Loomio

Some feedback - page size

Richard Grevers PublicSeen by 48

Some context: I'm on the wrong side of a new sort of digital divide. I live in rural Taranaki, with no landline or wireless broadband. So apart from the limited hours when I'm in the office in town (when I'm supposed to be doing work stuff!) 2/3 of my Internet access is via mobile broadband. Signal availability means I get one choice of provider - Telecom, and they have no option for more than 2GB of data a month at an affordable rate, after which it's 10c/MB.

Smartphone-only is also the only form of Internet access for a large chunk of the developing world, and although services in, say, India only cost 1/10000th what we get charged in NZ, it's all relative. In short, mobile is an important target audience for a tool like loomio, which ought to be as accessible as possible.

I'm finding myself blocked from participating in loomio discussions because the site just uses too much data. It's very simple and elegant looking, and feels as though it should be 100-200KB a page. But by my measurements it's 650 - 900KB.

I don't know if you are serving fully-optimized/minified code in this developmental stage, but here are my thoughts on data minimisation:

1) Does it need to be secure? Using https means that the js (just over 200KB) and all images (90% repeated on every page) are downloaded every time. Maybe secure pages could be an option for group creators? I can see the need for privacy to remain an option for some users, but not on open discussions such as this group.
2) Make emails more informative.
I get the daily update on the group. It tells me that there have been x comments. If it told me who they were by, I might remember whether they are ones I've already read.
I get emails for a new discussion or proposal. Couldn't they contain the full text to it so I don't have to visit the site to find out if it's relevant?
I get an email to say I've been tagged in a comment. Couldn't that include the comment?

Apologies if this has been covered before - I haven't had time to trawl through past discussions much.

Mike Hargreaves

Are you sure your figures are correct? Im getting 245kb with my cache cleared. 9kb on this page after cacheing. This is one of the more efficient sites I have come across.

Alanna Irving

Good questions! I don't know the answer to most of them, but I can say that more fully featured email notifications, including reply by email, is on the road map. Hopefully that will make a difference once it comes in!

Danyl Strype

@alannakrause A major upvote from me for 'reply by email'! This single feature would make Loomio 100% more accessible by people in Richard's position, as well as people with disabilities who have already optimized their email client for their needs.

At one point the Save Happy Valley forum used a forum>email tool which allowed reply by email to forum discussions. This was great for people like me, who prefer to do everything by email, and great for those who like to interact with the latest posts on the web, and vastly increased uptake and reduced tool proliferation. It also had the extra benefit of ensuring all discussions were preserved in a well-presented archive on the web. Go Loomio!

Richard Grevers

Analysing a page with about 10 comments and an open proposal, I'm getting 353KB in actual file sizes, excluding the HTML (wonders why Dragonfly doesn't give sizes of HTML files?). At best, using https would add about 3% to this, but the requests go to 5 different servers, two of which (gravatar and google analytics) serve multiple resources without a persistent connection, so overheads there might be as much as 100-200%. I'm also getting an expired certificate warning from be.autiful.net, and it looks as though my browser isn't downloading whatever resources come from there.

The site is fairly efficient compared to some - (WordPress anyone?) The HTML is elegant and efficient, apart from some debugging comments which will presumably disappear at some point. The CSS and javascript appear to be minified. I can't tell if they are being served gzipped.

The single biggest saving would be the 172KB js file, which is being downloaded afresh for every page request, despite being identical. Via this alone, savings should be 40%+ for non-secure with a reasonable cache-expiry.

Reply by email would indeed be great!

Richard Grevers

...and since they are usually able to use a lot less data, and Android app would be wonderful, but it's obviously much further down the track.

Tom Lord

This is something we're really keen to engage with - we do our best to make low-bandwidth accessible sites because our intended audience is often in less developed countries. We wrote some guidelines a few years ago at http://www.aptivate.org/webguidelines/Guidelines.html - this is of its time and pre-dates some modern web conventions and CMSs. I hope we can scrape together some spare design and tech time to look at this issue with you if that works for you!

Tom Lord

We've put reply by email into Econsensus and it works pretty well (after some work!). We probably have a more complicated system than you'd need because we allow two-level tiered conversations. We can create discussions and proposals by email, and reply to them - we can't create decisions by email at the moment (we have a slightly different conceptual model of the different "things" in the system to Loomio at the moment).

One issue we haven't solved with Email is whether/how to keep the full context of a conversation, without sending stuff that people don't want in every email, so I'm not sure this would totally address low-bandwidth accessibility without further thought. We currently only send the latest contribution, and leave the link for people to get the full context.

Thinking out loud, maybe a more advanced system could have the option to request the full thread of a particular discussion by email, returning a full email conversation, without too much extra work, if it turned out there was demand for that.