Loomio

When I can not change my own comments?

Carlos Gallo Garavano PublicSeen by 168

My comments made in any group Loomio, I can modify them any time, but have found three comments where I can not make the modification of the text.

I would like to know what the reason.

https://www.loomio.org/d/rF5sRH9y/try-it-sandbox-demo-a-better-experience-for-first-time-users-wanting-to-see-how-loomio-works

https://www.loomio.org/d/pxTFgzKI/remove-discussion-loomio-helper-bot

https://www.loomio.org/d/5I7l6JAS/trick-to-locate-my-discussions

Alanna Irving

@carlosgallogaravan this is a setting in the permission of a group. I've attached a screenshot of how the Loomio Community is set up. In other groups, you might be able to edit your comments at any time. In this group, it's set to allow editing until there is further activity in the discussion. The reason for this is because once the conversation has moved on, your contribution belongs to the group, not your yourself anymore. Again, this is a choice group coordinators can set for themselves.

Alanna Irving

Here's the permission settings for this group.

Greg Cassel

Thank you @alanna for providing the the full info-- I commented in a hurry earlier, and inadvertently engaged in misinformation. I had forgotten that Loomio already offers that flexibility per group settings.

Since this is a group which does not allow editing comments at any time, and my mistake is genuinely misleading, I may delete it. I can't remember the last time I deleted a comment anywhere, but perhaps it's appropriate for an irrelevant mistake.

UPDATE: I did delete the comment. I'm documenting it here, because, well-- long story, but I'm kind of hardcore anti-censorship (even self-censorship)!

"On Loomio, we can edit our own comments initially, but only until someone else has either (1) made another comment in that thread or (2) ‘liked’ our comment.
[EDITOR'S NOTE: that was the mistaken part of my comment. There's a group setting which provides an alternative.]

I personally agree with the philosophy behind this technical choice. The idea seems to be that we preserve the integrity of conservations as-they-happened. For instance: nobody ends up ‘liking’ a comment which then changes. Also, later viewers can always see the conversational flow which influenced, or even created, later comments.

Of course, this aspect of Loomio means that we should take some extra care to compose our comments more carefully than we might in some places, such as facebook."

--I'm grateful that Alanna clarified the Loomio group options. Sorry for taking up space with my personal explanation here! :)

Carlos Gallo Garavano

@gregorycassel I lack a comment I received by email or situation is correct, if it was removed

Carlos Gallo Garavano

I agree with what was said in the discussion
https://www.loomio.org/d/FrYcJ8aj/feature-update-editing-content-on-loomio

Prefer restrictions Loomio Community group to the existing freedom in the subgroup Ideas Features

Change title, description, comment, like , after comments from another member of the group or subgroup, you can generate ridiculous situations, contrary to what was stated in initial form, etc

I should be written in a comment when a member of the group or subgroup changes the title or description.

Carlos Gallo Garavano

It is necessary that members of the group or subgroup know or see the configuration of the group or subgroup, to avoid confusion as mine and that cause unnecessary queries.

Alanna Irving

I agree @carlosgallogaravan - i'll add that idea to make the group settings more visible to the roadmap