A Public Resource Management System
How can we benefit the cooperative, peer-to-peer, open source design community, and social enterprise and more broadly apply it to our living environments? How can the web can better engage people with the material world, while also enriching the social, strengthening personal bonds.
This briefer proposes the development of a public resource management widget for Loomio.
This can start by:
Building a knowledge and design database and library of ‘things’, ‘services’, ‘transport networks’, and the ‘places’ they inhabit that link to top facilitators that theorize, build, and maintain them.
As leading facilitators are identified, the hunt for the dream development team can begin—a team that may include some of these fields:
Operations Managers | UX Designers / Data Visualizers / Sensory Artists | Engineers: Software / Automation & Robotics | Product Designers | Materials Scientists | Hospitality | Architects | City Planners | Agriculturists & Landscape Artists
Those disciplines and more would address the following areas:
Agriculture and Fishing | Manufacturing | Repair and Installation of Machinery and Equipment | Electricity, Gas, and Water | Construction | Wholesale and Retail Trade | Transport Storage and Communication | Accommodation and Food Services | Information and Communications | Financial and Legal Activities | Professional, Scientific, and Technical Activities | Rental and Leasing Activities | Administrative and Support Services | Public Administration and Defense | Human Health and Social Work Activities | Community / Voluntary Services
The daunting complexity of the task can be narrowed by starting with a single location and a small set of processes. Company partners can distribute the workload while working in tandem. The framing can start with a single shop, factory, or transport route—and once templates are formed—expand to include city blocks, districts, and whole cities. From the beginning of development, the design principles must enable models flexible enough as not to require continuous work from scratch, by identifying core elements that can transfer to a variety of designs.
Loomio was based on saving time by making decisions more efficiently. This proposal shares the principle of time efficiency with the insanely ambitious goal of a publicly owned resource management application. It will require extensive modeling, roadmapping, and coordination of practically every known discipline on an unprecedented scale. It is here Loomio can leverage the talent of corporations and governments, with the aim of streamlining and integrating the processes of production, service, and decision making better aligned with user feedback, particularly with products and services in mind.
With this a public project, all processes should be made as transparent as possible, so long as it does not endanger any individuals. Mirror worlds generated by participants contributing 3D imagery, sound, and location data, in addition to other ways of data visualization and sensory output, will better enable the cooperation of both users and experts to accelerate innovation, not only for the Loomio platform, but in every field the platform facilitates. Placed in map view, logistics channels can be color coded with icons to provide clarity in depicting the type of good or service when observing streams.
Building this now is important. Facing the pandemic, with the need for lockdown measures, a publicly observable management system can greatly reduce the need for workers, reducing the spread of contagion, and enable the monitoring of processes, including the use of telerobotics to perform tasks, in a variety of locations from the safety of one’s home. Were this system already in place, thousands of lives would have been saved, as a single platform that coordinates a variety of efforts with ability to observe and anticipate demands, items such as ventilators and personal protective equipment, including the ability to direct the person in need to go to locations that can meet medical requirements, could have been utilized. A public resource management system would prevent corrupt governments and opaquely ineffective companies from holding the people that depend on their services to ransom and instead hold them to account. Just as materials, processes, and places become public knowledge, so too, those executing orders and fulfilling tasks. Having such a tool would not only save lives, but enrich life.
Once the proper connections from this proposal are made, with a list of lead developers and projects onboard, a document can be written up and collectively signed to make a proposal to a city, like Amsterdam, that is keen on implementing these ideas. Amsterdam seems like a good partnership considering they have recently expressed an effort to pursue Kate Raworth's Doughnut Economics framework. (https://bit.ly/34MlwQ0) Madrid and Barcelona may also be interested, given it has a healthy social centre culture. This would obviously include the use of Loomio to facilitate municipal decision making, and more ambitiously, may work to democratize the European Union itself, rapidly spanning the globe as an international framework. (See: DiEM25)
One pilot project can involve the partnership with or something like MIT's OpenAg initiative, able to provide food sustainably for the city, while reducing transport miles from imports. The various aspects of manufacturing, warehousing and feedstocks, transport, and construction can follow, outfitting the city with sensors that provide dashboards for non-experts to assess the health of the city, including the ability to participate in planning, product design, and all the other functions required to operate and manage a city.
OpenAg can be one of many partners that supply the open source restaurant, a concept demostrated by the Waag community in 2009. (waag.org/en/project/instructables-restaurant) Local farm and supply partners will be aware of each open restaurant, while the resturant will be aware of all participating projects that might serve it.
