Loomio

Sub Discussion / Issue

Craig Lambie PublicSeen by 33

Sometimes an issue is more complex than should we go to the moon on vacation.

Or just plain needs more than one decision to make the driving outcome happen.

Alanna Irving

Hey @craiglambie - can you give some examples of what you're talking about? Would be good to upwrap that a bit further.

Craig Lambie

For example.
Going to the moon on vacation, might first need
- what dates should we go on vacation?
- what should we do on vacation?
- budget?
Answered before you choose to go to the moon, so a sub-decision needs to be made, in order to allow the main decision to be made would be good.

Alanna Irving

Ah, I see. In that case I'd say... it's best not to start a proposal straight away. Allow the discussion to play out a little bit first, so those details can be talked about. Then when it's more clear what the group wants, it's time for a proposal.

Craig Lambie

Hi Alanna, maybe it is the geek in me, but comment style discussion doesn't really work for me, I like options, and I think this will result in more engagement.
eg.
What dates should we go on vacation:
22-27 Dec or 27 Dec-2 Jan or 3-7 Jan
eg. The only dates that I can have off are these dates, so you, in this case, would have to choose one of them.
This leads to a whole discussion about dates, part of the where, sure, but when I have time off work is pretty important, as I can't really go to the moon while I am working, there is little or no internet up there ;)

Alanna Irving

I guess for a discussion like that, there are already great tools out there like doodle.

We are developing something that's called the "ideas" feature, which isn't ready to release yet, but it's sort of an early stage way to source some options before it's time to start a proposal. Hopefully that will help!

There have been many in-depth discussions about the pros and cons of having multiple options at once, like this one - it's important to remember that Loomio is not trying to become a voting/polling app. Everything in Loomio is geared toward allowing discussion to evolve the solutions further.

Craig Lambie

Thanks @alannakrause I will follow on the other discussion, seems to be the same as this.
On that note - would be great if Loomio automatically suggested that earlier on in the process. I did do a search, but didn't find anything - so thanks for pointing me in that direction

Robert Guthrie

There is also a lot of talk about plugins for Loomio. I know that there is a desire from many users to have purpose specific "polling" apps/widgets available to quickly get information from the participants.

Things like multiple choice, mood indication, finding a time and more.

There is a bit of work to do to make sure these tools fit the culture of Loomio, and are understood as a means to get feedback from the group in an efficient way - rather than finding a majority to rule with - but I do believe they can be used to help in the concensus building process.

We just need to get to the point where we can support plugins, hopefully mid 2014 we'll be doing that.

Alanna Irving

I really agree about the "suggest similar discussion" idea @craiglambie ! I hope we can put that on the roadmap.