a system where by the easiest thing is also the right thing. For example New Zealand has one of the lowest rates of corruption in the world in terms of businesses and paying tax, this is a consequence of a very simple tax system.
It's easy. As there is more corruption by how much the power is concentrated, by diluting power the curruption is also reduced. So, it's easier to corrupt one than one dozen.
Well done on raising this as a concept Max. I believe corruption arises when the desire for individual acquisition overrides the desire for common good. Democracy is only as robust as its governance and the risk of consequences, so this is where I would focus my energies - in keeping governance transparent and accountable. In my experience toothless governance and rarely employed consequences is what allows corruption to take hold. This has been proven often. An example is leaked documents which raise awareness of an issue and may cause outrage at a personal level, but result in zero impact on the continuation of the behaviour uncovered.
Great question @maxnoble.
I agree with @ricardoaraujo - you can minimise the opportunity for corruption by devolving power as far as possible, by using decentralised structures, and rotating people through roles of significant influence.
In conversation with Jake Dunagan from Governance Futures Lab this morning, he put the question to us: 'how does Loomio handle bad actors?'
I haven't got a great answer yet, but I think one reason the platform is somewhat immune to bad actors (and corruption), is the nature of the governance model emerging here. I'd describe that model as being based on social relationships as opposed to say, a legislative body with a monopoly on violence (aka 'the State').
Having a monopoly on violence is a tremendous concentration of power that seems naturally to generate corruption, oppression, and alienation.
Taking violence off the table suddenly gives you a much greater incentive to work together: if you can't coerce someone into behaving a certain way, you're left with no other option but to appeal to empathy and reason.
I guess I'm saying an empathetic association seems to me to be less corruptible than a legalistic one.
I agree when @megrose says that keeping governance transparent and accountable is a key step in fighting corruption. As soon as everything is made available for consultation and there are no unecessary "secrets" (we have to take into account international politics and market regulation for example), there can be no "behind the doors" deals. Without these, I think corruption will just go down quickly.
Also, I think @joehopkirk is right to say that meaningful, fair, clear and simple laws will help a lot preventing curruption, because people will feel that "playing by the rules" is the best and fairest way for everyone. This will not exclude the existence of selfish people, which are more common in some societies than other I suppose :(
I’m not sure is just decentralizing is enough however, as suggested by @ricardoaraujo. If you decentralise a system that is based on patron-client relationships (bad democracies like those traditionally found in “Catholic” mediterranean /latin countries :p what Guillermo O’Donell called a delegative democracy), that would simply deepen the hierarchy, but the need for corruption, favours and deals would still be there. In my opinion, decentralization in this case would only spread corruption with it.
In terms of the violence monopoly, as @richarddbartlett suggested, that is “THE” power. I do wonder if decentralizing “violence” would make the state less corrupt… but I think it would lead to privatization of violence and that could easily lead to a “mafia-style” system. Basically, would it actually be possible to get violence off the table, without someone bringing it back in?
What would you all think?
Simplifying laws is one step, although people will be on a scale of selfish to selfless they will all behave in a way that makes them the hero of their own story.
Changing laws is the first step in creating an ecosystem that encourages a lack of corruption.
I agree, but I'd add that enforcing those laws is also important (I thought a bit more about it meanwhile)
To prevent corruption, it is fundamental to have not only a simple, understandable legislature, but also a working and trustworthy Rule of Law. This makes not only following the law the easiest (as suggested by @joehopkirk) but also the less risky option, as you know breaking the law ill have consequences (in many countries, it doesn't :(
A question that follows would be: what can we, as civil society, do to promote the rule of law?