In simple terms, this proposal is advocating to become something like Docker in that it provides a framework for any variety of projects to launch quickly and work and communicate with everyone else in the ecosystem, while also retaining a vision, roadmap, and collective mentorship that encourages the thriving population of that ecosystem, including mobilization to attract interest from and to convert legacy systems. Widgets or design elements must be assembled into an intuitively navigable library similar to that of Git, also coupled with a prediction engine that automatically draws up a list of widgets for each problem area as it is pursued within the design process.
Hack on! Such systems can develop using a planned staging of hackathons. The following tools assembled by the hackathon team at EUvsVirus are a go-to for making viable products from hackathons:
Miro: team collaboration, charts and planning
Airtable: collect data via a form view and manipulate it via table view
Bubble: build full apps without coding (database, view, logic)
Glide: build mobile web apps in minutes
Firebase: powerful and easy to setup backend with api and websocket support
Backendless: powerful and easy to setup backend with api and websocket support
InVision: easy to use design tool with click-dummy features
Workstreams: results-oriented, data-driven task management solution & kanban board app integrated to Slack
A number of hackathons can be planned to take on each sector and each area within a sector. It can start with the most vital areas such as energy, agriculture, manufacturing, logistics, services, and the most labor intensive aspect of the economy: maintenance.
Business plan. Once people and projects are onboard, having remotely and collectively developed a white paper and roadmap, we can then work to drum up funding. The funding would go to 'core support': cloud services, a core programming and design team, marketing/promoting/outreach and customer support. The program would be open source and free to use, enabling rapid adoption and networking of users within the ecosystem. Donation campaigns can be tried, as they seem to work for the Wikimedia and Mozilla foundations, but if needed, a monthly fee can be introduced to high volume users, with free use for low volume, small business/governments until, in time, the protocols are tweaked and usable without need for core support nor funding.
Thank you for considering and discussing this proposal. Feel free to contact me at knuggy@gmail.com. You can find me on Twitter: @nwcrav. For further context, see my writings at https://wiki.p2pfoundation.net/Nathan_Cravens. I'm up for a video chat. Once we have a sizeable group: brainstorming, outlining-detailing, and roadmapping can begin with an experienced facilitator or two privy to remote collaboration. Or, one can quietly apply this information to one's own work. I hope it inspires further development in the directions mentioned!
Compatible projects mentioned in the discussion below include:
Mozilla Hubs - summarize
commonspub.org - summarize
decko.org/ - summarize
fiware.org/ - summarize
github.com/holo-rea - summarize
gitlab.com/openengiadina - summarize
murmurations.network - summarize
https://solidproject.org/ - summarize
Projects that may adopt one or more of the above tools:
https://www.metabolic.nl/: reflowproject.eu/ - summarize
https://materiom.org/ - summarize
https://www.communecter.org/ - Open data, linking people to commons
https://github.com/pixelhumain/communecterMetabolism of Cities - summarize
www.aemslab.org.nz/from_the_ground_up - summarize
Waag - summarize
gitlab.com/openengiadina - summarize
What other people or projects might be helpful?
Concluding on a meditation:
Inspiration:
Eva Gladek: Sustainable Urban Systems and Circular Cities of the Future
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7o0qpe0vDwk&feature=emb_logo
@pukkamustard Looks like a good starting point.
Thanks for the mention @Danyl Strype!
@Nathan Cravens It is an ambitions vision! I like the idea of a "Docker" for variety of projects.
I agree that narrowing on a specific use-case and encouraging diverse initiatives to tackle their specific problems is a good way to face the daunting complexity. I believe the only thing required is agreeing on a common interoperable data-model, that is expressive enough to capture many different use-cases.
Finding such a minimal data-model that allows interoperability is a research question we are trying to approach with openEngiadina. We are focusing on a subset of RDF, the data-model of the Semantic Web, that has been proven to be extremely expressive and inter-operable. We are working on some details to make RDF usable in completely decentralized systems.
Examples of structured data that build on RDF and would just work include:
Like CommonPub (mentioned below) we are using ActivityPub (protocol for federated social networking) for creating, managing and disseminating content. This may be seen as an admission that data-management is primarily a social activity.
One little secret about ActivityPub is that the data-model is RDF. ActivityPub natively supports all existing RDF based vocabularies/ontologies.
openEngiadina was conceived for the management of "local knowledge". E.g. things such as events, local organizations and businesses, points of interest and status of infrastructure. The use-case might overlap with the system proposed.
