Reconsidering free public/paid private groups
big fan of testing pay-for-privacy with checks and balances, we are looking at this model in other enspiral start-ups
I strongly dislike the phrase "pay-for-privacy" - obviously the privacy of users personal information is not up for auction. Does Loomio have a privacy policy yet? It needs to factor in the points in the Franklin St Statement, , the EFF Bill of the Privacy Rights, and the Bill of Social Web Rights:
http://autonomo.us/2008/07/14/franklin-street-statement/
https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2010/05/bill-privacy-rights-social-network-users
http://opensocialweb.org/2007/09/05/bill-of-rights/
Having said that, I think Richard's idea is worth examining. I definitely like the idea of the end-user experience being tightly-integrated with the open source community experience. Would this be aimed at small or non-complex groups who don't need their own subgroups, or does the app support nesting of sub-sub-groups? Another question: do groups who have no money, and really need privacy, really need to have their discussions online?
Another criteria could be the licensing of the content; a group gets gratis use if they makes their Loomio discussions and proposals visible to the public, under a CreativeCommons license (you could choose one, or let the group choose, using the License Chooser on creativecommons.org). Groups who do this are contributing to a corpus of "open source consensus code", which other groups can reference as examples for the successes and failures of different consensus techniques, and different ways of using the Loomio tools to implement them. They're also sacrificing the ability to make their decisions in private. I reckon that earns them gratis use of the tool.
I am going come at this from a tiered service point of view. I think we should provide for all models of group discussion but instead of limiting what we offer on the free ones,offer bespoke features for the private groups hosted by us. I want to describe these groupsto bring into focus how Loomio can reorganize itself for both models.
[Strypey]"do groups who have no money, and really need privacy, really need to have their discussions online" - Yes! I am most often part of such groups, the informal fuzzy and [dont know what they want to do] ones - these are the baby grassroot orgs trying to get things off the ground and are composed of people with little common ground who need to find this common ground- [this accounts for the bulk of online discussion any way]. I think Loomio would fit in here wonderfully allowing admins of these groups to provide a truly decentralizing/democratic venue for ideas to be heard and disseminated and come to consensual decisions.
[Rich] "a private group hosted by us" - These are mature groups that have been collaborating for a while already. They probably have traditions in place to make decisions - ex: mod opens forum -->members are given rules to discuss -->mod puts up stickies on the forum on the most popular threads --->decisions.They are tired of this model and are looking for something fresh and its here where Loomio and the core team get together to "consult" and offer bespoke features [leveraging of already available modules] and put together a loomio group just for them. Here, there is an opportunity to package Loomio and offer it to these groups in license form. This solves privacy concerns as all data will be shared within their intranet.
Agreed Privacy should be a non-negotiable and has to encompass everything. However we can add more tiers to the public/free model
I worry that forcing a free trial to be public puts up a barrier for groups who want privacy as a table-stake feature, or are simply less comfortable having their trial discussions open on the internet.
The sort of initial discussions I could expect would be be around what Loomio is, how to use it, and how we could use it in our organisation. That's not something I would want publicly accessible (especially the latter), and would also be a roadblock for me getting colleagues to try Loomio.
I like the scholarship idea as Rich suggests, but I'm not sure users should need to apply for that just to get a private trial going.
The first battle is finding someone willing to champion Loomio in an organisation. The second is helping them get their colleagues on board. The third is getting them to pay for it.
My sense is that we minimise barriers to trial. Then once usage hits a level which shows the product has been adopted and is generating genuine value for that user, we charge subscription/koha.
Hey guys I don't have much to add right now, just wanted to say I am really digging the high quality of thinking and communicating in this discussion and I'm very grateful for the high quality humans we have on our team :) carry on!
@David there's no reason we couldn't do free public as I've described it, running alongside free limited private trials.
I agree with @Strypey that we need to get serious on privacy and we can use the work of e.g. the EFF to get started on that.