(I guess wikipedia could be useful for further information http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rule_of_law and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_society)
@carlosneves , i didn't said that the solution to corruption was to extend heirarqy but have the power diluted by more persons. If someone needs to make a business with some government organization for example and the decision relies in on person only, it is far easier to corrupt that person than if there was the need to corrupt three for example. It would be more risky because one of them may not be receptive to the atempt of curruption and talk. It also is less profitable because it is needed to split the money for more persons, so it is less desirable to do. Ofcourse that doing that dilution of power maybe hard to do because it is needed to be done by someone, and none of the politicians have interest in such a thing because they are the ones that take the most advantage of this state of things. So to change that we would need a political force(party) thas has a different organic model of operation that would implement that. Something that has the transparecy said by @megrose. But not only. In my opinion it must rely in a web platform that makes possible for people show their willings, what they want to be done, and so the party acts to acomplish them. And have everything acounted. For example, if i voted in someone in enviorment area to acomplish certaine promisse, and that is not being done, i could capture my vote back in the party site. This way the people elected must show work and acomplish thing or the decrease in the votes that elected him may put him in a very unconfortable situation, and even take away his credibility to stay in the place he was eleted for. another thing to avoid corruption, in every governament or organization where there is an assembly, deputies votes should controlled by the ones that had put him there. So, even if the prime-minister or chairman tries to make some business that is good to him and to some deputies, even those that he corrupted to vote in favor may not be able to cast their vote at 100% because that vote bellongs to the people that elected him. So, even is a corrupted deputie votes in favor of something, the members of the party/organization that elected that deputie will receive in their email that their deputie has voted for them in a certain question, in favor. By this time, people should be able to change that vote that was done in their name if they dont like it. So a vote of a deputie that represents 10000 persons, may not have that value because people should be able to change the vote done by their representaive if they dont like. Ad if 25% change that vote it doesnt have the same power. And as said before, if that becomes regular(cange the deputie vote) people should be able to take back the delegation done to that deputie and give it to anohter that they like best at that time. I think this is what need to be done in every democracie in the world. To create a party that has a really trasnparent, open and acessible way of keep people tunned in and participating, giving by this way the power to the people. I think that this kind of party would solve many problems, especialy the corruption problem. All the money that goes to corruption could be employed in so many thing. Solidariety, research, projects that wold make peoples lifes far better.
I did not changed the discussion discription, just made EDIT and then _SAVE
So you believe that the only way to fight corruption is political, that is, that people on their own cannot promote a fairer society, without interfering with the party system from within? For me, your starting point (the example of democratic system you take in account to form your ideias) seems a very poor democratic system to start with, maybe even a delegative democracy :(
I generally agree with your idea, but there are a few debatable remarks, that I think depends a lot on the kind of democratic system you're talking about. However, if I understood it correctly, it would seems you'd prefer what is called a majoritarian first-past-the-post system, such as the UK system, and an on-line platform such as the DemoEx or the e-Governement initiative in Estonia (again, the UK appears to be the top e-government - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E-Government#UN_e-Government_Readiness_Index).
However, I believe, as it would seem did the Athenians, that corruption is deeply rooted in the human behaviour, so more than forming a transparent party, one should force all parties to become as transparent as possible, through civil action. I believe that this is why the rule of law is so important, as previously discussed.
Also, as it could be of interest to you, Larry Diamond is starting a new democratic course online, for free. I expect him to adress some of these issues during the course :)
https://www.coursera.org/#course/democraticdev
Thank you for the share on that Stanford course. So if you believe that corruption is rooted in human behaviour you must not expect that people wont be corrupt because you tell them so. There needs be be a surveillance. And i talk about a way do do that surveillance within political parties. That is all the corruption that matters, because are the political parties that make and aprove the laws, and are they that do the fraudelent business that make every taxpayers more poor.
About the e-gov, i'm talking more about a demoex thing.
that rule of law is simply obeying the law and there is all kind of laws against corruption, so i think they are enough. We should otherwise erase all the laws that promote corruption,like the law that prohibits to make an accusation without proofs, the law that prohibits calls recordings without a judge consent(that figure that is a modern king), and the law of banking accounts secrecy.
So resuming, the way to fight corruption is as far as i'm concerned, by a true democratic political partie that executes the decisions of all their members, and by doing so it will act on the government and government institutions to improve them on all their flaws(also those that alow corruption, and they will do it by dilliting power on those institutions). And because the actions of politicians must have an ok of all members, whatever the case, the is no way to corruption prevail.
Buenos Aries has been running an Open Government model for the past couple years and it is looking really exciting
http://www.codeforamerica.org/2012/06/21/open-government-in-buenos-aires/
What If a small group of people create a proposal which is in their favor but the rest of the organization will suffer?