@pukkamustard I am really interested in openEngiadina and the combination of technologies you intend to use. One that I also had for an idea - the open innercircles community (sorry, teaser-only still) - I've been walking around with for a long time, and recently started to elaborate further. On a practical level innercircles will offer federated tech in support of residential communities. This is the part where I'm now communicating publicly about. On a higher level innercircles is a methodology of 'applied philosophy', with the intention to make adoption easier (ideally create a snowball effect) and tackle the complexity. But I'll not elaborate on the philosophy, as I do not intend to teach it. That does never work. It should be slowly grasped, interpreted, understood and adopted by free will. Giving this high level a good start - for me - is hardest part.
Back to technical. ActivityPub had as problem that it went from spec to implementations too quickly, and now the spec has serious catching up to do. In linked data circles the problem is that things are way to much in technical and academic realms. Many - otherwise very good applications - just don't catch people's fascination, and never reach a broader public. I see this too for instance in the Solid forum, where I made a bunch of comments of that nature.
The approach of openEngiadina is spot on. It's what is needed for the fediverse at large: to have frameworks that can deal with any linked data ontologies and exchange + process messages containing data that correspond to them. It should go much further than sending a Like and an Announce and e.g. Mastodon supporting one additional property there which is not in the spec. And there should be concrete practical applications that go further than standard blog and social media features. Which is why it is nice to have common ontologies - well-analysed business domains - be the basis.
Regarding openEngiadina project and tech approach.. it would be great if we tackle things from documentation and spec perspective from the start. Synergy between like-minded initiatives. You are programming now in Guile, but I will - probably, if things get that far - go for NodeJS and Typescript, because it has a way larger developer base. Imho we should avoid everyone inventing their own way of doing things. Curious about your thoughts in this regard..
PS. My mind was blown when in 2016 viv.ai announced a linked data-like service - "the universe of capabilities" - to be accessible and extensible by every developer for creating end-user applications in an ever growing semantic web (proprietary probably). See this video from 8:50min. They were acquired by Samsung, never heard of again.. until recently. Now hiring again. Hope we won't have proprietary semantic web in the near future.
@Nathan Cravens are you aware of Murmurations?
"Rather than creating centralised data sets, The Murmurations protocol makes it easy for Organisations to host data about themselves on their own web sites.
The data is structured in a way that it can be automatically ‘crawled’ and aggregated, based on specific filterable criteria, so that directories and maps are automatically updated about an organisation from a single authoritative source. That source being the organisation itself!"
There's a discussion about Murmurations on the SocialHub forum for ActivityPub developers.
The ability to crawl and aggregate and automatically generate directories and maps, sounds very useful!
This sounds quite like REA accounting, have a look at valueflo.ws - theres a Holochain implementation getting established if your wanna find @pospi and say hello. Bob and Lynn will also be able to point you in the same direction
On valueflo.ws: mapping of resource and process with tracking and tracing are vital. Holochain looks good for managing and securing data and perhaps hosting a credit system for a basic income.
There's a group of us who have been working on a concept to build something like this system for about a year.
Its taken awhile to nail down the specifications for the project because of its ambitious scope but we're making progress.
Our main systems architect, Gerry Gleason, first proposed it some time ago on the Open Manufacturing Google Group.
We're actually looking to build upon Decko, an open source wiki/database platform, which probably will fulfill our requirements without too much work. We're looking at the possibility of embedding Loomio proposal discussions/voting/decisions into Decko. People were discussing this back in 2015. Is there any update on whether this is possible yet?
https://www.loomio.org/d/ivga1ORm/embeddable-discussions-and-voting?p=11
"This is a really good point. I'm not sure how to find out what similar resources are going under-used in my area. All of this could be solved with a great website to map the resources. Both the physical/capital resources and the human ones. Maybe more important is that we develop the right kind of database and visualization tools to create and maintain an overall development roadmap. I hear that in other comments as well, the need to know what is done, and in particular to map out the parts of the roadmap for the shared tools, like this website to do the mapping.
