Loomio

Gathering #15 September 2, 2021 - Revisiting Money

Ronen Hirsch PublicSeen by 7

A container for preparations, documentation, and ripples from gathering #15

14:00-16:00 UTC (with possibility for overtime) @ Zoom

Ronen Hirsch

@Toni Blanco will you be able to setup a Zoom for this gathering?

  1. Share a link on discord 24 hours before the gathering.

  2. Be ready to record in case Josh is not able to show up.

  3. Have a way to share the recording privately (without making it public on the internet) with Josh.

Josh Fairhead

I will be able to show up, thanks for holding space though! :)

Ronen Hirsch

Context

This gathering is a space to explore a thread of conversation about the role of money within the generative process. @Jennifer Damashek started this in a comment on a card in the generative sequence and is now contained in this Loomio thread. Jennifer felt that the inclusion of the word "finance" alienated and excluded experiences of solidarity in her life circles

Jennifer and I had a dyad conversation followed by some email correspondence during which a volatile energy arose and was contained (Jennifer: please feel free to correct, comment, expand if you feel that the words I have chosen here are not aligned with your experience).

This gathering is intended to bring this conversation into the wider crew space.

Represent

Our previous gathering on the subject of money was personal. I would like to suggest that the theme of this gathering be slightly different.

It seems clear to me that the generative process has evoked different images and visions in each of us. To me, that is a beautiful outcome and speaks to the generative potential of this approach. It is most likely that the images that were evoked in each of us (by the same GP) are informed by our different life experiences.

In that spirit, I would like to suggest that at this gathering we arrive as representatives not just of our own personal experiences and needs, but of the communities and ecologies which we wish to serve and nourish. Let us try to bring to this gathering not just our personal needs, but the needs of the people and communities we are each involved in.

Remote

In addition, I would also like to remind us all that a key quality in the framing of our shared work in this crew is REMOTE!

If your communal experience has been biased towards physical proximity and face-to-face interactions, please remember to consider and reflect on the context of REMOTE microsolidarity.

The isolation forced upon many of us due to COVID played a key role in the formation of this crew. I did not have access to Microsolidarity until COVID arrived and forced a shift to remote/online work (that before COVID was also biased towards physical communities).

The invitation to form this crew was, on my part, a shot in the dark, a question really: am I the only one, or are there others who, like me, live in isolation and lack access to microsolidarity (or any solidarity?) in their physical worlds? If so, how many others - a handful, millions? Is this something we wish to tend to? if so, how? That is how the generative process was born and what it was designed to address.

This is not intended to exclude other solidarity contexts. But it does introduce an intentional bias: giving priority to the remote experience. COVID has demonstrated that crisis can force the remote context upon even established physical communities. COVID is likely not the last crisis we are going to face. I ask that we keep this in mind when we discuss the subject of money.

Toni Blanco

I shared what I learned by working on a different GP by myself here. Find there my interpretation of the "noise" caused by the "financial" word in the card.

Ronen Hirsch

prompts that are currently alive in me (with awareness of the nearing gathering) - both within the specific context for the gathering:

  • How are you arriving at this gathering? What baggage do you carry with you?

  • What would you like to take away with you from this gathering?

Josh Fairhead

Post meditation I wrote myself an note outline on my birthday that I've just processed, with synchronic priming from the above comment. It's brought up a lot in me and feels timely in relation to our gathering about money. This is what I'm carrying right now, pretty much a straight stream of conscious:


### 6 August


My birthday, typically the most difficult day in my life for several reasons. 1) I don't particularly like spotlights, 2) the relationship with my mother is quite transactional, this is a date where the expectation upon me is to trade my affection for the profane - material bribes and so forth, gifts with expectation and conditionality - thus not gifts. My wishes not to perform this ritual are never respected and even mentioning them brings discord. Rocks and hard places essentially.

Aside from personal feelings I also see the significance of dates in general as quite arbitrary. The Gregorian calendar is clearly full of errors (regarding the continuity of planetary cycles), so what makes this assignment meaningful? The power to believe and that's about it IMO.

This is the context behind this note.

---

Other years have been very tough to navigate but I'm proud of myself this round. There was little tension and my actions flowed in the appropriate ways. I think everyone got what they really wanted.