I like the idea of customised groups @Varun, I think this will be solved with a plug-in architecture a la Wordpress.
I think making loomio free for any group that is completely open is a great idea - the same as how github only counts your private repositories for your paid account.
I don't see any conflict between this and having paid for private groups or private groups that are free (based on whatever criteria we like)
I think we should have as low a barrier as possible for new users creating a private group so they can see if it will work in their organisation and would definitely advocate for a really easy sign up for a free trial experience.
Wow, my head is reeling! So many potential models in play right now. I am Finding it useful to think of a parallel process between free and paid Loomio services.
I like the idea of a free offer through the Loomio User Group. Some people may use this to try it out, but others will use it because it is fine by them to be open and public. Personally I would restrict this option through some criteria- the community could even agree the criteria, but I would be thinking of things like: social movement, under $xy turnover, aligned with active citizenship
This would then leave a very clean and clear parallel track for the paying users. Personally I think supporting people with engagement and facilitation will be as big a feature for paying users as the privacy. We are seeing engagement as a significant issue to help people with and we would not want to be investing time outside usual user community communications and online help/ education resources, to people getting a free service.
In short, I think the suggestion has real potential
One rule of thumb I discovered at Oblong is that of those people/ groups who are going to be interested in a social enterprise (like Loomio) are either:
* cash rich and time poor
* time rich and cash poor
If you are cash rich and time rich you can just pay for whatever you want, and spend as long as it takes to find the best value for your money. If you are cash poor and time poor, you're probably not going to have time to use Loomio, even gratis.
What you want to do is establish a model which makes it easy for:
* anyone who is interested to trial Loomio gratis (effortless promotion by network effect)
* cash-poor users (with time) to donate time
* time-poor user (with cash) to donate cash
If you have any point where a freeware service becomes payware, you need to make it really clear in advance what will trigger that change, and provide an export feature for those who wish to leave and take their data with them.
Instead of charging paying users to pay for Loomio as a whole - why not charge them for using awesome plugins - as development is already headed towards a plugin architecture. Take wordpress themes for example - there are some themes that do the job and are free [for cash poor time rich/poor] but wordpress is a monetizing engine through its plugins. If the Loomio team can "maintain" Loomio (barebones) as a free service and concentrate on making some really specific plugins to cater to various specialized groups (ex: education / civil services etc.) - we achieve both goals of maintaining "free"dom and enabling specialized "charged" service. Loomio in its original, vanilla form neednt ever change to a payware system at all.
Good point Varun. Also bearing in mind that 'vanilla' wordpress is pretty freaking amazing, and that there are tonnes of awesome free plugins too.
well vanilla Loomio is pretty freaking amazing as well !!! :) And hey who doesnt like vanilla ? Also everyone charges extra for the toppings! even non-dairy cow hugging vegans like mua 3:8)
Just an idea I wanted to test out on the crowd:
What if the Loomio User Group was free for anyone to use? It would be free to create public sub groups within this group but if you wanted a private group hosted by us, you would pay for access. To start with we'd have a limited number of invites to hand out every month, increasing the size of the group as we improve the feature-set to handle bigger crowds.
People would be incentivised to participate in the development and governance of the tool; which is exactly the qualities I'd like to encourage in members of all kinds of groups. We could make this a part of our messaging, using the limited invites to create a demand, where people would be banging on the door to get in and help guide the development of the platform.
I understand there was a concern with this model in that it would marginalise groups that have privacy needs, which will often be the kind of people that would benefit most from the tool. If we assume for the sake of argument that we could put checks and balances in place to mitigate this discrimination (i.e. the scholarship option we've talked about in the past), are there any other potential negative side effects with this model?
I'm not certain of the idea, I just want to try it out. Whatever governance model we settle on eventually, it will ideally be prefigurative of the model that is used to govern all sorts of innovative purposeful and sustainable groups: the kind of groups that are going to solve the world's most urgent problems.
We want to make sure we're creating an environment where these groups and these new models can flourish.