My biggest open source contribution has been to a Wiki/Database platform that already has all the necessary core features, and I'm hopping to engage teams in extending/customizing it. It is currently called "WAGN", http://wagn.org/ but will be rebranded as Decko sometime soon. It is the underlying platform for WikiRate http://wikirate.org. This customization for this project has been funding for a couple of years by an EU grant."
https://groups.google.com/forum/#!msg/openmanufacturing/FFEJWG90tuw/PELsRn4QAgAJ;context-place=msg/openmanufacturing/FFEJWG90tuw/sOEwbKBuBQAJ
Added a city focus at the conclusion of the proposal with an eye on Amsterdam and Madrid: Once the proper connections from this proposal are made, with a list of lead developers and projects onboard, a document can be written up and collectively signed to make a proposal to a city, like Amsterdam, that is keen on implementing these ideas. Amsterdam seems like a good partnership considering they have recently expressed an effort to pursue Kate Raworth's Doughnut Economics framework. (https://bit.ly/34MlwQ0). Madrid may also be interested, given it has a healthy social centre culture. This would obviously include the use of Loomio as to facilitate municipal decision making, and who knows, may work to democratize the European Union itself, rapidly spanning the globe. (See: DiEM25)
I have a couple of connections in Christchurch too.
That perspective will come in handy roadmapping this project.
Hi @Nathan Cravens and hi everyone here. I am new to this group, intro about me in my profile. If you are targeting Amsterdam, then you should be aware of Waag, a very cool organisation that is into these things already. It is led by Marleen Stikker, an internet pioneer from the start, and now often on Dutch TV talking about privacy concerns in corona tracing apps developed by Dutch government.
@aschrijver Waag looks like a great project. I'll be in touch.
didn't he work with the founder of Instructables on an open source restaurant concept?
Do you mean Marleen Stikker? Could well be. I am just following Waag on Mastodon and LinkedIn (both Dutch only, unfortunately).
That's neat. I may have mentioned the idea of an open cafe on the open manufacturing list around that time. Great to see some of those ideas were put into action. A public resource management system could make a return of that concept thrive, as local farm and supply partners will be aware of each open restaurant, while the resturant will be aware of all participating projects that might serve it. Placed in map view, logistics channels can be color coded with icons to provide clarity in depicting the type of good or service when observing streams.
We're looking to make a proposal to a VC fund in Chicago where Gerry is based.
https://www.theimpactengine.com/venturecapital
I have no experience in attracting VC funding, but I'd be happy to comment on your proposal if you like.
@Nathan Cravens this is a really interesting idea, as a loomio widget and also as accessible from wherever. I would be really happy to participate from the ValueFlows side, and I'm guessing others might as well. And with people bringing up various projects in this thread, and I know there are others, it sounds like there could be lots of possibilities for fruitful collaboration. (Hey, let's do an OAE! 🙂 )
Specifically related to REA/VF: @Josh Fairhead mentioned Holo-REA, a holochain economic framework implementing ValueFlows that other projects can build upon. A lot of that is built, with a handful of features remaining. Another project that recently became quite active is CommonsPub, a child of the fediverse that is extending ActivityPub (social networking protocol) with ValueFlows to combine the social and economic sides. Loomio as decision making might fit in with that. I suspect either of those projects would be happy to be a distributed VF backend to something like this proposal.
Another possibly interesting connection: The EU funded ReFlow project plans on using CommonsPub as a backend in piloting circular economy work in 6 cities, including Amsterdam.
Or, something completely new. Happy to contribute ValueFlows in any context that wants to build something for the next economy - seems like we have an unprecedented opportunity to fill a void and shape some of the future....
Amazing. ReFlow addresses the key points in the proposal and appears to have a solid ecosystem and partnerships that perfectly match the goals of the project. I will get in touch with them.
OAE sounds good. :)
Cool, will be interested in your results. If it helps, Bob and I are doing some work with the "backend" team from Dyne - but the project is way bigger than that, it is a bunch of coordinated teams from different organizations. From our limited point of view, we have the sense that Amsterdam could be the most involved and forward-looking pilot city; they are focusing on the textile industry as their pilot.
Added the paragraph:
One pilot project can involve the partnership with or something like MIT's OpenAg initiative, able to provide food sustainably for the city, while reducing transport miles from imports. The various aspects of manufacturing, warehousing and feedstocks, transport, and construction can follow, outfitting the city with sensors that provide dashboards for non-experts to assess the health of the city, including the ability to participate in planning, product design, and all the other functions required to operate and manage a city.
Added: In simple terms, this proposal is advocating to become something like Docker in that it provides a framework for any variety of projects to launch quickly and work and communicate with everyone else in the ecosystem.
Item removed
@hemiedwards Great. How can we move this forward?