A few days before the cursed day, I mentioned to my father the desire avoid transactionality and commerce with my mother. I told him that if we had to go for a meal on my mothers wishes (I'd rather treat the day as any other), then my wish would be to pay for everyone. He was fine with this.

---

The day unfolded pleasantly, no imperatives pushed upon me (especially in the morning) which was pleasant. I set off for a restaurant with my mother, my father following in his car with the dog. We arrived sat down and ordered. Tension between the parents was present but minimal (they were separating and were in the process of mediation). This was smoothed over and after eating my father grabbed the bill, despite my expressed wishes. It was a gift without being explicit and my wish to pay would have probably caused some form of guilt in my mother - though she wouldn't have issues with appropriating from him (as in her eyes he's taken from her). Thus it was a good move on his part to have ignored me and made the gesture he did in such a non-transactional spirit.

Upon return the necessary commerce was scheduled to begin. Overkill as expected; a little bit of weed, an aeropress, a hammock and Є200. I was promptly warned about refusing the currency or returning it and so ate the heartache of such profanity. We had coffee, cake and then they went their separate ways; my father going to sort the boats rigging out and mother doing something across the bay. I gladly smoked a spliff on my own with the dog howling for being left behind. Actually I smoked several before deciding it was time to meditate down by the water to relax after the unfulfilled potential for combustion. I was glad that this possibility went another direction than anticipated but still left saddened by the days transactionality and the inability to be heard on the matter.

As I had somewhat delayed at the table to be on my own for a while I hadn't realised that my father was already back from his dip. Passing through the house to grab my water and timer I entered the kitchen to find him in HIS birthday suit, or at least the bottom half of it. More gestures, this time in a more synchronistic way than intentional. He's often been told to cover himself throughout the years, either by my mother or by myself and the brother (for teenage embarrassment). He still harbours a feeling of being repressed about this it seems. An the lack of fucks given about this day seemed no accident - almost intentional, though not premeditated. My interpretation of this was that he was saying "remember where you came from" in his own way. Had I said anything I'm sure I would have met a rebuttal along these lines; but I said nothing other than excusing myself from the room and getting on with my own stuff. While not expressed, I imagine he was grateful not to be agitated about it "for once" (not that such a situation has occurred in the last ten to fifteen years). He carries the past with him on these kinds of things.

While down on the water, the meditation that came to me was a 369 triad of be loving, act gracefully and think clearly. At the same time, an insight of how to reconcile my desires regarding transactionality with my mothers - take it and spend it on her. She was confusing the language of commerce with correspondence due to her own material value system. Since she had asked me to get her weed earlier in the month, but she didn't like smoking tobacco, while smoked pure it knocked her out - I figured I'd get her a vaporizer. Easy.

This left some anxiety in me as I was in ways rejecting the transaction; she could have just skipped the step of giving me cash and bought it for herself but she'd probably not give herself permission to do such (despite thinking she had cancer and not telling anyone as I've just learnt - happily this isnt the case). Anyway, despite the potential volatility for taking such action (not fitting into her belief system about one way transactionality) I placed the order and later told her that I'd bought HER a birthday gift but it would take a few days to arrive. Speaking of deferred rewards, her response was "I hate when people say these kinds of things" - I realised telling her was a mistake as soon as I mentioned it but too late. On a deeper level I think I wanted her to associate the events of giving and receiving; if she didn't want the gift due to sentimental reasons then at least the situation was symmetrical.

Three days later the vaporizer arrived and I believe she was genuinely pleased. Having heard my use of language over a few weeks, she turned to me and asked "so is this commerce then?". My response was that "it's a middle ground" to which she was satisfied.

---

In my eyes, this is a pretty odd note. Without the years of context within my family unit it probably sounds like very little, maybe like the situations are normal or you may wonder what the deal is. Some may consider me an ungrateful brat, at least that's how I've been told to feel - which I don't think is fair. What's big about this experience - and infract the extended trip - is that while together, nobody was triggered. Typically someone is getting agitated every second minute; it would seem to me that the family's defence mechanism is to provoke and agitate each other in a vicious cycle.

Somehow this damage was avoided for the duration of my stay. I can't take credit for the behaviours of others but for me its big as I was able to concede my own beliefs in totality, suspend judgemet in entirity and procees why the fuck my familys so damn screwed up... while taking counter measures (word spells) which felt like a valuable contribution towards harmony. Honestly, I'm glad as hell to be out of that (heratbreaking) environment but the experience of sucessfully holding on to my integrity throughout the entire period was something that allows me to feel proud of my actions, if not a little exhausted.