Is there some way to randomly choose a person in the organization but outside of the group to act as a reviewer? Would it be helpful?
A core principle of Loomio is that people should have a say in a decision proportional to how much it affects them. So in your example @maxnoble ideally everyone affected would have a voice in the discussion. I know sometimes that's easier said than done!
@maxnoble choosing a random reviewer is the way it is done (or should be done) in science, to guarantee neutrality and objective thinking. So the good news is that it is possible to do (and scientist even do this for free!!!) ;) The problem is that "random" does not prevent conflict of interest...
On the other hand, a small group of people can create a proposal that is extremely selfish. However, if it has to be approved by the majority (or consensually), creating a proposal is not the same as approving the proposal. This should be the beautiful thing about democracy (that is not very well practiced in most countries, if in any!)
Let's say an ethnic minority proposes that a second minority is simply exiled (that could happen in fragmented countries such as those in Africa). Only if the majority accepts, can the second majority be exiled. Now, this would be a conflict between the first majorities or the second minority convincing the majority they are right (conflict by lobbying). As a side note, lobby is meant to be very healthy for democracy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lobbying. Of course this would not be feasible without a clear violation of the human right declaration, but I’m just illustrating the concept.
I believe that this is what @alannakrause means, but seen at the nation scale.
@carlosneves any thoughts about how to minimize conflicts of interest?
I think we can always find examples of extreme cases in every system. And those are very importnat makers. But I'm a strong believer in "I you want to know...give it a go" .test it. Then when it fails the test, and it will, we change it and try again. The quicker we can do this process of adaptive failure the closer we will get to a functioning and always dynamic system...
I would like to submit this "random person safety catch" beta testing, and when someone else in the programming side takes interest in this concept...we try it.
Any other ideas to test? Or improvements of my proposal idea?
@alannakrause good point "ideally everyone affected would have a voice in the discussion. I know sometimes that's easier said than done!"
How do we ensure that at do that? Thoughts?
@richarddbartlett I think this is a very important factor. Because we are going into the unknown with this project, we don't have any past attempts to help understand how powerful and thus effective this factor will be. And I suspect that we might be undervaluing it. Corruption is only relevant to our current system.
"nature of the governance model emerging here. I'd describe that model as being based on social relationships as opposed to say, a legislative body with a monopoly on violence (aka 'the State')."
@maxnoble yes this specific project is opening up new territory, but we don't need to overplay our novelty. As we try to construct new kinds of social relationships that allow people to coordinate without coercion, we have a rich history to draw on: marxists, free software advocates, feminists, p2p theorists, anarchists...
@maxnoble you’re definitively right that we have to try before we conclude it doesn’t work :)
Minimizing conflict of interest is virtually impossible, as it arises from intrinsic factors of each individual. However, if we focus on promoting horizontal relationships and cross-cutting cleavages across multiple “societal structures”, I believe it will be much easier to obtain better consensus and tolerances, resulting is less radical conflict of interests.
@alannakrause I would be interested to hear how Loomio are putting the following into practise: "A core principle of Loomio is that people should have a say in a decision proportional to how much it affects them". Who makes the decision as to how much it is affects someone? and how are the affected being involved in the decisions being made?
Good question @neilmorris ... I think it's definitely a work in progress. The first and foremost way we are trying to put that value into practice is by making Loomio itself. We're trying to create a tool that makes it easier for all kinds of groups to include the people affected in decisions. I think many times in society it's not that people disagree about who is affected by a decision (although sometimes they do of course). Most time people will concede that people are affected, but argue that including all of them in the discussion isn't feasible. Our representative democracy political system is the prime example of this. But most corporations and other institutions work the same way - people blatantly making decisions without consulting the people they affect. The easier we make that engagement, the less of a good excuse that becomes.
Has anyone from Loomio contacted Noam Chomsky?
He would love to see what we are doing and he could give us a tons in insights towards this project.
preventing curruption, in my opinion, requires a very active civil society (basically, so does democracy).
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_society
In terms of real ideas, there is a really good initiative in India that is spreading:
http://www.ipaidabribe.com/
and we could also start by demanding the local governments to used a partecipatory budget where the citizens can check were the money is going to be used:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Participatory_budgeting