Item removed
Item removed
OMG - testosterone anybody! Actually, look a little more deeply - at Blum Labs, Milken Foundation, Ergoinvest, ‘Find your city’s Maker Economy’, CityOS Foundation. Actually, it’s quite hard to find any background on CityOS Foundation - like, whose money is at work here. This kind of gloss and hype and penthouse offices doesn’t just rise from the streets - there must be VC underneath - or worse. On CityOS Labs . . .
The lab is located in the penthouse of the Energoinvest building. Link
On Ergoinvest . .
Bloomberg News noted in October 2015 that some portion of the $10 billion in mirror trades manipulated by Deutsche’s Moscow office involved monies associated with Putin associates and childhood friends Arkady and Boris Rotenberg. The Rotenberg brothers are known to have a long association with Ukrainian oligarch Dmitry Firtash, who in turn has long-time ties to Paul Manafort. Firtash is a member of the board of directors of Strategic Communications Laboratory Group (SCL Holding company), parent to Cambridge Analytica . . . etc Link
On Milken Foundation . . .
Michael Robert Milken (born July 4, 1946) is an American financier and philanthropist. He is noted for his role in the development of the market for high-yield bonds ("junk bonds"),[3] and his conviction and sentence following a guilty plea on felony charges for violating U.S. securities laws.[4] Since his release from prison, he has also become known for his charitable giving.[5][6][7][8] Milken was pardoned by President Donald Trump on February 18, 2020 Wikipedia
Note the white male global superprofessionals and dark money men - rather than the poor black women whose images get pasted on the front page of campaign literature (just like the Libracoin hype, which aims to annex the small-scale trading of the world’s unbanked).
Just sayin’ . . . this is a tangled sticky web. Tread carefully. CityOS is not from or for the streets, imo. Geeks - shouldn’t be suckered, maker spaces are being bugged and harvested, just like ‘free’ social media.
Item removed
It is quite hard to find information on CityOS Foundation, and what kind of money is behind it. When I followed links searching for more info, the above is the kind of content that came up. This is a tangled web. There was no straightforward answer to the question in plain sight. There was some quite disturbing stuff that did come into sight. This is not insinuation, it's an unresolved puzzle - why did one kind of material show up, and not another?
My opening comment about testosterone is a personal response to "“Zero to Hero” bootcamps" and the gung ho tone of the promo material for CityOS. My gut response made me want to discover where this glossy macho (yes, I think - maybe I'm too sensitive) stuff was coming from. Others may not have that same gut reaction - the material is there for others to check it out. But I didn't expect to find what did turn up. I guess I expected venture capital. I didn't expect dark money.
Equally, folks can assess for themselves whether 'Find your city's maker economy' is an approach coming from the streets or somewhere else. The link is there. My reading is, this isn't particularly dark, just the everyday kind of corporate capital tapping into community initiative and self-help.
Rather than being a tirade, most of my comment is clips from pages that showed up in the search. My reference to "white male global superprofessionals and dark-money men" and poor black women is because those were what appeared as I followed the links. What manifestly didn't appear was the plain answer to the question. I do believe that the question of the funding for CityOS is relevant in this group, since we know very well how insecure the financial/ownership basis of open source projects can make them, in relation to corporate power - we needn't look further than Microsoft and GitHub. The 'openness' of app ecosystems doesn't just refer to the codebase or the tech protocol?
So I feel 'tread carefully' is pertinent. William Burroughs used to say: Be careful whose money you pick up.
Item removed
I don't think issuing ultimatums is helpful. @mike_hales has raised a valid issue about the funding behind some of the code your projects may end up depending on. Perhaps he's got his wires crossed on some of the details, but surely the best response is to clarify exactly which projects you're referencing and what funding sources they have (if any), and leave it at that? We're all on the same team here; team human :) Be excellent to each other!
Item removed
Item removed
Item removed
Item removed
Item removed
Item removed
Item removed
Item removed
Item removed
I accept your apologies and I regret to some extent my shortness with you, but I do not appreciate it when people think that just because they have the right to free speech that they are entitled to opine on whatever they have a mind to no matter how ill informed they are or how unsolicited their opinion is. I am directing that at Mike whose instead of politely engaging in a meaningful exchange with me just vomited out random accusations and insinuations in the most discourteous and uncivil fashion. He didn't even have the grace to withdraw the comment, even when I specifically asked him to and clearly showed he was in error. I must say this who debacle has made me feel particularly unwelcome especially when both you and Danyl dismissed my concerns and took Mike's side when he was clearly in the wrong.
