Loomio

Change displayed information in #tags view

Steffen van BergeremSteffen van Bergerem Mon 13 Jan 2014 6:36PMPublicSeen by 84

There are several issues / feature requests on github affecting the #tags view. Let's discuss and vote which we want to implement/drop.

Steffen van Bergerem

Drop the number of followers from the tags page

proposal by Steffen van Bergerem Closed Mon 20 Jan 2014 6:01PM

Outcome
by Steffen van Bergerem Tue 25 Apr 2017 5:16AM

We will drop the number of followers from the tags page

Results

ResultsOptionVotes% of votes cast% of eligible voters
Agree13729Jonne HaßJason RobinsongoobDavid MorleytheradialactivePaul GreindlSeth MartinSteffen van BergeremSuperTux88jonsgerMarek MareckiXophaelAdrenalin
Abstain4223Jelle LangbroekNicoAltoMaciek ŁozińskiStarBlessed
Disagree161Karthikeyan A K
Block000 
Undecided13388Jon LemmonBenjamin KnightSean TilleyFlorian Staudachermaxwell salzbergTom ScottAlex AndrewsSleepyDaddySoftwareChris BlountHans FaseBilly O'ConnorDevendra MahraGiuseppe CALAMITAJeremy HuffmanFlaburganmovillaErwan Guyadergroovehunteradri xadorPawel Chojnacki

18 of 151 votes cast (11% participation)

Steffen van Bergerem

Steffen van Bergerem
Agree
Mon 13 Jan 2014 6:47PM

I don't think that it is important to know how many users are following a tag on your own pod. For some tags we even display the wrong number.

goob

goob
Agree
Mon 13 Jan 2014 7:09PM

I strongly agree - I think it's an irrelevant detail and would look better without this figure - especially where it's inaccurate!

Karthikeyan A K

Karthikeyan A K
Disagree
Tue 14 Jan 2014 2:42AM

Numbers are important

Jason Robinson

Jason Robinson
Agree
Tue 14 Jan 2014 12:29PM

Agree since it can never reflect the correct number since we dont' federate this information - if it we're global count it would be different imho.

StarBlessed

StarBlessed
Abstain
Sat 18 Jan 2014 8:30PM

Remove the number, yes. Remove WHO is following, no.

Paul Greindl

Paul Greindl
Agree
Sun 19 Jan 2014 1:11AM

As a feature we find it useful - to see which of the tags on a specific topic that is most used for example. But as Jason mentioned; without federating the numbers it's a bit useless. Interesting as a future-feature though ioho. /Ivan&Paul

Steffen van Bergerem

Steffen van BergeremSun 19 Jan 2014 10:19AM

@starblessed There is no feature to display who is following a tag. There is just a list of users who tagged themselves in their profile with a specific tag. Removing that list is not part of the proposal.

StarBlessed

StarBlessedSun 19 Jan 2014 11:08AM

@steffenvanbergerem - Thats what I meant. LOL!

If thats the case, Ill change my vote. Ill research a little more.

Steffen van Bergerem

Show (some) followers of a tag on the left side panel

proposal by Steffen van Bergerem Closed Mon 27 Jan 2014 11:09PM

Privacy issues will be covered by another vote/discussion. We can decide to make tag followings public/private via some settings so please just vote on the following question:

"Do we want to add (some) followers of a tag on the left side panel on the tags page?"

Results

ResultsOptionVotes% of votes cast% of eligible voters
Agree5263Sean TilleyJason RobinsonlebarjackKarthikeyan A KStarBlessed
Abstain4213Florian StaudachergoobIvan Gabriel MorénRich
Disagree10537Jonne HaßFlaburganPaul HillSeth MartinSteffen van BergeremSuperTux88FÁBIÁN Tamás LászlóNicoAltoXophaelmaliktunga
Block000 
Undecided13287Jon LemmonBenjamin Knightmaxwell salzbergTom ScottAlex AndrewsSleepyDaddySoftwareChris BlountHans FaseBilly O'ConnorDevendra MahraGiuseppe CALAMITAJeremy HuffmanmovillaErwan Guyadergroovehunteradri xadorPawel ChojnackiPirate PraveenBrent BartlettLennart Prelle

19 of 151 votes cast (12% participation)

Load More