Jennifer Damashek

Thank you for sharing these personal notes, @Josh Fairhead. I feel I know you better because of what you shared. My grandmother is transactional with gifts. I can relate to the discomfort and unpleasantness around such “gifts.”

Jennifer Damashek

I read most of this article. What struck me most when reading it was that Ken Wilbur seems to believe he knows more than is possible to know about human history. For example, in this paragraph:

Thus, Mary Wollstonecraft’s Vindication of the Rights of Women was written in 1792; it is the first major feminist treatise anywhere in history. It is not that all of a sudden, women became smart and strong and determined after a million years of oppression, dupedom, and sheepdom: it is that the social structures had evolved, for the first time in history, to a point that physical strength did not overwhelmingly determine power in culture. Within a mere few centuries—a blink in evolutionary time—women had secured legal rights to own property, to vote, and to “be their own persons,” that is, to have a property in their own selves.

I don't think we can know what human life was like for the vast majority of our collective history. My personal sense is that most human societies operated vastly differently than they do now, and our imaginations are severely limited by what we see around us.

Some other perspectives on human history point to the possibility that for most of our human history (which has been lost due to no written documents and few traces left behind to dig up) we have operated cooperatively and in more feminine, earth-centered ways.

http://www.matriarchiv.ch/?page_id=34&lang=en

https://www.amazon.com/Chalice-Blade-Our-History-Future/dp/0062502891

I wanted to add that the article did make me think more carefully about the idea of money being “evil” or “dirty” and I’m grateful you posted it, Alex. I don’t know that I agree with Ken Wilbur’s conclusions, but I also know I really don’t have any idea about what is the best way to get from where we as human beings are with money to where I would like to be.

Ronen Hirsch

"Ken Wilbur seems to believe he knows more than is possible to know"

that statement feels so ... whole :)

Thank you @Jennifer Damashek :)

Robert Damashek

Thank you @Alex Rodriguez for sharing these insights from Ken Wilber which I believe are directly related to our discussion and pondering on the role of money in this sacred work we have embarked upon. It seems to me that Wilber attempts to grapple with the role of money in a very pragmatic and practical way as part of the world we live in just like @Ronen Hirsch has done with his initial cards on Money. Yet I also think that Wilber does this by tying into the sacredness of everything through his discussion of non-duality, that the “I” can never really be separate or apart from any part of life. I love that he provides insights that the progressive liberation of society began to enable more to experience that non-duality as we returned to a more feminine-driven society. So thanks!

Alex Rodriguez

As I mentioned in our call, there is a HUGE grain of salt that any Ken Wilber essay needs to be taken with ... namely, his brusque misogyny tinged with an intellectual arrogance ... you point directly to those faults in your response @Jennifer Damashek and I agree completely. This is not what I was talking about when I mentioned our need to incorporate feminist economics into our conversation, haha!

Glad to hear that there was still something useful in there for you.

Alex Rodriguez

Ronen's request to all of us at the end:

-go over generative process again
-specifically, look deeply into the money section

question: is that whole enough to say "cycle 3 is complete enough for now"? Or do we want to spend more time now hashing out how money fits into the generative process?

Ronen Hirsch

I am sitting in my morning study session, ingesting and digesting Samkhya and thinking about something @Alex Rodriguez said yesterday regarding Buddhism and an attitude of "we are doing this now, in this lifetime" and I don't trust that attitude (and I feel I need to acknowledge I am currently biased towards seeing the shortcomings and failures of Buddhism!):

  1. I sense hubris in it, I sense an attitude of dominance and control, in this case applied to ... of all things spirit nature! as if liberation of the soul is a task aking to servicing a machine.

  2. I believe that somewhere in the Baghavad Gita (a text with which I am only superficially familiar) there is a teaching that says something like: not I, not by me, not for me.

  3. As I read these Samkhya verses that state that "discerning knowledge (the metaphysical principles outlined in Samkhya)is the key to the liberation of Spirit" ... and I can feel the temptation to think "here I am, studying this text, I get it, I have acquired discerning knowledge, I must be going free, and boy would that be a relief because this round of life has been abundantly unpleasant" ... but I do not think that's how it works. I feel I don't get to liberate my Spirit any more than I get to grow a beautiful flower. I can plant a seed and tend to the soil, I can study and practice, but liberation and beautiful flowers are not of me, not by me, not for me!