I wrote a preamble to the proposal you can read here: https://docs.google.com/document/d/e/2PACX-1vTySYsOelibFjJuXufPOB4c-Gz0eOz7JVanHqX1zrVd6D4PEgzlE7uXVNyTg8JkbxO-wQSjUzMUPyjq/pub I suppose now it is a matter of outlining, then detailing a more specific project this generalized system can inhabit; and work out the finer details as we go along. Feel free to point out areas I may have missed or any other projects that may relate to the proposal under discussion. I'm up for a one-on-one video chat. When it comes to brainstorming, outlining-detailing, and roadmapping, it would be best to do this with an experienced facilitator or two privy to remote collaboration.
I like your preamble, Nathan, although I have to admit I had great hesitation to open the Google Doc. It is against my principle, as I de-google from this big player that is only extractive to the local community. In this domain where we want to bring heads together, there are more with these same sentiments. Can we use other tools?
@aschrijver Thanks for making the exception, Arnold. I'm happy to adopt a different platform that provides the same function at your suggestion. In the hackathon section of the proposal there are programs listed that may also be detrimental to community building in the long term. Its really a delicate balance between pragmatism and an ethics based on openness and freedom, leaning too far either way, or relying too heavily on one set ideology, can create arbitrary boundaries or vulnerabilities that prevent goals from being achieved that could better serve local communities in the near term. In other words, as the thinking goes: to make great art sometimes the best tools are ones that are more exclusive and come at a price, but such tools when used toward the ethics of local community enrichment, endeavoring to quickly enable the creation of better tools than the ones used, made available sooner as open and free versions that are not just copies, but considerably more attractive and useful.
In the new paragraph on the business plan for this proposal my ethical view is clarified. Nothing is set in stone as it needs to first meet the needs of those interested in developing this project. I try to strike the balance if or when a need for funding is required to continue a standard quality of use and service expected of potential competitors, such as the services provided by SAP, Autodesk, and the like: first by campaigning regularly for funding, but if that were to fail or not be enough, add a paywall for high volume users, again, to keep users happy or at least happy enough not to rely on proprietary products. ReFlows is based on government funding, so that's an option I'll add to the proposal, but even government funding may not be enough, especially if the political climate continues to favor the privatization of government. If this meta-platform can take on two or three prioprietary product functions simulatenously, that would be a huge boon to the promise of openess and freeness, while maintaining privacy settings to the best degrees possible.
This line of thinking (what is good?) is reminding me to consider (what is useful?) the list of tools and projects related, featured toward the conclusion of the proposal, and asking the question, ideally having articulate-yet-concise answers from the developers of these tools—some who have graciously contributed to this conversation—how they might work in the context of this proposal. I'm more than willing to correct or narrow the complexity at the start, with the aim of meeting higher goals later, if it means adjusting a bit to enable a widget that already shows results with a willing and skilled group behind it. I also feel a need to elaborate (what is it exactly am I proposing?) a bit further on the function of the public resource management system by relating it to other applications, which incidently are proprietary, like SAP (operations management and logistics) and Autodesk (modeling operations real or imagined), as well as comparing it to LinkedIn (a platform that enables networking of expertise within an ecosystem) and Wix (a way a nonexpert or small child can design something easily that functions as it should). Again, these examples are proprietary, but well known for the sake of communication, with its potential detriment to emulating too completely, requiring an ongoing exercise in leaning or reaffirming toward the good—as we all work toward—enriching local communities.
I highly suggest Naomi Klein's latest article, 'Screen New Deal', which outlines Eric Schmidt et al.'s idealization toward the technological acceleration of the Silicon Valley profile during the pandemic. I've been thinking on this article quite a bit. It is a sort of reaction to 'IT’S TIME TO BUILD' by Marc Andreessen. (https://a16z.com/2020/04/18/its-time-to-build/) The technologies Schmidt and I advocate are the same, but how they are used (or rather who they would benefit) would differ, so the article provides a cautionary tale as we move forward in a post-pandemic world.
Naomi Klein, 'Screen New Deal' (https://theintercept.com/2020/05/08/andrew-cuomo-eric-schmidt-coronavirus-tech-shock-doctrine/) "If tech companies win their ferocious lobbying campaign for remote learning, telehealth, 5G, and driverless vehicles — their Screen New Deal — there simply won’t be any money left over for urgent public priorities..."
@pukkamustard how does this proposal by Nathan fit with the vision for OpenEngiadina?