  4. I recently heard an Israeli/Jewish scholar of Judaism and how it applies to psychology, suggest that the systemic brokenness he sees in western psychological thinking is that it is "self centered" ... that it is missing a god ... missing a "something greater than I" ... and I wonder if this is also a pattern present in Buddhist thinking or a pattern that was injected into Buddhist thinking when the west got its hands on it?

  5. I am also thinking of a theme I've heard Tyson Yunkaporta speak about: that in indigenous cultures you are systemically taught that you, as an individual, don't really matter, you are not special ... you may get to participate in something special ... but you yourself ... are not!

Ronen Hirsch

I am coming out of practice thinking: it is unbridled masculine dominance that is forever conquering.

It is everywhere. It is in Buddhism, it is in Yoga, it is in Decision Making, it is in Money and in Capitalism, in Nationalism, in Politics.

  • When this energy is unbridled it leads to understanding and a delusional sense of control: "I am riding this horse and I will bend it to my will"

  • When this energy is regulated it leads to a lifetime of practice and to a humble sense of mastery: "I don't know how this horse works, but we've been together long enough that she is able to carry me well, I can sit on her well, and we are able to move well together."

I believe it is not enough to practice the things we want to do well. We also have to closely examine our habits (our most established practices!) and stop investing in patterns and assumptions that work against us. If you practice Pranayama (breath practices) once a day for 15 minutes but spend another 1785 minutes a day living in stress and duress which constrains your breath ... which pattern do you think is going to dominate?

Jennifer Damashek

Thank you, Ronen for sharing your experience of what Alex said yesterday. I appreciated what Alex said and could relate to it. I have to admit I love Buddhism and resonate with Buddhist teachings, even though Buddhism did arise in a patriarchal context.

I can see how the words "we are doing this now, in this lifetime" can definitely seem like hubris and like there is an attitude of domination. It's possible someone who says those words may actually be coming from such a place.

However, I think it's also possible that a person who says those words could be coming from an authentic inner experience of being able to be liberated in this lifetime and in that case it might take a lot of courage to even say the words out loud. After all, if one believes that there is such a thing as liberation of a soul, it must happen in one lifetime or another, and if the soul were in a lifetime where it was possible, wouldn't that soul likely have the inner sense it was possible?

I think the key to knowing the difference inwardly is to realize that just because I may have the inner experience that I am going to accomplish something in this lifetime doesn't mean it will actually happen. What actually happens isn't something we can control. We might delude ourselves for a while, but reality always shows up, sooner or later.

Ronen Hirsch

My brief impressions from the gathering:

  1. I felt that the diverse positions and attitudes with which we arrived were well expressed and that some kind of unspoken consolidation took place. I felt empowered by the soft capacity of the group to hold itself together. I feel recurring and sustained appreciation that we have traveled this far together.

  2. Personally, the gathering was invigorating and nourishing for me and that echoed clearly in this morning's practice (the next day). I look forward to being able to have more (in quantity and quality) of these kinds of nourishing encounters, that we find a way to truly engage and come into service of this work.

  3. The money-related friction guided us into a kind of re-orientation of where we are collectively and how we got here.

  4. The re-orientation within the space allowed us to re-make a collective conscious choice about what it is we want to work on together (more on that in a coming proposal).

  5. The sense of being "re-oriented together" awoke a sense that maybe this cycle has reached maturity and is nearing completion (more on that in another upcoming proposal).

  6. I suggested that as a follow-up to the gathering that everyone revisits the GP as a whole (without getting hung-up on particulars) and gives special attention to the three money sequences.

  7. I will be following up with two proposals (mentioned above).

Scope of Work

poll by Ronen Hirsch Closed Mon 20 Sep 2021 9:01AM

The purpose of this proposal is to briefly summarize and check for alignment around the scope of work we outlined during this gathering.

  1. We remain true to the original invitation to tend to strangers who, at random times, discover space(s) with which they resonate and by spending time in the space they find others with whom they can come together into lasting crews that are able to do meaningful work together while practicing solidarity.

  2. In the space, they acquire and train in new skills. Practice is a key element to both acquiring new skills, getting to know and connect with others, and getting to know yourself in the context of these new others.

This framing does not exclude the application of the method to existing groups or established spaces where people are already together but feel they can benefit from the method.

There are other potentials that can be explored (such as crews coordinating with each other) that are outside the current scope. This does not exclude these potentials from our scope of work. This scope is a point of departure that is tangible and addressable and can lead to other needs and potentials that currently seem theoretical and out of reach.

This scope can be viewed as a business proposal outline. It points to a target audience and to addressable needs.

This proposal is offered as a multiple-choice poll in the hope that:

  1. It will enable you to express your position.

  2. It helps us sense if we are converging around a shared foundation upon which we can continue to build.

  3. It gives rise to any objections or reservations before we move forward.

  4. That we move forward with a clear and resonant sense of consent - that this is "good enough for now and safe enough to try.

I am giving this proposal almost two weeks so that everyone has time to reflect on it spaciously while revisiting the generative process. However, if we all address it earlier we will be able to sooner contemplate next steps.

Results

Josh Fairhead

I understand the scope outlined in this proposal.
I feel it points to a real need.
I feel this need can be address ethically and sustainably.
I have no objections to moving forward based on this framing.
I would like to see this need addressed.
I look forward to discovering what other needs may arise.
I would like to contribute to addressing this need.

I would like to contribute to addressing this need.

Right now, I don't personally feel compelled to tend to strangers. I've been doing this for quite some time already and am somewhat depleted from doing so (I have received, but perhaps not in proportion to what I've given). Thus I feel more compelled to tend to myself and those with whom I'm familiar and trust BEFORE tending to the needs of strangers.

In essence, I feel my extensionality is already stretched thin. I'd love to be able to stretch further but right at this moment I don't feel like it would be a good idea for me to be overly charitable; I continue in such a way I'll be the one requiring charity and that's not a good place to operate from. I'd thus like to build stable bases and replenish myself before moving back into a more generous and giving modality.

Jennifer Damashek

I understand the scope outlined in this proposal.
I feel it points to a real need.
I would like to see this need addressed.
I feel this need can be address ethically and sustainably.
I would like to contribute to addressing this need.
I look forward to discovering what other needs may arise.
I have no objections to moving forward based on this framing.

Thank you for the poll. After the meeting on the 2nd, re-reading the cards about money and reading this poll, I feel increased excitement about the project.

Alex Rodriguez

I understand the scope outlined in this proposal.
I feel it points to a real need.
I would like to see this need addressed.
I feel this need can be address ethically and sustainably.
I look forward to discovering what other needs may arise.
I have no objections to moving forward based on this framing.
I would like to contribute to addressing this need.

I still have some hesitancy around the vagueness of the terms "strangers" and "at random times" and also share Josh's concerns about my capacity for tending to strangers right now. But after really sitting with this for a few days I don't think that my concerns are blocking concerns; furthermore, I think that the things I'm tracking that have seemed to missing from the framing thus far could be integrated within the scope Ronen has outlined here.

Toni Blanco

I understand the scope outlined in this proposal.
I feel it points to a real need.
I would like to see this need addressed.
I feel this need can be address ethically and sustainably.
I would like to contribute to addressing this need.
I look forward to discovering what other needs may arise.
I have no objections to moving forward based on this framing.

I always assumed this and I am glad that we make it explicit: "This framing does not exclude the application of the method to existing groups or established spaces where people are already together but feel they can benefit from the method"

Ronen Hirsch

Thank you @Josh Fairhead for the honest expression in your reply to the Scope of Work poll. I wholly embrace you as you are, where you are. I look forward to a period during which the crew can serve and nourish you. For me, you presencing yourself, attending the gathering, and responding to the poll are all acts of vital and generous giving. Please stay tuned to where you are and, as long as you can, please continue to communicate your state of being, needs, and desires into the crew space.

Jennifer Damashek

I appreciate this response so much. I'm glad Josh expressed exactly where he is with the prospect of tending to strangers, and I'm glad he received this response.

Robert Damashek

I have attached below my thoughts on how the Money Cards could be potentially transformed to naturally embrace broader forms of value exchange without diminishing the near-term importance of money to support and sustain the crew.

Money in the GP & Cycle 3

proposal by Ronen Hirsch Closed Thu 23 Sep 2021 9:02AM

Yesterday I completed the reading of the GP with Maija. While going through the Money sequences their weakness as a center became a physically felt experience for me. This, together with the inputs offered by Robert (which I am still digesting), the tension expressed by Jennifer, a general unease around this part of the sequence, and the complexity of the subject matter have prompted me to make this proposal. This is also the 2nd proposal I promised to make in the wake of Gathering 15 and now it is mature and clear to me.

I have an image in mind of a hand-fan that represents the complexity of money. It has a center where there is a handle and the many blades that are connected to the center and represent the many intricate aspects of money. My intention, in the money sequences, was to tend to the handle in such a way that gradually over time the many blades will be able to connect to it. I now feel that, while I have pointed at something that may probably be needed (and better elaborated in the future) that I was also affected more by some of the blades but not sufficiently to the wholeness of the fan. This currently feels to me like an over-reach from the present moment.

My proposal is, therefore:

  1. To set aside the three Money sequences, to remove them, for now, from the core GP.

  2. To give ourselves space to gradually evolve the subject of money both in response to our needs (as we move forward together) and to the needs of the structure and its spaces (as they begin to manifest and meet real-world needs).

  3. To embrace a shared understanding that the subject of money needs to be addressed well in order to a) meet the needs of the crew; b) make it possible to manifest our ideas into a living ecology; c) tend to the well-being of the future structure and all of its inhabitants; d) interface well with the realities (constraints, potentials, needs, etc.) of the physical world as it currently is.

  4. To bring cycle 3 to completion and to explore what comes next.

I want to explicitly acknowledge that this proposal is effectively a bundle of 4 proposals. I preferred to offer them in this way as a whole instead of as 4 separate proposals. However, I ask that you take the liberty to relate to each of the proposals. If you have any reservations about or objections to any of them please indicate so in your response to the proposal, and that should and will block this proposal as a whole.

Results

Josh Fairhead
Consent

No objections with setting the issue aside for now; the current 'theory' outlined on C1 has always seemed fine to me on an intellectual level, but I appreciate the desire to ground theory in practice and see how we feel once such protocols are embodied. Sometimes the two worlds are incommensurable. If our little cell is to keep itself alive long term, it does seem of vital importance, but as work matures I'm sure we can find external validation in such a form. Lets end this cycle!

Alex Rodriguez
Consent

This analysis feels resonant to me and the proposal seems to follow naturally from that place. Thank you, Ronen, for distilling this. I'd like to suggest as part of point 4 that we have a closing gathering for Cycle 3.

Robert Damashek
Consent

I agree that it will be important to come back to this and come to a shared understanding about understanding both value agreements and money in terms of birth the needs of the crew and the needs of those who will inhabit and be served by the digital space.

Jennifer Damashek
Consent

I feel all 4 points are perfect right now.

Toni Blanco
Consent

I have not listened the last version of the GP yet, but I feel that this four-part proposal is wise and will let us frame the economic sustainability of both the space and crews with a fresh approach in the (near) future.

Jennifer Damashek

I read the proposal this morning and have been thinking about it since then. I'm wondering if the next cycle could include seeking to discover how to generate financial income (for those who want or need it in the crew) as we move forward from this place. I think there are possibilities around how the crew works together. People are hungry for new ways of relating/working together.

Some qualities of this way of working together that stand out to me:
1. Being fully present while listening and speaking
2. Only speaking/writing when it will move the group forward
3. Bringing our whole selves to work
4. Desiring to tend to what is best for the whole that emerges from the group
5. Looking for and expressing appreciation for gifts offered by others
6. Speaking what is felt/embodied knowledge and awareness rather than simply what our intellect or emotions may tell us
7. Allowing the process of work to unfold without knowing for sure where it is going

I also wonder if it's possible crews could be formed using the basics of the Generative Process without there even being a digital space...and that might help inform the actual building of the digital space.

Ronen Hirsch

This (apparently ongoing) thread from Richard Bartlett (started after I shared the GP with him) and has seeds to harvest regarding money:

https://twitter.com/RichDecibels/status/1439954274604224519

this especially stood out to me and prompted me to place this link here for future reference:

ppl cringe or want to avoid money in community; so they start out voluntary, or as cheap as possible so you wind up with a more fragile system: because the value flows are mostly invisible, you don't know if you're growing or dying, you don't know what needs attention